They looked for a correlation between the number of COVID cases and the number of people who had recently come back from the Wuhan military games. That is epidemiology.
By "they", you mean Amy Elise Winter, the poet.
There is a correlation between the population of a European country and the number of athletes it sent to an international event.
There is a correlation between the population of a European country and the number of COVID-19 cases in that country.
Neither of those correlations offers any kind of clue regarding the origins of COVID-19.
As a matter of statistics and mathematics, the combination of those two correlations implies a correlation between the number of athletes a country sent to the event and the number of COVID-19 cases in the country. That statistical/mathematical consequence cannot offer any kind of clue regarding the origins of COVID-19, because neither of its two antecedents offer any such clue.
Every study is not an in-depth evaluation. Most studies you see reported in the news, for example, are only pilot studies. The point of pilot studies is to investigate if a larger or more in-depth study should be undertaken.
This particular "pilot study" was a meaningless back-of-the-envelope calculation that offers absolutely no guidance concerning whether larger or more in-depth studies should be undertaken.
I'm not sure why that is such a difficult concept for some people in this thread to grasp.
Here's why: Because some of us possess some small degree of scientific and statistical literacy, and are able to apply what limited knowledge we possess when evaluating claims made in discussions such as this.
Of course the objective measures in that study weren't in any way conclusive. But they did show a correlation and that is enough to suggest it should be evaluated further.
As I have explained, this particular correlation is completely meaningless. Meaningless correlations do not suggest they should be evaluated further.
This is a science thread. I have an expectation people in this discussion understand the difference between weak and strong evidence, between a pilot study and a larger in-depth one, between a study using very limited resources and a well funded study, between the BS in a politically biased report and the evidence one can take away from that same report...
What you have heard from
angrysoba and from me is the result of people understanding those differences, and recognizing that your citation of Amy Elise Winter's letter to the editor does not even rise to the level of weak evidence, let alone something worthy of being called a "pilot study".
That is what you do with all of these sources, you evaluate them and assess their validity and usefulness.
Indeed. You may not like it when people do that, but we do it anyway.
Did that pilot study done on a shoestring budget tell us anything? Yes, it told us there might very well be a correlation between the military games and the rapid spread of COVID around the world.
No. What it really told us is that, when we restrict our attention to European countries, there is definitely a correlation between population and the number of athletes sent to an event, and it also told us there is definitely a correlation between the population of such countries and the number of COVID-19 cases in the country.
It is well worth investigating further.
No. The sun tends to rise in the east. If the sun were observed to rise in the west, then there would be reason to investigate further. Watching the sun rise in the east is not a reason to investigate further.
More populated countries tend to have more cases of COVID-19, and also tend to have more athletes. That makes the correlation between number of athletes and number of cases no more surprising or interesting or informative than the correlation between sunrise and a glow in the east. If the correlation observed by Amy Elise Winter did
not exist, then it would be reasonable to ask why and to investigate further. But that correlation
does exist, to which the proper scientific response is "Well, duh."