Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

Well there you have it.

Who needs science when a quick glance is all it apparently takes.

MM

The big mistake in Jones' lie. They show dust burning, and it expanded, looks like insulation. The dumb part for the nuts who did the paper, not a single sample they burned matched the release energy of thermite. Then you and 911 truth nuts can't look up the heat energy release by the office fires to understand extra effort was not required to collapse the WTC towers. You failed to read the NIST report, all you can do is post unrelated failed opinions based on fantasy. Are you a professional troll like KreeL?
 
"...Making these predictions could mean that I will can be proven WRONG by Millette, and indeed we have a first reaction that he has NOT yet found strontium chromate..."

This is quite significant as Oystein has made much of this in previous posts;

Oystein said:
"If you study Harrit's letter, the one you linked to in your previos post, you will find that in it he reveals that the red-gray chips contained traces of strontium and chromium. LaClede primer is specified to contain strontium chromate. Amazing, isn't it?"

Oystein said:
"These are the main reasons that justify the emphasis we put on LaClede paint: It contains exactly the things that Harrit found: aluminium silicate, hematite and strontium chromate in an orgamic matrix."

But Oystein totally ignores what Dr. Harrit had to say about this. As expected, Jim Millette appears to agree with Dr. Harritt.

Dr. Niels Harrit said:
"Minute signals in level with the noise are observed from sulfur, calcium,
chromium and strontium
...The resulting XEDS of this chip (Figure 6, below) displays tiny blips indicating the presence of chromium and zinc. They disappeared after the chips had been soaked/rinsed with the organic solvent. Therefore, they are believed to derive from surface contamination, which very well could have been from the primer paint(!)... The signals from zinc and chromium could be from a surface contamination with primer paint."

MM
 
Rhetorical questions are not expected to be answered.

They present a point of view.

MM
No - if you had read the original question you'd know that it's not a point of view although viewing is a necessity. ;)

If you think it's a point of view then kindly answer the original question which is:

I need some help from the truthers.

If I was looking at a sample of something and I believe that the surface was contaminated, but couldn't identify if it was via optical microscopy what machine would be the best to use to see the contamination and identify what that contamination was?

Thanks

Do you have an answer MM? If you think this is a "view" then you'll be able to come up with a valid alternative to what I'm clearly indicating. What machine do you think is the ideal analytical tool to identify surface contaminants?
 
It's not. Look at the chemistry.

Why are you waiting to see? You seem happy to agree if it agrees with your belief.

Have you heard of the term "conformation bias"?

[truther]
"paint ingredients by (insert favorite truther's name here)":

1- Color
2- Wet stuff

Obviously, the chip was made of more exotic material!
[/truther]
 
Last edited:
When Jim finds the 'primer' has the same thermitic qualities as Harrit found, then I would definitely call for an investigation into who made the paint and their reasons for doing so, as well as all the other questions that would arrive from this verification.

Where did Harrit do that?
 
Ivan, I knew about this Millette report generally and asked if I can attend. Cost of attendance is high, but yes, Dr. Millette has told me a couple weeks ago the initial results will be in our hands very soon. This conference is keeping him on track timewise because now he must do the research so he can prepare his lecture.
 
Ivan, I knew about this Millette report generally and asked if I can attend. Cost of attendance is high, but yes, Dr. Millette has told me a couple weeks ago the initial results will be in our hands very soon. This conference is keeping him on track timewise because now he must do the research so he can prepare his lecture.

Hi, Chris:o)
In the conference program, there is an entry:

(Friday 2/24)
10:00 a.m. - 10:20 a.m. C29 Update on Dust Particulate Analysis From the World Trade Center Disaster of
September 11, 2001
James Millette, PhD*

It means that Jim's Millette presentation will be quite short, perhaps with just some summary of preliminary findings; no time to go into details.
 
Btw, there is an another presentation "on topic" scheduled, just before the Jim's lecture:

"9:40 a.m. - 10:00 a.m. C28 A Review of the World Trade Center (WTC) Dust Screening Procedure
Richard S. Brown, MS*"

This could be in fact some "introduction" to Jim Millette's lecture, presented by his colleague from MVA.
 
Last edited:
There is the whole section devoted to the WTC disaster, with two more presentations:

Revisiting the World Trade Center Disaster of 9/11/2001
Moderator: Whitney B. Hill, MS
MVA Scientific Consultants
Duluth, GA
9:00 a.m. - 9:20 a.m. C26 Development of a Scanning Electron Microscopy Screening Method for World Trade
Center Dust
Amy M. Bern, MS*; Heather A. Lowers, MS; Gregory P. Meeker, MS; Jacky A. Rosati, PhD
9:20 a.m. - 9:40 a.m. C27 Lessons Learned About Spray Fireproofing Systems From the World Trade
Center Collapse
Roger G. Morse, Barch*


And, one more citation from the conference web:

"Video and/or audiotaping of any session(s) or parts thereof is not permitted without prior approval from the speakers and from the American Academy of Forensic Sciences."

Anyway, Chris, if you would be there, could you try to record at least lectures of Jim and Richard Brown? (But, it's not really necessary, if Jim Millette and Richard Brown are planning to provide you with some written/digital form of their presentations (?)).
 
Last edited:
But Oystein totally ignores what Dr. Harrit had to say about this. As expected, Jim Millette appears to agree with Dr. Harritt.

Not really. Harrit agrees with us that everything we would expect to find in a chip of La Clede primer is in some of his chips. Dork boy just makes the mistake of thinking that the strontium and chromium are surface contaminents.
 
Not really. Harrit agrees with us that everything we would expect to find in a chip of La Clede primer is in some of his chips. Dork boy just makes the mistake of thinking that the strontium and chromium are surface contaminents.

Lefty,
on this, Sunstealer asked an interesting question:
I need some help from the truthers.

If I was looking at a sample of something and I believe that the surface was contaminated, but couldn't identify if it was via optical microscopy what machine would be the best to use to see the contamination and identify what that contamination was?

Thanks
If there are contaminations from other dust constituents such as paints or gypsum, we should see them in the BSE and other micrographs. These images show details as small as tens of nanometers. Particles from gypsum and paint are MUCH larger than this - pigments alone can't be much smaller than 100nm, as they would then be smaller than the wavelength of visible light, and usually pigments are somewhere between 100nm and 10µm large.
So if the micrographs don't show particle contaminations, then they are quite likely not there.
It is interesting that they did not present any larger magnification for the MEK soaked chip that supposedly is contaminated with large amountss of different stuffs - only micrographs on that chip have scale markers 100µm and 500µm; the XEDS map 50µm. Contrast that with the magnifications for chips a-d which go down to 20, 10, 5 and 1µm. 1µm also on the XEDS maps. Harrit e.al. failed to show the clay platelets, for example.




On a personal note: It is interesting that I should have ignored some information, when in fact it is the truther/troll who ignored the really interesting stuff.

I might note that of course I am not ignoring the fact that Millette had not, as of a couple of days ago, found Sr-chromate - in fact, it was I who brought that up! Strange that someone would quote my talking about X, followed by the moronic claim that I am ignoring X. What the truther/troll is ignoring himself is the obvious fact that Millette hasn't finished his study and hasn't published any results. His not finding Sr-chromate could simply be due to the fact that he hasn't found enough of the chips a-d material. I can wait for the report and the data when they are read.
 
I might note that of course I am not ignoring the fact that Millette had not, as of a couple of days ago, found Sr-chromate - in fact, it was I who brought that up! Strange that someone would quote my talking about X, followed by the moronic claim that I am ignoring X. What the truther/troll is ignoring himself is the obvious fact that Millette hasn't finished his study and hasn't published any results. His not finding Sr-chromate could simply be due to the fact that he hasn't found enough of the chips a-d material. I can wait for the report and the data when they are read.
I have to admit that I barely understand most of the processes used to examine the chips. I am familiar with visible-light microscopy and have been since childhood, driven largely by an interest in biology.

My knowledge of chemistry is also a bit limited due to my being dyscalculic nearly to the point of being disabled.

So, I have to ask two things:

1) Would the strontium chromate be actually observable as crystals in the paint?

2) Can strontium chromate be disolved in the hydro carbon matrix?
 
I have to admit that I barely understand most of the processes used to examine the chips. I am familiar with visible-light microscopy and have been since childhood, driven largely by an interest in biology.

My knowledge of chemistry is also a bit limited due to my being dyscalculic nearly to the point of being disabled.

So, I have to ask two things:

1) Would the strontium chromate be actually observable as crystals in the paint?

2) Can strontium chromate be disolved in the hydro carbon matrix?

Hi, Lefty,

1) I think that those needle-shape crystals could be basically observable in the paint.
2) I think that strontium chromate can't be dissolved in hydrocarbon/(polymer) matrix (or better said: in the "wet paint" formulation containing some vehicles/solvents; concerning cured/solid epoxy paint, it can't be "dissolved" in the binder for sure). The solubility of strontium chromate seems to be generally very limited. It dissolves just very slightly in water, and it is soluble in hydrochloric acid and nitric acid, that's all I have found.
Some months ago I was interested if strontium chromate or zinc chromate dissolve in acetone or MEK (used in Bentham paper for extraction of "MEK chip"). It seems that those inorganic salts don't dissolve in any organic solvent (but here, I may be wrong, since I simply don't have enough info, my search was not really "thorough".)

Note: in principle, strontium chromate crystals could be also melted during curing of the epoxy or other paint based on crosslinkable polymers (at temperatures ca 100 to 150 degrees C). But up to now, I have not found any info on the melting point of SrCrO4...

Here is some short article on strontium chromate

Here is another article . It is written there: "It is slightly soluble in water (around 1 g/l) and perfectly stable up to 250°C." It perhaps means that this salt does not really melt and it decomposes at high temperatures.
Addendum: yes, strontium chromate really decomposes without melting, according to this MSDS. (No temperatures are given, but decomposition should occur above 250 degrees C.)

I'd like also to note that the "surface chemistry" of chromates in contact with steel/iron seems to be rather complex and perhaps these salts behave in some way which has not been considered here yet....
 
Last edited:
Hi all,
I can't be at the upcoming forensics meeting... too expensive. It looks like a pretty serious lineup and if there is anyone who can afford to fly to Atlanta and pay hundreds of dollars to attend and watch Dr. Millette's initial presentation, more power to you. We'll be getting some kind of initial report, I'm guessing right after the Forensics conference is over.
 
His not finding Sr-chromate could simply be due to the fact that he hasn't found enough of the chips a-d material. I can wait for the report and the data when they are read.

This is an honest question, so please don't take this as any kind of attack, etc, and I do appreciate what you Chris, Ivan, and Jim are doing because I think it's the right approach.

But isn't your comment exactly what you expect Twoofies to say if Jim does not find thermitic properties in the chip? In other words, why do you get to play this card, when you know Twoofies will be assaulted for making the same claim? Just curious, and again, it's an honest question. Thanks.
 
This is an honest question, so please don't take this as any kind of attack, etc, and I do appreciate what you Chris, Ivan, and Jim are doing because I think it's the right approach.

But isn't your comment exactly what you expect Twoofies to say if Jim does not find thermitic properties in the chip? In other words, why do you get to play this card, when you know Twoofies will be assaulted for making the same claim? Just curious, and again, it's an honest question. Thanks.

That is a incredibly falacious question, and you know it. It contains not only several ridiculous claims of its "honesty" but also begs the question and contains a straw man. Further, we all know it is not an honest question, because the answer is right in the post to which you are responding:

I can wait for the report and the data when they are read[y].

"honestly" Unbelievable
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom