Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

The perimeter vertical columns fell once, fewer collisions, although other building debris may have fallen atop them, releasing some paint, at ground level. The horizontal trusses collided an average ~ 50 times with the concrete atop, more collisions, paint chips expelled with the building dust. Three of the four faces of the perimeter columns and plates did not suffer from the interior collapse of the slabs. Perimeter columns were seen falling away generally whole.

My opinion is that some the missing paint from the columns is due largely from the salvage, hauling operations, and collisions at the base of the towers.
The dust samples from Millette and Harrit were taken a long distance from the buildings, being carried there by the collapsing dust clouds.
Similar for the vertical and horizontal core members.


Speculation - I'm not familiar with gray rust. Unless you are talking of the Millette, Harrit chips. Remember the Laclede electrocoating process where the paint is electro-chemically bonded to the surface of the steel? Those chips might be paint atop the delaminated electro-bonded steel without a rust layer. This might be a clue that all those chips are Laclede. Other non- electrocoated red primer paint chips might be paint with no steel attached to them ( I don't see why the paint bonding is so strong that it would separate and carry away a layer of steel), or paint attached to a weak oxidized layer (no gray layer but an all rust colored steel layer), not sufficiently magnetically attractive and therefore not studied. But I don't know.


My opinion is that the pinkish color on the steel is red color covered with pressed concrete dust, and/or pressed SFRM (for the columns and beams).
We know all the primer was red colored, therefore the yellowish areas above must be non primer materials pressed onto the steel.

Thanks, I agree, but my question was basically different: Why do you think that the most of the primer is missing on floor trusses, when you look at these photographs from NIST report?

Otherwise, we have agreed months ago that Laclede primer should be the most abundant in the dust, especially at longer distances from Ground Zero: collapses of WTC1/2 (and also of WTC7) should be the main sources of such a "distant" dust.

As for "electrochemically bonded" paint to the steel, I'm not sure (and I've perhaps forgot some important details) , but electrocoating can lead to some changes of the steel surface composition, leading e.g. to the formation of some layer with specific properties and (later) perhaps to the easy formation of its scales with attached paint, when exposed to the strong friction/deformation forces.

Anyway, NIST photographs of floor trusses do not have a resolution good enough for some "analyses" and they were taken probably months after the disaster. And since these trusses were apparently stored exposed to the outer weather (with rather acidic rains etc.) , the visible corrosion had to be to a considerable extent caused just during this storage.

And finally for "pinkish areas" visible in the second image: you can be right that they are e.g. pressed thermal insulation because of whitish "tint", but then, if this is a SFRM foam for protection of trusses (why it should be from perimeter elements?), then (hypothetically) even "better" for us: Laclede red paint could be preserved below this layer.

(The word "better" surely deserves its quotation marks, since these floor trusses are not available for us (for Jim Millette) anyway...)
 
Last edited:
I am in contact with some of the participants in the Bentham paper and I would be willing to link them to any posted findings that appear to be worth their attention.
...
I am hopeful that we can expect to hear the results of red chip ignition testing in inert gas and vacuum conditions in the not too distant future.

MM

This was from November 2011.

MM, have you heard of any progress there? Could you please get back in touch with some of the participants in the Bentham paper and ask them
  • if and when they will publish those DSC under inert gas results?
  • if and when they will publish their FTIR results?
  • if and when they will publish their XRD results?
  • if and when they will publish their TEM results?

Thanks!
 
This was from November 2011.

MM, have you heard of any progress there? Could you please get back in touch with some of the participants in the Bentham paper and ask them
  • if and when they will publish those DSC under inert gas results?
  • if and when they will publish their FTIR results?
  • if and when they will publish their XRD results?
  • if and when they will publish their TEM results?

Thanks!

To quote our favorite Troll on the JFK thread:

{Crickets Chirping}
 
This was from November 2011.

MM, have you heard of any progress there? Could you please get back in touch with some of the participants in the Bentham paper and ask them
  • if and when they will publish those DSC under inert gas results?
  • if and when they will publish their FTIR results?
  • if and when they will publish their XRD results?
  • if and when they will publish their TEM results?

Thanks!

To whom should I pass their reply to?

It is my understanding that they would prefer to correspond with either legitimate scientists or wait until there is a peer-reviewed paper that challenges their original findings.

MM
 
Originally Posted by Oystein
This was from November 2011.

MM, have you heard of any progress there? Could you please get back in touch with some of the participants in the Bentham paper and ask them
  • if and when they will publish those DSC under inert gas results?
  • if and when they will publish their FTIR results?
  • if and when they will publish their XRD results?
  • if and when they will publish their TEM results?

Thanks!
To whom should I pass their reply to?

It is my understanding that they would prefer to correspond with either legitimate scientists or wait until there is a peer-reviewed paper that challenges their original findings.

MM
This is new. They said they were going to publish their findings. I don't remember these conditions for releasing this information. Why the change? It hadn't stopped Harrit et al showing other data, arguing against paint etc., videos, blogging, burn chip vid. etc.

If this data were positive for thermite they would have published lickety-split.
 
To whom should I pass their reply to?

It is my understanding that they would prefer to correspond with either legitimate scientists or wait until there is a peer-reviewed paper that challenges their original findings.

MM

In other words, they'd rather dodge the question. Got it.

Unless they can provide any legitimate reason why they won't release the results to anyone else.

What's a legitimate scientist, in their book? Someone who doesn't question them? Someone who isn't "tainted" by being mentioned tangentially in an accusation of a whole organization of performing tests using the wrong procedure? Some other as to be determined criteria? Would they release it to one of my former profs at Northwestern? How about to a scientist in a government lab? Someone at NIST? My brother the Chemist?
 
To whom should I pass their reply to?

It is my understanding that they would prefer to correspond with either legitimate scientists or wait until there is a peer-reviewed paper that challenges their original findings.

MM

To the general and scientific public. Tell them to PUBLISH! It's been almost four years! Millette has presented his preliminary results early on, and has gone to academic and professional conferences with them.

Harrit et al. are hiding their results from the world. Holding back scientific results is considered bad style and generally frowned upon.

Tell them to PUBLISH! It is high time!
 
To the general and scientific public. Tell them to PUBLISH! It's been almost four years! Millette has presented his preliminary results early on, and has gone to academic and professional conferences with them.

Harrit et al. are hiding their results from the world. Holding back scientific results is considered bad style and generally frowned upon.

Tell them to PUBLISH! It is high time!

Gee Oystein, I'm sure they are waiting for you to finish polishing your LeClede primer paint paper.

Are you having difficulty getting it peer-reviewed?

Yes, Millette has done a clever job of milking a paper that hasn't been peer reviewed.

I doubt he has any intention of spending additional time seeking a peer review. He needed a paper for his presentation and 9/11 always arouses interest so he shuffled a bit of dust and basically said nothing controversial.

If he had set his oven at 430C and selected chips using the Resistivity test, he might have found himself in a position where he had to explain some difficult findings.

But being a good business man he avoided that Pandora's Box.

MM
 
To whom should I pass their reply to?

It is my understanding that they would prefer to correspond with either legitimate scientists or wait until there is a peer-reviewed paper that challenges their original findings.

MM
Let me guess. They don't want to jeopardize the acceptance among the worlds scientific community. Outside of here and the conspiracy theory world, no one takes it seriously.

Why would they release this data? Their followers don't want it.

Do you want it MM?
 
Gee Oystein, I'm sure they are waiting for you to finish polishing your LeClede primer paint paper.

Are you having difficulty getting it peer-reviewed?

Yes, Millette has done a clever job of milking a paper that hasn't been peer reviewed.
I doubt he has any intention of spending additional time seeking a peer review. He needed a paper for his presentation and 9/11 always arouses interest so he shuffled a bit of dust and basically said nothing controversial.

If he had set his oven at 430C and selected chips using the Resistivity test, he might have found himself in a position where he had to explain some difficult findings.

But being a good business man he avoided that Pandora's Box.

MM

What a smelly, Red Straw Misdirection Herring.

Paint chips have the facts on their side.
Oystein, Ivan, Sunstealer and others' fact filleting of Jones, Harrit et al's dog don't hunt flounder has gotten their goat. *

They are hiding the falsifying tests.
Hiding falsifying results is the mortal sin of scientists.
All the rationals, including some Truthers can see that.
How long can the remaining Truthers pretend not seeing this no pants on flim-flam.






*block that metaphor!
 
Last edited:
Gee Oystein, I'm sure they are waiting for you to finish polishing your LeClede primer paint paper.

Are you having difficulty getting it peer-reviewed?

Yes, Millette has done a clever job of milking a paper that hasn't been peer reviewed.

I doubt he has any intention of spending additional time seeking a peer review. He needed a paper for his presentation and 9/11 always arouses interest so he shuffled a bit of dust and basically said nothing controversial.

If he had set his oven at 430C and selected chips using the Resistivity test, he might have found himself in a position where he had to explain some difficult findings.

But being a good business man he avoided that Pandora's Box.

MM

Dodge + Dodge = 2 Dodges!
 
Gee Oystein, I'm sure they are waiting for you to finish polishing your LeClede primer paint paper.
Are they? Yes or no?

Are you having difficulty getting it peer-reviewed?
Am I holding back experimental results? Yes or no?
Are Harrit et al. holding back experimental results? Yes or no?


Yes, Millette has done a clever job of milking a paper that hasn't been peer reviewed.
I am not so hot for peer review. I'd be quite happy with the experimental results. Millette gave us his, quite comprehensively.

Are you interested in Harrit et al.'s held-back experimental results? Yes or no?
If not, why not?


I doubt he has any intention of spending additional time seeking a peer review. He needed a paper for his presentation and 9/11 always arouses interest so he shuffled a bit of dust and basically said nothing controversial.
I offer you a US$ 100 bet that Millette will have published by the end of this year. Are you ready to bet US$ 100 that he won't? Yes or no?Then PM me so we can arrange the details of how to settle the bet! :D

If he had set his oven at 430C and selected chips using the Resistivity test, he might have found himself in a position where he had to explain some difficult findings.
Yeah, might.
If Harrit had published the FTIR results and Farrer the TEM results and Jones the XRD results and whoever their DSC under inert result, they might have found themselves in a position where he had to explain some difficult findings.

Difference is: They already did the experiments and know the results. They KNOW WHY they are hiding them!

But being a good business man he avoided that Pandora's Box.

MM
Got a slur for Harrit et al., too?

I bolded six (6) questions, five of which are of the simple yes/no kind. I want you to answer these six (6) questions - the five yes/no question I want you to each answer with either a "yes" or a "no" or perhaps a "I don't know". I expect you of course to dodge all six (6) questions.
 
Gee Oystein, I'm sure they are waiting for you to finish polishing your LeClede primer paint paper.
Are they? Yes or no?

You are kidding?

Are you having difficulty getting it peer-reviewed?
Am I holding back experimental results? Yes or no?
Are Harrit et al. holding back experimental results? Yes or no?

Since you have never done any valid experimentation, and since you lack the qualifications to assess the results of any proper experimentation, it would seem impossible for you to have any experimental results to hold back.

Since you have zero credentials as a scientist, the Bentham Paper scientists would only tarnish their credibility if they shared unpublished results with you.

Yes, Millette has done a clever job of milking a paper that hasn't been peer reviewed.
I am not so hot for peer review. I'd be quite happy with the experimental results. Millette gave us his, quite comprehensively.

Are you interested in Harrit et al.'s held-back experimental results? Yes or no?
If not, why not?

Since you have zero qualifications to produce a scientific paper, it comes as little surprise that you are "not so hot for a peer review". You could present a bowel movement in this forum and your followers would accept it as filet mignon.

I am of course very interested in any findings that result from completed experimental work.

I doubt he has any intention of spending additional time seeking a peer review. He needed a paper for his presentation and 9/11 always arouses interest so he shuffled a bit of dust and basically said nothing controversial.
I offer you a US$ 100 bet that Millette will have published by the end of this year. Are you ready to bet US$ 100 that he won't? Yes or no?Then PM me so we can arrange the details of how to settle the bet! :D

Well you ignored my last PM to you so I have no reason to believe things have changed. A bet such as the one you propose would require you to reveal your true name and would also provide evidence of sock-puppetry which is a banning offence at JREF.

If he had set his oven at 430C and selected chips using the Resistivity test, he might have found himself in a position where he had to explain some difficult findings.
Yeah, might.
If Harrit had published the FTIR results and Farrer the TEM results and Jones the XRD results and whoever their DSC under inert result, they might have found themselves in a position where he had to explain some difficult findings.

Difference is: They already did the experiments and know the results. They KNOW WHY they are hiding them!

Well I disagree. If you can show that they have completed that work and are deliberately hiding it from reputable scientists, then I will make your concerns known to them. As I have always said, I am only interested in the truth and nothing would make me happier than to find out that the official story was true.

But being a good business man he avoided that Pandora's Box.
Got a slur for Harrit et al., too?

I bolded six (6) questions, five of which are of the simple yes/no kind. I want you to answer these six (6) questions - the five yes/no question I want you to each answer with either a "yes" or a "no" or perhaps a "I don't know". I expect you of course to dodge all six (6) questions.

Pumping out stupid question lists seems to be one of your favourite pastimes.

Normally I would ignore such garbage but my flight was delayed.

MM
 
Last edited:
You are kidding?
No, I am not. You wrote: "I'm sure they are waiting for you to finish polishing your LeClede primer paint paper."
I asked: Are they? Yes or no?
I wanted you to provide an answer of either "yes" or "no" to this.
I expected you to dodge the question.
You dodged the question.
I was right.
Please answer the question, anmd don't dodge it again::

(1) Are Harrit et al. waiting for me to finish polishing my LeClede primer paint paper, as you claimed, MM? Yes or no?

Since you have never done any valid experimentation, and since you lack the qualifications to assess the results of any proper experimentation, it would seem impossible for you to have any experimental results to hold back.

Since you have zero credentials as a scientist, the Bentham Paper scientists would only tarnish their credibility if they shared unpublished results with you.
I asked two yes/no questions.
I wanted you to provide two answers of either "yes" or "no" to this.
I expected you to dodge both question.
You dodged both questions: Your answer contains not "yes" and no "no."
I was right.
Please answer the questions, including a "yes" and "no" for either, and don't dodge then again::

(2) Am I holding back experimental results? Yes or no?
(3) Are Harrit et al. holding back experimental results? Yes or no?


[snipped a breach of Rule 12]
I am of course very interested in any findings that result from completed experimental work.
Thank you. You answered one question in the affirmative, against my expectation.

So let us make this explicit: (4) Yes, you, MM, are interested in Harrit et al.'s held-back experimental results.

Well you ignored my last PM to you so I have no reason to believe things have changed.
Oh that's right - I have you on ignore, so I can't even see that you PMed me, sorry about that.

A bet such as the one you propose would require you to reveal your true name
Correct, of course. Indicate that you WILL enter into the bet, and I take you off of ignore so we can work out details.

and would also provide evidence of sock-puppetry which is a banning offence at JREF.
LOL.
Who do you think I am??
JREF of course already knows my real name, and it is unique in their list of members' real names.

I will check if this accusation of sock-puppetry is an infractionable offence at JREF and, if it is, consider reporting you.

In any case, please do not repeat this breach of Rule 12!

Well I disagree. If you can show that they have completed that work and are deliberately hiding it from reputable scientists, ...
From the Bentham-paper:
The Gash report describes FTIR spectra which characterize this energetic material. We have performed these same tests and will report the results elsewhere.​
This was April 2009. Having already performed FTIR tests was already in the past almost four years ago!

I don't understand your second condition:
- "deliberately": Why is that important to you when you are "very interested in any findings that result from completed experimental work"? I propose that, when you mail Harrit, you just ask if their failure to publish was deliberate! I asked, and got ignored! I guess you can't blame me for that??
- "from reputable scientists": The entire point of publishing is to make a work of science available to ALL reputable scientists. By not publishing, they are hiding it from ALL reputable scientists. Do you understand that (no answer required).

...then I will make your concerns known to them. As I have always said, I am only interested in the truth and nothing would make me happier than to find out that the official story was true.
Please do. Let us know when you have written the mail to Harrit. Perhaps you can provide us with the full text of your mail then?

Pumping out stupid question lists seems to be one of your favourite pastimes.

Normally I would ignore such garbage but my flight was delayed.

MM
I see you haven't broken the habit. To repeat the three questions you dodged:

(1) Are Harrit et al. waiting for me to finish polishing my LeClede primer paint paper, as you claimed, MM? Yes or no? (The point here is to make you admit that you threw a red herring by your rhetoric)
(2) Am I holding back experimental results? Yes or no?
(3) Are Harrit et al. holding back experimental results? Yes or no?
(The point of these is to make you admit that, while I am not hiding any facts, Harrit et al. are. Asking me to publish anything has not the same weight as asking them to publish data they already have.)
 
Last edited:
Hi folks,

just checking in for a moment to let you know that I am (and always have been) physically and emotionally well. Sorry for not dropping anyone a note when it turned out that I would be unavailable for a longer stretch of time. I have a few things to sort out in my life and decided to stay away from time-eaters such as JREF for the time being.

I was shocked and saddened to read on another thread of the sudden passing away of our dear Ivan Kminek. Not sure what details have emerged about his death. His last post here was on september 02, 2013, and the Czech wikipedia says he died the next day: https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivan_Kmínek
So sad :(

Oystein
 
Hi folks,

just checking in for a moment to let you know that I am (and always have been) physically and emotionally well. Sorry for not dropping anyone a note when it turned out that I would be unavailable for a longer stretch of time. I have a few things to sort out in my life and decided to stay away from time-eaters such as JREF for the time being.

I was shocked and saddened to read on another thread of the sudden passing away of our dear Ivan Kminek. Not sure what details have emerged about his death. His last post here was on september 02, 2013, and the Czech wikipedia says he died the next day: https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivan_Kmínek
So sad :(

Oystein
Welcome back!:)
 
Hi folks,

just checking in for a moment to let you know that I am (and always have been) physically and emotionally well. Sorry for not dropping anyone a note when it turned out that I would be unavailable for a longer stretch of time. I have a few things to sort out in my life and decided to stay away from time-eaters such as JREF for the time being.

I was shocked and saddened to read on another thread of the sudden passing away of our dear Ivan Kminek. Not sure what details have emerged about his death. His last post here was on september 02, 2013, and the Czech wikipedia says he died the next day: https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivan_Kmínek
So sad :(

Oystein

Welcome back! I've been using your blog as reference on Metabunk and also on Kevin Ryan's article on the Millette paper. Thanks for all that work!

IIRC someone at JREF was in touch with Ivan's wife or girlfriend and was told he passed away from a heart attack. Sorry I can't find a better reference for you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom