Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Rumble video? Who is this doctor? Is he actually a doctor or anything relevant? Is he a lawyer? Why is this even here?
Mainly because he presents evidence and a timeline of the Covid 19 pandemic that you are welcome to refute point by point.

Lad's a financial analyst well known for promulgating lies about covid.
Why here is the good doctor now, promulgating lies about covid before the European Union Parliament in May 2023

And no, he has no relevant expertise.
Doctor David E. Martin PhD delineates his expertise and bona fides in the Biological warfare agents field in the Rumble video above.
Well, I wish I could say I was surprised that someone with no qualifications is being lauded as some kind of expert on this topic, but that has been a recurring theme.
Until you point out examples of this man "promulgating lies" and his "lack of expertise on this topic" in his presentation before the European Union Parliament You owe the good doctor an apology.
 
Last edited:
Why here is the good doctor now, promulgating lies about covid before the European Union Parliament in May 2023


Doctor David E. Martin PhD delineates his expert bona fides in the Biological warfare agents field in the Rumble video above.

Until you point out examples of this man "promulgating lies" and his "lack of expertise on this topic" in his presentation before the European Union Parliament You owe the good doctor an apology.
Nope. That’s not how it works.

I’m asking you what his credentials are to decide whether it is a good use of my time to watch the video.

The heuristics so far are not promising.

If YOU tell me his credentials I might consider watching or looking into it more. Can you do that?
 
"In his 20-minute presentation to the summit, Martin argued that the U.S. government and leading vaccine-maker Pfizer nefariously manufactured and released coronavirus before both the 2003 SARS pandemic and COVID-19 pandemic in order to ensure that the world would accept a universal vaccine template. While he claimed to present evidence of U.S.-sponsored biological terrorism on slides during his presentation, none of the summit recordings showed these slides and therefore leave most of his claims without proof of hard evidence for viewers." link

Martin's claim: “SARS is the research developed by humans, weaponizing a life system model to actually attack human beings, and they patented it in 2002.”; “The intent was to get the world to accept a universal vaccine template, and the intent was to use coronavirus to get there”

Science Verdict's response: "Misleading: Contrary to Martin’s claims, early research on coronaviruses didn’t involve modified viruses nor human experimentation apart from studies of infections with naturally-occurring human coronaviruses establishing that these viruses caused colds.
Factually inaccurate: Old patent applications for coronavirus vaccines and vectors cited by Martin are for animal coronaviruses. None of them is related to SARS-CoV-2 nor do they prove that the virus was developed as a bioweapon." link2

Martin's ideas are pretty far out there.
 
"In his 20-minute presentation to the summit, Martin argued that the U.S. government and leading vaccine-maker Pfizer nefariously manufactured and released coronavirus before both the 2003 SARS pandemic and COVID-19 pandemic in order to ensure that the world would accept a universal vaccine template. While he claimed to present evidence of U.S.-sponsored biological terrorism on slides during his presentation, none of the summit recordings showed these slides and therefore leave most of his claims without proof of hard evidence for viewers." link

Martin's claim: “SARS is the research developed by humans, weaponizing a life system model to actually attack human beings, and they patented it in 2002.”; “The intent was to get the world to accept a universal vaccine template, and the intent was to use coronavirus to get there”

Science Verdict's response: "Misleading: Contrary to Martin’s claims, early research on coronaviruses didn’t involve modified viruses nor human experimentation apart from studies of infections with naturally-occurring human coronaviruses establishing that these viruses caused colds.
Factually inaccurate: Old patent applications for coronavirus vaccines and vectors cited by Martin are for animal coronaviruses. None of them is related to SARS-CoV-2 nor do they prove that the virus was developed as a bioweapon." link2

Martin's ideas are pretty far out there.

Well, what a surprise!

@Fonebone, don't you think that YOU owe us an apology for wasting a few minutes of our lives hearing about that crank?

Say you're sorry!
 
Well, what a surprise!

@Fonebone, don't you think that YOU owe us an apology for wasting a few minutes of our lives hearing about that crank?

Say you're sorry!
"No great epidemic has ever evolved divorced from major socio-political upheaval."
Dr. Leonard Horowitz 2003
[excerpt]...
These PSYOPS for command and control warfare (C2W), military and behavior experts correctly advise, best support a well-defined rapidly evolving "Revolution in Military Affairs" (RMA) which is synonymous to a the evolution into "a form of human slavery" in which the captives-the world's population, including you and your loved ones-would not perceive this enslavement.
The RMA incorporates the use of debilitating biological weapons and incapacitating chemicals, similar to the toxic carcinogenic organophosphate pesticides deployed against mosquitoes in the "War Against the West Nile Virus." These are often called "non-lethal warfare" agents, yet are indeed deadly. Death results slowly along with advancing mortality from such toxic exposures. Larger profits are made by allied pharmaceutical and medical industrialists as victims of the "non-lethal" exposures die slowly, commonly in expensive hospitals and long-term care facilities, from chronic debilitating diseases. Most of these ailments, including the plethora of autoimmune diseases and newer cancers, were virtually non-existent 50 years ago. This fact, alone, strongly suggests a modern socio-economic and political conspiracy. Unless you simply wish to believe it is God's will or man's greed that has brought these conditions to bear upon humanity.

"People are all too willing to relinquish their civil rights and personal freedoms in the wake of such engineered frights." [/excerpt]
 
Last edited:
Looks like there is another paper out about the common ancestors of SARS and SARS-CoV-2:


The emergence of SARS-CoV in 2002 and SARS-CoV-2 in 2019 has led to increased sampling of related sarbecoviruses circulating primarily in horseshoe bats. These viruses undergo frequent recombination and exhibit spatial structuring across Asia. Employing recombination-aware phylogenetic inference on bat sarbecoviruses, we find that the closest-inferred bat virus ancestors of SARS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2 existed just ~1–3 years prior to their emergence in humans. Phylogeographic analyses examining the movement of related sarbecoviruses demonstrate that they traveled at similar rates to their horseshoe bat hosts and have been circulating for thousands of years in Asia. The closest-inferred bat virus ancestor of SARS-CoV likely circulated in western China, and that of SARS-CoV-2 likely circulated in a region comprising southwest China and northern Laos, both a substantial distance from where they emerged. This distance and recency indicate that the direct ancestors of SARS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2 could not have reached their respective sites of emergence via the bat reservoir alone. Our recombination-aware dating and phylogeographic analyses reveal a more accurate inference of evolutionary history than performing only whole-genome or single gene analyses. These results can guide future sampling efforts and demonstrate that viral genomic fragments extremely closely related to SARS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2 were circulating in horseshoe bats, confirming their importance as the reservoir species for SARS viruses.
 
My understanding of this is that some other species of animal was necessary for the jump from bats to humans.

I wonder if @Capsid has seen it or has any opinion one way or another?

My opinion is that what Pekar, Worobey and co. are doing is actual science. Whereas what, say, Alina Chan and Matt Ridley are doing is more like the equivalent of Graham Hancock’s contribution to archeology.
 
Does the lab-leak hypothesis necessarily mean that the virus was being engineered as a weapon and accidentally escaped? Or does the lab-leak hypothesis mean only there was a mutational study (possibly gain of function) of the virus for basic science reasons and this variant escaped? The reason why I ask this (probably naive) question is that the idea of a virus as a weapon has some problems. Once the virus is released, it might jump species to farm animals and cause worldwide starvation, meaning it could do as much harm to the country of origin as the country being attacked. I don't mean to suggest that viruses are never bioweapons, however.
 
Last edited:
Does the lab-leak hypothesis necessarily mean that the virus was being engineered as a weapon and accidentally escaped? Or does the lab-leak hypothesis mean only there was a mutational study (possibly gain of function) of the virus for basic science reasons and this variant escaped? The reason why I ask this (probably naive) question is that the idea of a virus as a weapon has some problems. Once the virus is released, it might jump species to farm animals and cause worldwide starvation, meaning it could do as much harm to the country of origin as the country being attacked. I don't mean to suggest that viruses are never bioweapons, however.

Chris, that's a good question.

I think the main issue with the lab-leak hypothesis is that doesn't seem to be one theory. Instead, proponents will pick up and discard any component of a theory at will with the sole aim of implicating the lab or a lab (the lab in question itself also does not seem to be a settled matter in lab leak circles). It doesn't seem to matter which. In fact, the origin of SARS-CoV-2 has coincided with the evolution of another virus, which is the meme "lab leak hypothesis". It bumbles around trying to find purchase on mental receptors, and when it doesn't, it mutates and tries again.

The bioweapon theory was the OG lab leak theory, IIRC, or perhaps the original strain. One of the big neon signs for this one was the fact that there was a BSL-4 lab (The only one in China!!!! so the the claim went; although even then it wasn't as there is a BSL-4 in Harbin as well) at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Sometimes the current meme will retain some of its ancestral links to this original strain, as when some of the GOP Congresspeople blather on about Chinese military connections to Covid. It was against these claims that a lot of the original papers and letters such as Proximal Origins and Daszak's letter to the Lancet were written. But it seems that even intelligence services around the world find these claims to be... unlikely at best. As you say, the theory doesn't really make a lot of sense.

As the bioweapon theory failed to really get going, the gain of function arguments took over. Now it is not the BSL-4 labs that raise eyebrows, instead it is reports of work on pseudoviruses and virus collections from caves in Yunnan Province took over. Now it is claimed that BSL-2 labs may have been the culprit, and it is claimed to have come either from a separate WIV campus or maybe from the Wuhan CDC labs that were close to the Huanan Wet Market. Jeffrey Sachs, possibly following the Chinese lead, has decided that the lab that should be implicated is Ralph Baric's lab in the University of North Carolina.

Also, the lab leak theory has multiple sub-theories about how it got into and out of the lab. Some claim the virus was extracted from some sick miners and then underwent serial passaging in the lab. Some claim that the collectors of viruses themselves got sick directly from bats. Some, like Matt Ridley and Alina Chan wrote a whole book essentially arguing that SARS-CoV-2 came from RaTG-13, the closest known virus to SARS-CoV-2 that the WIV had sampled, although either not long before the book came out or shortly after, a virus in Laos called BANAL-52 was discovered that was closer to RaTG-13.

For me, it seems that the fundamental core of the zoonotic theory remains the same, with some gaps that need to be filled in (as with most emerging viruses), whereas the lab leak theory is a collection of factoids which often don't cohere.
 
My understanding of this is that some other species of animal was necessary for the jump from bats to humans.

I wonder if @Capsid has seen it or has any opinion one way or another?

My opinion is that what Pekar, Worobey and co. are doing is actual science. Whereas what, say, Alina Chan and Matt Ridley are doing is more like the equivalent of Graham Hancock’s contribution to archeology.
I thought an intermediate species was proposed. Most likely raccoon dogs, which were present in the Huannan market. However, no virus was looked for either in the market or possible intermediate hosts, so will never know definitively unless we have SARS-COV-3.
 
As more science is done the evidence in favour of a natural zoonotic event increases. No new evidence in favour of a lab leak is being found. The problem is that it is never going to be possible to prove the zoonotic theory absolutely.

David Martin mentioned above believes that SARS was also bioengineered and both SARS (N-CoV-1) and Covid (N-CoV-2) were US bioweapons. he also believes HIV originated in hepatitis B vaccinations*. (Empirically untrue, because after HIV appeared a look back was done on people who received the hepB vaccine and they didn't develop AIDS.)

*The original hepatitis B vaccine was from live inactivated virus extracted from the blood of Americans with chronic hepatitis infection, many were prisoners and drug addicts who were at high risk of HIV. The inactivation process for the hepatitis B virus destroyed HIV, so the vaccine although theoretically a potential risk for HIV did not transmit HIV, but sadly also failed to immunise against HIV (which theoretically it might have done).
 
I thought an intermediate species was proposed. Most likely raccoon dogs, which were present in the Huannan market. However, no virus was looked for either in the market or possible intermediate hosts, so will never know definitively unless we have SARS-COV-3.
Yes, it has already been proposed that an intermediate species was involved, and the environmental swabs found evidence of raccoon dogs being kept in the wet market, specifically in areas associated with numerous early human infections.

The wet market was apparently cleaned up in a bid to stem the outbreak. Animals kept there were apparently destroyed and it was only later that mass swabbing of animals took place in and around the city, but susceptible animals such as raccoon dogs were already out of the picture.

May I ask if you know whether phylogenetic tests could be used to find evidence of the virus having been put through the serial passaging sometimes claimed by lab leak proponents of having produced the furin cleavage site?

I think there are two different arguments sometimes made by lab leakers, although I don’t know enough about the technical details:

A) that the furin cleavage site was developed through serial passaging, perhaps in transgenic mice.

B) that the furin cleavage site was inserted in the lab, either from another virus or somehow created there.

Again this seems to me to be part of lab leak proponents MO, that they might propose more than one theory at the same time and hop from one to the other depending upon what other contingent ideas are available.
 
Yes, it has already been proposed that an intermediate species was involved, and the environmental swabs found evidence of raccoon dogs being kept in the wet market, specifically in areas associated with numerous early human infections.

The wet market was apparently cleaned up in a bid to stem the outbreak. Animals kept there were apparently destroyed and it was only later that mass swabbing of animals took place in and around the city, but susceptible animals such as raccoon dogs were already out of the picture.

May I ask if you know whether phylogenetic tests could be used to find evidence of the virus having been put through the serial passaging sometimes claimed by lab leak proponents of having produced the furin cleavage site?

I think there are two different arguments sometimes made by lab leakers, although I don’t know enough about the technical details:

A) that the furin cleavage site was developed through serial passaging, perhaps in transgenic mice.

B) that the furin cleavage site was inserted in the lab, either from another virus or somehow created there.

Again this seems to me to be part of lab leak proponents MO, that they might propose more than one theory at the same time and hop from one to the other depending upon what other contingent ideas are available.
I don't think its possible reconstruct how the FCS could have been inserted through phylogeny. Do you mean by conducting serial passages and see what arises? That could be done but I still think an intermediate host is needed. Sampling the wet market for RNA would have been informative.
 
A good description of why the FCS could not have been bioengineered is here.


In essence
1) It was not a FCS that had ever been used in research before, and in doing research there would be no reason to choose an entirely novel FCS when there are 'off the shelf' ones that you would know worked.
2) The coding does not fit with how a human would code it. Humans would be consistent with the coding for amino acids and use the triplets that are highest affinity and less likely to break or mutate.
3) The insertion site is not where a human would insert the FCS.
4) peculiarities of how this FCS site works in particular the impact of nearby sequences, means that it could have not been designed by humans who did not have the technology or knowledge in 2019 to do this.

It is a complex bodge typical for an evolved system, but impossible to have designed ab initio.

The article also discusses how the FCS gets lost with passage, so the variants do show that they weren't the result of prolonged laboratory culture. There is a link on the web page to a detailed referenced pdf, which is worth downloading.

It is worth remembering the authors of the proximal origins paper initially thought a lab leak was likely. when they looked at the genetic sequences in detail they realised that a lab engineered virus was unlikely and that is what they said. They changed their minds, which some interpret as meaning they were got at, but more parsimoniously it meant they went where the evidence pointed them; to a natural zoonotic event.
 
Does the lab-leak hypothesis necessarily mean that the virus was being engineered as a weapon and accidentally escaped? Or does the lab-leak hypothesis mean only there was a mutational study (possibly gain of function) of the virus for basic science reasons and this variant escaped? The reason why I ask this (probably naive) question is that the idea of a virus as a weapon has some problems. Once the virus is released, it might jump species to farm animals and cause worldwide starvation, meaning it could do as much harm to the country of origin as the country being attacked. I don't mean to suggest that viruses are never bioweapons, however.
Doctor David E Martin believes nature's natural zoonotic function can be weaponized and in the case of Covid-19 demonstrates through patents and timelines exactly who, how and why the devolution of the annual winter influenza, the corona virus, was altered and groomed into the bio-weapon SARS2-covid19 influenza in order to terrorize the world's population into an abnormal panic and in conjunction with the world's mass medias inveigled the population stampede to the safe and effective miracle remedy, the vaccine.
May 2008
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2289981/
[excerpt] Zoonoses Likely to Be Used in Bioterrorism [/excerpt]
 
Last edited:
Doctor David E Martin believes nature's natural zoonotic function can be weaponized and in the case of Covid-19 demonstrates through patents and timelines exactly who, how and why the devolution of the annual winter influenza, the corona virus, was altered and groomed into the bio-weapon SARS2-covid19 influenza in order to terrorize the world's population into an abnormal panic and in conjunction with the world's mass medias inveigled the population stampede to the safe and effective miracle remedy, the vaccine.
May 2008

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2289981/[excerpt] Zoonoses Likely to Be Used in Bioterrorism [/excerpt]
Except the patents were about animal coronaviruses.

There is no way that the various allegations from David martin (who has no scientific background) could result in SARS-cov-2. Nor SARS -CoV-1 which he also alleges was engineered in the same way.) He does not argue for a laboratory leak as he argues the US government deliberately created a virus and deliberately released it. The Chinese were innocent victims of a massive conspiracy between 'Big Pharma', governments etc.

Even if you accept it was theoretically possible to engineer a virus, that is different from proving it did happen, there is no evidence that any of these putative steps actually occurred. Also bio-engineering by the methods he talks about could not have resulted in SARS-CoV-2.

He talks about a universal vaccine being the reason for engineering he virus, but no such vaccine exists nor could exist.

Scientifically what he argues is complete nonsense that is why his talk is almost completely fact free and full of oblique references and insinuations.

Notably your reference does not mention coronaviruses as potential bio-warfare pathogens.

If you are really interested in facts rather than conspiracy theories read this article.

www.protagonist-science.com

Treacherous ancestry​

An extraordinary hunt for the ghosts of SARS-CoV-2
www.protagonist-science.com
www.protagonist-science.com
 
Why would anyone "terrorize the world's population into an abnormal panic and in conjunction with the world's mass medias inveigled the population stampede to the safe and effective miracle remedy, the vaccine"? Who would gain what by doing such a thing?
 
Except the patents were about animal coronaviruses.
Yes! Patents obtained on animal coronaviruses altered by Gain of Function manipulations.Dr. Martin
There is no way that the various allegations from David martin (who has no scientific background) could result in SARS-cov-2. Nor SARS -CoV-1 which he also alleges was engineered in the same way.)

He does not argue for a laboratory leak as he argues the US government deliberately created a virus and deliberately released it. The Chinese were innocent victims of a massive conspiracy between 'Big Pharma', governments etc.
This short Video the research of david E Martim indicates ,with evidence, the Chinese and American scientists were Siamese twins in the quest for corona virus Gain of Function research and development of SARS -Covid2.

Even if you accept it was theoretically possible to engineer a virus, that is different from proving it did happen, there is no evidence that any of these putative steps actually occurred. Also bio-engineering by the methods he talks about could not have resulted in SARS-CoV-2.

He talks about a universal vaccine being the reason for engineering he virus, but no such vaccine exists nor could exist.

Scientifically what he argues is complete nonsense that is why his talk is almost completely fact free and full of oblique references and insinuations.
Complete with facts, dates, patent numbers and contract trail timelines.

Notably your reference does not mention coronaviruses as potential bio-warfare pathogens.
If you are a genuine truth-seeker
this link provides an excellent primer
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7150198/#b0010
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom