Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

In my opinion, this committee has no evidence to support most of its claims, and that it is basically a partisan hack job.
Quelle surprise.
There is no evidence of a precursor virus in the Wuhan lab, still less for Fauci having funded the creation of SARS-CoV2.

The complaints about the FDA discouraging people from turning to ivermectin is a stupid sideline. Apparently some idiots are upset because the FDA effectively mocked people who claimed that ivermectin was a cure or a prophylactic for Covid.


When it comes to masks, there is something infuriating about this. In Japan, people universally masked up, and I am pretty sure that that, plus a kind of soft lockdown slowed the spread of the virus.
This isn't about facts or evidence. That's all just BS the liberal elites use to control us. The only thing that's actually real and matters is our freedoms, and how the government - by merely existing - abrogates them. The FDA discouraging people from turning to ivermectin is not a stupid sideline, it's right at the heart of the matter. How dare they attempt to infringe on our fundamental right to take whatever we please?

You have to understand why this medicine is so important to us. You see, Covid doesn't exist, because if did then enforced quarantines would be reasonable. So we won't abide by them, which means we could get Covid - and then we will need a powerful drug to diispatch it before it kills us.

In case you still don't get it, let me spell it out for you - my freedoms matter, yours don't. It's all about me being able to do whatever I want - however 'stupid' it may be. If you tell me something's stupid then I will do it just to prove that you can't intimidate me. I had to obey your rules when I was a kid because you were bigger than me, but I'm an adult now so I don't have to do what you tell me anymore!

I would also suggest that the fact that flu almost completely dropped off during the Covid years indicates masking and social distancing must have done something.
Yes, and it was devastating - for the 'health' industry.
 
True! SARS-CoV-2 was a leaked bioweapon made by Fauci in a Chinese lab. Also, it doesn't exist, which is why the vaccines are just a form of control, through chips - just ask RFK Jr. He knows that the Wi-Fi is giving us all brain cancer. Also, they stopped us taking ivermectin which is the real cure for the bioweapon that doesn't exist.
 
Idiocy and severe cope with the facts that are so evident now are still strong in this forum thread.
.
Politics has no place in scientific reality but many of you delusional leftists just keep pretending it matters. Lalalalalala. "Not from the lab"... lalalalala. CRAZY conspiracy!
Right wing conspiracy because it is the obvious source... lalalalalalalal.... nothing to see here......

The spillover scam doled out to us within days of the virus spreading is discredited 1000x over. Just deal with it.
 
Idiocy and severe cope with the facts that are so evident now are still strong in this forum thread.
.
Politics has no place in scientific reality but many of you delusional leftists just keep pretending it matters. Lalalalalala. "Not from the lab"... lalalalala. CRAZY conspiracy!
Right wing conspiracy because it is the obvious source... lalalalalalalal.... nothing to see here......

The spillover scam doled out to us within days of the virus spreading is discredited 1000x over. Just deal with it.
Lots of rhetoric there, sherkeu, about the "spillover scam". Who was "doling out the spillover scam"?
 
Well the White House has spoken, we can close down this thread, what Trump says must be true he is the PotUS.


Lab leak is now cannon. Universities and researchers who dispute this will be viewed as enemies of the state, if non-US citizens they can expect to be deported, there will be no government funding for research that might contradict the Lab Leak theory and presumably funding for supporters.

What I think is especially egregious is the naming of particular scientists framing them as enemies of the state Fauci, Daszak, Morens.
 
Let's look at the claims on the website front page:

1. The virus possesses a biological characteristic that is not found in nature.

That's false.

2. Data shows that all COVID-19 cases stem from a single introduction into humans. This runs contrary to previous pandemics where there were multiple spillover events.

Not according to a few papers on the origin which saw two introductions. In addition, it is strange to argue that previous pandemics show multiple spillover events when we don't know the origin of all of them.

3. Wuhan is home to China’s foremost SARS research lab, which has a history of conducting gain-of-function research (gene altering and organism supercharging) at inadequate biosafety levels.

This is broadly true, although I think some scientists will dispute some of those terms.

4. Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) researchers were sick with COVID-like symptoms in the fall of 2019, months before COVID-19 was discovered at the wet market.

This has been claimed but some of the claims look dubious. At one point the proponents even named who they thought the workers were but this looks more and more like BS.

5. By nearly all measures of science, if there was evidence of a natural origin it would have already surfaced. But it hasn’t.

This is silly. There are all kinds of illnesses which we do not know the origins are. Claiming "all measures of science" would have detected it is moronic. Think about HIV/AIDS for example. It took a long time to find the origins, and even now, many of the MAGA people claim something that goes against the scientific consensus.

Then they link to the House report which goes on about all kinds of bugbears of the right-wing such as how ivermectin was ridiculed as a treatment for Covid-19 which presumably made it harder for the Trump-supporting hucksters to sling their snakeoil, etc...

And more stuff about how the Great Barrington Declaration was unfairly demonized, etc...

Anyway, these are the types of people in charge now, so just hope that bird flu doesn't become a pandemic this presidential term.
 
I don't know what to say. Much of the report has been covered throughout this thread. I used to write quite a lot about this, but it seems that few people are interested, and quite often people will turn up in the thread to complain that there is nothing new in the posts, which is true.

In my opinion, this committee has no evidence to support most of its claims, and that it is basically a partisan hack job.

There is no evidence of a precursor virus in the Wuhan lab, still less for Fauci having funded the creation of SARS-CoV2.
Reason reported, "The White House budget calls for slashing $17 billion in funding for the National Institutes of Health (NIH), citing the agency's failure to properly monitor risky gain-of-function research it funded at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV)—where the COVID-19 pandemic plausibly originated. "While evidence of the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic leaking from a laboratory is now confirmed by several intelligence agencies, the NIH's inability to prove that its grants to the Wuhan Institute of Virology were not complicit in such a possible leak, or get data and hold recipients of Federal funding accountable is evidence that NIH has grown too big and unfocused," reads the budget summary released on Friday."
Reading the passage above brought me back to this thread. Is there a consensus among scientists on the origin? I suspect that there is.
 
Reason reported, "The White House budget calls for slashing $17 billion in funding for the National Institutes of Health (NIH), citing the agency's failure to properly monitor risky gain-of-function research it funded at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV)—where the COVID-19 pandemic plausibly originated.
"While evidence of the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic leaking from a laboratory is now confirmed by several intelligence agencies, the NIH's inability to prove that its grants to the Wuhan Institute of Virology were not complicit in such a possible leak, or get data and hold recipients of Federal funding accountable is evidence that NIH has grown too big and unfocused," reads the budget summary released on Friday."
Reading the passage above brought me back to this thread. Is there a consensus among scientists on the origin? I suspect that there is.
"confirmed"!?

Jesus frickking Christ.

No, it is not confirmed by intelligence agencies. Mostly what we are seeing are some intelligence agencies saying that they have a low confidence belief in either one origin or another.

On the other hand, the last that I heard was that the majority of relevant scientists believe in a natural, zoonotic origin, mostly likely involving the wet market.

Some people will claim that the only reason why these experts believe this is because they have been misled by a cabal headed up by Peter Daszak or Anthony Fauci.

Or... they are doing so because their funding relies on it.

In other words, cynically suggesting that the scientists are stupid or corrupt.

No doubt that plays well with MAGA.
 
The reason you don't see any evidence, @angrysoba, is because you've dismissed it all with a hand wave while elevating weak evidence despite it not sufficiently supporting the natural spillover theory.

As for which side of the aisle supports which theory, those are all red herrings that don't support either theory. The fact that Trump believes COVID is the "China Virus" is meaningless one way or the other. It does not in any way contradict the lab leak theory. The same was true re the initial right-wing support for the lab-leak hypothesis: that didn't support either origin theory.

Some of these political positions do provide some evidentiary support when one looks at the first emails between a group of US scientist administrators who then within days refuted their own email exchanges. Short of a confession, there had not been time to change their conclusions.
 
Last edited:
The reason you don't see any evidence, @angrysoba, is because you've dismissed it all with a hand wave while elevating weak evidence despite it not sufficiently supporting the natural spillover theory.
I didn’t say “I don’t see any evidence”.

But some of the claims are easy to dismiss such as your claim that there had been a “study” that correlated participation in the Wuhan Military Games with cases at a particular time in Europe. It was a laughably pathetic “study”.

Similarly, I dismissed the “evidence” of some guy who went on InfoWars to say he had once worked at EcoHealth alliance years before the pandemic and now wants Daszak and Fauci to be executed. You were reading his book and promising to tell us all the juicy gossip once you found it. As far as I remember you never reported back what you found in the book.


As for which side of the aisle supports which theory, those are all red herrings that don't support either theory. The fact that Trump believes COVID is the "China Virus" is meaningless one way or the other. It does not in any way contradict the lab leak theory. The same was true re the initial right-wing support for the lab-leak hypothesis: that didn't support either origin theory.

Some of these political positions do provide some evidentiary support when one looks at the first emails between a group of US scientist administrators who then within days refuted their own email exchanges. Short of a confession, there had not been time to change their conclusions.
The scientists who were looking into it, including the authors of the Proximal Origins paper, absolutely were concerned that the virus appeared potentially tampered with. But what do you think they were considering? Possibly the fact that they knew (better than we did) that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was right there in the city, and that coupled with the structure of the virus was what formed much of their early concerns. It was after they looked into other viruses not too far removed from SARS-CoV-2 and found that the structure wasn’t as unusual as they had initially feared that they changed their position on this.

I don’t know how it is that you claim to know how quickly someone can do this.
 
As it happens, it was those initial concerns that led to some of the intelligence services around the world making initial assessments of a likely lab-origin.

In Jeremy Fararr’s book, he said that when people like Andersen and Holmes had said that they thought it was lab-manipulated they started giving numbers like 80%.Farrar says Patrick Vallance immediately got on the phone to British intelligence to tell them.

In recent times we have seen reports about, say, German intelligence claiming that they put the lab origin at 80%. But what we also see is that those were assessments made at almost the same time and often with similar wording. In other words these intelligence agencies often give assessments based on what the scientists think at the time or else they simply report things with low confidence because they really don’t know.

Anyway, the question was what scientists think now, and as I mentioned the surveys tend to show scientists in a relevant field think there was a natural origin.


a research team led by the Global Catastrophic Risk Institute (GCRI) and Nemesys Insights conducted a rigorous survey of global expert opinion. The anonymous survey included 168 virologists, infectious disease epidemiologists, and other scientists from 47 countries in a geographic sample of both developed and developing countries. This is the first-ever systematic study of expert opinion on the origin of COVID-19.

Main findings from the survey include: • The study’s experts overall stated that the COVID-19 pandemic most likely originated via a natural zoonotic event, defined as an event in which a non-human animal infected a human, and in which the infection did not occur in the course of any form of virological or biomedical research. The experts generally gave a lower probability for origin via a research-related accident, but most experts indicated some chance of origin via accident and about one fifth of the experts stated that an accident was the more likely origin. These beliefs were similar across experts from different geographic and academic backgrounds.
 
Last edited:
From the journal Science: "Bhattacharya also shares the view held by some politicians and scientists that SARS-COV-2 did not jump from animals to humans naturally, but leaked from a Wuhan, China, lab that had genetically engineered the virus to be more dangerous...Bhattacharya is a signatory on letters calling peer-reviewed papers in Science and elsewhere that support a natural origin for SARS-Cov-2 “potentially products of scientific misconduct—including fraud” and deserving of retraction—a stance the journals have rejected." That is...interesting.
 
Last edited:
Further research favours a zoonotic transfer on at least two occasions at the Wuhan wet market.
We find that these two recently published T/T genomes do not represent an evolutionarily intermediate haplotype and were, instead, derived from either lineage A or lineage B. However, we cannot conclusively determine from which lineage they were derived. After including additional data from the start of the pandemic, including these two T/T genomes, we again find a discrepancy in the molecular clock when inferring the ancestral haplotype of SARS-CoV-2, corroborating existing evidence for the separate introductions of SARS-CoV-2 lineages A and B into the human population in late 2019.
we identified SARS-CoV-2 lineages that may have spread from the market, and additional samples of a sublineage of lineage A with three mutations, including one found in closely related bat coronaviruses. Although our analysis of early pandemic genomes suggests that this mutation is unlikely to characterize the immediate SARS-CoV-2 ancestor, it is more plausible than two previously proposed ancestral genomes. These findings reinforce the proposed emergence of SARS-CoV-2 from the wildlife trade at the Huanan market, demonstrating how new data continues to both solidify and clarify our understanding of how the pandemic began.
Study on infected health care workers also identifies the earliest geographic focus as the wet market.
High–high clustering occurred in the infection hot spot area, which was mainly concentrated around the South China Seafood Market in the central city.
A study on blood donors finds no evidence of significant circulation of SARS-CoV-2 before December 2019.
Our findings showed no SARS-CoV-2-specific antibodies existing among blood donors in Wuhan, China before 2020, indicating no evidence of transmission of COVID-19 before December 2019 in Wuhan, China.

So further research supports the zoonotic origin and contradicts some alternative theories such as an early outbreak amongst laboratory staff or at the military games.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom