Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bull ****. That's just people here and their confirmation bias, and once again trying to drag this thread over to the CT forum.

Have you found any sources to cite that challenge the facts in those sources I cites? [looks back a few pages] Nope, not a single source countering the sources I've cited.

I don't have to have citations to counter the charges of "money laundering".

I also told you that the Times article is paywalled. It is pretty unreasonable for you to expect me to go to the link, pay a subscription fee, then read through the link to find the charges I apparently have to counter...etc...

What YOU must do, what I INSIST you do, is make a clear case with readily available documents for this "money laundering" and then I can see if it holds up.

Until you even make a coherent case, I have no obligation to you to find sources for anything.
 
I'm fine you didn't like my use of the term. Whatever floats your boat.

The money went to Daszak's company and he gave some to Shi when the US did not approve of funding her work. You are sidetracking the thread. You really should move on and get back to the thread topic.

The sources I'm referring to have to do with countering actual evidence of the origin hypothesis, not some evidence of your nitpick over a term. I am not the least bit interested in what you think of the term, money laundering and I don't imagine anyone in the thread is either.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure that's true. Have you done your back of the envelope calculation or are you just making that assessment up?

What data did you access and use in your assertion?

I don't think you've proven your case here. I'd need to see which countries you think are larger and sent more attendees to the games. And I'd need to see the numbers of attendees.

Which you are obviously welcome to do....


You've gone to a lot of trouble here but you haven't posted data to back up your assertion.

It doesn't matter, lay person or established researcher. Wise wrote the letter to the scientific journal "Irish Journal of Medical Science" describing the study and the results and the journal published the letter.

Not sure if you'll see the page and search criteria but this is the search result.


I think sometimes in this forum people get so immersed in discounting invalid sources they don't recognize when weak but not invalid evidence is posted.

If you have that rebuttal evidence you should post it. We would all benefit from that.

This is quite sad actually, SG.

What you variously describe as an "epidemiology study" or a "pilot study" or and a "correlational study" is nothing more than her typing in the numbers of athletes who went to the Wuhan Military Games from European countries into one column of Excel, and then going to the Worldometer site, looking up how many total cumulative cases of Covid-19 had been reported up to that particular day, which happened to be October 2020 (in other words, about a year after the Wuhan Military Games), and then typing them into another column on Excel. After that, she apparently made a scatter plot, just like anybody above the age of 5 years old could do.

She then also did a Pearson's R correlation test which is also a very simple thing to do.

You can literally do this type of thing in a matter of minutes if you are so inclined, and just to show how easy it is to do... I did the same.

Except, instead of just plotting the European countries, let's look at all the countries involved:

That paper said:
The data on the number of athletes and the number of COVID-19 cases per country were extracted from internet sources [1–4] and were examined from a European perspective. Figure Figure11 displays the graphical plot of the number of athletes per country against the number of cases of COVID-19 in that country. Note the strong correlation between these variables indicated by the curve fit and regression analysis.

So I did the same thing as the writer did.

I
took the number of athletes participating in the Wuhan Military Games from Wikipedia.

And I used the WayBack Machine to find the number of cases of Covid-19 from October 20th, which is the data that the author used.

Putting those numbers into Excel, instead of the Pearson's R of 0.7 that she got, I instead got the decidedly less impressive 0.31.

You can also see the scatter plot that I made from the data. Far less impressive than the cherry-picked data from the Irish Journal of Medicine letter, and a further important point to consider is that this does not include data of countries that sent no athletes to Wuhan.

For example, there were no athletes from the United Kingdom, and yet by October 2020 there were over 740,000 cases. How does this fit in with the theory? Answer: it doesn't.
 

Attachments

  • Wuhan Military Games and Infections.png
    Wuhan Military Games and Infections.png
    8 KB · Views: 6
I'm fine you didn't like my use of the term. Whatever floats your boat.

The money went to Daszak's company and he gave some to Shi when the US did not approve of funding her work. You are sidetracking the thread. You really should move on and get back to the thread topic.

The sources I'm referring to have to do with countering actual evidence of the origin hypothesis, not some evidence of your nitpick over a term. I am not the least bit interested in what you think of the term, money laundering.

SG: Accuses Peter Daszak of "money laundering" and claims that it is totally proven.
AS: Explains the meaning of money laundering.
SG: I don't care!

For the third time (or is it fourth, because I can't keep up with the number of dodges from SG), could you please link to some claims from that Times article. I don't have a subscription.

Don't make me suspect you haven't even read the article you are linking to.
 
You've gone to a lot of trouble here but you haven't posted data to back up your assertion.
angrysoba has posted the relevant data.

With my highlighting:
It doesn't matter, lay person or established researcher. Wise wrote the letter to the scientific journal "Irish Journal of Medical Science" describing the study and the results and the journal published the letter.

Not sure if you'll see the page and search criteria but this is the search result.
Article
The impact of the World Military Games on the COVID-19 pandemic
Amy Elise Winter in Irish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -) (2021)

Download PDF (158 KB) View Article

I think sometimes in this forum people get so immersed in discounting invalid sources they don't recognize when weak but not invalid evidence is posted.
It is also true that at least one person has become so eager to defend her sources that she responds to criticism without even getting the name of her source right.

Look, you have contributed a lot of good stuff to this thread, but you have also degraded the signal-to-noise ratio of your posts by interpreting criticism of your sources and arguments as personal attacks and by responding to those perceived attacks in a knee-jerk, slapdash manner. If only 10% of your posts include questionable sources, allegations, or arguments, but you respond to criticism of those sources/allegations/arguments by engaging in an extended back-and-forth in which you write ten or more posts per criticism, as has been close to your recent average, then your signal-to-noise ratio won't be higher than 50%.

Please don't blame your degraded signal-to-noise ratio on those who take the time to read your posts and to note potential problems with your sources and arguments. You have the power to improve your signal-to-noise ratio regardless of what other people do.
 
SG, you must admit that the "lab leak hypothesis" looks and sounds like an evil scientist myth.

[qimg]https://media3.giphy.com/media/1XeHuHcR6Mo50PibPW/200w.webp?cid=ecf05e47nzs45zabc6l5jdivjv6r4eftwgjrb1612u8voa5u&rid=200w.webp&ct=g[/qimg]

We are not talking evil, we are talking incompetence. And incompetence is omnipotent.
 
We are not talking evil, we are talking incompetence. And incompetence is omnipotent.

If we were simply talking about incompetence, then yes, I could give house room to the idea of a lab leak.

That said, SG's going further than that.

She is claiming that:

1. Peter Daszak was involved in "money laundering".
2. He and Zhengli Shi, instead of announcing they had discovered a spillover event, something that they are both ostensibly interested in, decided to cover it up.
3. Then, they embarked on presumably secret gain of function research.
4. ??????
5. Profit!

We don't know why they would want to do that. SG argues it is because of 600,000 dollars which seems like a pitifully small amount of cash to be "laundering" when it makes far more sense that Daszak and Shi could have added the discovery of a spillover event to their CV with far more chance of getting big grant money.

On top of that, it seems that Fauci, Andersen, Jeremy Farrar, Patrick Vallance, Andrew Rambaut, Angela Rasmussen, Dominic Dwyer, Eddie Holmes, and many many other virologists have decided to cover up for Daszak and Shi. Why would they do this?

Well, some people such as Richard Ebright have made claims outright that they have been paid off. He is quoted as saying that Daszak has a lot of funding money and that buys a lot of omerta. To me that definitely sounds as though he is accusing them of evil, not just incompetence. Just the other day, the writer of Spillover, David Quanmen, was asked how much money EcoHealth had given him for writing his book. Quanmen said he got the money from his publisher and from National Geographic, but Ebright claimed he was "bought and paid for" (this is literally what he said)...
 

Attachments

  • Ebright Bought and Paid for.jpg
    Ebright Bought and Paid for.jpg
    22.9 KB · Views: 7
  • Quanmen and borisfly.jpg
    Quanmen and borisfly.jpg
    41.4 KB · Views: 5
I notice that Richard Ebright has since deleted his Tweet accusing David Quanmen of being "bought and paid for". He probably realized it was libellous. But I still have the screenshots.
 
The impact of the World Military Games on the COVID-19 pandemic by Amy Elise Winter has popped up again.
This is a statistical study that shows a correlation between the number of athletes at the World Military Games in Wuhan from 18th to 27th of October 2019 and the number of COVID-19 cases per European country one year later. She ignored the epidemiology which is the earliest known case was in early December 2019. The first case recorded outside of China was in Thailand on 13 January 2020. There are no known cases from these 9308 athletes returning to their countries in late October 2019 or from the spectators in China before early December 2019 or elsewhere between November 2019 and 13 January 2020.
Her correlation is not about the spread of COVID-19. What she has probably shown is that the largest European countries have the largest number of travelers visiting China in December 2019 and early 2020. We have to wonder if her correlation would persist if other countries were added. North Korea sent 156 athletes, the USA sent 172 athletes, Russia sent 243 athletes, Canada sent 104 athletes, etc.
 
Last edited:
The impact of the World Military Games on the COVID-19 pandemic by Amy Elise Winter has popped up again.
This is a statistical study that shows a correlation between the number of athletes at the World Military Games in Wuhan from 18th to 27th of October 2019 and the number of COVID-19 cases per European country one year later. She ignored the epidemiology which is the earliest known case was in early December 2019. The first case recorded outside of China was in Thailand on 13 January 2020. There are no known cases from these 9308 athletes returning to their countries in late October 2019 or from the spectators in China before early December 2019 or elsewhere between November 2019 and 13 January 2020.
Her correlation is not about the spread of COVID-19. What she has probably shown is that the largest European countries have the largest number of travelers visiting China in December 2019 and early 2020. We have to wonder if her correlation would persist if other countries were added. North Korea sent 156 athletes, the USA sent 172 athletes, Russia sent 243 athletes, Canada sent 104 athletes, etc.

Yes, and the UK sent 0 athletes, so presumably there would have been 0 cases in October 2020. Obviously this is not the case, and the UK had some of the highest numbers of cases, hospitalizations and deaths in the world in October 2020. The numbers were twice as high as Germany's despite Germany sending 243 athletes - the second highest number of athletes from a European nation (after France).

The European countries which sent the most athletes were France (273), Germany (243), Poland (193), Italy (139) and Spain (111). This is probably not too surprising given that it more or less probably reflects the numbers of military personnel they have. And what is more, it probably correlates more or less with population size. After almost a year of the pandemic being in full swing, any noticeable disproportionate effects of the pandemic's spread would have been smoothed out by the virus's spread through the population which was also, more or less, uniform throughout Europe. Some countries such as Germany had had some moderate success in slowing the spread, but by and large the numbers of infections more or less reflected the numbers of people in the population.

So...what does this "study" show us? Nothing! It really only shows that if you cherry-pick the European countries who sent athletes, and if you ignore all the other countries that sent athletes, and if you also ignore all the countries that didn't send athletes, then you can find a correlation between the size of a European country's military and the number of people who got sick with Covid-19. That is a thoroughly underwhelming finding.

What would you do if you wanted to find some other more interesting correlation?

Well, maybe you could look at serology tests from the athletes? Or maybe you could look at military bases from which countries sent athletes to see if the infections spread out from there? Presumably athletes' families would have started getting sick, and then their children would have spread it around their schools. Any evidence for that?

Of course, these kinds of disproportionate effects would be visible early in the pandemic. Surely we would be talking weeks, or at most a couple of months into the pandemic. Once you start looking at figures 10 months into the pandemic, there is almost no chance of finding anything remotely interesting. But then what do I know? I have never had epidemiological training and I have never written letters to the Irish Journal of Medical Science.
 
You can insult me all you want. None of that means anything. I'm not going to suddenly turn into a CTer because I've taken a stand here that is being hand-waved away. I'm confident in my posts here.

In the meantime, no one has posted much of anything except trying to tear down my posts.


You guys got nothing, or at most a very tiny bit. All the while the evidence for a lab accident accumulates. You can nitpick everything you choose to cherry pick. When it comes down to it, not everything I've posted has equal weight. There's nothing wrong with that.



From my POV it is the argument from incredulity being used to deny the lab accident hypothesis not the other way around. I find that bizarre considering how much evidence has accumulated supporting the lab accident and how the natural origin hypothesis is stalled in its tracks.

And for a skeptics board, wow, talk about ignoring an hypothesis because one can't change beliefs when more evidence is uncovered.

And no, I haven't ruled out a natural event but I need to see some actual evidence if I'm going to shift the weight here on which origin is more likely.

I have yet to find any of you pointing out where in the WHO report it supports the assertion that was made in several citations here that the WHO team found evidence of the first cases being definitively exposed to a different Wuhan wet market.

crickets

Any evidence frozen food carried the virus to Wuhan?

crickets

Any evidence COVID in some precursor form was found circulating in any animals on any wild animal farms?

crickets

Any evidence pangolins were the source other than a particular gene segment might have found its way into the mix in the Yunnan bats?

crickets

Any evidence for the two lineages originating from someplace other than Wuhan?

crickets

Any evidence for any of the earliest cases originating outside of Wuhan?

crickets

Any evidence cases sputtered and died out before one took off?

crickets



People here could easily say x or y is weak evidence without applying any significance to the fact I posted it and it doesn't meet someone's standard. I think some of you should really take a deep breath and recognize this discussion is not about attacking people. It is about presenting evidence supporting one's case, not about presenting evidence showing off what a clever person one is.


No worries, carry on. You'll have to forgive me for not responding to the insults and attacks. I keep waiting for some evidence of a natural spillover and I find it sorely lacking. But beyond that, I'm not putting up with the **** here today. I don't need to.
 
Last edited:
You can insult me all you want.


I'm not insulting you. I am telling you that the "study" you claim promotes the Wuhan Military Games as superspreader theory does no such thing.

If anything you are insulting us by assuming you can pass off such a pathetic letter as evidence of the Wuhan Military Games superspreader event.

I would just like you to say, "Ah yes, I see what you mean." But no, you double and triple down on it and make ever more ludicrous claims about how the letter is a pilot study, an epidemiological study, a correlational study etc...

I am addressing the actual data you posted and the actual "studies" you present and for some reason, instead of discussing it, you assume it is a personal attack. It is not!

How is it even possible to have a discussion if you see any and every disagreement of the "evidence" you present as being a personal attack?

None of that means anything. I'm not going to suddenly turn into a CTer because I've taken a stand here that is being hand-waved away. I'm confident in my posts here.

In the meantime, no one has posted much of anything except trying to tear down my posts.

What are you expecting to be posted? You are the one putting forward theories. You have to expect that such theories are going to be analyzed. That is what happens here.

You guys got nothing, or at most a very tiny bit. All the while the evidence for a lab accident accumulates. You can nitpick everything you choose to cherry pick. When it comes down to it, not everything I've posted has equal weight. There's nothing wrong with that.

Does the evidence for a lab leak accumulate? It seems to me that various theories are put forward, and many of them are shown to be not particularly compelling.



From my POV it is the argument from incredulity being used to deny the lab accident hypothesis not the other way around. I find that bizarre considering how much evidence has accumulated supporting the lab accident and how the natural origin hypothesis is stalled in its tracks.

I think the problem here is that you have a different expectation of how quickly the natural origins of a zoonotic spillover should be found. I think it is far easier to drum up some drama and scour documents and emails and look in the cloud for "deleted sequences" and discover financial discrepancies etc... than it is to do the painstaking field research which would need to be done to discover the natural origins.

I tend to find it more believable when virologists who are involved in this kind of thing are more convinced of natural origins than they are of a lab leak. This is partly because we as laypeople cannot be expected to know the ins and outs of this process and have to rely, to some extent, on their expertise.

For example, Michael Worobey:

Worobey suspects that after a SARS-CoV-2 progenitor jumped from animals to humans, it pingponged back and forth, steadily adapting to its new host. This could have happened at the market and gone unnoticed for weeks, as the outbreak only surfaced when several people became severely ill, a relatively rare outcome of a SARS-CoV-2 infection. Or the virus could have first infected animal farmers in remote villages. “If this happened in a small town, it’s quite probable it would never have taken off,” says William Hanage, an evolutionary biologist at Harvard University. Then animal traders might have brought the virus to markets in Wuhan, a city of 11 million.

Link

These are merely plausible hypotheses, not determined facts. But that is hardly unusual for science.



And for a skeptics board, wow, talk about ignoring an hypothesis because one can't change beliefs when more evidence is uncovered.

What is funny about this is that you and others have been waving around quoted by people like Zhengli Shi, David Baltimore and others that had them saying they thought lab leak then changed their minds. For some reason you find it suspicious that so many scientists changed their mind when presented with new evidence yet they are doing exactly what you are complaining others don't. So it is silly of you to play the "I'm more Skeptical than you" card. If you want to prove your credentials there, just at least say you were wrong about that letter to the Irish Journal of Medical Science. If you keep digging your heels in on that one, I find the claims that you do skepticism to be literally incredible.

And no, I haven't ruled out a natural event but I need to see some actual evidence if I'm going to shift the weight here on which origin is more likely.

I have yet to find any of you pointing out where in the WHO report it supports the assertion that was made in several citations here that the WHO team found evidence of the first cases being definitively exposed to a different Wuhan wet market.

crickets

Any evidence frozen food carried the virus to Wuhan?

crickets

Any evidence COVID in some precursor form was found circulating in any animals on any wild animal farms?

crickets

Any evidence pangolins were the source other than a particular gene segment might have found its way into the mix in the Yunnan bats?

crickets

Any evidence for the two lineages originating from someplace other than Wuhan?

crickets

Any evidence for any of the earliest cases originating outside of Wuhan?

crickets

Any evidence cases sputtered and died out before one took off?

crickets



People here could easily say x or y is weak evidence without applying any significance to the fact I posted it and it doesn't meet someone's standard. I think some of you should really take a deep breath and recognize this discussion is not about attacking people. It is about presenting evidence supporting one's case, not about presenting evidence showing off what a clever person one is.


No worries, carry on. You'll have to forgive me for not responding to the insults and attacks. I keep waiting for some evidence of a natural spillover and I find it sorely lacking. But beyond that, I'm not putting up with the **** here today. I don't need to.

No, there is very little evidence for any of that. Nobody is saying otherwise.

That doesn't mean that some of those points are not plausible origins. The virus must have come from somewhere, and right now we have no evidence it came from a lab. If it had come from a lab, where is the evidence it was in the lab. That's the problem!
 
The WHO study states cases were associated with other markets

I have yet to find any of you pointing out where in the WHO report it supports the assertion that was made in several citations here that the WHO team found evidence of the first cases being definitively exposed to a different Wuhan wet market.
crickets...
A post of "crickets" nonsense that stows she has not understood WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part which states
Many of the early cases were associated with the Huanan market, but a similar number of cases were associated with other markets and some were not associated with any markets. Transmission within the wider community in December could account for cases not associated with the Huanan market which, together with the presence of early cases not associated with that market, could suggest that the Huanan market was not the original source of the outbreak. Other milder cases that were not identified, however, could provide the link between the Huanan market and early cases without an apparent link to the market. No firm conclusion therefore about the role of the Huanan market in the origin of the outbreak, or how the infection was introduced into the market, can currently be drawn.
... Retrospective investigations identified additional cases with onset of disease in December 2019, and not all the early cases reported an association with the Huanan Market.(2)
Clinical review of early cases conducted as part of Phase 1 studies
As part of the Phase 1 studies, a review was carried out of all cases reported as potential cases of COVID-19 with onset in December 2019, including all cases that were accepted as formally notified
cases in the NNDRS system and other cases that were re-interviewed in December 2020 or January 2021.
...
For those cases where the information was available, 55.4% had a history of recent exposure to a market: 28.0% to the Huanan market only, 22.6% to other markets only, and 4.8% to both. 44.6% had no history of market exposure (see Fig. 24 and Annex E4). Cases with market exposure were more evident among the early cases but exposure to other markets occurred in the earliest cases as much as exposure to the Huanan market. The case reported with the earliest onset date (8 December) had no history of exposure to the Huanan market
...
Identification of early cases and role of Huanan Market among early cases
(repeats the other markets statement)
...
Fig. 6. 174 COVID-19 pneumonia cases classified by genome sequence availability and market exposure. Top: the time series; bottom: the spatial distribution - note: “Huanan market” and “Other market” in the legend refer to market exposure for the 13 early cases sequenced.
Anyone with access to the NNDRS system could repeat their analysis. Maybe this is the CDC data at National Notifiable Diseases Surveillance System (NNDSS). Or it may be CDC China.
 
Last edited:
Back to that new Science article:

A great deal of speculation about the pandemic’s origin has centered on six men who developed severe respiratory illnesses in 2012 after clearing bat feces from a copper mine in Mojiang, in China’s Yunnan province. Three of them died. Lab-origin proponents have suggested the men were infected with a coronavirus, a belief fed by a 2013 master’s thesis that provided no direct evidence. That bat virus, they argue, either was SARS-CoV-2 or was turned into it through genetic engineering.

When the miners fell ill, Shi and co-workers were asked to sample bats at the mine, which they did on several occasions. They discovered nine new SARS-related viruses (see sidebar, below). One of these, dubbed RaTG13, is 96.2% genetically identical to SARS-CoV-2, the closest overall similarity yet found. A loose-knit group whose members call themselves DRASTIC—for the Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating COVID-19—has driven a heated discussion about possible links between RaTG13 and SARS-CoV-2.

Shi has reported that her lab tested blood from the miners and did not find evidence of coronaviruses or antibodies to them. Wang, who helped with these analyses, finds the assertion that the team suppressed evidence of SARS-CoV-2’s link to the Mojiang mine preposterous. “We wanted to prove that a coronavirus caused the deaths,” says Wang, who grew up in Shanghai but is now an Australian citizen. “If we proved that another SARS-like virus was in humans in China that would have been scientifically brilliant,” he says. “It’s a Science or Nature paper. No scientist is going to wait for this to leak.”
Even Bloom agrees with that logic. “That’s one of the strongest arguments you can make against a lab accident,” he says. “On the other hand, I feel like a lot of these questions could be resolved pretty easily by enhanced transparency.”

We have noted this before, but it is nice to hear it from Linfa Wang, and also to hear that Jesse Bloom agrees...

The theory that there was a new coronavirus in the mines that killed three miners would have been massive news in the virology world. The fact that no coronavirus could be isolated from samples or that no coronavirus could be proved, only means that either...

1.) They tried to discover one and failed either because there wasn't one, or not enough evidence of one to make a determination.

OR

2.) There really was a spillover... and everything that follows is abject conspiracy theorizing.

Does anyone see why the lab leak is often considered a conspiracy theory?

It is not because a lab leak is, per se, a conspiracy theory, but all the "evidence" has to be forced into a narrative where there are always scientists doing devious things and covering stuff up, etc... and for reasons that don't make a lot of sense.
 
Back to that new Science article:
And many reputable scientists disagree.

BBC last May: Covid origin: Why the Wuhan lab-leak theory is being taken seriously
But in recent weeks the controversial claim that the pandemic might have leaked from a Chinese laboratory - once dismissed by many as a fringe conspiracy theory - has been gaining traction....

So why has it come up again?
Because reports swirling around the US media have raised fresh concerns over the lab-leak theory. And some scientists who were once sceptical of the idea have expressed fresh openness to it.

There are just as many articles like this as there are people conveiniently trying to dismiss it as a CT. All these scientists are not CTers much as you'd like that to be true. And they are not all Dump and GOP rumor promoters.



as said:
The theory that there was a new coronavirus in the mines that killed three miners would have been massive news in the virology world. The fact that no coronavirus could be isolated from samples or that no coronavirus could be proved, only means that either...
You don't even know that for sure. There were specimens sent to various labs that as of yet have not been accounted for or addressed. And that bit was found in the masters thesis in 2012, long before the pandemic. In addition, that is only one of several possible scenarios.



as said:
1.) They tried to discover one and failed either because there wasn't one, or not enough evidence of one to make a determination.

OR

2.) There really was a spillover... and everything that follows is abject conspiracy theorizing.
:id: Is that like the spillover promoters who can't find a single source animal the spillover came from?



as said:
Does anyone see why the lab leak is often considered a conspiracy theory?

It is not because a lab leak is, per se, a conspiracy theory, but all the "evidence" has to be forced into a narrative where there are always scientists doing devious things and covering stuff up, etc... and for reasons that don't make a lot of sense.
No, it is not a CT per se, you got that part right.

The rest is simply not true. It's being pushed as a CT for political reasons to protect the WIV researchers. And they've been successful getting others to buy into that premise before any evidence was actually looked at (well documented in this thread) and by people who can't accept that researchers in China might, gasp, actually be covering up a mistake that led to a worldwide pandemic.

No, the evidence need not be shoehorned into anything. That's turning a blind eye to the evidence. Hell, there is even a researcher in China who contracted COVID from a lab exposure! Let me say that again: There is even a researcher in China who contracted COVID-19 from a lab exposure!(Also documented in this thread.)

That's much closer to a smoking gun than anything on the spillover side of the debate.


The miners didn't die of a fungus. It's not rocket science to see that was a direct provable lie Shi told.

And I don't think Wang put anything to rest just as that last Australian who worked at WIV did not either. There is plenty of contradictory evidence. And there are other labs looking at coronavirus in Wuhan as well as the fact specimens would not have been studied in the level 4 lab.



But evidence is evidence and you can only squelch what the evidence supports when there are so many eyes looking at it. Other researchers have begun to speak up.

Vanity Fair (one article free per month unless you pay) The Lab-Leak Theory: Inside the Fight to Uncover COVID-19’s Origins
Throughout 2020, the notion that the novel coronavirus leaked from a lab was off-limits.
Just as many in this thread are trying to do: lalalalalalalal I see/hear nothing.

Those who dared to push for transparency say toxic politics and hidden agendas kept us in the dark. ...

The Lancet statement effectively ended the debate over COVID-19’s origins before it began. To Gilles Demaneuf, following along from the sidelines, it was as if it had been “nailed to the church doors,” establishing the natural origin theory as orthodoxy. “Everyone had to follow it. Everyone was intimidated. That set the tone.”

The statement struck Demaneuf as “totally nonscientific.” To him, it seemed to contain no evidence or information. And so he decided to begin his own inquiry in a “proper” way, with no idea of what he would find....
Demaneuf collected data on all the lab accidents in Chinese labs since SARS and there had been many including accidents where students and workers became infected with SARS.

From there DRASTIC began collecting well documented evidence and sharing it on Twitter.

There are just as many articles like this as there are people conveiniently trying to dismiss it as a CT. All these scientists are not CTers. They are not fringe scientists. And they are not all Dump and GOP rumor promoters.




And here you are again dragging the CT crap into the science thread because that is really your only argument. Don't like someone else's POV, ignore the evidence and call them a CTer.
 
And many reputable scientists disagree.

BBC last May: Covid origin: Why the Wuhan lab-leak theory is being taken seriously

There are just as many articles like this as there are people conveiniently trying to dismiss it as a CT. All these scientists are not CTers much as you'd like that to be true. And they are not all Dump and GOP rumor promoters.



You don't even know that for sure. There were specimens sent to various labs that as of yet have not been accounted for or addressed. And that bit was found in the masters thesis in 2012, long before the pandemic. In addition, that is only one of several possible scenarios.



:id: Is that like the spillover promoters who can't find a single source animal the spillover came from?



No, it is not a CT per se, you got that part right.

The rest is simply not true. It's being pushed as a CT for political reasons to protect the WIV researchers. And they've been successful getting others to buy into that premise before any evidence was actually looked at (well documented in this thread) and by people who can't accept that researchers in China might, gasp, actually be covering up a mistake that led to a worldwide pandemic.

No, the evidence need not be shoehorned into anything. That's turning a blind eye to the evidence. Hell, there is even a researcher in China who contracted COVID from a lab exposure! Let me say that again: There is even a researcher in China who contracted COVID-19 from a lab exposure!(Also documented in this thread.)

That's much closer to a smoking gun than anything on the spillover side of the debate.


The miners didn't die of a fungus. It's not rocket science to see that was a direct provable lie Shi told.

And I don't think Wang put anything to rest just as that last Australian who worked at WIV did not either. There is plenty of contradictory evidence. And there are other labs looking at coronavirus in Wuhan as well as the fact specimens would not have been studied in the level 4 lab.



But evidence is evidence and you can only squelch what the evidence supports when there are so many eyes looking at it. Other researchers have begun to speak up.

Vanity Fair (one article free per month unless you pay) The Lab-Leak Theory: Inside the Fight to Uncover COVID-19’s OriginsJust as many in this thread are trying to do: lalalalalalalal I see/hear nothing.

Demaneuf collected data on all the lab accidents in Chinese labs since SARS and there had been many including accidents where students and workers became infected with SARS.

From there DRASTIC began collecting well documented evidence and sharing it on Twitter.

There are just as many articles like this as there are people conveiniently trying to dismiss it as a CT. All these scientists are not CTers. They are not fringe scientists. And they are not all Dump and GOP rumor promoters.




And here you are again dragging the CT crap into the science thread because that is really your only argument. Don't like someone else's POV, ignore the evidence and call them a CTer.

Congratulations, you found some sensationalist news articles to say, "It was Forbidden to Believe in Lab Leak once, but not any more!!!!!1111!!!eleventy!"

I guess you will throw that on the "Evidence for Lab Leak" pile.

Also, nobody at all thinks it is impossible to catch Covid 19 in a lab. That is a complete and utter strawman.

Of course it is possible to become infected with pathogens you are studying in a lab.

What is the difference between almost all cases of infections within a lab and the lab leak theory?

Can anybody guess?

The difference is that there was no evidence that SARS-CoV2 was in the lab in the first place.

Now, if you can find evidence that it was, you have an argument.

Cannot find it? No? Well, then... we are back where we started with it being a mystery where it came from...

This isn't rocket science! Geeze!
 
Said it before, but bears repeating. If China was responsible via a lab leak, there is literally nothing they would not do to cover it up. They have ultimate and complete control over the media and the internet.

Maybe people haven't realised quite how things have changed in China in recent years since Xi took over, but those changes are rapidly accelerating. All the signs are there is a Cultural Revolution 2.0 on its way, China is pulling up the drawbridge and spurning western ideals and culture far more now than at any time since the 1960s. Expect this to increase under Xi.

Chinese state media last week accused the US of economic, cyber and even biological warfare against China, and has stated it will reject the unbridled capitalism that brought it out of poverty.

However, for the moment they still need the rest of the world, and admitting that there is even a chance that Covid came from an unintentional lab leak must never be even considered as a possibility, as they know that is the one thing that would turn the entire world against them. That they cannot afford.

Does all this then make the lab leak more likely than spillover? No, not in the slightest.

But its worth noting that to expect Chinese scientists to be as open as those outside of China, and working with the same set of assumptions and mindsets is simply naïve. Everything is China is political now.
 
Said it before, but bears repeating. If China was responsible via a lab leak, there is literally nothing they would not do to cover it up. They have ultimate and complete control over the media and the internet.

Maybe people haven't realised quite how things have changed in China in recent years since Xi took over, but those changes are rapidly accelerating. All the signs are there is a Cultural Revolution 2.0 on its way, China is pulling up the drawbridge and spurning western ideals and culture far more now than at any time since the 1960s. Expect this to increase under Xi.

Chinese state media last week accused the US of economic, cyber and even biological warfare against China, and has stated it will reject the unbridled capitalism that brought it out of poverty.

However, for the moment they still need the rest of the world, and admitting that there is even a chance that Covid came from an unintentional lab leak must never be even considered as a possibility, as they know that is the one thing that would turn the entire world against them. That they cannot afford.

Does all this then make the lab leak more likely than spillover? No, not in the slightest.

But its worth noting that to expect Chinese scientists to be as open as those outside of China, and working with the same set of assumptions and mindsets is simply naïve. Everything is China is political now.

I don't disagree with any of that.

I also don't think that a lab leak is out of the question. It certainly could have happened.

The problem is that most of the arguments I have heard from it are based on flimsy evidence.

So what do you do if you don't trust China and you have to rely on experts in the field?

Well, you listen to those experts, and most of the experts seem to be more persuaded by natural spillover arguments.

The experts on the side of lab leak often don't turn out to be people who are actually in the right field of expertise, OR they have some political partizanship, OR they have some kind of long-running feud and an axe to grind.

Also, many of the arguments seem to be pushing forward different scenarios - from the idea that it was someone bitten by a bat, to the idea that there was secret gain of function happening from an incident in 2012, to the idea that the structure of the virus looks man-made. It seems that they cannot all be correct, but lab leakers are happy to let the doubts mutate into virulent narratives of their own.
 
So you have no issue admitting one can get COVID in a lab accident, angrysoba, but you think it couldn't have happened to start the pandemic?

And you post that the lab leak hypothesis is a CT then pretend you didn't really say that? "People are saying" comes to mind.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom