Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

Ivan, according to your second link, TiO2 is 0,5% of the kaolin there. According to Murray [1], page 87, TiO2 is between 0.8 and 2.4% of various kaolins. So yes, that's significant - the most important inclusion of any elements other than Si, Al and O, competing with Fe.

However, as 2.4% TiO2 in Al-silicate, the highest value, is just under only 1% in the total LaClede pigment, it would be 0.28% in the paint. SrCrO4 is 4 times as prominent, at 4% of the pigment. Millette was aware that he should keep an eye open for chromate, but found Ti instead. Even Harrit found and labeled Cr and Sr, but no Ti, in his May/JHune 2009 letter. An honest conclusion at this point would thus be that what Millette found is more likely not the LaClede formulation. On the other hand, I am not yet convinced that he looked at the "right" chips.



[1] Murray, Haydn H.: Applied Clay Mineralogy; Occurrences, Processing and Application of Kaolins, Betonites, Palygorskite-Sepiolite, and Common Clays. Elsevier, 2007; ISNB: 978-0-444-51701-2
 
Oystein, without seeing any micrographs, spectra or other data, all such debate is premature. Now, you are right, chips closely investigated by Jim could be something else than Laclede paint (some other paint).

Btw, what do you think about my complaint above? If we (from Europe) must wait several hours to be allowed to contribute into the "Jim's study thread", any real coherent discussion is not possible, I think:mad:
 
Oystein, without seeing any micrographs, spectra or other data, all such debate is premature. Now, you are right, chips closely investigated by Jim could be something else than Laclede paint (some other paint).

Btw, what do you think about my complaint above? If we (from Europe) must wait several hours to be allowed to contribute into the "Jim's study thread", any real coherent discussion is not possible, I think:mad:


I don't understand why Jim Millette does not give the reference of Laclede Paint: he gives Tnemec but this paint does no match....
On the other side, Laclede match perfectly.
:confused:
Did he know the Laclede Paint ?
 
I don't understand why Jim Millette does not give the reference of Laclede Paint: he gives Tnemec but this paint does no match....
On the other side, Laclede match perfectly.
:confused:
Did he know the Laclede Paint ?

Now it is quite clear that Jim Millette does not know Laclede paint and its composition. In some respects, it's good, since any truther can't complain that Jim has supposed to find some particular paint we are expecting.

So far, everything Jim described by words (except found Ti and "missing" SrCrO4) is in a very good agreement with our expectations for Laclede paint: epoxy binder, iron oxide and kaolinite particles with expected sizes/shapes, gray layer as oxidized steel...
But, let's wait for the spectra and micrographs. If, e.g. micrographs show the same microstructure as Bentham chips (a) to (d), and the content of main elements is the same, there is just little chance that they were two red primers used in WTC which were completely identical except some tiny differences, like the minute content of Sr and Ti. In this case, I would look more for some "artifacts" in the results than for some paint different from "Laclede":cool:
 
Last edited:
Now it is quite clear that Jim Millette does not know Laclede paint and its composition. In some respects, it's good, since any truther can't complain that Jim has supposed to find some particular paint we are expecting.

So far, everything Jim described by words (except found Ti and "missing" SrCrO4) is in a very good agreement with our expectations for Laclede paint: epoxy binder, iron oxide and kaolinite particles with expected sizes/shapes, gray layer as oxidized steel...
But, let's wait for the spectra and micrographs. If, e.g. micrographs show the same microstructure as Bentham chips (a) to (d), and the content of main elements is the same, there is just little chance that they were two red primers used in WTC which were completely identical except some tiny differences, like the minute content of Sr and Ti. In this case, I would look more for some "artifacts" in the results than for some paint different from "Laclede":cool:


One should also take into account the fact that they may not have used the paint they claimed they did.......folks have been known to cut corners if they think they can get away with it. The architect may have specified LaClede but vendor may have used an "equivalent"
 
Oystein, without seeing any micrographs, spectra or other data, all such debate is premature. Now, you are right, chips closely investigated by Jim could be something else than Laclede paint (some other paint).

Btw, what do you think about my complaint above? If we (from Europe) must wait several hours to be allowed to contribute into the "Jim's study thread", any real coherent discussion is not possible, I think:mad:

I can live with that. In fact, a short while ago I asked the moderators to put this thread on moderated status. I got no reply and take that as a "no".
 
I don't understand why Jim Millette does not give the reference of Laclede Paint: he gives Tnemec but this paint does no match....
On the other side, Laclede match perfectly.
:confused:
Did he know the Laclede Paint ?

He was aware to look out for strontium chromate because that's in a particular paint formulation, but he didn't find any. So the chips that Jim descibes are NOT a perfect match for LaClede paint. The chips that Harrit describes are, albeit with the strontium chromate signal being weak and coming from one chip (a) only. (If you disregard SrCrO4, the match is perfect, but a red paint with hematite and kaolinite is so mundane and usual, it could be LaClede, or could be some other paint. In my view, it's the SrCr=4 that makes LaClede stand out)
 
Ivan, according to your second link, TiO2 is 0,5% of the kaolin there. According to Murray [1], page 87, TiO2 is between 0.8 and 2.4% of various kaolins. So yes, that's significant - the most important inclusion of any elements other than Si, Al and O, competing with Fe.

However, as 2.4% TiO2 in Al-silicate, the highest value, is just under only 1% in the total LaClede pigment, it would be 0.28% in the paint. SrCrO4 is 4 times as prominent, at 4% of the pigment. Millette was aware that he should keep an eye open for chromate, but found Ti instead. Even Harrit found and labeled Cr and Sr, but no Ti, in his May/JHune 2009 letter. An honest conclusion at this point would thus be that what Millette found is more likely not the LaClede formulation. On the other hand, I am not yet convinced that he looked at the "right" chips.[1] Murray, Haydn H.: Applied Clay Mineralogy; Occurrences, Processing and Application of Kaolins, Betonites, Palygorskite-Sepiolite, and Common Clays. Elsevier, 2007; ISNB: 978-0-444-51701-2

3 of the 4 dust samples are far away from WTC7, making them likely WTC1,2 exclusively.

Millette selected those chips which had both a red layer (primer) and a gray layer (“rust”), to match those found in Harrit’s study.
2. Using a stereomicroscope, particle chips showing the characteristic red/gray were removed and washed in clean water.
There’s no mention of the ratio of these magnetic red/gray chips to magnetic red/no gray chips (if any) disregarded.
Perhaps (?) Laclede’s electro-phoresces primer application process eliminates this gray “rust “ layer (“involving a direct current through deionized water paint bath”) and then baking, producing red layer chips with no gray "rust" layer.

NCSTAR 1-1A Chapter 6- Painting p.147 pdf
http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire05/PDF/f05086.pdf

This process, dipping in a liquid bath tank, of applying primer paint to complex shaped trusses is more economical than spray painting, which was likely used for priming the other simpler surfaced steels, boxes WF shapes that applied the primer atop a thin “gray rust” layer.

electrocoating http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrophoretic_deposition
 
Last edited:
One should also take into account the fact that they may not have used the paint they claimed they did.......folks have been known to cut corners if they think they can get away with it. The architect may have specified LaClede but vendor may have used an "equivalent"

I think we should be very nit-picky about words such as "specification". The NIST report has two documents about the LaClede primer in Appendix B of NCSTAR 1-6B, starting on page 155 of the PFD file:

  • One is a letter dated "July 17, 1967" bearing the titel "RECOMMENDED PAINT SPECIFICATION". It is unclear who sent this to whom, but sounds like those in charge of designing the towers sent this to prospective steel manufacturers. So note first that it is only a recommended specification. Sound like deviations were permitted. It says that "...primer shall be furnished in accordance with Pittsburgh Plate Glass Company Standard V.C. 41901 or equal". I don't know if anyone has been able to figure out what that standard implies. It goes on: "...paint shall be furnished in the manufacturer's standard red or gray color as specified" (my italics). The rest of this document talks about physical properties, but no mention of composition. It seems that this recommendation is pretty open towards the pigments used.
  • The second document is from LaClede Steel, dated September 1, 1967, and lists the recipe ("Formula LREP - 10001") for "LaClede Standard Steel Joist Paint". This formulation is not called a "specification" - it seems to be more like LaClede is reporting on what they typically used, or intended to use, as of September 1967.
Is it possible that they changed the formula before actually painting the joists? I think yes, as we have no evidence that an actual specification including SrCrO4 was included in the contract documents. Is it likely? I'd guess no - I think the simplest and most likely assumption is that they did use the formulation as reported.


ETA: The contract between LaClede and PONYA, which details specs such as paint, was signed in October 1967, according to NIST NCSTAR 1-1A (page 144 PFD).

Does anybody know if these contracts can be downloaded somewhere?
 
Last edited:
How frrustrating to see real technical discussions about Millette's study being broken into two threads! I'm going to ask the moderators if they can moderate it "after the fact" and just clean up inappropriate posts. That's what I thought moderating was about, not holding up discussion (my assumption). It's worth it to have some kind of moderation tho. And it's been helpful to have the discussion broken into two parts: 1) the technical discussion and 2) the "personal" stuff, like Cate Jenkins, accusations of frraud etc. But we shouldn't break it out into three threads!
 
BTW James Millette's peer-reviewed study will come out later, obviously. I'm sure he would welcome your input, once you pore over his many figures and photos, to propose a specific kind of paint this might be. Positively identifying the paint in the final study would be better than saying "It's paint, I don't have a perfect match for it yet, but it's definitely not thermitic material of any kind."
One observation he made was that the paint chips were found in all four separate locations where he got his dust. Whatever it is, it was used a lot in the WTC.
 
How frrustrating to see real technical discussions about Millette's study being broken into two threads! I'm going to ask the moderators if they can moderate it "after the fact" and just clean up inappropriate posts. That's what I thought moderating was about, not holding up discussion (my assumption). It's worth it to have some kind of moderation tho. And it's been helpful to have the discussion broken into two parts: 1) the technical discussion and 2) the "personal" stuff, like Cate Jenkins, accusations of frraud etc. But we shouldn't break it out into three threads!

Don't worry so much, mate!
I think we will soon get used to the moderated status of your new thread. And I think if among the few of us here, who take an informed interest in the two topics, we can agree to discuss the Millette results Re:thermite or not in your thread, and keep the arguments pro and contra LaClede paint here. An occasional cross-post will hopefully be tolerated.
 
BasqueArch: interesting comments. I asked some months ago if electrocoating technology could have some influence on the "way" how the coated steel oxidizes during coating. No answer. Still, I think that some thin layer of oxidized steel is being formed during time under any paint (?).
Hypothetically, it can be that chips studied by Jim are not Laclede paint, but some very similar WTC paint instead, which is just very easily attracted by magnet because of strong magnetism of attached oxidized steel... In this case, even comparatively rare paint can prevail as the samples. But, this just an another premature hypothesis:o)

Oystein: We would be much better informed if we can get some info from PPG Industries (probable manufacturer of "Laclede paint"). Perhaps, discussing now the "official" scientific study of WTC red primer paint chips, it is a time to ask them again (??). I also think that you should post our "white paper" on Laclede paint to Jim Millette, although it has not been fully edited/reviewed yet.

Chris: I agree with you: "Millette study thread" should be moderated in "ex-post" manner, otherwise it could be almost useless and not really interesting.
 
Last edited:
The part of strontium chromate is very very weak in the composition of Laclede paint.
I think you need a (very) lucky strike to find it during the tests.
 
Last edited:
The part of strontium chromate is very very weak in the composition of Laclede paint.
I think you need a (very) lucky strike to find it during the tests.

I totally disagree. In fact, it. should be easy to find. One part in 25 of the pigment must be SrCrO4. If all pigments ar the same size, you just need to look at 100 pigments. 55 will be hematite, 41 kaolinite, and 4 strontium chromate. They all have their distinctive shapes (plate, grain, needle). If the chromate particles are larger (I think they are), they are easier to spot; if they are smaller, they are more numerous.
In the bulk XEDS, Sr may hide next to Si, and the peaks above 14 keV may be too weak if your beam energy is isufficient (20keV is barely sufficient, nbut 25keV should do), but finding Cr should be easy-peasy for an experienced researcher like Millette.
 
...
Oystein: We would be much better informed if we can get some info from PPG Industries (probable manufacturer of "Laclede paint"). Perhaps, discussing now the "official" scientific study of WTC red primer paint chips, it is a time to ask them again (??). I also think that you should post our "white paper" on Laclede paint to Jim Millette, although it has not been fully edited/reviewed yet.
...

I am a little frustrated that my real life is too busy this week to put the finishing touches to the paper. I am hardly at home where I have my resources. My sister and here family just returned after having lived overseas for 4 years, and two choir projects are now turning into high gear with extra rehearsals... I am now posting from work, where I have internet, but not what I need to edit the paper.
 
It's possible that all sorts of different paints were used by different manufacturers. Things like this are quite usual - the customer will give a specification, i.e. the paint has to conform to this standard but you can apply what you want as long as it's to that standard and above.

It's entirely feasible that a manufacturer or even LaClade used the cheaper zinc chromate inhibitor rather than the more expensive strontium chromate inhibitor. I don't think for this application that it would matter.
 
I totally disagree. In fact, it. should be easy to find. One part in 25 of the pigment must be SrCrO4. If all pigments ar the same size, you just need to look at 100 pigments. 55 will be hematite, 41 kaolinite, and 4 strontium chromate. They all have their distinctive shapes (plate, grain, needle). If the chromate particles are larger (I think they are), they are easier to spot; if they are smaller, they are more numerous.
In the bulk XEDS, Sr may hide next to Si, and the peaks above 14 keV may be too weak if your beam energy is isufficient (20keV is barely sufficient, nbut 25keV should do), but finding Cr should be easy-peasy for an experienced researcher like Millette.

Yes, I agree.... but only if you are looking for SrCr04!
Before you do this job (with photographs) we had never suspected the presence of needles (strontium chromate).

The spectra gives elements for a restrain area. That's why you can obtain the sprectra for each components (fig 11 of Harrit's paper).

So if you are not specificaly looking for SrCrO4, it's possible to miss it.
I think it's the case.
 
OK but Jim Millette was very unambiguous when he told me he found no SrCrO4!

Perhaps because he was looking at the “Unknown” spray primer paint applied to the core columns and floor WF beams , painted atop a mild layer of “rust”. The known exterior columns Tnemec paint was a comparatively small area, with little chipping in the collapse and a minor contributor to the dust.

Perhaps the electrocoated (anodic or cathodic?) Laclede primer does not have a “rust” gray layer, yet retains its magnetic properties due to its 55% iron oxide content in the pigment. 55 (38%)parts iron oxide+41(28%) parts Al Si + 4 (3%) parts SrCr + 45 (31%) parts epoxy = 145 parts total for pigment and epoxy (the deionized water evaporates)

The electrocoating process may be anodic or cathodic, depending on the charge applied the substrate. Although the processes are virtually the same, properties of the resultant coating are dissimilar. Anodic systems, which were the first to be used for electrocoating, apply paint to positively charged substrates. The negatively charged pigment and resin particles deposit onto the substrate (anode). One disadvantage of this process is that substrate metals dissolve and become incorporated into the coating, which affects surface properties.

[URL]http://www.engineershandbook.com/MfgMethods/electrocoating.htm[/URL]
The water content of the paint/vat solution evaporates during the subsequent baking (20 min at 350F or so) after the immersion of the trusses. The primer and epoxy remain as a hard coating on the steel.

ETA:
The first patent for a cathodic EPD product was issued in 1965 and assigned to BASF AG. PPG Industries, Inc. was the first to introduce commercially cathodic EPD in 1970.
wikipedia. Towers were started 1968 completed in 1970 and 1971. The trusses were installed before the process was available = anodic electrocoating.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom