Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

Hi gang,

OK I have a preliminary answer from my lab guy. Want to run this by everyone on both sides of the argument to see if this sounds fair:

1) His lab has access to 12 different WTC dust samples. So there are two possible ways we can go: a) We can use one or more of his samples, and he can try to find a match for the red-gray chips Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al used. b) We can get some of the red-gray chips from Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al which THEY say are unignited thermite. This would be the clear preference for round one, because if he uses one of his own samples, Kevin Ryan and others would not be able to be sure they weren't just testing a paint chip. As I've said, Kevin has told me he has both WTC paint chips AND the chips he says are thermitics and they are not the same. The samples may need to be cut up if they are too large (unlikely) but otherwise they will not be destroyed in the testing, and the samples can be returned.
Certainly, a sample of the same material used by Harritt/Jones/Ryan would be preferable. Is there a realistic chance of getting a sample? Sorry, haven't been following the thread closely.

2.) This guy has extensive forensic experience and is used to people wanting a certain result and having to give them objective lab results that may or may not agree with their preconceived notions. he assured me that he will do the best lab tests he can and will give us the results of those tests, whether they are the results we want or not.
In my experience with analytical chemists, I'd be suprised if he didn't have experience trashing preconceived notions. They are concerned with the chemistry/microscopy etc. more than they are with the results you may be looking for.

3.) The process takes around three weeks.
Seems reasonable to me. In fact I'd say that's a fairly quick turn-around.

4.) At this point, he is assuming the red-gray chips from the Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al experiment are very small, not even in the millimeter range. If this is true, he feels a $200 X-Ray diffraction test would not have the needed sensitivity.

5.) The best he can do is to say that if thermitic material exists in the red-gray chip, it's less than, say, 5% or 1% or whatever. In other words, he cannot prove a negative claim such as "there is NO thermitic material" here, but he can assert that if there is thermitic stuff, it is of a very small percentage.

6.) X-Ray diffraction might work on a piece the size of the end of my pinky finger if the material is pure, but if it is a mix of materials there would be so many X-Ray peaks it would be impossible to identify what was in it with any certainty. It might be of some value as a supplemental test, and the cost is only $200.

7.) The two tests he recommends are Polarized Light Microscopy and Scanning Electromicroscopy. Total approximate cost for these tests would be $750 per sample. This is why using a Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al sample would be more affordable; otherwise he would want to do several tests on several different WTC dust samples.

8.) Before he writes up a proposal he will check in with a couple other guys to make sure he's not missing another vitally important test.

MM, Bill Smith, Clayton et al does this seem fair to you?

Oystein, Sunstealer, Tom et al, does this make sense as a protocol?

Months of research and this guy seems to have the clearest understanding of anyone I've talked to of how to move forward, as well as a commendable sense of scientific objectivity. Thoughts anyone?
I'm not an expert on this, so I'll only say that I think it depends on which samples you use.

Without the original, you might have to do several additional types of analysis in order to rule out most objections from truthers.
 
Last edited:
"Hi gang,

OK I have a preliminary answer from my lab guy. Want to run this by everyone on both sides of the argument to see if this sounds fair:

1) His lab has access to 12 different WTC dust samples. So there are two possible ways we can go: a) We can use one or more of his samples, and he can try to find a match for the red-gray chips Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al used. b) We can get some of the red-gray chips from Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al which THEY say are unignited thermite. This would be the clear preference for round one, because if he uses one of his own samples, Kevin Ryan and others would not be able to be sure they weren't just testing a paint chip. As I've said, Kevin has told me he has both WTC paint chips AND the chips he says are thermitics and they are not the same. The samples may need to be cut up if they are too large (unlikely) but otherwise they will not be destroyed in the testing, and the samples can be returned.

2.) This guy has extensive forensic experience and is used to people wanting a certain result and having to give them objective lab results that may or may not agree with their preconceived notions. he assured me that he will do the best lab tests he can and will give us the results of those tests, whether they are the results we want or not.

3.) The process takes around three weeks.

4.) At this point, he is assuming the red-gray chips from the Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al experiment are very small, not even in the millimeter range. If this is true, he feels a $200 X-Ray diffraction test would not have the needed sensitivity.

5.) The best he can do is to say that if thermitic material exists in the red-gray chip, it's less than, say, 5% or 1% or whatever. In other words, he cannot prove a negative claim such as "there is NO thermitic material" here, but he can assert that if there is thermitic stuff, it is of a very small percentage.

6.) X-Ray diffraction might work on a piece the size of the end of my pinky finger if the material is pure, but if it is a mix of materials there would be so many X-Ray peaks it would be impossible to identify what was in it with any certainty. It might be of some value as a supplemental test, and the cost is only $200.

7.) The two tests he recommends are Polarized Light Microscopy and Scanning Electromicroscopy. Total approximate cost for these tests would be $750 per sample. This is why using a Harritt/Jones/Ryan et al sample would be more affordable; otherwise he would want to do several tests on several different WTC dust samples.

8.) Before he writes up a proposal he will check in with a couple other guys to make sure he's not missing another vitally important test.

MM, Bill Smith, Clayton et al does this seem fair to you?

Oystein, Sunstealer, Tom et al, does this make sense as a protocol?

Months of research and this guy seems to have the clearest understanding of anyone I've talked to of how to move forward, as well as a commendable sense of scientific objectivity. Thoughts anyone?"

It is unfortunate that it will be so costly.

I say this with the 'gut feeling' that I can trust you Chris, but I doubt the response you get, at least in this forum, will be acceptable compensation for the expense.

Unless the testing shows the indisputable presence of thermite, all indications so far suggest a positive finding will be rejected out-of-hand by Official Story side.

And if the testing fails to reveal the presence of thermite, the 9/11 truth advocates will question the validity of the source dust and/or the unbiased integrity of those performing the tests.

Personally, I would still like to see the testing proceed.

MM
 
It is unfortunate that it will be so costly.

I say this with the 'gut feeling' that I can trust you Chris, but I doubt the response you get, at least in this forum, will be acceptable compensation for the expense.
...

I'd like to take this remark as an opportunity to repeat and point out that part of the response in this forum is the pledges by several members, including myself, to chip in real money (something MM only hints at but never takes serious). Chris, when the plan stands and the quotes are in, contact me how much you need.

MM, are you in, too? Willing to support this with a bit of your own, real money?
 
It is unfortunate that it will be so costly.

I say this with the 'gut feeling' that I can trust you Chris, but I doubt the response you get, at least in this forum, will be acceptable compensation for the expense.

Unless the testing shows the indisputable presence of thermite, all indications so far suggest a positive finding will be rejected out-of-hand by Official Story side.

See, this is where you fail to comprehend the basic differences between truthers and skeptics...

And if the testing fails to reveal the presence of thermite, the 9/11 truth advocates will question the validity of the source dust and/or the unbiased integrity of those performing the tests.

Personally, I would still like to see the testing proceed.

MM

...but, you pretty much nailed this one on the head. No matter what, when it shows it ain't thermXte, it'll be dismissed 7 way to Sunday by the truther side.

I agree. I'd love to see it too. A great chance for real science to dropkick truthers in the nuts... again. :D
 
I'd like to take this remark as an opportunity to repeat and point out that part of the response in this forum is the pledges by several members, including myself, to chip in real money

I've got a C-Note available for it. More, if you end up short.
 
Chris,

is my understanding correct, that the question which you are asking the lab is "do the red-gray chips contain thermite - yes or no?" and that the answer would be a "yes" or a "no (below detection limit)", plus a short essay telling us "here is why", including a documentation of method, process and obtained data? Then this should definitely be done on a sample that was pre-screened by Kevin Ryan, or any other of the main Bentham authors (Harrit, Jones or Farrer).

I do not understand how the methods your lab guy proposes help to prove or rule out thermite:
  • SEM (Scanning Electromicroscopy) was done in the Bentham paper - we see kaolinite and hematite pigments, but these truthers don't admit it's hematite; More SEM images of the same will only lead to more denial of the same.
  • Polarized Light Microscopy seems to be mainly used in geology to analyse minerals, although I am by no means educated enough about it, so I have to trust the guy there or not... Not sure how that helps to distinguish between elemental and bound aluminium, for example.

If he does SEM, then I understand that doing an additional XEDS of the red layer should be relatively cheap, if his lab offers XEDS at all. I'd suggest this not because it is a good method to identify thermite, but to establish that the sample he is looking at is similar to chips a-d in the Bentham paper: If the sample contains lots of C, O, and Fe, slightly more Si than Al, and traces of Sr and Cr, then we know we have Harrit's material and are analysing the right chips. If the XEDS spectrum is considerably different, he should stop and get back to us, maybe look for other chips.

As for chip size: Mark Basile reported a "lucky chip", his #13, that was about 2mm long and 1.5mm wide, iirc, and that seemed to be the largest chip he found. I am pretty sure the truther side already exploited the larger chips, so I, too, am sceptic if larger chips can be found. If Kevin can't provide one, maybe your lab guy can sift through his other 12 samples; in that case, preliminiary XEDS to establish similarity with chips a-d is essential.
Yes your understanding is correct about my question.

As for chip size, very small chips are fine except for the X-Ray Diffraction. I'm hoping that Kevin Ryan or someone will give us one of the chips THEY believe is thermitic. If they refuse, will the test be worth it?

Thank you everyone for your generosity, and thank you MM for trusting me. I'm going to wait till I get a final answer from Lab Guy; in the meantime, opinions anyone on going forward if we have to use Lab Guy's red-gray chips instead of Ryan/Harrit/Jones et al's???
 
See, this is where you fail to comprehend the basic differences between truthers and skeptics...



...but, you pretty much nailed this one on the head. No matter what, when it shows it ain't thermXte, it'll be dismissed 7 way to Sunday by the truther side.

I agree. I'd love to see it too. A great chance for real science to dropkick truthers in the nuts... again. :D

Ain't going to happen. you can show that shroud of Turin is a medieval fake but the believers won't pay the slightest attention. :(
 
I'm in for a few bucks.

Maybe we could contact the JREF also to see if they are willing to chip in a few bucks.

Chris, You should contact Darat and maybe DJ Grothe to see if they would be willing to chip in.

Cheers!
 
5.) The best he can do is to say that if thermitic material exists in the red-gray chip, it's less than, say, 5% or 1% or whatever. In other words, he cannot prove a negative claim such as "there is NO thermitic material" here, but he can assert that if there is thermitic stuff, it is of a very small percentage.
Doesn't that mean both parts should agree beforehand on a percentage of what is considered definitely enough to bring the towers down, and what is such a negligible quantity that it's not worth worrying about?

I think that it's a must that if X% of thermitic material is found, it be ignitable. Can that be checked?
 
Doesn't that mean both parts should agree beforehand on a percentage of what is considered definitely enough to bring the towers down,...
You are glossing over the biggest issues facing the claims for thermXte used in CD.

Chris Mohr has been generous in attempting to meet the truthers - the pro thermXte sub set - on their own ground. A sort of presumption that "if there was thermXte on ground zero there is cause for concern."

There is only "cause for concern" if you/we yield the ongoing debate to being "fought" on the truthers territory. There is a much bigger set of issues other than "was thermXte there" which the truthers don't want to discuss. Why from the outset should we yield the scope of debate to them so they can ensure that we only consider a small portion of relevant evidence?

I have said many times and in non "scientific" shorthand "It matters not if there was 100tonnes of thermXte on site - it wasn't used in CD." I have been reprimanded several times for not being scientifically pure in that claim. By people who missed the point I make which is valid.

Let's say there was 100tonnes of thermXte on site.

How was it used to assist the collapses by causing some elements of CD?

As far as I know no one (other than me on another forum) has attempted to show how thermXte could be used in a method that can prima facie pass engineering tests of plausibility.

What elements were cut?

At what stage of the collapse?

How was the material placed without the perpetrators getting caught?

How was the material kept viable through the events of aircraft impact?

I could keep going but I won't. At least another ten such questions each of which is a killer to the CD claim if they cannot be answered, And no pro-thermXte person to my knowledge has even addressed them.

Suffice to say that claims such as your "both parts should agree beforehand on a percentage of what is considered definitely enough to bring the towers down" is grossly oversimplifying the situation. And those words are being very polite. :)
 
Doesn't that mean both parts should agree beforehand on a percentage of what is considered definitely enough to bring the towers down, and what is such a negligible quantity that it's not worth worrying about?

I think that it's a must that if X% of thermitic material is found, it be ignitable. Can that be checked?

You are right in principle, but who on the truther side would you ask to enter into such an agreement - MM? Water-boy Kevin Ryan?

Being silent on amounts and percentages is one of the great shortcomings of the Bentham paper: They neither estimate how much Al and Fe2O3 there is in one mass unit of the chips, nor do they tell us what mass percentage of the same is in their nano-thermite reference, namely Tillotson's.
Basile provides such numbers in a presentation - it turns out that there is so little of both Al and Fe that there'd less then 5% thermite in the red layer even if all the Al was elemental - which it can't be. So at this point in time we know already that even if there is "thermite" in the chips, it is much too little, an irrelevant percentage.

It can be easily shown that a red chip that's 5% nano-thermite and >70% organic matrix (again, I am referring to Basile, who finds >70% carbon alone) gets >98% of its thermal energy from thermal combustion and less than 2% of its energy from thermite. Cut off the atmospheric oxygen supply, and 5% thermite alone wouldn't be enough to heat the chip to 440°C, the ignition temp of the chip according to the Bentham paper, which would be the minimum to sustain the reaction.

Since I am totally confident that chips a-d contain no elemental Al at all, hence no thermite at all, I suggest we skip this step on agreeing on numbers beforehand. It would just be a waste of time. However, I submit that anything below 5% would be irrelevant. (In fact, anything below 50% would be nonsense, but I am willing to make it easy on them)
 
Hi Chris,
I have the same point as Oystein: I don′t understand how SEM or polarized light microscopy can prove elemental aluminum. But, I know almost nothing about optical microscopy using polarized light.

Let me suppose that your lab guy has already somehow got/separated just red chips of our interest, i.e. with microscopic appearance and XEDS signatures of chips (a) to (d) closely described in Bentham paper (which is a necessary prerequisite for any meaningful research, as regards falsification or proving of Bentham paper main conclusion).

I understand why you keep this line (proving or disproving thermite, not paints), but I still don′t think that it can bring conclusive results without very thorough and expensive research.

From methodological point of view: We are interested in red-gray chips (a) to (d) from the dust and we have two main hypotheses on their origin.

1) Laclede paint hypothesis. In this case, just (affordable) FTIR microscopy can give us conclusive proofs that this hypothesis is right (if we are lucky enough and epoxy binder and kaolinite particles are unambiguously proven in this way).

2) Nanothermite hypothesis. Conclusive proof of elemental aluminum in the chips might be very difficult. Moreover, aluminum had to be highly oxidized in platelets with thicknesses ca 40 nm, present in chips (a) to (d). Look to this Tillotson paper on real superfine thermite made by sol-gel technique http://www.doeal.gov/FOIADOCS/DOC00329.pdf , p. 343: round “aluminum” particles with ca 30 nm diameter were composed of ca 70 % of aluminum oxide and mere 30 % of metallic aluminum even in this really working “nanothermite”…

What is easier, to prove some particular paint (with well-known composition), or to prove nanothermite (via elaborate determination/disproof of elemental aluminum)?
And… isn′t so that positive experimental proof(s) of Laclede paint would mean the final disproof of thermite (at least for people whose way of thinking is not heavily distorted with trutherism)?
Of course it′s up to you and your lab guy now. But, I still think that any real research has to be oriented to get some conclusive results quickly and efficiently.
 
Last edited:
Pgmeno, The "percentage of thermXte" issue is this: if Lab Guy can find ANY thermXte he will report it. If he cannot find ANY evidence of thermXte, he will report that, with the caveat that his tests could make this determination with limited sensitivity. So if there were one molecule of thermite, it would not be detected. If the red-gray chip were, say, 0.02% thermite, it would not be detected. His tests will determine that percentage of sensitivity, not an agreement with Kevin Ryan.

Ivan's objection (looking for paint is easier than disproving thermXte) is a good one and I will pass it on to Lab Guy. Still, I want to ask the question, is there thermXte in the dust? If Lab Guy looks for paint instead of dust it would save money, but it would also be less impressive to people inclined to believe there is thermXte there.

Ozeco may well be right about his 100 tons of thernXte argument, but that is another argument for down the road IF Lab Guy produces evidence of tons of the stuff. I doubt he will, so for now the argument is on the back shelf in my mind. If I'm wrong and Lab Guy finds thermXte, then yes, we'd have to look at a broader body of evidence, such as what thermitic damage would look like in the rubble, why the whole collapsing building didn't light up like the sun (watch real thermite burning and you'll see what I mean), how this stuff could actually destroy a building so fast etc etc etc. So for now I leave this argument on the back burner. Same with the chain of custody argument. If Lab Guy finds thermXte, it will be essential to test one of his samples as well to be sure the Kevin Ryan sample isn't tainted, but first things first.

MM's rather despairing assertion that "debunkers" will reject a positive test for thermXte and "truthers" will reject a negative test has much truth. But each of us in an individual. I and several other extreme doubters of the CD theory have already said this would shift us away from our near-100% certainty of natural collapse, and several committed doubters of the official story have personally told me a negative test would have a big impact on them as well. It will be a process... some will not budge in their positions and even reject the whole test, while others will say, hmmmmmmmmmm...... Me, I won't become a Truther overnight from a positive test result, but that loud hummmmmming sound you would hear from Denver would be me.
 
I will only contribute if the result and its impact are agreed by all sides.

Unfortunately, that'll never happen. The twoof movement only dies when the self-proclaimed head honcho's (Gage, Harrit) accept reality. That'll never happen because the deaths of 3,000 innocent people is their meal ticket.
 
Basile provides such numbers in a presentation - it turns out that there is so little of both Al and Fe that there'd less then 5% thermite in the red layer even if all the Al was elemental - which it can't be. So at this point in time we know already that even if there is "thermite" in the chips, it is much too little, an irrelevant percentage.
In that case, I have to ask, what is the point of doing the analysis?

We already know that if there was any kind of thermite, it would be an insignificant amount, so what else is there to say? What would this analysis do, confirm his findings? What for? Basile already has a reputation among truthers and he has debunked the ability to use the material for the purported intention, were it indeed thermitic.

Unless, of course, the chips Basile checked were not true Scotsmen, er, thermitic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom