Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

This may seem like an odd question, but is primer paint bi-layered?

This question is really rather odd, but anyway for your record:

1) Basically, primer paint can be even bilayered (applied in two layers), e.g. when intended for some extremely exposed surfaces, or in other cases, where the maximal corrosion protection is required.

Bilayered structure of primer can't be expected if the binder stays soluble in the used solvent after application, since the second paint layer will inevitably dissolve the first layer (at least partially). This is the case when linear (non-crosslinked) polymers, denoted as thermoplastics, are used in the binder (polyvinylacetate, polyacrylates, polystyrene copolymers etc.).

When crosslinkable polymer is used as a binder (e.g. epoxy as in WTC Laclede paint, alkyd resin used in WTC Tnemec paint), the first layer is crosslinked (usually be heating), forming basically insoluble (or badly soluble) three-dimensional chemical network during so-called curing/hardening. Such polymers are called thermosets and in this case, the second paint layer will not dissolve the first one during application and both layers may be distinguished by some analysis (perhaps).

Indeed, some paint chips found in the WTC dust can be bilayered, since they can consists of primer paint (red or not) and the second, "finishing" paint.

But why to bother with this? Concerning red chips closely analyzed in Bentham, they are attached to some gray layer, which consists of iron oxide mostly. No organic binder is present (according to XEDS spectra), so those layers are almost for sure rusted steel.

Btw, I would like to ask you now: "This may seem like an odd question, but is nanothermite expected to be bi-layered?":blush:
 
Last edited:
Is nano-thermate bi-layered? I guess it could be based on what it is designed to accomplish.

Have you ever taken a time-release medicine tablet? Isn't it bi-layered?

Edited to add: I didn't mean to let this go without commenting on your previous post, but isn't red primer (with your additives) still just one color? I see no finishing paint on the steel we see in photos of the WTC construction. It just looks reddish in color.
 
Last edited:
cjnewson88, KreeL,
I see you lack infornation about the subject matter.

Only the red layer has an organic matrix and contains pigments. Thus, only the red layer is paint.
The gray layer is iron oxide with small amounts of carbon an manganese. It is totally clear that this is oxidized structural steel.

Primer paint gets painted on structural steel.
The top few micro meters of any steel surface are always oxidized.
This top layer can spall off under large forces, such as are experienced by the floor joists when they find themseves in the middle of the collapse of 300,000 tons of building material.
When the oxide layer flakes off, it may retain the red primer paint coating.
 
cjnewson88, KreeL,
I see you lack infornation about the subject matter.

Only the red layer has an organic matrix and contains pigments. Thus, only the red layer is paint.
The gray layer is iron oxide with small amounts of carbon an manganese. It is totally clear that this is oxidized structural steel.

Primer paint gets painted on structural steel.
The top few micro meters of any steel surface are always oxidized.
This top layer can spall off under large forces, such as are experienced by the floor joists when they find themseves in the middle of the collapse of 300,000 tons of building material.
When the oxide layer flakes off, it may retain the red primer paint coating.

Then clearly when Harrit compared known primer paint with oxidized steel against the red/grey chips in the ash, they should have matched.
 
Then clearly when Harrit compared known primer paint with oxidized steel against the red/grey chips in the ash, they should have matched.

Yes, if Harrit had compared with the right paint formulation. He didn't. That is what this thread is all about. I recommend that you read it from the beginning, and reply only after you have seen all the arguments in this thread that converge on the conclusion that the red layer of the most interesting chips is LaClede standard primer, a paint previously not considered by anyone else. Also, you might want to look at my blog post Steven Jones proves primer paint, not thermite which shows that the authors did in fact find at least one match between a red chip and a WTC paint, they just failed to realize it.
 
Yes, if Harrit had compared with the right paint formulation. He didn't. That is what this thread is all about. I recommend that you read it from the beginning, and reply only after you have seen all the arguments in this thread that converge on the conclusion that the red layer of the most interesting chips is LaClede standard primer, a paint previously not considered by anyone else. Also, you might want to look at my blog post Steven Jones proves primer paint, not thermite which shows that the authors did in fact find at least one match between a red chip and a WTC paint, they just failed to realize it.

That's an interesting concept, especially if we find out that LaClede standard primer is thermitic.
 
Last edited:
That's an interesting concept, especially if we find out that LaClede standard primer is thermitic.

No, that paint is not thermitic. I asked you to read this thread before responding. Please do so now before asking more unnecessary questions. If you had read it, you would know already exactly what ingredients that paint has, and that elemental aluminium is not among them. Aluminium appears exclusively as inert aluminium silicate.
 
No, that paint is not thermitic. I asked you to read this thread before responding. Please do so now before asking more unnecessary questions. If you had read it, you would know already exactly what ingredients that paint has, and that elemental aluminium is not among them. Aluminium appears exclusively as inert aluminium silicate.

Alas, we can only wait until your independent laboratory confirms Harrit's findings.

Edited to add: confirms or denies.
 
Last edited:
Alas, we can only wait until your independent laboratory confirms Harrit's findings.

Edited to add: confirms or denies.

As a matter of fact, I fully trust that Harrit's data is good as far as it goes and hope that our lab confirms it. Then, our lab will, in addition, do some competent tests. The problem with Harrit that their methods, as a set, were incompetent, have been incompetently presented, and that their conclusions are even more incompetent. This is hihlighted perhaps best by the fact that in two years of work they failed to identify the abundant hematite. Hematite is Fe2O3 - the most common form of oxide of the most common metal, one of the most mundane and simplest to identify substances for any materials analyst. This team of nine "researchers" are so incredibly incompetent, they needed to be told that they were looking at plenty of hematite. Really, in terms of material sience, this is akin to a traffic accident investigator who needs to be told that one of the cars involved in an accident is a Toyota Corolla.
 
This may seem like an odd question, but is primer paint bi-layered?
Wouldn't that be two coats of the same color?
You've already been answered, but this image from NCSTAR 1-3C Appendix D should speak for itself:

paint.jpg

(better resolution image here: http://zelikow.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/pp_harrit_figure-8-new.png but I don't have permission to hotlink it)

Remember that they only collected chips attracted by a magnet, therefore there's no chip among those analyzed which doesn't have steel attached to it.
 
Thanks for the image, pgimeno. I think after KreeL's reaction to it (acknowledgment or ignorance; acceptance or handwave; or perhaps intelligent (!) follow-up question), I shall decide if he is an asset to this sub-forum, or a troll.



I have just been made aware of another truther blog post from the 911blogger.com about our new chip test:
A replication of Thermite study is coming within weeks from Dr. James Millette.
The post itself is curteous.

Some "interesting" comments, including a curteous, if cautious, one by Steven Jones
SE Jones said:
I cannot comment on Millette's impartiality at this time; I'm waiting to see his methods and the results that he actually publishes.

and a vile, personal attack, coupled with a clear statement of intent to reject any evidence that doesn't fit his delusions as fraud, by an indivual I had so far debated civilly, sometimes reaching agreement on other issues, at the 911forum:
SnowCras said:
Milette is being paid $1000 to debunk the nanothermite paper by German JREFer "Oystein". He will complete the assignment as requested and paid for. Personally,. I believe there is not a chance in hell he's going to 'confirm' the findings, but if he does, I think his principals will be very upset.

Don't be fooled by Chris Mohr's fake civility and Millette's supposed impartiality. Their agendas are much clearer if you read their online postings when they think truthers aren't watching.

Oystein has been coming around the911forum and has made his intentions and methods quite clear. Facts be damned.

I don't trust either side of the debate much anymore, but I remain dedicated to facts. The findings as published in the Active Thermitic Materials paper are not commensurate with any sort of 'paint'. The only thing which would explain the findings without nano-thermite would be scientific fraud.
 
You have a real thing for calling honest disagreement, trolling.

Willful ignorance is not "honest disagreement".

And just because you have made an argument countless times, that does not mean that people who still want to argue the point are trolls.

It would be nice if you had any new data to make reopening the argument have a point......if you don't you are just trolling.

No one forces you to participate here ozeco41.

No one forces you either......you will not be missed.
 
Then clearly when Harrit compared known primer paint with oxidized steel against the red/grey chips in the ash, they should have matched.
Yes, if Harrit had compared with the right paint formulation. He didn't. That is what this thread is all about. I recommend that you read it from the beginning, and reply only after you have seen all the arguments in this thread that converge on the conclusion that the red layer of the most interesting chips is LaClede standard primer, a paint previously not considered by anyone else. Also, you might want to look at my blog post Steven Jones proves primer paint, not thermite which shows that the authors did in fact find at least one match between a red chip and a WTC paint, they just failed to realize it.

You believe the red chips represent LaClede primer but not Tnemec primer.

You claim the red chips were only investigated for the presence of Tnemec primer.

Because the testing proved negative, it was concluded that the red chips were not Tnemec primer.

Does this not suggest that the Tnemec primer, which we know must have existed in the dust in significant quantity, must have appeared differently from the red-gray chips in the WTC dust?

Does it not seem odd that your favored LaClede primer paint completely avoided such a comparable transformation?

And your link;
http://oystein-debate.blogspot.com/2011/03/steven-jones-proves-primer-paint-not.html

You betray your heavy bias by accusing the scientists whom, unlike yourself, are qualified to explain what they observed, as hand wavers because they legitimately note that the MEK sample contained contaminants.

Dr. Niels Harrit said:
"Minute signals in level with the noise are observed from sulfur, calcium, chromium and strontium...The resulting XEDS of this chip (Figure 6, below) displays tiny blips indicating the presence of chromium and zinc. They disappeared after the chips had been soaked/rinsed with the organic solvent. Therefore, they are believed to derive from surface contamination, which very well could have been from the primer paint(!)... The signals from zinc and chromium could be from a surface contamination with primer paint."

As I said before;

"So yes he acknowledges the possibility of your primer paint as surface contamination.

Nothing new there."

MM
 
...
Does this not suggest that the Tnemec primer, which we know must have existed in the dust in significant quantity, must have appeared differently from the red-gray chips in the WTC dust?

Does it not seem odd that your favored LaClede primer paint completely avoided such a comparable transformation?
Assertion by question.

And your link;
http://oystein-debate.blogspot.com/2011/03/steven-jones-proves-primer-paint-not.html

You betray your heavy bias by accusing the scientists whom, unlike yourself, are qualified to explain what they observed, as hand wavers because they legitimately note that the MEK sample contained contaminants....
Being qualified to judge something is does not mean they were not hand-waving. I note that you do not actually deny that they were hand-waving. In fact, your basic argument is "You said my experts are wrong, therefore you're biased, therefore aliens."

The conclusion is obvious and inescapable: samples a-d are the same material, the MEK sample is a different material. It follows that any results that the authors find for the MEK sample cannot be applied to samples a-d. The authors hand-wave these results by speculating on surface contamination (p. 17). But this is not confirmed by any tests. We must assume, for the moment, that the MEK sample is of a different material than samples a-d, and that the finding of elemental Al in it (dubious as this is in itself) cannot be extrapolated to samples a-d.
See? Oystein asserts it's a hand-wave because it is unsupported speculation meant to explain away uncomfortable results.

Why do you have such dislike for our resident Deutschmann anyway?
 
I need some help from the truthers.

If I was looking at a sample of something and I believe that the surface was contaminated, but couldn't identify if it was via optical microscopy what machine would be the best to use to see the contamination and identify what that contamination was?

Thanks
 
I'm hoping that Jim will be able to identify the organic binder material seeing as this was completely by-passed by Harrit et al.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom