Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

So Worobey et al fixed an error in their paper?

Oooowww, discredits everything else. :rolleyes:

The authors thanked attention being brought to the error. It still leaves missing and biased data as I have noted repeatedly including with supporting data in this thread.

The rest of your comments are unsupportable nonsense.
 
Last edited:
So Worobey et al fixed an error in their paper?

Oooowww, discredits everything else. :rolleyes:

The authors thanked attention being brought to the error. It still leaves missing and biased data as I have noted repeatedly including with supporting data in this thread.

The rest of your comments are unsupportable nonsense.

Please explain as succinctly as you can:

a) what missing data you are referring to

b) what biased data you are referring to

and please do not say "I've documented this in the thread", "use Google", "refine your search skills" etc... or other such evasive responses as we have seen how that goes.

Remember, that YOU have now introduced this new claim by Lisewski, and you have seen the response.

Instead of simply accepting it, you have reacted sarcastically with "So Worobey et al fixed an error in their paper?

Oooowww, discredits everything else. :rolleyes:"

This really makes it hard to see you as arguing in good faith. Wouldn't it be better to respond more like this:

"Oh, it's good that they responded to the point about duplicate data, and I am glad to see they corrected their error. However, I still would like to see some response to 1 and 2."
 
Please explain as succinctly as you can:

a) what missing data you are referring to

b) what biased data you are referring to....
Why should I bother when I've posted these two things multiple times?

Try this, address the missing data I have repeatedly posted about and prove you actually read what I said and why you object to it.

And Worobeys bias, paraphrase how/why I described his underlying bias and why you don't think he has an underlying bias.

At least attempt an effort to debate these issues instead of asking me to repeat what I've posted over and over and over .....
 
Why should I bother when I've posted these two things multiple times?

Try this, address the missing data I have repeatedly posted about and prove you actually read what I said and why you object to it.

And Worobeys bias, paraphrase how/why I described his underlying bias and why you don't think he has an underlying bias.

At least attempt an effort to debate these issues instead of asking me to repeat what I've posted over and over and over .....

I expected as much...

Please explain as succinctly as you can:

a) what missing data you are referring to

b) what biased data you are referring to

and please do not say "I've documented this in the thread", "use Google", "refine your search skills" etc... or other such evasive responses as we have seen how that goes.
Remember, that YOU have now introduced this new claim by Lisewski, and you have seen the response.

Instead of simply accepting it, you have reacted sarcastically with "So Worobey et al fixed an error in their paper?

Oooowww, discredits everything else. :rolleyes:"

This really makes it hard to see you as arguing in good faith. Wouldn't it be better to respond more like this:

"Oh, it's good that they responded to the point about duplicate data, and I am glad to see they corrected their error. However, I still would like to see some response to 1 and 2."
 
I expected as much...

You expected as much?

That's odd,I expected better of you. You vacillate between an actual discussion and this kind of nonsense asking me to repeat something I posted over and over and over and over and over .....

Worobey's missing data? :rolleyes:

His bias? :rolleyes:

You can't even be more creative than that? :rolleyes:
 
Bottom line, the evidence leans heavily toward a lab origin.

What gets in the way?

The politics starting with Trump's outrageous interference through to the current GOP carrying on with the House investigation wanting oh so much to keep blaming China. And there's the side show of Rand Paul wanting to get a 'gotcha' on Fauci about his lying re the GoF research funding.

Then there is the actual matter of some of the WIV GoF funding being traceable to the NIH. More than a few people don't want that to get out.

Fauci's earliest emails with his colleagues certainly pointed toward their belief the lab was the origin.

Their quick reversal claiming to have found out some supposed evidence it couldn't have been the lab was a pretty flimsy back-peddle.

China does not want it known the pandemic is actually traceable to labs in Wuhan (be it the WIV or the CCDC). They continue to withhold critical data on the earliest cases.

George Gao, head of CCDC, now retired, stated publicly the lab origin should not be ruled out. Earlier there was an effort to point the finger outside of China altogether. The Chinese government also preferred to promote this scenario.

Peter Daszak manipulated a number of things from the letter to the Lancet to his interference in the initial WHO investigation team. His goal was to direct suspicion away from the lab-leak, pushing the false narrative the lab origin was a CT. Tedros called him out on that saying the lab origin had not been investigated. More than a few researchers citing a conflict of interest requested the WHO block Daszak from being assigned to any future WHO teams assigned to investigate the WIV.

While investigating the lab origin hypothesis did suffer a setback of at least a year, more and more researchers have questioned dismissing that hypothesis.

There are some researchers like Jesse Bloom of the Fred Hutch Cancer Research Center in Seattle who have maintained an open mind, following the evidence. There's a strong incentive not to criticize fellow researchers, he's been very cautious about that.

Then you have Worobey who stood to have his ego stroked by publishing a very heavily biased study claiming he sees the epicenter of cases surrounding the Wuhan Seafood wet market. The problem is the market was identified early on as a super-spreader site and the data on a good 1/3 of the earliest cases which could have confirmed or refuted whether the market was the initial site continue to be blocked by the Chinese government. [I color coded that for you AS. ;)]


I hit post instead of preview, a sign I need to finish this later.
 
Last edited:
You expected as much?

That's odd,I expected better of you. You vacillate between an actual discussion and this kind of nonsense asking me to repeat something I posted over and over and over and over and over .....

Worobey's missing data? :rolleyes:

His bias? :rolleyes:

You can't even be more creative than that? :rolleyes:

Yes. I expected as much because I literally predicted your response.
 
Then you have Worobey who stood to have his ego stroked by publishing a very heavily biased study claiming he sees the epicenter of cases surrounding the Wuhan Seafood wet market. The problem is the market was identified early on as a super-spreader site and the data on a good 1/3 of the earliest cases which could have confirmed or refuted whether the market was the initial site continue to be blocked by the Chinese government. [I color coded that for you AS. ;)]


I hit post instead of preview, a sign I need to finish this later.

But what was the bias?

If it is ascertainment bias then he answers these questions in the supplementary material.

(Besides, you attribute bad motives to him as though that in and of itself refutes his paper. It is bad faith methodology to simply claim he wrote the paper because of ego).

What is Worobey supposed to do with data that is not available to him?

By that rationale, EVERYBODY is ignoring data that is unavailable to them, because nobody has that data.

Unless your response to missing data is to simply make up what the missing data consists of. That's a god-of-the-gaps type argument.
 
I was referring to Tedros' comments after the initial WHO report.

WHO Director-General's remarks at the Member State Briefing on the report of the international team studying the origins of SARS-CoV-2; 30 March 2021


But you know that. Attacking me is all some people in this thread have.

As for news reports and secondary sources, those are flooding the media more and more, asserting the scientific evidence supports the spillover hypothesis. Yet what scientific evidence is that?

Not a lot, not any more since Worobey's flawed study, and certainly not enough to support the conclusions being asserted. "Peer reviewed, published" does not mean conclusive conclusions nor does it confer any special weight to the results. Many peer reviewed published studies contradict other peer reviewed published studies.


Technical Comment: Duplicate, Missing, and Biased Data in the Worobey et al. Study Undermine Their Main Result; Dec 2022


Secondary sources indeed. :rolleyes:

You claimed "the hypothesis (laboratory leak) was not examined at all." I am pleased you are now walking away from this and actually looking at the primary source where what he actually says further study is needed.

The team also visited several laboratories in Wuhan and considered the possibility that the virus entered the human population as a result of a laboratory incident.

However, I do not believe that this assessment was extensive enough. Further data and studies will be needed to reach more robust conclusions.

Although the team has concluded that a laboratory leak is the least likely hypothesis, this requires further investigation, potentially with additional missions involving specialist experts, which I am ready to deploy.

This is completely different from your claim that a laboratory source was "not examined at all."

FWIW more studies have been done since then.None of which favour a laboratory leak hypothesis.
 
Why should I bother when I've posted these two things multiple times?

I can find no evidence you have ever made such a post. I know of posts where you refer to "data" that no one should reasonably expect to exist in the first place but I can't find any other example where you say what data you think is "missing"

Regardless of what you think you have posted in the past no one knows what data you are referring to and no one can find it in this thread. At this point it's up to you to post it again because for all reasonable purposes you are referring to nonexistent posts.
 
OK, let me get this straight, angrysoba: There was data not available to Worobey so his analysis wasn't flawed because he carried on with a study but couldn't help it data was missing? :boggled:

Huh?

angrysoba said:
By that rationale, EVERYBODY is ignoring data that is unavailable to them, because nobody has that data.
Huh?

Actually in this case China has that data but regardless you are making no sense. You are claiming a researcher should just carry on and draw conclusions despite lacking critical data because it isn't the researcher's fault? :boggled:

Let me guess, you don't think the missing data was critical. Riiight.


Here's a summary:

The seafood wet market was identified early on as a super-spreader site.

Cases of COVID occurred before the wet market cluster but China has withheld the demographic data from these earliest cases.

So Worobey ignores those earlier cases except to rationalize they must have been infected at other markets. He has no evidence whatsoever that was the case but it fills in a major plot hole in his study.

Angrysoba says it wasn't Worobey's fault he ignored that big fat plot hole in his study. (Did I get that part right?)


Other related problems: The fact 2 initial lineages were found, A & B, is seen by some as evidence of 2 spillover events occurring, thus explaining the fact a good 1/3 of the earliest cases cannot be connected to the seafood wet market.

But there is no direct evidence of one spillover, let alone 2.


OTOH, the two lineages differ by only 3 nucleotides (IIRC) and at least one researcher (Quay) thinks A came first and B is a variant of A. That makes a lot more sense than claiming there were 2 spillover events.

Supposedly given one hasn't found direct evidence the 2 lineages evolved after COVID was introduced into the human population ergo said lineages must have evolved while circulating within the intermediate species.

Does that make a lick of sense? No, it doesn't. We know COVID variants occur within the infected human population. In fact, variants are common. Is there a trail of those variants exactly, including every nucleotide change as it drifted from one person to another? No.

Yet we are to believe a variant evolving within the human population doesn't account for lineages A&B while speculating the lineages must represent variants that occurred as COVID circulated within an intermediate species when we cannot find even a single infected intermediate species?


As for Worobey's bias, no one should have to explain that to you but I have in a number of past posts.
 
OK, let me get this straight, angrysoba: There was data not available to Worobey so his analysis wasn't flawed because he carried on with a study but couldn't help it data was missing? :boggled:

Huh?

Huh?

Actually in this case China has that data but regardless you are making no sense. You are claiming a researcher should just carry on and draw conclusions despite lacking critical data because it isn't the researcher's fault? :boggled:

Let me guess, you don't think the missing data was critical. Riiight.


Here's a summary:

The seafood wet market was identified early on as a super-spreader site.

Cases of COVID occurred before the wet market cluster but China has withheld the demographic data from these earliest cases.

*****BZZZZZT!****

Could you link to evidence for this, please.

So Worobey ignores those earlier cases except to rationalize they must have been infected at other markets. He has no evidence whatsoever that was the case but it fills in a major plot hole in his study.

Where are you getting the highlighted from? Where does Worobey say there were other cases linked to other markets prior to the Huanan Seafood Market cases?

If you believe this, no wonder you are having trouble accepting or even entertaining the market spillover hypothesis. You don't even know what is claimed.

Angrysoba says it wasn't Worobey's fault he ignored that big fat plot hole in his study. (Did I get that part right?)

You did not.





As for Worobey's bias, no one should have to explain that to you but I have in a number of past posts.

When you say "Worobey's bias", yes, I would like you to explain that to me.

The only thing I have seen from you so far are ad homs about him being driven by ego to relive his glory days.

If that is your idea of bias, then I have no need to answer it, because it is nothing more than your snide interpretation of someone's motives.
 
So much for "ignoring" the earliest cases, Worobey even wrote an article on the earliest cases and made some important observations:

the earliest known cases should not necessarily be expected to be the first infected or linked to Huanan Market: They probably postdated the outbreak’s index case by a considerable period (10). Moreover, only ∼7% of SARS-CoV-2 infections lead to hospitalization (11); most fly under the radar. Similarly, it is entirely expected that early, ascertained cases from a seafood market would be workers who were not necessarily directly associated with wildlife sales once the outbreak began spreading from human to human. The index case was most likely one of the ∼93% who never required hospitalization and indeed could have been any of hundreds of workers who had even brief contact with infected live mammals.

We know there was asymptomatic spread, and only a relatively small number of people need to be hospitalized.

This is different from the idea of the lab leak in which so many WIV workers get so sick that they have to go to hospital.

BUT it turns out that the earliest known case may not have been infected by Covid until 16th December. Remember, Worobey is not claiming to know who the first case is. It's the claim that the first case may be impossible to detect.

Crucially, however, the now famous “earliest” COVID-19 case (1), a 41-year-old male accountant, who lived 30 km south of Huanan Market and had no connection to it—illness onset reported as 8 December—may have become ill with COVID-19 considerably later (12). When interviewed, he reported that his COVID-19 symptoms started with a fever on 16 December. This is corroborated by hospital records and a scientific paper that reports his COVID-19 onset date as 16 December and date of hospitalization as 22 December (see fig. S1). This suggests that he may have been infected through community transmission after the virus had begun spreading from Huanan Market. He believed that he may have been infected in a hospital or on the subway during his commute; he had also traveled north of Huanan Market shortly before his symptoms began (12). If his symptoms indeed began on 16 December, then it postdated multiple cases in workers at Huanan Market, making a female seafood vendor there the earliest known case, with illness onset 10 December (see fig. S1). Notably, she reported knowledge of several possible COVID-19 cases in clinics and hospitals that were near Huanan Market from 11 December, and Huanan Market patients were hospitalized at Union Hospital as early as 10 December (see fig. S1).

I don't see any claim that earlier cases came from other markets.

I think Skeptic Ginger is mixing up different things, perhaps misattributing some speculation by Peter Daszak after the initial visit to China by the WHO group to Worobey instead.
 
Well, we have this...

Link

Unconfirmed reports of early cases
A September 2020 review noted about the hypothetical possibility that the COVID-19 infection had already spread to Europe in 2019 by presumptive evidences including pneumonia case numbers and radiology in France and Italy in November and December.[1] However, a subsequent retrospective surveillance report determined there was no evidence of SARS-CoV-2 circulation in Rome (Italy) during this period.[2]

Some medical and environmental analyses in Italy, France, and the US found results which suggested the virus was circulating prior to December 2019 by several weeks. A WHO report states: "the study findings were not confirmed, methods used were not standardized, and serological assays may suffer from non-specific signals". It urges further investigation of these potential early events.[3]

So yeah, possibly the virus was circling outside of China before December 2019, and that's certainly what China would like everyone to believe.

But...not confirmed.

October and November
See also: Investigations into the origin of COVID-19
According to an ABC news report, the American National Center for Medical Intelligence shared intelligence regarding a potential respiratory disease in Wuhan. This was denied by the Pentagon.[4] On 13 March 2020, the South China Morning Post reported that Chinese government records suggest that the first case of infection with COVID-19 could be traced back to a 55-year-old Hubei resident on 17 November.[5]

On 23 May 2021, The Wall Street Journal reported that newly disclosed U.S. intelligence obtained that three researchers working at the BSL-4 laboratory of the Wuhan Institute of Virology were hospitalized with COVID-like symptoms. The report added weight to calls for a broader probe into the theory that the COVID-19 virus could have escaped from a laboratory.[6][7] However, a WHO report states "introduction through a laboratory incident was considered to be an extremely unlikely pathway".[3] Since then, the head of the WHO COVID-19 origins investigative team, Peter Ben Embarek, has stated that the Chinese authorities exerted pressure on the WHO report conclusions, and that he in fact considers an infection via a researcher's field samples to be a "likely" scenario.[8]

So this is again possible, but again, there seems to be little confirmed.

I can't find a non-paywalled version of the article that works, but...

Link

...the Guardian seems to have some reporting on that back then.

It seems though that there has been no follow-up on it, and is not that reliable.

Who knows?

Is this what you are talking about?
 
Well, we have this...

Link



So yeah, possibly the virus was circling outside of China before December 2019, and that's certainly what China would like everyone to believe.

But...not confirmed.



So this is again possible, but again, there seems to be little confirmed.

I can't find a non-paywalled version of the article that works, but...

Link

...the Guardian seems to have some reporting on that back then.

It seems though that there has been no follow-up on it, and is not that reliable.

Who knows?

Is this what you are talking about?

Against the BSL4 case is that Andersen was working in the BSL4 laboratory at the time and was unaware of any outbreak of illness.
https://www.newsweek.com/coronaviru...anielle-anderson-australian-scientist-1604711
She has received a great deal of abuse on line so the number of comments by her are few despite being perhaps the best independant eye witness to events in WIV upto December 2019.
 
The seafood wet market was identified early on as a super-spreader site.

What do you mean by "super spreader event"? Are you saying that there were a lot of cases there so it must be a super-spreader event and therefor couldn't be the point of origin.

In terms of the normal usage of "super spreader event" this clearly doesn't fit the events at the Wuhan fish market. The cases did not occur all at once as part of a single event rather they accumulated over the course of several weeks. Second, since there were two virus lineages involved it could not have been a single event.


Other related problems: The fact 2 initial lineages were found, A & B, is seen by some as evidence of 2 spillover events occurring, thus explaining the fact a good 1/3 of the earliest cases cannot be connected to the seafood wet market.

This is false. The ~1/3 of early cases that hadn't been to the market still had a proximal link to it. They either lived or worked in relatively close proximity to it.
Other related problems: The fact 2 initial lineages were found, A & B, is seen by some as evidence of 2 spillover events occurring, thus explaining the fact a good 1/3 of the earliest cases cannot be connected to the seafood wet market.

But there is no direct evidence of one spillover, let alone 2.

Maybe in Stawman world, but you also need to consider the fact that it was too early to expect multiple virus lineages. The most logical explanation for the existence of 2 lineages that early in the pandemic is that these lineages arose before the first human infection.

This is no issue for zoonosis because there lineages could easily emerge in animal populations before moving on to infect humans. It's a major issue for lab leak because there is no viable explanation for why there were two lineages that early nor is there any viable explanation for how they both got to the same place at the same time, a dozen miles away from the location of the supposed leak and don't show up anywhere near the lab until much later on.
 
Well, we have this...

Link

So yeah, possibly the virus was circling outside of China before December 2019, and that's certainly what China would like everyone to believe.

But...not confirmed. [snip] Is this what you are talking about?
No.

Potential Italy cases were discussed early in the thread. China wanted to point the finger away from themselves. IIRC there simply were no conclusive tests for COVID prior to Dec 2019 but I would need to review what we discussed pages back. It's not the earlier cases I'm talking about.

Honestly angrysoba if you don't know what I'm talking about it seems like willful ignorance. You don't read what I post half the time then demand I repeat what I posted. The fact there were a number of cases that China refused to provide the specifics on was an issue from the very beginning of the pandemic. How you don't remember this says a lot that you really aren't interested in challenging your current belief the origin was a spillover.

If I had to guess I'd say your reading the book, Spillover, set that bias up in your head and you can't let it go no matter how many reliable sources say neither origin hypothesis has been ruled in or out.

Here's the most recent time I discussed the problematic early cases:
It was determined the duplicate data was an error that Worobey corrected. I'll post a more detailed discussion of the paper in a new post.
 
Technical Comment: Duplicate, Missing, and Biased Data in the Worobey et al. Study Undermine Their Main Result; Dec 2022
It was determined the duplicate data was an error that Worobey corrected. One criticism of the study's conclusion was there were no negative controls.
Here are some other specifics from the paper:
Therefore, in contradiction to the key claim by Worobey et al., it cannot be inferred that the observed closer proximity of the 120 cases not epidemiologically linked to the Huanan market is due to their origin being at that market. Together with a previous technical comment [2], which directly questioned the exclusive Huanan market origin of the earliest SARS-CoV-2 lineage B cases, this evidence further invalidates the market origin hypothesis of SARS-CoV-2
IOW Worobey made a lot of assumptions the data did not support. I have said so numerous times.


Addendum 1 [11 March 2023]: Documented written statements from the corresponding author of the Worobey et al. study as well as from the responsible senior editor of Science magazine (see Supplemental Information below) acknowledge these above errors and data problems. Yet, to date, Worobey et al. and Science editors have, despite their official announcements, failed (a) to address and to resolve said point 1 and point 2 above as well as the previous point in the eLetter [2] from 16 October 2022, and (b) to correct the scientific record in question.
 
Against the BSL4 case is that Andersen was working in the BSL4 laboratory at the time and was unaware of any outbreak of illness.
https://www.newsweek.com/coronaviru...anielle-anderson-australian-scientist-1604711
She has received a great deal of abuse on line so the number of comments by her are few despite being perhaps the best independant eye witness to events in WIV upto December 2019.
They weren't doing coronavirus work in the BSL4 lab; it was done in the BSL2 lab. The level 4 lab wasn't even ready at the time the pandemic started. They hadn't resolved a number of issues like adequate staff training.

Shi's problems with online harassment weren't relevant at the time the first cases occurred.


You also continue to ignore certain facts that have been well documented in this thread and documented in multiple sources. It's not that hard to look up 'WIV coronavirus research done in BSL2 lab'. Try it, see what you get. I get multiple sources from DuckduckGo and none on the first page of Startpage. I rarely use Google so I did not check there.

Maybe that's part of the problem, you guys are using inefficient search engines. Just a thought.

Also re the earliest cases try searching for 'China continues to withhold information on earliest COVID cases'. The first 2 hits are the WSJ and the NYT but scroll past those and there are a half dozen alternatives that are not paywalled.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom