One Million Rupees Offer to prove "Homeopathy is Paranormal"

Mojo said:
I notice that the guy posting gibberish seems to be claiming qualifications remarkably similar to "Dr." MAS's (at least to the extent that MAS seems to be able to keep track of the qualifications he claims...).

Duly added to the "Evade the questions" thread.
Click to expand...
I think there was a small program circulating that would allow you to write l33t, I cannot remember where... I think that he just copied and pasted the op of mas thread, adding some tidbit.
I'm still not sure if it's a juvenile troll or another of the reincarnations of the mas collective.
Maybe it's mas actively trying to demonstrate that he is really the head of the computer club. Hey h3 c4n wr1t3 l33t right?:D

[edited for the spelling of the l33t part :D]
 
Incidentally, if the gibberish guy is MAS, he's breaking the forum rules over there, as both identities have posted in the Chance to Win One Million Dollar Prize Money, Prove Homeopathy thread.

"NCHPakistan" the forum administrator over there has stated in this thread that
You are allowed to create limited duplicate alias for special reasons. But you are not allowed to enter in the same thread with another name or location ie. If you have entered in a thread with pen name “Bango” then the same person “Bango” is not allowed to send posts in the same thread with another pen name / alias.
Click to expand...
Do you think any action is likely to be taken? Non-Sense Homeopath, for example, seems very big on the idea of impartial moderation of forums.
 
Mojo said:
[...] Do you think any action is likely to be taken? Non-Sense Homeopath, for example, seems very big on the idea of impartial moderation of forums.
Click to expand...
well even if they ban him (and it won't happen), nothing will prevent him to post as a guest...
uh, moreover I wouldn't use the words "non-sense homeopath" and "idea" in the same sentence. You seem to imply that he is actually able to formulate a coherent though...
 
Non-Sense Homeopath said:
M Sarwar, Don't go after randi trolling members.

Homeo man is triple Ph.D in Veterinary and A. Sheikh is tetra Ph.D in chemistry. If I say like this, this does not mean that I am correct. Unless you specify your exact name, qualification, postal address, social identity number and phone number so that we could verify your claim, just like DR. MAS presented an example. His personal profile tells you everything.
Click to expand...
NSH, I asked MAS for a simple clarification of his "qualifications" over on this thread weeks ago. I didn't ask him for his name, address, phone number or shoe size, I merely asked that he tell me where he did each of his claimed qualifications, and how long each one took.

Guess what answer I got?
Originally posted by Dr.MAS
Click to expand...
I hope you didn't believe him too when he listed his qualifications at you. Did you?
 
Mojo said:
Incidentally, if the gibberish guy is MAS, he's breaking the forum rules over there, as both identities have posted in the Chance to Win One Million Dollar Prize Money, Prove Homeopathy thread.

"NCHPakistan" the forum administrator over there has stated in this thread thatDo you think any action is likely to be taken? Non-Sense Homeopath, for example, seems very big on the idea of impartial moderation of forums.
Click to expand...

Why do they need to create aliases? I don't understand why people need to hide behind false identities. Unless you want to troll, there's no reason to have more than one identity.
 
Perpetual Notion (my emphasis) said:
Why do they need to create aliases? I don't understand why people need to hide behind false identities. Unless you want to troll, there's no reason to have more than one identity.
Click to expand...
You just answered your own question ;).

Hans
 
Originally posted by Gaga I think there was a small program circulating that would allow you to write l33t, I cannot remember where... I think that he just copied and pasted the op of mas thread, adding some tidbit.
I'm still not sure if it's a juvenile troll or another of the reincarnations of the mas collective.
Click to expand...
That was my guess too - that he ran Dr. MAS's post through a translator site. But based on that, I wouldn't assume he was in MAS's group. Could be from any side of the discussion.

I'm wondering now if any of the MAS collective posts here were straight-forward or if they all were based on some game they are playing with the JREF. Maybe they don't even believe the Avogadro's number views they were expressing initially. Good to be able to brighten someone's day, I suppose. Maybe it will become clearer during the exciting seminar.
 
flume said:
That was my guess too - that he ran Dr. MAS's post through a translator site. But based on that, I wouldn't assume he was in MAS's group. Could be from any side of the discussion.

I'm wondering now if any of the MAS collective posts here were straight-forward or if they all were based on some game they are playing with the JREF. Maybe they don't even believe the Avogadro's number views they were expressing initially. Good to be able to brighten someone's day, I suppose. Maybe it will become clearer during the exciting seminar.
Click to expand...
I have to admit that I'm totally stumped on that. I mean, I encounter every day more than my rda of loons, but come on, these people are supposed to be grownups.
They're perhaps playing doctor but they need nonetheless a bare minimum of social skills to survive doing that. The way they behave is not what I would accept from an adult should I have to deal with him in 'real life' i.e. outside an internet forum.
When I try to look at the thing from afar, it all seems like a big joke, but who would go through the hassle of organizing such a foolish game? (well there's people who would go to any lenght for a joke, think of Stansted :D)

I wonder what kind of patients visit the asian dumb foundation there and what happens to them :(
 
BTW, now that we can see the picture in a larger scale, it seems strange that the nose hole is considerably darker than any other dark pixels in the picture. Although I am sure it is not difficult to photograph lepers and disfigured people in Pakistan (in Bangla Desh she would probably have been the victim of an acid attack), I am also of the opinion that somebody has "improved" on the picture in a photo editor!

(Edited for typo)
 
It is also clear that there is something very wrong with the skin over her entire face.

It's looking possible that homeo man's story is just a tissue of lies. I merely throw that out as a possibility.
 
I'm assuming this is all just more desperate distraction to avoid answering any questions about homeopathy.

It's quite despicable really isn't it.
 
And it is quite interesting that he has a photo of the patient from the street when she is begging. I would have thought his photos would have come from his clinic?

I’ve a terrible feeling that Homeo Man may not be telling us the complete truth.
 
Darat said:
And it is quite interesting that he has a photo of the patient from the street when she is begging. I would have thought his photos would have come from his clinic?
Click to expand...
I wondered exactly the same in the new thread he opened.
Darat said:

I’ve a terrible feeling that Homeo Man may not be telling us the complete truth.
Click to expand...
Like for example what happened to her since he took the photo more than half a year ago.
 
Homeo Man said:
I post a case without comments

http://img179.echo.cx/img179/2929/woman23yz.jpg

Edited by Darat: 
Image edited to link. The image may be disturbing to some Members since it features a very disfigured lady.


See this picture.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=57544
Click to expand...

Homeoman I have been reading with interest. It seems as above with these so called skeptics that they will just blank out the reality they can't deal with in a rational way. banning your picture was the last straw for me and i had to join and express my disgust with this behaviour against you and other proponents of homeopathy. homeopathy has been proven beyond all reasonable doubt to be effective in many cases, it just hasn't been explained by science. And because of this these so called skeptics just try to shut discussion off with insult, divert it with sophistry or ban people for obviously made up reasons.
 
amazingdan said:
Homeoman I have been reading with interest. It seems as above with these so called skeptics that they will just blank out the reality they can't deal with in a rational way. banning your picture was the last straw for me and i had to join and express my disgust with this behaviour against you and other proponents of homeopathy. homeopathy has been proven beyond all reasonable doubt to be effective in many cases, it just hasn't been explained by science. And because of this these so called skeptics just try to shut discussion off with insult, divert it with sophistry or ban people for obviously made up reasons.
Click to expand...
Welcome to the forum, dan. You may take your place over in the corner.

wright7.jpg


Homeoman will be along shortly to spell you.
 
Mojo said:
Do you have any evidence to support this statement?
Click to expand...

there's the sophistry i mentioned. everyone knows there is evidence for effictiveness. an hour in a library or ten minutes on google will confirm that. it is simply foolish to claim that homeopathy has been adequately debunked. hard to swallow for many so called skeptics so it seems, but that is the way it is.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom