Sunstealer
Illuminator
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2007
- Messages
- 3,128
Bingo!Lefty,
on this, Sunstealer asked an interesting question:
If there are contaminations from other dust constituents such as paints or gypsum, we should see them in the BSE and other micrographs. These images show details as small as tens of nanometers. Particles from gypsum and paint are MUCH larger than this - pigments alone can't be much smaller than 100nm, as they would then be smaller than the wavelength of visible light, and usually pigments are somewhere between 100nm and 10µm large.
So if the micrographs don't show particle contaminations, then they are quite likely not there. It is interesting that they did not present any larger magnification for the MEK soaked chip that supposedly is contaminated with large amountss of different stuffs - only micrographs on that chip have scale markers 100µm and 500µm; the XEDS map 50µm. Contrast that with the magnifications for chips a-d which go down to 20, 10, 5 and 1µm. 1µm also on the XEDS maps. Harrit e.al. failed to show the clay platelets, for example.
Obviously the Socratic method doesn't work with truthers.
I was going to write a piece regarding contamination but quickly realised that it was going to get very technical very quickly and that in essence I was going to have to write a war and peace post on the workings of the SEM in relation to spot beam size and the use of EDX in different modes (which ultimately would be a waste of time because truthers wouldn't be able to follow it).
What you have said is in essence what I was driving at. If Harrit et al claim primer paint was a contaminant then the only thing they could have done to get the EDX spectra for Fig 14 was to have singled out a flake of primer on their thermite and then performed EDX spot-scan on that flake!
It's possible they did an area scan but anyone with any competence would realise that the result is widely different from samples a-d and therefore be highly skeptical of the result and investigate further. This they didn't do.
Fig 31 in their paper clearly shows what their thinking process was because they claim that's thermite too even though that chip bears no resemblance to the others shown, visually or chemically.
1. Can it be separated with a magnet?
2 Is it red?
3. If 1 and 2 are true then all samples are the same and all samples are thermite.