A) We see in
http://www.nist.gov/customcf/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=101432
p.156 pdf Figure-D4 that most of the spalled red primer column paint does not contain a gray steel/rust layer. Based on this picture alone, one would expect most (by surface area) of the red primer paint not to contain gray steel layer.
This result was after application of >650C temperatures alone and may not reflect the bonding of the primer and steel/rust layer due to impact and spalling.
Millette’s culling of the red/gray paint chips (to match Harrit et al) may have excluded the red/no gray Laclede and other primer paint chips.
The Laclede paint unlike the Tnemec paint (likely spray painted) was electrocoated. This process allows coating of complex, hard to reach surfaces, like the trusses. In this process, likely anodic, (cathodic was first put in use in 1970) “ substrate metals dissolve and become incorporated into the coating, which affects surface properties.” (see below)
This might additionally explain the lack of or minimal and thin gray layer in the excluded red/no gray paint chips.
The water content of the paint/vat solution evaporates during the subsequent baking (20 min at 350F or so) after the immersion of the trusses. The primer and epoxy remain as a hard coating on the steel.
Wow, thanks for the leads!
a. The NIST images you show (from NIST NCSTAR 1-3C Appendixes) show Tnemec. A different paint with a different kind of matrix, applied differently to a different steel using a different method (heating inteand of mechanical stress). I Don't think we can compare the two. The matrix is sure to deteriorate at 650°C and lose its former properties, one of them perhaps being adhesiveness.
b. I believe that red-only chips of any kind of paint do not show up (prominently) in Jones's studies because they are not magnetic, which would indicate that the gray layer is the magnetic one.
Ohhhh that gives rise to a specific, cheap and simple request to Jones/Harrit/Ryan: If they could please...
- Select red-gray chips based on their being magnetic
- separate red and gray layers
- test each layer individually
Which layer is attracted to a magnet?
c. Baking the freshly coated steel at 350°F/177°C fopr 20 minutes would probably not do much to oxidize the surface, given the data in the paper that I linked to a few posts up. (Not that anyone suggests this, just mentioning it). So any surface oxidation happened either during manufacture (hot-rolling) of the angles and chords (before electrocoating), or during the electrocoating itself (if "
substrate metals dissolve and become incorporated into the coating") involves oxidation), or during the 30 years of sitting in more or less air-conditioned, dry environment under paint - or a combination of the three.
d. We can say nothing about red-only chips as no ome has studied them. With the exception of HenryCo, afaik.
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/News_english.html
HenryCo however does not tell us how he obtained red-only chips from his 7g of dust samples. With magnet or by sight?
I just sent him an email, asking.
(Anyway, I am not convinced that his one (?) red-gray chip is "our" kind of chip - red layer only 10µm.)
Laclede chips properties to look for:
a. Magnetic (the iron pigment content),
b. Red (seen in photos of the trusses),
c. With no or minor (thickness compared to the ones selected) gray iron oxide layer (anodic electrocoating process),
d. Smaller sized chips than the ones selected since they electrobonded more firmly to the steel than the larger gray (“rust”) chips and would chip off in smaller pieces.
e. Contains SrCr
f. A greater net surface area of these Laclede chips, perhaps near 50% of all red/gray plus red/no gray chips due to our previous painted surface area calculations.
B) Of course perhaps another anti-oxidant besides the SrCr was used by Laclede.
Hmmm
a. I disagree. Pure Hematite is at most very weakly magnetic. Rust is not readily attracted to a magnet. Other iron oxides are more magnetic, but should be present at most in trace amounts.
b. Sure.
c. Why? How do you know the thickness of the steel layer affected by electrocoating? Plus, processes before and after the coating could create more surface oxidation.
d. Again, why? Before or after electrocoating, other processes may have produced larger spalls. Plus, since the mere presence of red-gray chips from LaClede paint would indicate that paint adheres more strongly to the gray layer than gray layer to the steel substrate, this means that the bond between substrate and gray layer must have been relatively weak to begin with,
for whatever reasons.
e. Sure
f. As a first approximation, yes. Deduct from this ~50% a bit to account for red paints other than those from twin tower structural steel (perhaps WTC7 steel, and non-steel paint). Then there is a possibility that different primers and different steels spall off bi-layered chips in different ratios, and finally I think that the different levels and kinds of mechanical stress that the different types of steel suffered in the collapses would also affect the relative abundance of the various kinds of chips.
B) Yes, that is a logical possibility, but I think it not very likely, for two reasons: 1. The formulation we know (From NCSTAR 1-6B, App. B, p. 157) is not a specification communicated to LaClede, but more an information from LaClede of what their shop primer actually was in 1967. Could of course be that they changed the formulation later, and we have no record thereof. 2. I am still somewhat confident that the Sr and Cr signals in Harrit's letter mean something.