Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

I noticed on his spectra for all three samples, they also show two small spikes that are not labelled.

Following the Ca spike, the is a spike at the point labelled "4" and, follwing Fe, there is a peak at 7.

Having no idea what any of this means, I have to ask, could either of the these pikes represent either strontium or chromium.

Hey lefty,
it's a bit tedious, you can look up the energy levels for all elements here:
http://csrri.iit.edu/periodic-table.html
Just click on the element symbol for the element of interest, and look in the column "Edge Energies". That column contains a number of "levels". Usually, the K-alpha and K-level produce the highest peaks, sometimes K-beta or L1 also produce something visible.

What you see near 4 keV is probably the second, K-(plus K-beta)-level, oc Ca
What you see near 7 keV is the K/K-beta of Fe.

Chromium (Cr) would have peaks at 5.4 and just under 6, and strontium (Sr) at 14.2 and around 15.8-16.1. I see none of those anywhere in Henryco's spectra - another reason to reject them as identical with a-d. I have to admit though that the Sr-signals in Harrit's May 2009 letter are really tiny in the noise, and can easily be missed. I actually don't see them, it was apparently software that put these labels there for Harrit:
Harrit_figure-5b.png
 
a
I noticed on his spectra for all three samples, they also show two small spikes that are not labelled.

Following the Ca spike, the is a spike at the point labelled "4" and, follwing Fe, there is a peak at 7.

Having no idea what any of this means, I have to ask, could either of the these pikes represent either strontium or chromium.

Lefty: Nonspecified peaks at ca 4 and 7 KeV should also belong to Ca and Fe, look e.g. to the Bentham Fig. 14 for comparison.

Oystein: Those calcium and sulfur peaks are almost everywhere (except Bentham chips (a) to (d)). I can have a look if e.g. calcium sulfate can be a component in primer paints for corrosion protection. Could we "overlook" some really abundant WTC red paint with calcium sulfate as pigment? Or perhaps with pigment containing Si, Al, and Ca? (My intuition tells me that calcium sulfate as pigment is not good for anticorrosive coatings, since dehydrated calcium sulfate (hemihydrate) is highly hygroscopic. And any potential change in chemical composition/volume, e.g. absorption/desorption of water, is not desirable for pigments intended for such "heavy duty" applications. But, my intuition can be wrong:blush:)
 
Last edited:
Lefty: Nonspecified peaks at ca 4 and 7 KeV should also belong to Ca and Fe, look e.g. to the Bentham Fig. 14 for comparison.

Oystein: Those calcium and sulfur peaks are almost everywhere (except Bentham chips (a) to (d)). I can have look if e.g. calcium sulfate can be a component in primer paints for corrosion protection. Could we "overlook" some really abundant WTC red paint with calcium sulfate as pigment? (My intuition tells me that this pigment is not good for anticorrosive coatings, since dehydrated calcium sulfate (hemihydrate) is hygroscopic itself. But, my intuition can be wrong:blush:)

Remember, Jones presented in December 2009 the XEDS spectrum of paint from a WTC perimeter column, probably a variety of Tnemec - on the right:
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-pTcvrD8qd.../wZiQx9pfX5U/s1600/JonesPrimerPaint-2m51s.jpg
(ETA: The high peak in the middle is mislabeled - it's Ca, not C)

In "WHY THE RED/GRAY CHIPS ARE NOT PRIMER PAINT", on page 3, Harrit shows that the Tnemec pigment contains "Calcium Silicates and Aluminates 6-10%". That would only be 3.3-5.5% Ca-Si or Ca-Al in the hardened paint, but at least it's a start.
There is additionally diatomaceous silicate in Tnemec paint - that might add some Ca, although d.s. is mostly silica.
 
Last edited:
Oystein: yes, I have just noticed that Bentham Fig. 14 shows roughly similar XEDS spectra as Fig. 5 in Henryco's document. From this point of view, some of Henryco's chips could be Tnemec paint (which is expected anyway). But, no conclusion can be of course made:confused:
 
Last edited:
Oystein: yes, I have just noticed that Bentham Fig. 14 shows roughly similar XEDS spectra as Fig. 5 in Henryco's document. From this point of view, some of Henryco's chips could be Tnemec paint (which is expected anyway). But, no conclusion can be of course made:confused:

No. Henryco has no Zinc.
 
No. Henryco has no Zinc.

This can be (tentatively) attributed to the "sensitivity" of the Henryco's XEDS device or his "methodology", and zinc peak is not really big in Bentham Fig. 14. But of course, it doesn't make sense to "fabricate" such hypotheses (or even conclusions) with so little data:cool:
 
I suppose it is too much to expect that those who financed research that Dr. Millette was otherwise unwilling to undertake, should receive some of the preliminary data before the rest of the world?

Not providing a free invite to the person who organized the financing is just 'insult to injury'.

It sounds like Dr. Millette played you like a fish Chris.

MM
Hi MM and all,

Part of Dr. Millette's finalization of his research is to run his initial test results past a panel of experts. This is the first part of the peer-review process. Someone may well pick up something he missed. After the presentation, he may have to take into account some of the things that this group of international forensic experts have said about his study. I may have been mistaken when I said we'd get a preliminary result PRIOR to the convention.

Hope this helps. Don't assume the worst; it's not his convention and free passes aren't his to distribute. Keep in mind neither you nor I are even qualified to ask the kinds of technical questions that will dominate this discussion!

Consider the fact that Dr. Millette has also put thousands of dollars of the lab's money into preparing this study. Also remember, we haven't paid him a penny yet. The agreement is that we get the study, then he gets paid. If he is taking a bit more time to receive input from this world forensics convention, I'm OK with that.
 
Hi MM and all,

Part of Dr. Millette's finalization of his research is to run his initial test results past a panel of experts. This is the first part of the peer-review process. Someone may well pick up something he missed. After the presentation, he may have to take into account some of the things that this group of international forensic experts have said about his study. I may have been mistaken when I said we'd get a preliminary result PRIOR to the convention.

Hope this helps. Don't assume the worst; it's not his convention and free passes aren't his to distribute. Keep in mind neither you nor I are even qualified to ask the kinds of technical questions that will dominate this discussion!

Consider the fact that Dr. Millette has also put thousands of dollars of the lab's money into preparing this study. Also remember, we haven't paid him a penny yet. The agreement is that we get the study, then he gets paid. If he is taking a bit more time to receive input from this world forensics convention, I'm OK with that.

Excellent post, and one I hope that our friends will take to heart before posting grossly uninformed rants in the future.

There are certain posts in this thread that betray a wee bit of apprehension about the results, is there not?

/hey mm, having made several presentations at expensive seminars, let me just add this comment regarding your belief that they hand out freebies: Bwhahahahaha!!!! Oh mercy. Hell, many of them only give the PRESENTERS a discount.
 
Hi MM and all,

Part of Dr. Millette's finalization of his research is to run his initial test results past a panel of experts. This is the first part of the peer-review process. Someone may well pick up something he missed. After the presentation, he may have to take into account some of the things that this group of international forensic experts have said about his study. I may have been mistaken when I said we'd get a preliminary result PRIOR to the convention.

Hope this helps. Don't assume the worst; it's not his convention and free passes aren't his to distribute. Keep in mind neither you nor I are even qualified to ask the kinds of technical questions that will dominate this discussion!

Consider the fact that Dr. Millette has also put thousands of dollars of the lab's money into preparing this study. Also remember, we haven't paid him a penny yet. The agreement is that we get the study, then he gets paid. If he is taking a bit more time to receive input from this world forensics convention, I'm OK with that.

I am not assuming anything.

Since you now indicate that our funding was not immediately required, nor representing a majority interest in his research, one has to wonder what motivated him to investigate the sensational Bentham Paper findings now?

As he was well aware of the Bentham Paper, surely it wasn't just your contact with him that provided his necessary motivation to seek investigative clarification at this late date?

MM
 
I am not assuming anything.
Good one.

Since you now indicate that our funding was not immediately required, nor representing a majority interest in his research, one has to wonder what motivated him to investigate the sensational Bentham Paper findings now?

As he was well aware of the Bentham Paper, surely it wasn't just your contact with him that provided his necessary motivation to seek investigative clarification at this late date?

MM
Would you care to make an actual assertion?
 
I am not assuming anything.

Since you now indicate that our funding was not immediately required, nor representing a majority interest in his research, one has to wonder what motivated him to investigate the sensational Bentham Paper findings now?

As he was well aware of the Bentham Paper, surely it wasn't just your contact with him that provided his necessary motivation to seek investigative clarification at this late date?

MM

Uhhh, Chris asked him to do it and offered to offset the expenses.

You are not really this obtuse are you?

Why are you so afraid of this paper, MM?

By the way, as you seem so caught up in the money, I and several others are willing today to send you back whatever you contributed.
 
I am not assuming anything.

Since you now indicate that our funding was not immediately required, nor representing a majority interest in his research, one has to wonder what motivated him to investigate the sensational Bentham Paper findings now?

As he was well aware of the Bentham Paper, surely it wasn't just your contact with him that provided his necessary motivation to seek investigative clarification at this late date?

MM
Cool your jets everyone. Let's give credit to MM for being a donor to this study.

And MM, I don't have all the answers re Dr. Millette's motivations, but I will say this: he was hired to do WTC dust testing in the early 2000s. Since then, the whole 9/11 disaster has been the subject of countless engineering and chemical studies from student-level on up to peer-reviewed studies. Most structural engineering schools put their students to the task of studying the collapses on 9/11. It's very, very interesting and instructive to everyone from a scientific point of view. Dr. Millette himself has taken out the dust and given them a look-see a couple times in the past, but never really did a full-scale study.

Along comes this English major Chris Mohr who says I can raise $1000 from people on both sides of the argument, can you do a real serious scientific study of the dust looking at the Bentham papers? If you are asking why Dr. Millette would do a multi-thousand dollar study for a thousand dollars, I would guess:

1.) personal scientific interest
2.) a chance for his lab to make a stellar presentation on a fascinating topic at an international forensics conference (and indeed, his dust presentation is one of three that people at his lab are doing on 9/11, all no doubt building up to his cutting-edge, new-data presentation). This has enormous promotional value for his lab. Imagine you are a forensics expert in Chicago and you have a complex case that requires the skills of a top lab... Millette's lab will be in your mind after seeing the presentations.
3.) There is a whole section of this convention for forensics students, and as I said, students worldwide cut their teeth on 9/11 technical issues. I am sure Dr. Millette is serving the educational function of this convention for forensics students as well.

The timing for both me and Dr. Millette was perfect, don't you agree? And have you ever been interested in doing something but weren't moved to act until someone else came along and encouraged you to do it? I sure have. In this case, I motivated him to do the study now. MM you and I can hardly wait for the results, but hey, we'll have to. I'm not going to rush him.
 
Since then, the whole 9/11 disaster has been the subject of countless engineering and chemical studies from student-level on up to peer-reviewed studies. Most structural engineering schools put their students to the task of studying the collapses on 9/11. It's very, very interesting and instructive to everyone from a scientific point of view..

This can't be true, someone would have reported the "inside job" by now.

:rolleyes:
 
DGM one would think that hundreds of engineering schools worldwide would have discovered that NIST's findings violated the basic law of physics, but I guess they must not know what they are talking about.;)
 
DGM one would think that hundreds of engineering schools worldwide would have discovered that NIST's findings violated the basic law of physics, but I guess they must not know what they are talking about.;)
No, didn't you hear? They were afraid of losing grants or jobs. Try to keep up.

:D
 
No, didn't you hear? They were afraid of losing grants or jobs. Try to keep up.

:D

Because as we all know, nobody had EVER risked their jobs or grants to expose mass murder in the history of Earth ;)
 
Conversation with Dr. Jim Millette

The size of MM's contribution is irrelevant. He made a contribution, thanks MM. BTW I got a couple of $5 contributions from people on the JREF side of things, people who are on fixed incomes but wanted to show their support. I'm grateful for all contributions of all sizes. Shall we start attacking everyone and accusing them of making paltry contributions when you don't know what you're talking about? And not all 9/11 Truth people are opposed to this. MM is my most skeptical donor, to be sure, but three other donors from the 9/11 Truth side are considerably more enthusiastic (one donated $100 by the way). Also, one 9/11 blogger just said he's glad the thermitic dust is being looked at seriously (so am I!).

More importantly for everyone, Dr. Millette called me today. He had indeed told me he had targeted Feb 15 as the date to release his data. He has done so many experiments, including replication of many of the experiments of Harrit et al and then more, that he is "overwhelmed" at the moment by all the data. He asked my permission for him to put the data together, present it at the forensics convention, and give us his report by February 29 and of course I said fine. I told him I had kind of come to that conclusion anyway, that we'd all get a better report after it gets its first two rounds of peer reviews (one from people at his own lab in the next couple days, a second round from the forensics experts next week). His report to us will be released to us before the third and final round of the peer review, which will be part and parcel of the publication process. He'll let us know as soon as his final work is published as well, several months down the road.
 
Last edited:
Chris, there's an easy solution. Just ask Millette what he came up with before the shills at the conference hack it up and take out all the thermatic material. ;)
 
I am not assuming anything.

Since you now indicate that our funding was not immediately required, nor representing a majority interest in his research, one has to wonder what motivated him to investigate the sensational Bentham Paper findings now?

As he was well aware of the Bentham Paper, surely it wasn't just your contact with him that provided his necessary motivation to seek investigative clarification at this late date?

MM


Being offered $1000...........and after a little thought, the chance of getting another paper published. We professionals like that sort of thing:D
 
...
Ok, but why should he reveal where his data is leading before all of the data is processed?
...

More to the point: How should Jim KNOW where his data is leading before all of the data is processed? It's the hallmark of truther science when researchers know where their raw data is pointing before they actually process the data.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom