Mr. Skinny
Alien Cryogenic Engineer
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2001
- Messages
- 7,843
Certainly, a sample of the same material used by Harritt/Jones/Ryan would be preferable. Is there a realistic chance of getting a sample? Sorry, haven't been following the thread closely.Hi gang,
OK I have a preliminary answer from my lab guy. Want to run this by everyone on both sides of the argument to see if this sounds fair:
1) His lab has access to 12 different WTC dust samples. So there are two possible ways we can go: a) We can use one or more of his samples, and he can try to find a match for the red-gray chips Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al used. b) We can get some of the red-gray chips from Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al which THEY say are unignited thermite. This would be the clear preference for round one, because if he uses one of his own samples, Kevin Ryan and others would not be able to be sure they weren't just testing a paint chip. As I've said, Kevin has told me he has both WTC paint chips AND the chips he says are thermitics and they are not the same. The samples may need to be cut up if they are too large (unlikely) but otherwise they will not be destroyed in the testing, and the samples can be returned.
In my experience with analytical chemists, I'd be suprised if he didn't have experience trashing preconceived notions. They are concerned with the chemistry/microscopy etc. more than they are with the results you may be looking for.2.) This guy has extensive forensic experience and is used to people wanting a certain result and having to give them objective lab results that may or may not agree with their preconceived notions. he assured me that he will do the best lab tests he can and will give us the results of those tests, whether they are the results we want or not.
Seems reasonable to me. In fact I'd say that's a fairly quick turn-around.3.) The process takes around three weeks.
I'm not an expert on this, so I'll only say that I think it depends on which samples you use.4.) At this point, he is assuming the red-gray chips from the Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al experiment are very small, not even in the millimeter range. If this is true, he feels a $200 X-Ray diffraction test would not have the needed sensitivity.
5.) The best he can do is to say that if thermitic material exists in the red-gray chip, it's less than, say, 5% or 1% or whatever. In other words, he cannot prove a negative claim such as "there is NO thermitic material" here, but he can assert that if there is thermitic stuff, it is of a very small percentage.
6.) X-Ray diffraction might work on a piece the size of the end of my pinky finger if the material is pure, but if it is a mix of materials there would be so many X-Ray peaks it would be impossible to identify what was in it with any certainty. It might be of some value as a supplemental test, and the cost is only $200.
7.) The two tests he recommends are Polarized Light Microscopy and Scanning Electromicroscopy. Total approximate cost for these tests would be $750 per sample. This is why using a Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al sample would be more affordable; otherwise he would want to do several tests on several different WTC dust samples.
8.) Before he writes up a proposal he will check in with a couple other guys to make sure he's not missing another vitally important test.
MM, Bill Smith, Clayton et al does this seem fair to you?
Oystein, Sunstealer, Tom et al, does this make sense as a protocol?
Months of research and this guy seems to have the clearest understanding of anyone I've talked to of how to move forward, as well as a commendable sense of scientific objectivity. Thoughts anyone?
Without the original, you might have to do several additional types of analysis in order to rule out most objections from truthers.
Last edited:
