Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ignoring the opinions, accusations, insinuations and side tracks being bantered about in this thread it appears that, as of Sept 1 2021, there is precious little hard evidence pointing to an actual day one, single location origin of COVI-19. At this time, with 6+ million dead and the disease endemic in the world population I really don't see that the determination matters much any more, outside of academic scientific curiosity.

Of course it matters. We want to avoid it in the future.
 
Of course it matters. We want to avoid it in the future.

If it was an accidental lab leak this could be avoided in the future by? Improving lab security? If lab security related to methods is currently inadequate then that can be identified and improved without knowing the exact mechanism of the "escape" of this particular organism.

If it was an intentional lab leak/release then that could be avoided in the future by? Improving lab security? If lab security related to integrity of personnel is currently inadequate then that can be identified and improved without knowing the exact mechanism of the release of this particular organism.

If it is a naturally occurring virus that was transferred from animals to humans without ever being present in a lab then this can be prevented by? Altering nature to prevent future occurrences of such organisms?
 
If it was an accidental lab leak this could be avoided in the future by? Improving lab security? If lab security related to methods is currently inadequate then that can be identified and improved without knowing the exact mechanism of the "escape" of this particular organism.

If it was an intentional lab leak/release then that could be avoided in the future by? Improving lab security? If lab security related to integrity of personnel is currently inadequate then that can be identified and improved without knowing the exact mechanism of the release of this particular organism.

If it is a naturally occurring virus that was transferred from animals to humans without ever being present in a lab then this can be prevented by? Altering nature to prevent future occurrences of such organisms?

In fact, humans have been altering nature and much of the result of that alteration has been reduced natural habitats for a large number of animals and the increasing of jumps of viruses from their reservoir hosts to new hosts, and often these will spillover to humans: Hendra, Ebola, Nipah, SARS-1, MERS and AIDS all likely came from wildlife and often because of humans interaction with wildlife.

Many virologists argue that this is what makes virus surveillance important and also experiments with viruses in labs to see which have pandemic potential.

Another side of this argument is that, no, those virologists are wrong, and what they are doing is making a pandemic more likely because of their visits to the countryside and their playing with the viruses.

So I don't think this is merely an academic argument, although prior to Covid-19 the argument was indeed being fought in academia and hence there had been arguments about whether or not such research should have been allowed.
 
In fact, humans have been altering nature and much of the result of that alteration has been reduced natural habitats for a large number of animals and the increasing of jumps of viruses from their reservoir hosts to new hosts, and often these will spillover to humans: Hendra, Ebola, Nipah, SARS-1, MERS and AIDS all likely came from wildlife and often because of humans interaction with wildlife.

Many virologists argue that this is what makes virus surveillance important and also experiments with viruses in labs to see which have pandemic potential.

Another side of this argument is that, no, those virologists are wrong, and what they are doing is making a pandemic more likely because of their visits to the countryside and their playing with the viruses.

So I don't think this is merely an academic argument, although prior to Covid-19 the argument was indeed being fought in academia and hence there had been arguments about whether or not such research should have been allowed.

I don't have any real argument with anything you say here. I just don't see you providing any useful effects that will come from a day one, location one identification for the COVID-19 virus.
 
I don't have any real argument with anything you say here. I just don't see you providing any useful effects that will come from a day one, location one identification for the COVID-19 virus.

I don't have anything useful to provide I am afraid. :con2:

I am just arguing over the evidence because that's what we do here.

Ultimately, however the origins are discovered I will have nothing to do with it.

And that goes for pretty much anything else that we argue about.

That said, the results of the finding probably wouldn't be meaningless.

It might come about that Gain of Function research really is too dangerous.

Alternatively, virologists might indeed find spillover incidents that lead to changes in how humans interact with nature.

Like I said, none of this will come from me, but I don't see the origins question as trivial. Far from it.
 
Well for example you might locate your labs somewhere else than in the middle of the city. As for animal source, unregulated consumption of wild animals can be improved upon.
I seriously doubt there would be nothing to learn.
 
...

Because that would certainly explain why most of your posts are from "LunaticRightWingConspiracies.com"
Bull ****. That's just people here and their confirmation bias, and once again trying to drag this thread over to the CT forum.

Have you found any sources to cite that challenge the facts in those sources I cites? [looks back a few pages] Nope, not a single source countering the sources I've cited.
 
Ignoring the opinions, accusations, insinuations and side tracks being bantered about in this thread it appears that, as of Sept 1 2021, there is precious little hard evidence pointing to an actual day one, single location origin of COVI-19. At this time, with 6+ million dead and the disease endemic in the world population I really don't see that the determination matters much any more, outside of academic scientific curiosity.

I agree with the bolded part.

There has been little new evidence though there has been some. For one, several sources support the conclusion there was a single initial event and that happened in Wuhan.

And we are now almost 2 years out and still no animal spillover source has been found. And China is still refusing to share some of the evidence they have.

But in general we are at the same place here that most scientists are at: both hypothesis are still on the table.
 
Last edited:
If it was an accidental lab leak this could be avoided in the future by? Improving lab security? If lab security related to methods is currently inadequate then that can be identified and improved without knowing the exact mechanism of the "escape" of this particular organism.

If it was an intentional lab leak/release then that could be avoided in the future by? Improving lab security? If lab security related to integrity of personnel is currently inadequate then that can be identified and improved without knowing the exact mechanism of the release of this particular organism.

If it is a naturally occurring virus that was transferred from animals to humans without ever being present in a lab then this can be prevented by? Altering nature to prevent future occurrences of such organisms?
I don't believe there is a shred of evidence that it was intentional.

There are a number of proposals about mitigating the lab risks, none of which are likely to be implemented.

But now we are in new territory. If it turns out this pandemic was the result of a lab accident it will give these researchers an unmistakeable lesson in how dangerously they have been acting.

If it was a natural spillover what is done will depend on if the source came from the wild animal trade or some direct exposure to the bats in Yunnan.
 
I don't believe there is a shred of evidence that it was intentional.
There are a number of proposals about mitigating the lab risks, none of which are likely to be implemented.

But now we are in new territory. If it turns out this pandemic was the result of a lab accident it will give these researchers an unmistakeable lesson in how dangerously they have been acting.

If it was a natural spillover what is done will depend on if the source came from the wild animal trade or some direct exposure to the bats in Yunnan.

FTR neither do I. And I am not suggesting anyone here does. I just included it as one of the options to be considered.
 
From an epidemiological POV (my area of expertise)

It's hard to believe that anyone with real expertise in epidemiology would have referred to Amy Elise Winter's letter to the editor as an "epidemiology study".

 
It's hard to believe that anyone with real expertise in epidemiology would have referred to Amy Elise Winter's letter to the editor as an "epidemiology study".

Why? You don't have to agree with the conclusions. No one is taking the results to mean anything was proven. It was a pilot study. That doesn't mean it wasn't a valid study. Are pilot studies a new concept for you?

They looked for a correlation between the number of COVID cases and the number of people who had recently come back from the Wuhan military games. That is epidemiology.

Every study is not an in-depth evaluation. Most studies you see reported in the news, for example, are only pilot studies. The point of pilot studies is to investigate if a larger or more in-depth study should be undertaken.

I'm not sure why that is such a difficult concept for some people in this thread to grasp.

Of course the objective measures in that study weren't in any way conclusive. But they did show a correlation and that is enough to suggest it should be evaluated further.

If you think I posted it as some kind of conclusive evidence you would be mistaken. This is a science thread. I have an expectation people in this discussion understand the difference between weak and strong evidence, between a pilot study and a larger in-depth one, between a study using very limited resources and a well funded study, between the BS in a politically biased report and the evidence one can take away from that same report...
For example, Daszak is a seriously politically biased source and it puts the WHO report in the same category. But there are a lot of things in the WHO report that shouldn't be discounted. Some of the report includes a systematic review of sentinel indicators of illness all over China in the whole year of 2019. That was very relevant and not affected by Daszak's influence.

That is what you do with all of these sources, you evaluate them and assess their validity and usefulness.
Did that pilot study done on a shoestring budget tell us anything? Yes, it told us there might very well be a correlation between the military games and the rapid spread of COVID around the world. It is well worth investigating further.

Whether any of the involved countries are investigating further is out of those researchers control. It depends on if the countries involved choose to look more closely at the people who participated in the Wuhan military games. That pilot study will be of value if it triggered any of those countries to look closer.
 
They looked for a correlation between the number of COVID cases and the number of people who had recently come back from the Wuhan military games. That is epidemiology.
By "they", you mean Amy Elise Winter, the poet.

There is a correlation between the population of a European country and the number of athletes it sent to an international event.

There is a correlation between the population of a European country and the number of COVID-19 cases in that country.

Neither of those correlations offers any kind of clue regarding the origins of COVID-19.

As a matter of statistics and mathematics, the combination of those two correlations implies a correlation between the number of athletes a country sent to the event and the number of COVID-19 cases in the country. That statistical/mathematical consequence cannot offer any kind of clue regarding the origins of COVID-19, because neither of its two antecedents offer any such clue.

Every study is not an in-depth evaluation. Most studies you see reported in the news, for example, are only pilot studies. The point of pilot studies is to investigate if a larger or more in-depth study should be undertaken.
This particular "pilot study" was a meaningless back-of-the-envelope calculation that offers absolutely no guidance concerning whether larger or more in-depth studies should be undertaken.

I'm not sure why that is such a difficult concept for some people in this thread to grasp.
Here's why: Because some of us possess some small degree of scientific and statistical literacy, and are able to apply what limited knowledge we possess when evaluating claims made in discussions such as this.

Of course the objective measures in that study weren't in any way conclusive. But they did show a correlation and that is enough to suggest it should be evaluated further.
As I have explained, this particular correlation is completely meaningless. Meaningless correlations do not suggest they should be evaluated further.

This is a science thread. I have an expectation people in this discussion understand the difference between weak and strong evidence, between a pilot study and a larger in-depth one, between a study using very limited resources and a well funded study, between the BS in a politically biased report and the evidence one can take away from that same report...
What you have heard from angrysoba and from me is the result of people understanding those differences, and recognizing that your citation of Amy Elise Winter's letter to the editor does not even rise to the level of weak evidence, let alone something worthy of being called a "pilot study".

That is what you do with all of these sources, you evaluate them and assess their validity and usefulness.
Indeed. You may not like it when people do that, but we do it anyway.

Did that pilot study done on a shoestring budget tell us anything? Yes, it told us there might very well be a correlation between the military games and the rapid spread of COVID around the world.
No. What it really told us is that, when we restrict our attention to European countries, there is definitely a correlation between population and the number of athletes sent to an event, and it also told us there is definitely a correlation between the population of such countries and the number of COVID-19 cases in the country.

It is well worth investigating further.
No. The sun tends to rise in the east. If the sun were observed to rise in the west, then there would be reason to investigate further. Watching the sun rise in the east is not a reason to investigate further.

More populated countries tend to have more cases of COVID-19, and also tend to have more athletes. That makes the correlation between number of athletes and number of cases no more surprising or interesting or informative than the correlation between sunrise and a glow in the east. If the correlation observed by Amy Elise Winter did not exist, then it would be reasonable to ask why and to investigate further. But that correlation does exist, to which the proper scientific response is "Well, duh."
 
By "they", you mean Amy Elise Winter, the poet.

There is a correlation between the population of a European country and the number of athletes it sent to an international event.

There is a correlation between the population of a European country and the number of COVID-19 cases in that country.

Neither of those correlations offers any kind of clue regarding the origins of COVID-19.
I'm not sure that's true. Have you done your back of the envelope calculation or are you just making that assessment up?

What data did you access and use in your assertion?

As a matter of statistics and mathematics, the combination of those two correlations implies a correlation between the number of athletes a country sent to the event and the number of COVID-19 cases in the country. That statistical/mathematical consequence cannot offer any kind of clue regarding the origins of COVID-19, because neither of its two antecedents offer any such clue.

This particular "pilot study" was a meaningless back-of-the-envelope calculation that offers absolutely no guidance concerning whether larger or more in-depth studies should be undertaken.
I don't think you've proven your case here. I'd need to see which countries you think are larger and sent more attendees to the games. And I'd need to see the numbers of attendees.

Here's why: Because some of us possess some small degree of scientific and statistical literacy, and are able to apply what limited knowledge we possess when evaluating claims made in discussions such as this.
Which you are obviously welcome to do....


More populated countries tend to have more cases of COVID-19, and also tend to have more athletes. That makes the correlation between number of athletes and number of cases no more surprising or interesting or informative than the correlation between sunrise and a glow in the east. If the correlation observed by Amy Elise Winter did not exist, then it would be reasonable to ask why and to investigate further. But that correlation does exist, to which the proper scientific response is "Well, duh."
You've gone to a lot of trouble here but you haven't posted data to back up your assertion.

It doesn't matter, lay person or established researcher. Wise wrote the letter to the scientific journal "Irish Journal of Medical Science" describing the study and the results and the journal published the letter.

Not sure if you'll see the page and search criteria but this is the search result.
Article
The impact of the World Military Games on the COVID-19 pandemic
Amy Elise Winter in Irish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -) (2021)

Download PDF (158 KB) View Article

I think sometimes in this forum people get so immersed in discounting invalid sources they don't recognize when weak but not invalid evidence is posted.

If you have that rebuttal evidence you should post it. We would all benefit from that.
 
SG, you must admit that the "lab leak hypothesis" looks and sounds like an evil scientist myth.

200w.webp
 
SG, you must admit that the "lab leak hypothesis" looks and sounds like an evil scientist myth.

[qimg]https://media3.giphy.com/media/1XeHuHcR6Mo50PibPW/200w.webp?cid=ecf05e47nzs45zabc6l5jdivjv6r4eftwgjrb1612u8voa5u&rid=200w.webp&ct=g[/qimg]

No it ******* doesn't!

It sounds like an hypothesis China, Shi and Daszak among others tried to squelch and after a year there is now a majority of researchers that believe both hypotheses, a natural event and a lab accident are plausible. Yes it is a majority.

Some people can't let go of the initial portrayal of the lab accident as highly unlikely.

What is highly unlikely OTOH is not finding a source of a natural spillover after nearly 2 years.

What is highly unlikely is the virus entered the population ready to go following a natural event.

What is unlikely is that a natural event took place far from Yunnan where one might expect it and instead took place in a city where multiple labs were specifically studying coronaviruses, and not just that but coronaviruses that posed a risk of a pandemic.


These kinds of lab accidents where people were infected with deadly diseases have occurred multiple times in multiple countries. To pretend that only happens in the movies or whatever is naive.
 
No it ******* doesn't!

It sounds like an hypothesis China, Shi and Daszak among others tried to squelch and after a year there is now a majority of researchers that believe both hypotheses, a natural event and a lab accident are plausible. Yes it is a majority.

Some people can't let go of the initial portrayal of the lab accident as highly unlikely.

What is highly unlikely OTOH is not finding a source of a natural spillover after nearly 2 years.

What is highly unlikely is the virus entered the population ready to go following a natural event.

What is unlikely is that a natural event took place far from Yunnan where one might expect it and instead took place in a city where multiple labs were specifically studying coronaviruses, and not just that but coronaviruses that posed a risk of a pandemic.


These kinds of lab accidents where people were infected with deadly diseases have occurred multiple times in multiple countries. To pretend that only happens in the movies or whatever is naive.

The idea that it's a lab leak sounds like it's a human-made virus.

You MUST admit that sounds like a CT.
 
The idea that it's a lab leak sounds like it's a human-made virus.

You MUST admit that sounds like a CT.
Move past sounds and read the words. Just leave this thread and read the report the Biden administration just released. Man made is pretty close to rejected, but lab leak is plausible. They are not the same thing.

And even though it doesn't seem to be a likely explanation for Covid 19, man made virus should not sound like a conspiracy theory. Humans are quite definitely making viruses. That is simply a fact.
 
The idea that it's a lab leak sounds like it's a human-made virus.

You MUST admit that sounds like a CT.
Lab accidents have happened including a recent one cited here where the researcher got COVID 19 from a lab accident. How was that event a CT?

Your premise requires a specific definition of "human-made".

From my post # 2205:

According to Bostickson, "This research involved 'novel' bat coronaviruses inoculated into immuno-suppressed mice with humanised features, such as hACE2, and possibly humanised lungs, bone marrow, etc..." He added that "Such experiments were a recipe for disaster, as we know."

SG said:
In immunosuppressed humans, infection with COVID 19 results in more viral replication and the incidence of variant strains emerging. No doubt it is similar in immunosuppressed mice with related coronaviruses.
So would you include any strains of coronavirus that resulted from such a technique in your definition of "human-made"?



Who is Bostickson?
On Friday (Jan. 8), a researcher who goes by the pseudonym Billy Bostickson and his colleagues at DRASTIC (Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating Covid-19) posted a Twitter thread demanding answers about a state-funded project at the WIV in 2019 that involved infecting transgenic mice with bat coronaviruses. The scientist who headed this project is assistant researcher Hu Ben (胡犇), according to the National Natural Science Foundation of China.

Is DRASTIC credible? Yes. They uncovered both the masters and PhD theses on the 6 miners infected in Yunnan back in 2012 that was at fist mistaken for a new SARS outbreak. They addressed the data bases China took offline in Sept 2019.

How the coronavirus origin story is being rewritten by a guerrilla Twitter group - The group, known as Drastic, has investigated, corrected, uncovered and agitated in a quest to uncover the pandemic's starting point.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom