Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

Everybody, seriously: It is totally 100% worth- and pointless to try to convince MM of anything, make him retract or admit anything, or prove him wrong or anything.

Why do you guys try?

He is trolling this thread! He has nothing to contribute to the topic, and neither have you guys! You know he is fundamentally wrong, I know it, everybody knows it, and we all know that he will never ever admit it - so cut it out already!
 
Yet you have 0 evidence it wasn't. I can only think it was an outright intentional lie or you were assuming.

Nice though how you failed to address the fact that Jones has refused to supply samples to outsiders.

I give you an 8.5. Your dismount was fair, but you didn't quite stick the landing.

And you believe Dr. Jones should act as a WTC dust supplier for every Tom, Dick and Harry that wants a sample?

There are a lot of sources.

I'm sure there must be tons of the stuff at Fresh Kills landfill.

Free for the taking.

MM
 
Why do you guys try?

He is trolling this thread! He has nothing to contribute to the topic, and neither have you guys! You know he is fundamentally wrong, I know it, everybody knows it, and we all know that he will never ever admit it - so cut it out already!

Agreed! I'm bored with the ball of yarn!
 
@ DGM, or anybody in or near NYC:

DGM, was it you who offered a while ago to go to wherever they store WTC debris, and try to obtain a sample of Floor Joist Surface?

At any rate, it would be great if someone reading this thread who is near New York City could help us out here!

If we get such a sample of actual floor joist primer, then we could have it analysed. I am thinking of two approaches:
a) Either do the same tests that Harrit e.al. did - maybe even give THEM a sample, too
b) Give it to the same lab that Chris Mohr goes to with his red-gray-chips sample he hopefully gets from Kevin Ryan



And if everybody who has nothing substantial to add to the thread topic stays out, maybe this post will be seen by those to whom it may concern ;)
 
"Since the red chips ignite at 430 C, they could very well have been used to create the high ignition temperature required for thermite or thermate."
"So could a plane crash and subsequent MASSIVE explosion. Why didn't that ignite the thermite?"

I suggest you do some homework and look up the ignition requirements for thermite.

MM
 
Everybody, seriously: It is totally 100% worth- and pointless to try to convince MM of anything, make him retract or admit anything, or prove him wrong or anything.

Why do you guys try?

He is trolling this thread! He has nothing to contribute to the topic, and neither have you guys! You know he is fundamentally wrong, I know it, everybody knows it, and we all know that he will never ever admit it - so cut it out already!

If you were really that certain you wouldn't have to do so much hand waving.

I am not trolling, just replying to posts directed at me.

Too funny.

MM
 
Last edited:
@ DGM, or anybody in or near NYC:

DGM, was it you who offered a while ago to go to wherever they store WTC debris, and try to obtain a sample of Floor Joist Surface?
Wasn't me. I live closer to NY than you but it's still not a hop-skip-jump. I did offer to help pay for the tests (the offer still stands).

:)
 
Wasn't me. I live closer to NY than you but it's still not a hop-skip-jump. I did offer to help pay for the tests (the offer still stands).

:)

Dang.... how many pages of useless spamming by and with MM do I have to browse now to find who suggested he could try to get a sample for us... grrrrr
 
Everybody, seriously: It is totally 100% worth- and pointless to try to convince MM of anything, make him retract or admit anything, or prove him wrong or anything.

Why do you guys try?

He is trolling this thread! He has nothing to contribute to the topic, and neither have you guys! You know he is fundamentally wrong, I know it, everybody knows it, and we all know that he will never ever admit it - so cut it out already!

Will do.

There are many other threads where the display of ignorance can be viewed.


My apologies. Carry on
 
heated to no more than 430 °C, red chip go boom

Since the red chips ignite at 430 C, they could very well have been used to create the high ignition temperature required for thermite or thermate.

MM
lol


So could a plane crash and subsequent MASSIVE explosion. Why didn't that ignite the thermite?



I suggest you do some homework and look up the ignition requirements for thermite.

MM
Here is homework, and from the idiots, the nut case paranoid conspiracy theorists who can't figure out 911 given the answers, we have the insane Jones paper, "Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe", we have
a thermitic reaction actually occurs as in that case ignition is observed when the red material is heated to no more than 430 °C.
Means all the thermite in your delusional fantasy burned up shortly after aircraft impacts. I bet the follow nuts don't agree with your version of 911, if you had one;
Niels H. Harrit, Department of Chemistry, University of Copenhagen, Denmark,
Jeffrey Farrer, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT 84602, USA,
Steven E. Jones, S&J Scientific Co., Provo, UT, 84606, USA,
Kevin R. Ryan, 9/11 Working Group of Bloomington, Bloomington, IN 47401, USA,
Frank M. Legge Logical Systems Consulting, Perth, Western Australia,
Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth, Berkeley, CA 94704, USA,
James R. Gourley, International Center for 9/11 Studies, Dallas, TX 75231, USA,
and Bradley R. Larsen, S&J Scientific Co., Provo, UT, 84606, USA.

Wonder if the University of Copenhagen knows Niels is nuts on 911? The same for Jeffrey at Brigham Young, do they know they have a nut on the staff?


Jet fuel fires burn 1200 F/600 C, a temperature above the insane Jones says your super-duper-secret-nano-nonsense-thermite auto ignites at. Thus all your secret thermite would ignite in a few minutes after impacts. This makes your lie super-duper-dumb. There is not a lol big enough to do your delusions justice.
 
Last edited:
Triforcharity was from NYC and was on the FDNY. Maybe he knows someone.

Thanks, I'll ask him. Tri hasn't posted in this thread - someone else, I forgot who, offered a while back in this thread to go there. :(
 
And you believe Dr. Jones should act as a WTC dust supplier for every Tom, Dick and Harry that wants a sample?

There are a lot of sources.

I'm sure there must be tons of the stuff at Fresh Kills landfill.

Free for the taking.

MM

Which isn't what we were talking about. But its OK, I am sure yo got to find a way to run away from it.

If you were really that certain you wouldn't have to do so much hand waving.

I am not trolling, just replying to posts directed at me.

Too funny.

MM

Oh the irony.
 
Last edited:
Hi gang,

OK I have a preliminary answer from my lab guy. Want to run this by everyone on both sides of the argument to see if this sounds fair:

1) His lab has access to 12 different WTC dust samples. So there are two possible ways we can go: a) We can use one or more of his samples, and he can try to find a match for the red-gray chips Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al used. b) We can get some of the red-gray chips from Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al which THEY say are unignited thermite. This would be the clear preference for round one, because if he uses one of his own samples, Kevin Ryan and others would not be able to be sure they weren't just testing a paint chip. As I've said, Kevin has told me he has both WTC paint chips AND the chips he says are thermitics and they are not the same. The samples may need to be cut up if they are too large (unlikely) but otherwise they will not be destroyed in the testing, and the samples can be returned.

2.) This guy has extensive forensic experience and is used to people wanting a certain result and having to give them objective lab results that may or may not agree with their preconceived notions. he assured me that he will do the best lab tests he can and will give us the results of those tests, whether they are the results we want or not.

3.) The process takes around three weeks.

4.) At this point, he is assuming the red-gray chips from the Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al experiment are very small, not even in the millimeter range. If this is true, he feels a $200 X-Ray diffraction test would not have the needed sensitivity.

5.) The best he can do is to say that if thermitic material exists in the red-gray chip, it's less than, say, 5% or 1% or whatever. In other words, he cannot prove a negative claim such as "there is NO thermitic material" here, but he can assert that if there is thermitic stuff, it is of a very small percentage.

6.) X-Ray diffraction might work on a piece the size of the end of my pinky finger if the material is pure, but if it is a mix of materials there would be so many X-Ray peaks it would be impossible to identify what was in it with any certainty. It might be of some value as a supplemental test, and the cost is only $200.

7.) The two tests he recommends are Polarized Light Microscopy and Scanning Electromicroscopy. Total approximate cost for these tests would be $750 per sample. This is why using a Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al sample would be more affordable; otherwise he would want to do several tests on several different WTC dust samples.

8.) Before he writes up a proposal he will check in with a couple other guys to make sure he's not missing another vitally important test.

MM, Bill Smith, Clayton et al does this seem fair to you?

Oystein, Sunstealer, Tom et al, does this make sense as a protocol?

Months of research and this guy seems to have the clearest understanding of anyone I've talked to of how to move forward, as well as a commendable sense of scientific objectivity. Thoughts anyone?
 
Like you said, the cooperation of Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al would be important but their lack of cooperation might end up cheaper. If they don't want verification of their findings that sort of answers our questions anyways.

If they decide to agree to give up the samples, I'm in ($), if not, it's a waste of time and money on an issue no one really cares about.
 
Hi gang,

OK I have a preliminary answer from my lab guy. Want to run this by everyone on both sides of the argument to see if this sounds fair:

Thoughts anyone?

If it's going to cost $750 then it makes sense to test one of the alleged nanothermite chips, I think.

Who's paying for this? I can chip in if needed. (Oo! That's a pun!) :)

cheers

AE
 
If it's going to cost $750 then it makes sense to test one of the alleged nanothermite chips, I think.

Who's paying for this? I can chip in if needed. (Oo! That's a pun!) :)

cheers

AE
That's the problem. Without their cooperation they can always claim our samples were just not the right ones.

It's up to them.
 
Last edited:
Chris,

is my understanding correct, that the question which you are asking the lab is "do the red-gray chips contain thermite - yes or no?" and that the answer would be a "yes" or a "no (below detection limit)", plus a short essay telling us "here is why", including a documentation of method, process and obtained data? Then this should definitely be done on a sample that was pre-screened by Kevin Ryan, or any other of the main Bentham authors (Harrit, Jones or Farrer).

I do not understand how the methods your lab guy proposes help to prove or rule out thermite:
  • SEM (Scanning Electromicroscopy) was done in the Bentham paper - we see kaolinite and hematite pigments, but these truthers don't admit it's hematite; More SEM images of the same will only lead to more denial of the same.
  • Polarized Light Microscopy seems to be mainly used in geology to analyse minerals, although I am by no means educated enough about it, so I have to trust the guy there or not... Not sure how that helps to distinguish between elemental and bound aluminium, for example.

If he does SEM, then I understand that doing an additional XEDS of the red layer should be relatively cheap, if his lab offers XEDS at all. I'd suggest this not because it is a good method to identify thermite, but to establish that the sample he is looking at is similar to chips a-d in the Bentham paper: If the sample contains lots of C, O, and Fe, slightly more Si than Al, and traces of Sr and Cr, then we know we have Harrit's material and are analysing the right chips. If the XEDS spectrum is considerably different, he should stop and get back to us, maybe look for other chips.

As for chip size: Mark Basile reported a "lucky chip", his #13, that was about 2mm long and 1.5mm wide, iirc, and that seemed to be the largest chip he found. I am pretty sure the truther side already exploited the larger chips, so I, too, am sceptic if larger chips can be found. If Kevin can't provide one, maybe your lab guy can sift through his other 12 samples; in that case, preliminiary XEDS to establish similarity with chips a-d is essential.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom