Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

My lab guy has been busier than I thought, talking to several chemists and trying to create an economically viable protocol to test for thermitic material in the WTC dust. In the meantime, his curiosity inspired him to do a few more preliminary tests of his own on the WTC dust his lab has in its possession. By the end of this week Santa may have something for us yet. It's fun finding a chemist who won't weigh in on an opinion until he gets the data, even for a theory that is unpopular in most of the scientific community. This is the kind of guy who will lend credibility to the results.

You mean it is always nice to find someone honest.

Hopefully if he sees distressing results, he will remain impartial.

MM
 
I hope this for all of us, but the best I can do MM is to promise to accept the results myself and invite others (you, your fellow 9/11 Truth people, my fellow 9/11 natural collapse advocates) to keep an open mind as this inquiry progresses. It's going to be a process. I know for myself that if the chips test positive I'll still have other questions but there will be a shift in my perspective and a new journey of inquiry. Many will not accept this invitation, but if some of us do, that's a start.
 
Thanks again for your effort, Chris. Since I (we) still don't know what experiments are planned by "your" chemist(s) it's basically impossible to have any opinion now. Anyway, I am looking forward to any results of this planned research on the red chips...
 
.... I know for myself that if the chips test positive I'll still have other questions but there will be a shift in my perspective and a new journey of inquiry. Many will not accept this invitation, but if some of us do, that's a start.
Many of us have already taken that what for you is a "new journey of inquiry". We would collectively agree "no CD" which is the driver reason for pursuing the thermXte residue issue. (There is a secondary reason - purely scientific curiosity.)

Those who think like me have been concerned to answer the question "CD or not?" and it is a lot easier to answer by paths other than analysing for residues.

Still you knew that. Best wishes with your initiative. :)
 
And, if he doesn't see distressing results, you will become impartial.

Do you have a problem with reading comprehension?

By impartial I meant that he remain honest about his findings regardless of any horrific conclusions they may lead him to.

I have always been ready and willing to support the Official Story if and when it gets properly investigated.

Too much of the Official Story is based on foregone conclusions and far too little on a thorough and open minded scientific investigation.

MM
 
Do you have a problem with reading comprehension?

By impartial I meant that he remain honest about his findings regardless of any horrific conclusions they may lead him to.

I have always been ready and willing to support the Official Story if and when it gets properly investigated.

Too much of the Official Story is based on foregone conclusions and far too little on a thorough and open minded scientific investigation.

MM

Uh huh.

:rolleyes:

Which is why you'll never discuss basic problems that truthers can't even invent a way around, such as how the (bleep) did the explosives survive for an hour?
 
Too much of the Official Story is based on foregone rational conclusions and far too little on a thorough and open minded scientific investigation looking at crackpot theories involving a magical explosive that leaves no tangible evidence and works quietly.
MM
Here is my chop on this. Send it to Radio, ready to transmit!
 
Lab Guy's Protocol

Hi Gang,

Santa's dropped off quite a present for me... my Lab Guy has gotten real interested in the WTC dust. For $1000 he will do several tests on the red-grey chips and with his own nickel will do more, including "PLM, SEM, TEM and FTIR after sample treatment." He has still indicated scientific neutrality about what we will find... no conclusions till the test results are in. He has already done some initial tests on the red-grey chips in his lab's collection of WTC dust. We're hoping to get a sample of red-gray chips from Kevin Ryan, which he believes has thermitic material in it.

Anyway, family time and lots of work over the holidays so I will return to this either next week or in early January, but I welcome any comments in the meantime. Hope your holidays are swell everyone: don't eat to to discomfort and don't take the family madness too seriously!
 
OK, Chris:o)
Oystein, perhaps we can take it as some "impuls" that we should formulate our hypotheses as soon as possible and publish them at least on your blog; otherwise, our priority concerning red paints as culprits might be lost.
Anyway, Merry Christmas to everybody (including MM, Bill etc.);)
 
Last edited:
Just for the sake of clarity, "he" refers to Kevin Ryan, not your chemist, correct?
Yes, I am going to ask Kevin Ryan to give us some red-gray chips which Kevin Ryan believes have thermitic material in them. Lab Guy has told me that his initial tests have not yet yielded evidence of thermite, but Lab Guy also says "Additional testing by PLM, SEM, TEM and FTIR after sample treatment may tell us differently." This indicates to me that he has not formed a conclusion prior to receiving all the data.
 
OK, Chris:o)
Oystein, perhaps we can take it as some "impuls" that we should formulate our hypotheses as soon as possible and publish them at least on your blog; otherwise, our priority concerning red paints as culprits might be lost.
Anyway, Merry Christmas to everybody (including MM, Bill etc.);)
Oystein and Ivan:

I like the idea of you fairly quickly publishing your hypothesis about red-gray chips being paint, and any analysis you have made of the data as shown by the original Harritt et al experiments. Even if it's just on a blog, I would forward that on to Lab Guy and he'd have that info to look at. It's two different approaches anyway: you looking for evidence of paint and Lab Guy looking for evidence of thermitic materials.

This has been a slow process even getting to this point. Next step after Christmas will be to write to Kevin Ryan, Richard Gage and other 9/11 activists and see if I can get Kevin to agree to yield up some chips he thinks are thermitic. If we get those, then there is raising the $1000, as in checks in hand. Then the experiments, written results. To quote my Lab Guy, "We will only invoice you after we have sent you a report with something substantial." It sounds like the report will be pretty meaty. As I said, he wants to put a lot of his own time into this and the full resources of his lab, well beyond $1000 worth, so we'll get some strong scientific results here.
 
I'm willing to throw $CDN20 at this.
pm me with an address once you are ready.

Anyone else willing to part with twenty bucks? ETA: how about the eqivalent of approx 1 hour's pay after taxes. 1/40th of a week's take-home pay
MM?
 
Last edited:
I'm willing to throw $CDN20 at this.
pm me with an address once you are ready.

Anyone else willing to part with twenty bucks? ETA: how about the eqivalent of approx 1 hour's pay after taxes. 1/40th of a week's take-home pay
MM?
MM has already made arrangements with me to pitch in. And several other 9/11 Truth people have offered as well. No one is under any obligation to contribute, but all contributions are welcome. Remember, some of us have six-figure incomes and others of us are on fixed-income modest pensions. This will be a no-guilt pitch I promise!
 
MM has already made arrangements with me to pitch in. And several other 9/11 Truth people have offered as well. No one is under any obligation to contribute, but all contributions are welcome. Remember, some of us have six-figure incomes and others of us are on fixed-income modest pensions. This will be a no-guilt pitch I promise!
I'm in. Let me know how you want to handle it. PayPal works good or I can send you a check.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom