Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

Exactly what is this "blind acceptance"?

MM


ROTFLOL. The Jones "team", Paper, peer review and publishing is an incompetent joke yet you accept it without question. It would not have passed as a term paper in a junior college. They fail utterly to show that it was thermite yet you seen unable to understand that. Then to add insult to injury they fail utterly to exclude the most likely material paint (no scraping a few flakes of a paint of BYUs football stadium does not count :))
Adding further injury they then refuse to make the material readily available so that it can be independently tested requiring meaningless "assurances" as if they would be a guarantee of anything.


MM, like the duck.........It looks like paint, behaves like paint, there would be paint so the odds are that's exactly what it is.

as opposed to termite, which it does not look like, behave like and is extremely unlikely to be there EVEN IF it was a CD.........
 
ROTFLOL. The Jones "team", Paper, peer review and publishing is an incompetent joke yet you accept it without question. It would not have passed as a term paper in a junior college. They fail utterly to show that it was thermite yet you seen unable to understand that. Then to add insult to injury they fail utterly to exclude the most likely material paint (no scraping a few flakes of a paint of BYUs football stadium does not count :))
Adding further injury they then refuse to make the material readily available so that it can be independently tested requiring meaningless "assurances" as if they would be a guarantee of anything.


MM, like the duck.........It looks like paint, behaves like paint, there would be paint so the odds are that's exactly what it is.

as opposed to termite, which it does not look like, behave like and is extremely unlikely to be there EVEN IF it was a CD.........

Has mockery and lies about people who are far more academically accomplished than you obviously are, been a successful debate tactic for you?

MM
 
[
Why bother?

I did not say painting on thermite.

So no painted on thermite? Good we are getting somewhere. Still the question remains why bother with Nano thermite. Why introduce another failure point in the process.

Nanothermite igniting at 430 C allows greater flexibility.

Please explain. Mythbusters don't seem to have much of a problem setting the stuff of so why would "they" need to use nano thermite. What do they gain from doing so????

"They found lots of dust which is certainly what would have happened to brittle ceramics."

Guaranteed??? so none of the minimum of thousands of these things survived

"Timers? OMG They never found the damn black boxes, and very few recognizable solid objects and you think timers would be readily observable?"

Perhaps not but it would be taking one hell of a risk......the strangest things survived.

I've made the case for pulverization in the melted metal thread.

No you tried to make the case, not the same thing.

As far as where the planes struck, it has already been acknowledged, even if not by you, that remote control and strategically placed beacons could accomplish exact target points.

Only at the cost of adding hundreds more into the plot......for zero add.

Well if nothing else we have refined MMs version of events. There were RC aircraft hitting buildings preloaded with thermite.
Now I wonder what "they" would have done if something had malfunctioned..........opps plane missed, opps thermite went off early, oops it didn't go off at all and gets found when when recovering the bodies......

anyway we are not supposed to be derailing this thread.......the Thermite makes no sense thread is more appropriate for this nonsense.
 
sns, the topic is not "everybody please try to convince MM". the topic is "Which paint is this?". The answers are already in. You are not adding to it.

So you are only trying to convince MM.


Can you give me an honest answer, please: What chances do you see that your debate with MM will convince him it's paint?

If you're answer is "0%", I have a follow-up question. Maybe you can guess what it is.
 
"The thread succeeded a long time ago in answering the question laid out in the title and the OP: The origin of the chips a-d is LaClede standard primer from floor joists.

No more progress is needed.

I do not expect any progress until anybody brings new data. Chris Mohr from his lab, or maybe someone who volunteers to secure samples of LaClede paint from actual stored WTC floor joists."
"I'll start, or pick up where I left it more than 2 months ago, next week. Maybe this should then become a group effort that we coordinate elsewhere.

Who is interested in contributing to such a paper? Drop me a line and leave your mail address. Authors will of course have to reveal their real names and usual personal info (such as academic degree and where they got it from).

I use LibreOffice - it's a free, open-source alternative to Microsoft Office, of which I don't have a private and legal copy. Is that okay with you?"
"sns, the topic is not "everybody please try to convince MM". the topic is "Which paint is this?". The answers are already in. You are not adding to it.

So you are only trying to convince MM.


Can you give me an honest answer, please: What chances do you see that your debate with MM will convince him it's paint?

If you're answer is "0%", I have a follow-up question. Maybe you can guess what it is."

You are quite right Oystein. It is not about convincing me. Try convincing anyone outside of your predictable group of sycophants here in JREF.

So far, without even a sample of the actual substance you claim is the red chip material, you are declaring a definitive finding that the red chips are Leclede primer paint.

That is quite a trick.

MM
 
So far, without even a sample of the actual substance you claim is the red chip material, you are declaring a definitive finding that the red chips are Leclede primer paint.


MM

Unfortunately Dr. Jones refuses to share any of his samples with anyone outside his cherry picked circle. And you people actually believe him in spite of that...that is some trick.
 
Unfortunately Dr. Jones refuses to share any of his samples with anyone outside his cherry picked circle. And you people actually believe him in spite of that...that is some trick.

Well that is a lie.

Of course if you can prove there is truth in your assertion, I will retract.

MM
 
Well that is a lie.

Of course if you can prove there is truth in your assertion, I will retract.

MM



HUH? Your responses are always so mind boggling.

If you say its a lie, then it suggests you know that Steven Jones HAS shared his samples outside his cheery picked circle. There is nothing anyone can show you that will change that fact. So do you know he has done that or not?
 
This is all so very distracting!

As for samples, we are comparing material from at least two different sources. One is red-gray chips from WTC dust, one is LaClede primer on WTC floor joists.
- As for dust: Chris Mohr is working to secure a sub-sample and have it analiysed. There is nothing in this thread that we can do to help him, or else Chris would post a request for help here. Everythin else is purpose-free speculation
- As for actual paint: MM is right, we don't have a sample of the actual stuff. With this, we are on par with Harrit e.al. who never put their hands on actual nanothermite. But we are still in a position that's better than theirs: We know at least with nice precision the material composition of our target paint, whereas Harrit must (or can) make wild speculations.
 
"Unfortunately Dr. Jones refuses to share any of his samples with anyone outside his cherry picked circle. And you people actually believe him in spite of that...that is some trick."
"Well that is a lie.

Of course if you can prove there is truth in your assertion, I will retract."
"HUH? Your responses are always so mind boggling.

If you say its a lie, then it suggests you know that Steven Jones HAS shared his samples outside his cheery picked circle. There is nothing anyone can show you that will change that fact. So do you know he has done that or not?"

Without defining your terms Edx, your question is unanswerable.

What is his "cheery picked circle"?

Too funny.

MM
 
"This is all so very distracting!

As for samples, we are comparing material from at least two different sources. One is red-gray chips from WTC dust, one is LaClede primer on WTC floor joists.
- As for dust: Chris Mohr is working to secure a sub-sample and have it analiysed. There is nothing in this thread that we can do to help him, or else Chris would post a request for help here. Everythin else is purpose-free speculation
- As for actual paint: MM is right, we don't have a sample of the actual stuff. With this, we are on par with Harrit e.al. who never put their hands on actual nanothermite. But we are still in a position that's better than theirs: We know at least with nice precision the material composition of our target paint, whereas Harrit must (or can) make wild speculations."

Distracting from what?

I thought you declared victory and all that was left was to sweep up after the party and find a peer-review publisher for your tell-all paper on the red chip primer paint?

"The thread succeeded a long time ago in answering the question laid out in the title and the OP: The origin of the chips a-d is LaClede standard primer from floor joists.

No more progress is needed."

Ah yes, you have a paper list of Leclede primer paint ingredients, at least two of which I believe are unobtainable because they are too toxic.

Meanwhile Dr. Harrit and his group of accomplished scientists, using real laboratory facilities, and testing real WTC dust samples, have eliminated primer paint as a possible candidate for the red chips.

But declare success if you like. Your paper is meaningless and you know it.

MM
 
Meanwhile Dr. Harrit and his group of accomplished scientists, using real laboratory facilities, and testing real WTC dust samples, have eliminated primer paint as a possible candidate for the red chips.
MM

They did? Can you link us to their data for comparison to what was found here?
 
Well that is a lie.

Of course if you can prove there is truth in your assertion, I will retract.

MM

I just love how you assume its a lie before you even find out if there is evidence to support the conclusion. Oh well, such is the "truth". Let the mental gymnastics begin.

“I got a call last night from a guy named Jay Levin, the founder of the LA Weekly. …He recently interviewed a Gene Corley…[who] is a forensic engineer and was hired by FEMA to look for (certain) things in the dust. Evidence of explosives wasn't one of them. …apparently, he now wants to have another look. If this is potentially a whistle-blower scenario, it could be a wonderful thing…”

[...]

"Here is my recommendation: request that Mr. Corley acquire several ‘official’ WTC dust samples directly from the USGS, and scrutinize these for red/gray chips as defined in our paper. Based on our scientific team's experience, those samplings taken nearer to ‘ground zero’ will be more likely to contain larger numbers of these red/gray particles, so the ‘nearest samples’ should be sought.”"
 
It was not an assumption.

I love how you assume it was an assumption.

MM

Yet you have 0 evidence it wasn't. I can only think it was an outright intentional lie or you were assuming.

Nice though how you failed to address the fact that Jones has refused to supply samples to outsiders.

I give you an 8.5. Your dismount was fair, but you didn't quite stick the landing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom