The Big Dog
Unregistered
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2007
- Messages
- 29,742
OK but Jim Millette was very unambiguous when he told me he found no SrCrO4!
Do you have the link to the article yet?
I could not locate it on Millette's web site.
OK but Jim Millette was very unambiguous when he told me he found no SrCrO4!
Perhaps because he was looking at the “Unknown” spray primer paint applied to the core columns and floor WF beams , painted atop a mild layer of “rust”. The known exterior columns Tnemec paint was a comparatively small area, with little chipping in the collapse and a minor contributor to the dust.
Perhaps the electrocoated (anodic or cathodic?) Laclede primer does not have a “rust” gray layer, yet retains its magnetic properties due to its iron oxide (25.8%) + Al Si (19.3%) +SrCr (1.9%) + (53%) epoxy total for pigment and epoxy (the deionized water evaporates and not counted)
The electrocoating process may be anodic or cathodic, depending on the charge applied the substrate. Although the processes are virtually the same, properties of the resultant coating are dissimilar. Anodic systems, which were the first to be used for electrocoating, apply paint to positively charged substrates. The negatively charged pigment and resin particles deposit onto the substrate (anode). One disadvantage of this process is that substrate metals dissolve and become incorporated into the coating, which affects surface properties.
I wonder what this means to a metallurgist and the likelyhood of finding a gray ("rust") layer under an electrocoated paint on steel not exposed to the weather.
[URL]http://www.engineershandbook.com/MfgMethods/electrocoating.htm[/URL]The water content of the paint/vat solution evaporates during the subsequent baking (20 min at 350F or so) after the immersion of the trusses. The primer and epoxy remain as a hard coating on the steel.
ETA:The first patent for a cathodic EPD product was issued in 1965 and assigned to BASF AG. PPG Industries, Inc. was the first to introduce commercially cathodic EPD in 1970.wikipedia. Towers were started 1968 completed in 1970 and 1971. The trusses were installed before the process was available = anodic electrocoating.
I've seen Galvalume zinc over steel sheets electrocoated for > 20-30 years not exposed to rain, and the surfaces look almost new no rust.
Chris: Thanks a lot for the link to Jim Millette's figures and spectraI'm responding here since the moderation of Jim's study thread still seems to be rather "clumsy" to me
Frankly, I have just came back from the pub enjoying some beers, but anyway: looking at the spectra and other results, I'm even more convinced now that Jim has studied the same chips as Bentham chips (a) to (d), i.e. "Laclede primer paint").
Well, I will reconsider this claim tomorrow morning, but I have little doubt that I will change this opinion as sober![]()

...
Also, he overestimates the proportion of volatile Thinner and Spirits in the wet paint; he claims that 40% of the wet paint are volatile, when the true value is closer to, or even below, 30% (I'll calculate that later)
...
He was aware to look out for strontium chromate because that's in a particular paint formulation, but he didn't find any. So the chips that Jim descibes are NOT a perfect match for LaClede paint. The chips that Harrit describes are, albeit with the strontium chromate signal being weak and coming from one chip (a) only. (If you disregard SrCrO4, the match is perfect, but a red paint with hematite and kaolinite is so mundane and usual, it could be LaClede, or could be some other paint. In my view, it's the SrCr=4 that makes LaClede stand out)
I think there is an easy explanation for the absence of strontium chromate: Dr. Millette cleaned the chips with water!
Strontium chromate is more or less soluble in water depending on the pH of the solution. In alkaline solution strontium chromate is only poorly soluble, but in neutral and acidic it is much better soluble. I assume that he dissolved the strontium chromate during the cleaning process. It would be interesting to know if he tested the water for strontium chromate (I only have a slow connection since wednesday and made no attempt to download his report).
Interesting. The chromate is blended with the other pigment materials, blended with the epoxy, electrocoated onto the steel and then baked until dry and hard.
Is it likely that it would wash off?