One Million Rupees Offer to prove "Homeopathy is Paranormal"

[dogbite666]

Hello sheikh ask him to clearly indicate, what is his actual demand to prove? If he could be able in succeeding his demand, he is eligible for prize money.

MAS, The demand was for him to prove that homeopathy works above the placebo effect. How many times must that be asked? how many times are the both of you going to obsfucate and claim you've won the JREF million?

It seems to me that both of you are simply trying to get a rise out of the members of this forum, because you so obviously can't prove that homeopathy works.

 

[Mojo]

Hello sheikh ask him to clearly indicate, what is his actual demand to prove? If he could be able in succeeding his demand, he is eligible for prize money.

If you are referring to me here, all I was aking was that Sheikh keeps the promise he made here, when he posted:

Originally Posted by dogbite666:
Please tell us how you would control this test, i.e. how would you know if it was the Camphor remedy having an effect on the patient or placebo, or even if their condition changed by chance?

If I were to carry out this test I would take 3 groups. One group would be given a homeopathic remedy, one a placebo and one group is given nothing. I would ensure that the patients and the people prescribing the homeopathic remedy and judging the results didnt know which patients belonged to which group.

If homeopathic Camphor remdy is effective in treating patients with the ailments you described then the group which were given the remedy will show greater improvments than the other 2 groups. DO YOU AGREE Dr. A Sheikh???

Proving how? this is our job!

We will prove it with double blind test. if we will fail then we will leave homeopathic practice for ever.

You can only demand to prove what we will claim. Our claim is quoted above.

To keep his promise, all he has to do is either to prove in a double blinded test that homoeopathic camphor can cure the conditions he mentioned in the thread or to leave homeopathic practice. I'm not sure who the other people are that he included in this promise when he said "we": are you one of them?

 

[Dr. MAS]

MAS, The demand was for him to prove that homeopathy works above the placebo effect. How many times must that be asked? how many times are the both of you going to obsfucate and claim you've won the JREF million?

It seems to me that both of you are simply trying to get a rise out of the members of this forum, because you so obviously can't prove that homeopathy works.

Yes this is the proper demand or challenge which you were trying to put.

Ok Now second part of our question is to justify your demand, why you think it does not work?

 

[steenkh]

Ok Now second part of our question is to justify your demand, why you think it does not work?

Because you and Sheikh have never been serious from the start? Because you both do not trust your principles so much that you would risk a test?

 

[Dr. MAS]

we believe and understand the principles and also practice them. You are not homeopath, you are not involve in homeopathy, you never used them, you have no clinical experience, you have only book knowledge, you have no idea of practical implementation. First get acquinted with them.

 

[MRC_Hans]

In other words, MAS: You are unable to explain the principles you claim to believe and understand?

Hans

 

[Z]

In other words: Dr. MAS is a fraud and a scam artist, and he's been rumbled; and now he needs his out.

Fine. Get out.

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

In other words, MAS: You are unable to explain the principles you claim to believe and understand?

Hans

which principle? we believe on principles and we ar practicing too. Which principle you are talking about?

 

[Dr. MAS]

We believe and practice according to the principle laid down by Hahnemann. You don't know the principles.

 

[Jeff Corey]

You are a fool and a simpleton if you don't believe that many people here are familiar with the pseudoscience of homeopathy. We know it is a fraud, a fake, a criminal scam that kills people who need real medical treatment. That is why , I at least, hold you in contempt as a bottom feeding parasite who steals money from ill people.