Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

Lefty,
on this, Sunstealer asked an interesting question:

If there are contaminations from other dust constituents such as paints or gypsum, we should see them in the BSE and other micrographs. These images show details as small as tens of nanometers. Particles from gypsum and paint are MUCH larger than this - pigments alone can't be much smaller than 100nm, as they would then be smaller than the wavelength of visible light, and usually pigments are somewhere between 100nm and 10µm large.
So if the micrographs don't show particle contaminations, then they are quite likely not there. It is interesting that they did not present any larger magnification for the MEK soaked chip that supposedly is contaminated with large amountss of different stuffs - only micrographs on that chip have scale markers 100µm and 500µm; the XEDS map 50µm. Contrast that with the magnifications for chips a-d which go down to 20, 10, 5 and 1µm. 1µm also on the XEDS maps. Harrit e.al. failed to show the clay platelets, for example.
Bingo!

Obviously the Socratic method doesn't work with truthers.

I was going to write a piece regarding contamination but quickly realised that it was going to get very technical very quickly and that in essence I was going to have to write a war and peace post on the workings of the SEM in relation to spot beam size and the use of EDX in different modes (which ultimately would be a waste of time because truthers wouldn't be able to follow it).

What you have said is in essence what I was driving at. If Harrit et al claim primer paint was a contaminant then the only thing they could have done to get the EDX spectra for Fig 14 was to have singled out a flake of primer on their thermite and then performed EDX spot-scan on that flake!

It's possible they did an area scan but anyone with any competence would realise that the result is widely different from samples a-d and therefore be highly skeptical of the result and investigate further. This they didn't do.

Fig 31 in their paper clearly shows what their thinking process was because they claim that's thermite too even though that chip bears no resemblance to the others shown, visually or chemically.

1. Can it be separated with a magnet?
2 Is it red?
3. If 1 and 2 are true then all samples are the same and all samples are thermite.
 
And if he doesn't? Will you denounce Harrits findings?
Cue dodge.

This is new stuff. I'll wait to see what Jim has to say about it. ...
I suppose that if Jim confirms Harrit's findings that you will push for a new investigation into 9/11? Arson is arson, afterall.

I owe me five bucks.

I love how Truthers literally can't even acknowledge a hypothetical scenario where they're wrong.
 
Last edited:
This is an honest question, so please don't take this as any kind of attack, etc, and I do appreciate what you Chris, Ivan, and Jim are doing because I think it's the right approach.

But isn't your comment exactly what you expect Twoofies to say if Jim does not find thermitic properties in the chip? In other words, why do you get to play this card, when you know Twoofies will be assaulted for making the same claim? Just curious, and again, it's an honest question. Thanks.

I might note that of course I am not ignoring the fact that Millette had not, as of a couple of days ago, found Sr-chromate - in fact, it was I who brought that up! Strange that someone would quote my talking about X, followed by the moronic claim that I am ignoring X. What the truther/troll is ignoring himself is the obvious fact that Millette hasn't finished his study and hasn't published any results. His not finding Sr-chromate could simply be due to the fact that he hasn't found enough of the chips a-d material. I can wait for the report and the data when they are read
There you go. Truthers will come up with some unsupported nonsense and declare it to be absolute fact, Oys has advanced a potential explanation but is open to other possibilities.
 
I have to admit that I barely understand most of the processes used to examine the chips. I am familiar with visible-light microscopy and have been since childhood, driven largely by an interest in biology.

My knowledge of chemistry is also a bit limited due to my being dyscalculic nearly to the point of being disabled.

So, I have to ask two things:

1) Would the strontium chromate be actually observable as crystals in the paint?

2) Can strontium chromate be disolved in the hydro carbon matrix?

1) Here are some micrographs of strontium chromate from a pigment compendium. This is transmission microscopy:
SrCr_7_Image.jpg

SrCr_3_Image.jpg

SrCr_2_Image.jpg

SrCr_1_Image.jpg

As Dr. Millette wrote the other day, these pigments would indeed be visible as pale yellow chrystal under a good microscope.

2) Ivan went a bit deeper into that.
I am talking from my gut here: I expect most of the LaClede paint to have stayed cool at all times, and thus not have degraded thermally. It wouldn't make sense to use pigments in a matrix that dissolves them. I am very convinced that tese pigments are still in the paint, and if Jim finds chips that resemble (a)-(d) but can't find strontium chromate in them, that would be a serious blow to the LaClede theory. I'd like to discuss it with Jim then - maybe he has reasons why barely over 1% of that stuff is too little to be reliably detected? - but am ready to admit that, despite all these months of certainty, the LaClede theory could not be proven.
 
This is an honest question, so please don't take this as any kind of attack, etc, and I do appreciate what you Chris, Ivan, and Jim are doing because I think it's the right approach.

But isn't your comment exactly what you expect Twoofies to say if Jim does not find thermitic properties in the chip? In other words, why do you get to play this card, when you know Twoofies will be assaulted for making the same claim? Just curious, and again, it's an honest question. Thanks.

Honest? Strange that you left out this part of my previous post when you quoted me:
...
I might note that of course I am not ignoring the fact that Millette had not, as of a couple of days ago, found Sr-chromate - in fact, it was I who brought that up! Strange that someone would quote my talking about X, followed by the moronic claim that I am ignoring X. What the truther/troll is ignoring himself is the obvious fact that Millette hasn't finished his study and hasn't published any results. ...
I guess it is pretty obvious that we should all wait with our conclusions until the study is done and we have the data.

When I speculated that Millette maybe hasn't found enough of the right specimens yet, I meant that maybe he had, as of the time that he wrote to Chris, not come across what I am looking for. I am keeping my fingers crossed and hope that the data, when final, will show one of these two:
  • No chips in Millettes samples have the chemical and physical signature of chips (a)-(d) - in that case, no preditions about them can be verified or falsified. We'd then probably get a discussion about why Jones found so many and Millette none, and I have no idea yet how that might pan out
  • Millette does find chips similar to (a)-(d) and also finds SrCrO4 in them. Then it's game over
Of course I am aware of the third ans last possibility:
  • Jim finds chips similar to (a)-(d), but no SrCrO4 in them, although in his assessment he should have found a 1% occurence of it, if present. In that case, my theory is falsified


You see, I still stand by what I said earlier:
...I have specific predictions for these ingredients:

  • ...
  • In addition, I predict the finding of strontium chromate crystals
Making these predictions could mean that I can be proven WRONG by Millette, and indeed we have a first reaction that he has NOT yet found strontium chromate.
...




Now that is the comclusions with regard to MY objective in the study, which is to get data that would help us to verify or falsify the LaClede theory.

Jim however has a contract with Chris, and both Jim and Chris have objectives different from mine. In short, they are looking for evidence of thermite. So even if we have to reject the idea that some chips are LaClede primer (as specified in that NIST appendix), the study could still prove or disprove that any or all chips are thermitic in nature. In the simplest case, Jim looks at x different kinds of red-gray chips and finds them all lacking in elemental Al.
 
Re: Steel anticorrosion primers in the TT:
Table abbreviated. Tons for both Towers.
My primer notes in ( ) added

NCSTAR 1-3A http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire05/PDF/f05157.pdf

Total tonnage ~ 190,000 tons of steel for both Towers

Laclede tonnage from http://survivethejivealive.blogspot.com/

As far as I could find, the NIST Tnemec primer spec (Tnemec 69,95)came from Piitsburg-De Moines Steel Co, who only fabricated the 4th to 9th floor exterior columns.
NCSTAR 1-3C
ETA: Found Tnemec 99 specified by Pacific Car Foundry for their exterior columns. It appears this is Pacific's specs for their primer for their work. "Please find PCH (Pacific Car and Foundry) painting spcecifications ..." Tnemec 99
NCSTAR 1-6A
http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build05/PDF/b05035.pdf


Approximately 94,600 tons of steel with known primers (Tnemec and Laclede. Leclede primer for the trusses may represent more paint by steel weight, due to their greater surface area to weight ratio) ; 95,400 tons with unknown steel primers.
This may explain other steel anti-corrosion primer paints that may be found.

Your 24,000 tons of floor joists could be for one tower only. Greg Urich calculated the following amounts of structural steel (all metric tons) for one tower:
22,929 core columns
28,849 ext columns
6,300 ext spandrels
8,145 floor inside core, steel component of CDL (without rebar and deck)
26,382 floor outside core, steel component of CDL (without rebar and deck)
SUM: 92,020

On the other hand, a while ago I compiled an excel sheet where I put down the dimensions of the different steel element (L-bars, round bars) of the joist, did the necessary additions and multiplications to get total surface per truss, floor and tower; re-using that sheet to compute steel volume and then weight, I get 12,800 metric tons per tower (110 floors above ground).

Anyway, I need to find your post again, so:
# oysteinbookmark
 
Ivan, I knew about this Millette report generally and asked if I can attend. Cost of attendance is high, but yes, Dr. Millette has told me a couple weeks ago the initial results will be in our hands very soon. This conference is keeping him on track timewise because now he must do the research so he can prepare his lecture.

I suppose it is too much to expect that those who financed research that Dr. Millette was otherwise unwilling to undertake, should receive some of the preliminary data before the rest of the world?

Not providing a free invite to the person who organized the financing is just 'insult to injury'.

It sounds like Dr. Millette played you like a fish Chris.

MM
 
I suppose it is too much to expect that those who financed research that Dr. Millette was otherwise unwilling to undertake, should receive some of the preliminary data before the rest of the world?

That makes perfect sense, since (1) we know that Millette won't do that, and (2) the rest of the world will be at the conference.

Not providing a free invite to the person who organized the financing is just 'insult to injury'.

And that makes perfect sense, because everyone who presents at a conference gets to hand out "free invites."

MM, you present me with a Hobson's choice.
 
That makes perfect sense, since (1) we know that Millette won't do that, and (2) the rest of the world will be at the conference.



And that makes perfect sense, because everyone who presents at a conference gets to hand out "free invites."

MM, you present me with a Hobson's choice.

To be fair...
I'm sure if JREF funded a multimillion dollar study, there might be a few free tickets in the deal.
 
I suppose it is too much to expect that those who financed research that Dr. Millette was otherwise unwilling to undertake, should receive some of the preliminary data before the rest of the world?

Not providing a free invite to the person who organized the financing is just 'insult to injury'.

It sounds like Dr. Millette played you like a fish Chris.

MM

how do you play a fish?

stop looking for things to complain about and just wait
 
That makes perfect sense, since (1) we know that Millette won't do that, and (2) the rest of the world will be at the conference.



And that makes perfect sense, because everyone who presents at a conference gets to hand out "free invites."

MM, you present me with a Hobson's choice.

You miss the most salient point.

Supposedly, until Chris Mohr organized the financing for the research, Dr. Millette, just like the rest of the disinterested scientific community, was going to DO ABSOLUTELY NOTHING!

Thanks to our financing, he is now in the position of making a presentation.

If it was done on his initiative and his dime, I would be completely understanding.

MM
 
You miss the most salient point.

Supposedly, until Chris Mohr organized the financing for the research, Dr. Millette, just like the rest of the disinterested scientific community, was going to DO ABSOLUTELY NOTHING!

Thanks to our financing, he is now in the position of making a presentation.

If it was done on his initiative and his dime, I would be completely understanding.

MM

and yet you're the only 1 whining about it
 
I suppose it is too much to expect that those who financed research that Dr. Millette was otherwise unwilling to undertake, should receive some of the preliminary data before the rest of the world?

Not providing a free invite to the person who organized the financing is just 'insult to injury'.

It sounds like Dr. Millette played you like a fish Chris.

MM

I disagree. Dr. Millette already said that he is providing a service for MUCH less than what we have all chipped in to finance.

The fact that he's doing this at a loss, is more than enough for me.

I can wait for the report.

(Nice try at getting any of our feathers ruffled though. )
 
I suppose it is too much to expect that those who financed research that Dr. Millette was otherwise unwilling to undertake, should receive some of the preliminary data before the rest of the world?

Not providing a free invite to the person who organized the financing is just 'insult to injury'.

It sounds like Dr. Millette played you like a fish Chris.

MM

Giving out preliminary data is unwise as folks tend to jump the gun and make unsupported claims:rolleyes:

And since the paper will be published what difference does it make if Chris gets a freebie invite or not.
 
You miss the most salient point.

Supposedly, until Chris Mohr organized the financing for the research, Dr. Millette, just like the rest of the disinterested scientific community, was going to DO ABSOLUTELY NOTHING!

They arent doing absolutely nothing they are working on other things :rolleyes: They are disinterested because only a few fringe fanatic believe iron microspheres and these paint chips prove ZOMG inside job.
 
Well, we are waiting for some results of Jim Millette...

Meanwhile, I'd like to link again interesting page of Henryco with his micrographs of "red-red" chips.

Once again: as you can see, he frequently observed some gray/shiny areas even in non-burned chips. His chips stayed red after heating and, as regards for XEDS, only carbon peak was missing/was very small after heating (expected, since polymer binder was burned out from this paint).

It's impossible to say if all those chips were the same material, but they simply look similar.
Notably, all three XEDS (Fig.5) show distinct peaks of Ca and S, similar like in the first two chips shown by Jim Millette. Henryco thinks that it is from surface contamination, but these elements still can be present in the chip material in all cases. Are we looking here at some chips different (by origin) from Bentham chips (a) to (d)? Who knows...:cool:
 
Last edited:
Well, we are waiting for some results of Jim Millette...

Meanwhile, I'd like to link again interesting page of Henryco with his micrographs of "red-red" chips.

Once again: as you can see, he frequently observed some gray/shiny areas even in non-burned chips. His chips stayed red after heating and, as regards for XEDS, only carbon peak was missing/was very small after heating (expected, since polymer binder was burned out from this paint).

It's hard to say if all those chips were the same material, but they simply look similar.
Notably, all three XEDS (Fig.5) show distinct peaks of Ca and S, similar like in the first two chips shown by Jim Millette. Henryco thinks that it is from surface contamination by gypsum (probable), but still these elements can be present in the chip material in all cases. Are we looking here at some chips different (by origin) from Bentham chips (a) to (d)? Who knows...:cool:
I noticed on his spectra for all three samples, they also show two small spikes that are not labelled.

Following the Ca spike, the is a spike at the point labelled "4" and, follwing Fe, there is a peak at 7.

Having no idea what any of this means, I have to ask, could either of the these pikes represent either strontium or chromium.
 
...
It's impossible to say if all those chips were the same material, but they simply look similar.
Notably, all three XEDS (Fig.5) show distinct peaks of Ca and S, similar like in the first two chips shown by Jim Millette. Henryco thinks that it is from surface contamination, but these elements still can be present in the chip material in all cases. Are we looking here at some chips different (by origin) from Bentham chips (a) to (d)? Who knows...:cool:
But that's the thing - HenryCo, like Harrit e.al., fails to thoroughly label and describe chips, so that it would become possible to distinguish them. He, too, puls the "could be contamination" card without putting in any effort to identify the contamination.
In Fig 13, he has waaaay too much Ca and S for my taste. With such different data, the null-hypothesis clearly is "no, Henryco's chips are not the same material as a-d". Speculation and asking questions is not the way to change that null-hypothesis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom