Does the lab-leak hypothesis necessarily mean that the virus was being engineered as a weapon and accidentally escaped? Or does the lab-leak hypothesis mean only there was a mutational study (possibly gain of function) of the virus for basic science reasons and this variant escaped? The reason why I ask this (probably naive) question is that the idea of a virus as a weapon has some problems. Once the virus is released, it might jump species to farm animals and cause worldwide starvation, meaning it could do as much harm to the country of origin as the country being attacked. I don't mean to suggest that viruses are never bioweapons, however.
Chris, that's a good question.
I think the main issue with
the lab-leak hypothesis is that doesn't seem to be one theory. Instead, proponents will pick up and discard any component of a theory at will with the sole aim of implicating
the lab or
a lab (the lab in question itself also does not seem to be a settled matter in lab leak circles). It doesn't seem to matter which. In fact, the origin of SARS-CoV-2 has coincided with the evolution of another virus, which is the meme "lab leak hypothesis". It bumbles around trying to find purchase on mental receptors, and when it doesn't, it mutates and tries again.
The bioweapon theory was the OG lab leak theory, IIRC, or perhaps the original strain. One of the big neon signs for this one was the fact that there was a BSL-4 lab (The
only one in China!!!! so the the claim went; although even then it wasn't as there is a BSL-4 in Harbin as well) at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Sometimes the current meme will retain some of its ancestral links to this original strain, as when some of the GOP Congresspeople blather on about Chinese military connections to Covid. It was against these claims that a lot of the original papers and letters such as Proximal Origins and Daszak's letter to the Lancet were written. But it seems that even intelligence services around the world find these claims to be... unlikely at best. As you say, the theory doesn't really make a lot of sense.
As the bioweapon theory failed to really get going, the gain of function arguments took over. Now it is not the BSL-4 labs that raise eyebrows, instead it is reports of work on pseudoviruses and virus collections from caves in Yunnan Province took over. Now it is claimed that BSL-2 labs may have been the culprit, and it is claimed to have come either from a separate WIV campus or maybe from the Wuhan CDC labs that were close to the Huanan Wet Market. Jeffrey Sachs, possibly following the Chinese lead, has decided that the lab that should be implicated is Ralph Baric's lab in the University of North Carolina.
Also, the lab leak theory has multiple sub-theories about how it got into and out of the lab. Some claim the virus was extracted from some sick miners and then underwent serial passaging in the lab. Some claim that the collectors of viruses themselves got sick directly from bats. Some, like Matt Ridley and Alina Chan wrote a whole book essentially arguing that SARS-CoV-2 came from RaTG-13, the closest known virus to SARS-CoV-2 that the WIV had sampled, although either not long before the book came out or shortly after,
a virus in Laos called BANAL-52 was discovered that was closer to RaTG-13.
For me, it seems that the fundamental core of the zoonotic theory remains the same, with some gaps that need to be filled in (as with most emerging viruses), whereas the lab leak theory is a collection of factoids which often don't cohere.