Robrob
Philosopher
- Joined
- Aug 29, 2011
- Messages
- 5,497
Did I say it was paint?
MM
Let me check the name of this thread again...
"Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?"
Did I say it was paint?
MM
The conclusion from this thread that it is indeed paint is pretty compelling in my opinion, made by people who appear to know what they are talking about, but I'm no expert.
If it's not paint it was designed to be identified as paint. Clever bastards!
According to the Jesse Ventura interview with Steven Jones, Jones believes that they painted Nano thermite onto stuff and then he said when it dried became a "high explosive"!!
I guess that was before he decided nano thermite merely acted as "matches" for all the actual splosives and so didnt presumably need to actually melt anything.
Since the red chips ignite at 430 C, they could very well have been used to create the high ignition temperature required for thermite or thermate.
The conclusion from this thread that it is indeed paint is pretty compelling in my opinion, made by people who appear to know what they are talking about, but I'm no expert.
If it's not paint it was designed to be identified as paint. Clever bastards!
The evidence is compelling in my opinion as well. However, I ask an analytical chemist to read the paper to get his opinion. I only mentioned to him that the paper posited thermite and I didn't mention paint at all.Of course it is compelling for you.
They could have claimed it was dog feces and you would have agreed.
MM
Given this and the absence of any indication that it might be something other than paint, it becomes almost a certainty.His conclusion: It was paint. Based on his opinion and the additional info in this thread, I think it's the most probabable conclusion to reach.
Since the red chips ignite at 430 C, they could very well have been used to create the high ignition temperature required for thermite or thermate.
MM
I don't agree that it's a certainty. Just highly probable.Given this and the absence of any indication that it might be something other than paint, it becomes almost a certainty.
Of course it is compelling for you.
They could have claimed it was dog feces and you would have agreed.
MM
I don't agree that it's a certainty. Just highly probable.
One would really need a sample of the dust they used in their analysis to say with certainty.
I don't expect that will ever happen though. If Harrit, et.al. really wanted to convince people, I think, give the criticism this paper has received, would have made the material available for further analysis.
One can hope I suppose.
Chemist, Mark Basile performed independent analysis and agrees with their findings.
Funny thing, Henry C (I'm at a loss for his name) did too. He doesn't agree.Chemist, Mark Basile performed independent analysis and agrees with their findings.
I have corresponded with some of the paper's authors and they have indicated that they are quite willing to provide dust samples for independent analysis.
Understandably, they need to be assured that any investigation will be professional and without obvious bias.
MM
Well, I offered to investigate trying to have a sample analyzed at my workplace several years ago. However, before I went to the the trouble, I asked (on this forum) if Truthers would accept analytical results that came from a government laboratory and the opinion was "No". Not one Truther said they would accept it.Chemist, Mark Basile performed independent analysis and agrees with their findings.
I have corresponded with some of the paper's authors and they have indicated that they are quite willing to provide dust samples for independent analysis.
Understandably, they need to be assured that any investigation will be professional and without obvious bias.
MM
Since the red chips ignite at 430 C, they could very well have been used to create the high ignition temperature required for thermite or thermate.
MM
Oh no you don't - answer the question.
What possible use could there be in a paint that ignites at twice the temperature of paper (commonly found in an office building) for setting off magic thermite? You destroy your own argument!!
Of course it is compelling for you.
They could have claimed it was dog feces and you would have agreed.
MM

Since the red chips ignite at 430 C, they could very well have been used to create the high ignition temperature required for thermite or thermate.
MM
Oh the irony. Given your blind acceptance of Jones et al I doubt you would recognize dog feces if you had it served up to you on a plate. Funny thing is that it would be a safe bet that there is more feces in that dust than thermite.![]()
Understandably, they need to be assured that any investigation will be professional and without obvious bias.
MM
why bother when there are conventional ways of doing just that that would be easier to attach, what advantage do you think painting on a thermite might give you especially if its only as an igniter? Curious how nobody found any of the ceramic or similar containment vessels required to make thermite cut steel? Or any timers, shock cord etc required to get them to go off when planned. Strange too that there were no unignited charges left..........how do you think they managed to arrange for the planes to hit just the right floor or do you think these things were on every floor????