Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

You've already been answered, but this image from NCSTAR 1-3C Appendix D should speak for itself:

[qimg]http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/cache/paint.jpg[/qimg]
(better resolution image here: http://zelikow.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/pp_harrit_figure-8-new.png but I don't have permission to hotlink it)

Remember that they only collected chips attracted by a magnet, therefore there's no chip among those analyzed which doesn't have steel attached to it.

I can see with my naked eye that is primer paint. Harrit compared that to the red/grey chips. Didn't match.
 
Yet they didn't perform one single test that might pin the material down as thermitic, yet concluded it was. Professional?

And they didn't publish in a reputable journal. Professional?

Compared to publishing rubbish in Popular Mechanics? Perhaps.
 
Honestly, I have full confidence that Jim will confirm Harrit's findings. I hope you will read and understand his paper when he publishes his findings.
 
This is new stuff. I'll wait to see what Jim has to say about it.

Why is this primer paint you keep espousing so exotic? Just another question that needs to be asked.
 
This is new stuff. I'll wait to see what Jim has to say about it.

Why is this primer paint you keep espousing so exotic? Just another question that needs to be asked.
It's not. Look at the chemistry.

Why are you waiting to see? You seem happy to agree if it agrees with your belief.

Have you heard of the term "conformation bias"?
 
Last edited:
I suppose that if Jim confirms Harrit's findings that you will push for a new investigation into 9/11? Arson is arson, afterall.
 
I can see with my naked eye that is primer paint. Harrit compared that to the red/grey chips. Didn't match.

That (whether or not those chips match that primer) wasn't the question you asked that pgimeno replied to. You must have aq very short attention span.

The question you asked was whether primer is bi-layered. The photo shows that yes, when primer spalls off steel and some of the (oxidized ) steel surface sticks to the red paint, you indeed get a red-gray layered material, which would be easy to break into chips. It doesn't matter much which primer you use.

You also asked if it wouldn't be two coats of the same color. The answer ist: No, because the gray layer isn't paint, it is oxidized steel.

Please look again at the context yourself and acknowledge that you now understand, because you can see with your naked eyes that it is a red layer of primer paint with a gray layer of spalled-off steel adhering to it:

This may seem like an odd question, but is primer paint bi-layered?
Wouldn't that be two coats of the same color?
You've already been answered, but this image from NCSTAR 1-3C Appendix D should speak for itself:

paint.jpg

(better resolution image here: http://zelikow.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/pp_harrit_figure-8-new.png but I don't have permission to hotlink it)

Remember that they only collected chips attracted by a magnet, therefore there's no chip among those analyzed which doesn't have steel attached to it.
 
When Jim finds the 'primer' has the same thermitic qualities as Harrit found, then I would definitely call for an investigation into who made the paint and their reasons for doing so, as well as all the other questions that would arrive from this verification.
 
When Jim finds the 'primer' has the same thermitic qualities as Harrit found, then I would definitely call for an investigation into who made the paint and their reasons for doing so, as well as all the other questions that would arrive from this verification.
And if he doesn't?
 
When Jim finds the 'primer' has the same thermitic qualities as Harrit found, then I would definitely call for an investigation into who made the paint and their reasons for doing so, as well as all the other questions that would arrive from this verification.
What "thermitic qualities" ????
 
I can see with my naked eye that is primer paint. Harrit compared that to the red/grey chips. Didn't match.
Regardless of the fact that it didn't match the paint that they tested (which is expectable as they didn't test the right type of paint, as this thread reveals), your initial question is now fully answered:
This may seem like an odd question, but is primer paint bi-layered?
Now it starts to be clear that that was just a bait, an attempt to insinuate that it can't be what we claim it most likely is, and not an honest question, because when it turns out that we have a reasonable answer, you claim that the image isn't valid because it's primer paint (which is what your first question inquired about).

It should be obvious for anyone, including you, that a different type of primer paint to that tested by Harrit et al. can also have rusted steel attached, therefore the bi-layered nature is expectable from primer paint, making your insinuation moot.

*points to sig*

Unless you rectify your attitude and show genuine interest in learning, I'm done with you. Actually reading the thread would be a good start to show good faith.
 
I suppose that if Jim confirms Harrit's findings that you will push for a new investigation into 9/11? Arson is arson, afterall.

I'll post this one last time:

I hope that Jim finds some chips with which he can replicate Harrit's data.

The problem is not in the "findings" (the data from SE, BSE, XEDS, DSC), its in the interpretation.
The methods are not sufficient to properly and unambiguously characterize the material. That is the first level of incompetence.
The data is presented in a chaotic fashion the paper. Obviously, Harrit e.al. have done random things on random particles and picked random data points to present in the paper, being totally ignorant of the obvious fact that they had several different kinds of particles. This is the second level of incompetence.
Finally, they draw conclusions that are not supported even by their chaotically picked data points. The conclusions are actually contradicted by the data. And they are ignorant of easier, more parsimoneus explanations. This is the final level of incompetence.



So step 1 for Millette, as far as I am concerned in THIS thread (remember what this thread is about? Right: Identifying paint), will be to find chips that match Harrit's chips a-d in visual appearance, BSE micrographs, XEDS spectrum overall and XEDS maps of 5 elements.
Then he will do additional (competent!) tests on these chips that will unequivocally reveal the chemical composition and chemical bonds of all the visually distinguishable ingredients of the chips, including those that Harrit e al never forned any conclusions on. These ingredients are: Gray layer, organic matrix, small faceted crystals and larger platelets. I think I also see a third, needle-shaped, kind of crystal. I have specific predictions for these ingredients:
  • Gray layer will prove to be several iron oxides, with traces of manganese and carbon (unknown bindings)
  • Organic matrix will prove to be cured epoxy
  • Small grains will be confirmed as hematite (Fe2O3) - a conclusion that Harrit already shares
  • Platelets will be aluminium silicate, possibly with traces of Ca, K, S, Mg and Ti (the last three are a slight evolution of earlier predictions; I have looked at good references for natural kaolin deposits today)
  • In addition, I predict the finding of strontium chromate crystals
Making these predictions could mean that I will can be proven WRONG by Millette, and indeed we have a first reaction that he has NOT yet found strontium chromate.

However, with regards to thermite, I further predict that there will be absolutely no elemental Al (or well below some threshold of insignificance, like 0.1%), rendering the materiel immediately "non-thermitic".


Summary: I hope Jim will confirm Harrit's data, and then show that it actually is the data of a paint formulation indistinguishable from LaClede standard primer, and not thermite at all.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom