Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

In that case, I have to ask, what is the point of doing the analysis?

We already know that if there was any kind of thermite, it would be an insignificant amount, so what else is there to say? What would this analysis do, confirm his findings? What for? Basile already has a reputation among truthers and he has debunked the ability to use the material for the purported intention, were it indeed thermitic.

Unless, of course, the chips Basile checked were not true Scotsmen, er, thermitic.

You guys put an incredible amount of weight on a single dust sampling.

I have argued in the melted steel thread that higher concentrations of red chips in the building footprints are a reasonable expectation.

The Mark Basile sample came from outside WTC Ground Zero. My expectation is that that dust would hold lower concentrations of red chips.

MM
 
You guys put an incredible amount of weight on a single dust sampling.

I have argued in the melted steel thread that higher concentrations of red chips in the building footprints are a reasonable expectation.

The Mark Basile sample came from outside WTC Ground Zero. My expectation is that that dust would hold lower concentrations of red chips.

MM
You also argued that the debris under ground zero was "hermetically sealed" keeping it from bursting into flames until the right moment (thus making the thermite burn for months).


:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You also argued that the debris under ground zero was "hermetically sealed" keeping it from bursting into flames until the right moment (thus making the thermite burn for months).

So what is your point other than adding to your post count?

MM
 
In that case, I have to ask, what is the point of doing the analysis?

We already know that if there was any kind of thermite, it would be an insignificant amount, so what else is there to say? What would this analysis do, confirm his findings? What for? Basile already has a reputation among truthers and he has debunked the ability to use the material for the purported intention, were it indeed thermitic.

Unless, of course, the chips Basile checked were not true Scotsmen, er, thermitic.

Ask Chris what his point is.

My interest is to get some more data towards proving LaClede paint.

Our common goal is to totally destroy Harrit & Co in a way that even truthers cannot deny.
 
You guys put an incredible amount of weight on a single dust sampling.

I have argued in the melted steel thread that higher concentrations of red chips in the building footprints are a reasonable expectation.

The Mark Basile sample came from outside WTC Ground Zero. My expectation is that that dust would hold lower concentrations of red chips.

MM

Lower concentration in the overall dust, yes, but the individual chips themselves would be the base material that is being tested and unless they are a high percentage thermitic material they simply would not sustain a thermitic reaction. The tests are on individual chips, not the dust en masse. If the test of the individual chips come up with no measurable thermite then its safe to assume there is none at all as a material that contains a low percentage would be useless to heat up anything as it would not ignite.
 
You also argued that the debris under ground zero was "hermetically sealed" keeping it from bursting into flames until the right moment (thus making the thermite burn for months).


:rolleyes:

The topic of this thread is still "identify the paint", not "discuss thermite theory". I am cool with talking about Chris' quest to have chips analysed to rule out thermite, as I hope I will get useful data for paint identification as a side effect. But beyond that, debate with MM about his thermite delusions is fruitless, and, in my opinion, solidly off-topic. I'd like to kindly ask to not pursue that hopeless endeavour any further in this thread. Thanks.
 
The topic of this thread is still "identify the paint", not "discuss thermite theory". I am cool with talking about Chris' quest to have chips analysed to rule out thermite, as I hope I will get useful data for paint identification as a side effect. But beyond that, debate with MM about his thermite delusions is fruitless, and, in my opinion, solidly off-topic. I'd like to kindly ask to not pursue that hopeless endeavour any further in this thread. Thanks.
Sorry...................................

:boxedin:
 
The topic of this thread is still "identify the paint", not "discuss thermite theory". I am cool with talking about Chris' quest to have chips analysed to rule out thermite, as I hope I will get useful data for paint identification as a side effect. But beyond that, debate with MM about his thermite delusions is fruitless, and, in my opinion, solidly off-topic. I'd like to kindly ask to not pursue that hopeless endeavour any further in this thread. Thanks.

To be clear, it is fine for Chris to talk about thermite but when I respond in kind it is a no-no?

Hmmm as Chris would say.

MM
 
Ask Chris what his point is.

My interest is to get some more data towards proving LaClede paint.

Our common goal is to totally destroy Harrit & Co in a way that even truthers cannot deny.

I thought your goal was to publish an ego-feeding paper that knocked down major scientific research by proving the red chips were primer paint?

So far all your proof has amounted to little more than puffery.

MM
 
I'd like to take this remark as an opportunity to repeat and point out that part of the response in this forum is the pledges by several members, including myself, to chip in real money (something MM only hints at but never takes serious). Chris, when the plan stands and the quotes are in, contact me how much you need.

MM, are you in, too? Willing to support this with a bit of your own, real money?

Has MM replied to this yet?
Money is needed at this time to make progress.
 
For posteriority, here is a summary of Mark Basile's analysis:

This from this video. Can someone download this video, so we still have it in case it's taken off of Youtube? Thanks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJ7hXrmMRPc#!

According to the presentation, between 30:00 and 31:26 minutes, he received a bag with "a few table-spoons" of dust collected by Janette MacKinlay in January 2008. Janette MacKinlay is one of the four contributors of dust samples to Harrit e.al.. The dust had been collected from
"her fourth-floor apartment at 113 Cedar St./110 Liberty St. in New York City, across the street from the WTC plaza. As the South Tower collapsed, the flowing cloud of dust and debris caused windows of her apartment to break inward and dust filled her apartment. She escaped by quickly wrapping a wet towel around her head and exiting the building. The building was closed for entry for about a week. As soon as Ms. MacKinlay was allowed to re-enter her apartment, she did so and began cleaning up. There was a thick layer of dust on the floor. She collected some of it into a large sealable plastic bag for possible later use in an art piece" (Bentham paper, page 9).​
Basile isolated various dust particles from the sample, using a magnet and a petri dish, among them “iron based microsperes, Red/gray chips, Red chips, Rust, Wire”, also “Silicate or glassy spheres”.
Basile_32_07_MagneticDustComponents.jpg

(screenshot taken at 32:07)

One particular red/gray flake, designated “#13”, was photographed through a microscope (at 39:00),
Basile_39_00_Chip13_Photo.jpg

and analysed using XEDS and then heated till ignition, and the burning recorded on video through a microspcope.

Here is the XEDS data, shown at 39:30 in the video:
Basile_39_30_Chip13_XEDS.jpg

[edited this image; I originally had a wrong graph up here]

This is how he describes the heating (40:17):
Basile_40_17_Chip13_HowToHeatIt-1.png


I am not showing the burn video sequence here. I don't think screenshots do it justice. It's at 41:42 - 41:59 in the video. (I forgot - what do I have to add to a YT URL to go directly to a time stamp - say, 41:40? Thanks)

The XEDS graph resembles closely Fig. 7c in Harrit e.al., albeit with relatively less Fe or more Al and Si. While we have doubts about the precision of the Weight % listed in the table, we note that the weight proportion of Si : Al, 1.71% : 1.68%, translates to molar proportions of 98 : 100, in other words, according to Basile's calculation, there are only 2% fewer Si atoms in the red material than Al atoms.

We further note that about 73% carbon represents > 90% organic matrix. 2.63% Fe could represent 3.76% Fe2O3, binding 1.13% O. 1.71% Si could represent 7,86% aluminium silicate (kaolinite, Al2Si2O5(OH)4), binding 4.38% O. All other elements together are 1.8%.

(edit: I removed discussion of supposed possibility of there being thermite - that would be off topic here - and instead posted it in an appropriate thread)
 
Last edited:
For posteriority, here is a summary of Mark Basile's analysis:

This from this video. Can someone download this video, so we still have it in case it's taken off of Youtube? Thanks!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJ7hXrmMRPc#!

SNIP...

I haved saved a copy of the video as an .MP4 in 1080p.

I am not showing the burn video sequence here. I don't think screenshots do it justice. It's at 41:42 - 41:59 in the video. (I forgot - what do I have to add to a YT URL to go directly to a time stamp - say, 41:40? Thanks)

SNIP....

Code:
[url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJ7hXrmMRPc#t=41m42s[/url]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJ7hXrmMRPc#t=41m42s
 
Thermite is composed primarily of iron oxide and aluminum oxide.

Rusted re-bar and aluminum wiring are kind of common in sky scrapers, right?

So what's the point?
 
Ivan Kminek: I have the same point as Oystein: I don′t understand how SEM or polarized light microscopy can prove elemental aluminum.

If i got the samples, i would use a soft x-ray synchrotron beamline with a photon energy of around 1.6 keV, as recommended by Argonne National Laboratory Center for Nanoscale Materials.
 
I have often wondered if threads about thermite would exist if the chips of paint submitted to harrit where in fact Blue or Yellow or Green.

Thermite painted on an inch think would not amount to much, even if ya could get it to ignite and keep it in place. 70 years on and we still can't even guarantee that a solid ball of thermite encased in a steel shell will melt a tanks barrel let alone help demolish two 110 story building. Give it a rest will ya.
 
I was just thinking about predictions we would derive from a "LaClede paint theory" if we used the methods employed by Harrit e.al, Basile, Couannier and whoever else studied red-gray chips.

The theory goes like this:
"When the twin towers collapsed, paint and primer was scraped off of all sorts of surfaces. Scraped-off paint and primer mixed with the general dust and was deposited around Ground Zero. Jones found red-gray chips that represented two or more red paints clinging to spalled-off steel and possibly other surfaces. One such paint was LaClede primer paint from floor joists."​

In this thread, we have found that several predictions about this LaClede theory are confirmed by Harrit and Basile, among them:
  • The Almond produced the expected XEDS spectrum for a mix of the materials in the spec for floor joist primer
  • We expect to see the known shapes and sizes of crystals of some iron oxide(s) and aluminium silicate(s), and indeed they are there: rhombohedral hematite and stacks of kaolinite platelets
  • We expect to see organic matrix ignitinng and burning in air somewhere in a range between 325°C and 500°C
  • We expect an energy output of more than 4 kJ/g - indeed, two of the four samples satisfy that expectation
  • We expect some of the gray layers to contain a small amount of manganese, besides large amounts of iron and oxigene. And yes, there is manganese in at least 3 of the 4 gray layers

There are some more predictions that I just thought of that I don't think anybody has looked into here - so here's a call-out for input:
  1. LaClede primer contains a small amount of strontium chromate as pigment. With a little luck, these might show up in the photomicrographs. What would strontium chromate pigments look like? Size and shape? Does anyone see any?
  2. What would we expect with regard to the geometric properties of the gray layer - what range of thickness, would there usually be more gray than red material, what would edges look like... I think the best evidence here would be photomicrographs of known epoxy primer on spalled-off steel from other sources.

Are there any other predictions that we can test with their data that I forgot?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom