Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Not any more flimsy than a natural spillover when after almost 2 years no source animal can be found. That you deny that is flimsy evidence because then you can pretend such an absence of evidence is understandable.I don't disagree with any of that.
I also don't think that a lab leak is out of the question. It certainly could have happened.
The problem is that most of the arguments I have heard from it are based on flimsy evidence.
You conveniently ignore scientists who are in the field and think the lab leak is very plausible. Of course you dismiss a wealth of legit evidence by attacking the people who presented it with ad homs and anything else to hand wave it away, but at the same time you ignore Daszak's and Shi's blatant conflict of interest.So what do you do if you don't trust China and you have to rely on experts in the field?
Well, you listen to those experts, and most of the experts seem to be more persuaded by natural spillover arguments.
The experts on the side of lab leak often don't turn out to be people who are actually in the right field of expertise, OR they have some political partizanship, OR they have some kind of long-running feud and an axe to grind.
I bolded your straw man.Also, many of the arguments seem to be pushing forward different scenarios - from the idea that it was someone bitten by a bat, to the idea that there was secret gain of function happening from an incident in 2012, to the idea that the structure of the virus looks man-made. It seems that they cannot all be correct, but lab leakers are happy to let the doubts mutate into virulent narratives of their own.
Is there supposed to be something wrong with the idea there are a number of scenarios a lab accident might have occurred? Just how many different scenarios are being pushed about a natural event? Let me help you with that.
wet market: no evidence of a second wet market
wild animal farm, no source animal found
frozen food, no evidence
somewhere outside of Wuhan, the evidence supports Wuhan was the location of the initial event
pangolins, the coronavirus only matches in one segment and no pangolins were found being sold in Wuhan, and they are rare to find in a wet market in the first place
spillovers in general always need a number of mutations to get it right, no evidence of such an adjustment period from animals to humans
no past lab accident causing a new pandemic, ??? as if there can never be a first one when PPPs (potential pandemic pathogens) are being increasingly studied in labs around the world
wild animal farm, no source animal found
frozen food, no evidence
somewhere outside of Wuhan, the evidence supports Wuhan was the location of the initial event
pangolins, the coronavirus only matches in one segment and no pangolins were found being sold in Wuhan, and they are rare to find in a wet market in the first place
spillovers in general always need a number of mutations to get it right, no evidence of such an adjustment period from animals to humans
no past lab accident causing a new pandemic, ??? as if there can never be a first one when PPPs (potential pandemic pathogens) are being increasingly studied in labs around the world
Anything I missed?
Last edited:

