One Million Rupees Offer to prove "Homeopathy is Paranormal"

[Vikram]

MAS,

I'm not going to dignify a person like you with the prefix 'Dr.'. Someone who feels that patients should bow to his authority and not attempt to inquire into the nature of their illnesses is nothing more than a creep.

As a doctor of medicine, I make every attempt to explain to my patients their diseases using terms that they can understand. To deny them that right because they are "illeterate" is so incredibly arrogant and unethical that I'm truly having to force myself to not violate Rule 8 right now.

 

[delphi_ote]

MAS,

I'm not going to dignify a person like you with the prefix 'Dr.'. Someone who feels that patients should bow to his authority and not attempt to inquire into the nature of their illnesses is nothing more than a creep.

As a doctor of medicine, I make every attempt to explain to my patients their diseases using terms that they can understand. To deny them that right because they are "illeterate" is so incredibly arrogant and unethical that I'm truly having to force myself to not violate Rule 8 right now.

Creep?! I'm calling him EXACLTY what he is: a fraud, a liar, and a crook. Du. Mas is giving sick people water and telling them they'll be healed! Okay... strike one. Then he has the nerve to tell them they're "too ignorant" to understand his "diagnosis?" I guess "I just made it up" IS pretty hard to understand. Those 5 words are probably hard to swallow when you're sick, poor, and uneducated. What does it matter if he "educates" his "customers" or not? Du. Mas will still be counting their money all the same.

I'm sure he won't translate "mekhbesi" for us. He won't tell us how he diagnosed this "illness" or how he "treated" it. Surely with other doctors in the house, his "expert medical opinion" wouldn't fall on "ignorant" ears, but we all know the real reason he won't "educate" us. He's not qualified to talk about genuine medicine. He's a fraud taking advantage of the uneducated.

As far as I'm concerned, the time to be patient with Du. Mas is over.

 

[thaiboxerken]

Yes, Mas is a fraud and a troll. He should be held accountable for any lives that he's destroyed or hurt.

 

[Ashles]

Dr. MAS instead of paying for us to come over to Pakistan, why not spend a much smaller amount of money applying for this prize.

It's worth a LOT more than a million rupees, and you don't even have to explain how homeopathy works or whether it is 'paranormal' or not.

All you have to do is tell the difference between homeopathic remedies and their stock substance.
It could be by testing, actually healing patients... whatever you like.

Could you do it? If so, why not apply?

I know this is hardly new, but, since Dr. MAS fever is winding down around here after a rather disappointing display, I thought you might like to end with some kind of explanation for not applying for the million dollar challenge?

Hello?

Hellooo....?

 

[sackett]

Such language! Where are your manners?

I would NEVER imply that Dr. MAS is a cynical, lying, cheating, swindling, ignorance-loving quack with no interest in anything but bilking his hapless victims out of their last anna. Although it’s true that an unscrupulous charlatan MIGHT post here for purposes of bolstering his ramshackle reputation, nothing that I say should EVER be thought to suggest such a thing. If Dr. MAS says that he shills, excuse me, sells homeopathy out of a disinterested wish to do good and not at all for profit, I promise that I will not post ONE WORD of doubt. After all, an astute scientist like Kumar would surely not endorse a cheap snake-oil peddling crook. The very idea is outrageous.

 

[Psiload]

A patient was came, I examined him and suggested my medicine. I took two hours in case taking and repertorization for that special case.

At the end, the patient family inquired from me, "DOCTOR SAHIB INNO KEE HAI" (WHAT IS WRONG WITH HIM?).

I said, you came here for treatment, I have no time to teach you because your level of understanding is very poor. I read homeopathy for 11 years, I can't tell you what is the problem with your patient in few minutes but I assure you he will be all right within 15 days.

The patient family again said, "KHUDARA SANO AAI TO DAS DIO AINO BEMARI KE HAI" (FOR GOD SAKE, WHICH DISEASE HE IS SUFFERING FROM). I said, you can't understand because you have very low qualification, for clear understanding I have wasted my 11 years in study and you can't understand it in just one minute.

Ok Doctor, "SIRF BEMARI DA NA DAS DIO" (JUST TELL THE NAME OF DISEASE). Family member inquired. I said, "he is suffering from mekhbesi".

Family members inquired "AI KI HONDA HAI" (WHAT IS MEKHBESI DISEASE), I said, I have already told you, you cannot understand becuase you are illeterate. I have no time to teach you. I just assure you, he will be all right in short time. Education which I got after 11 years of study, you are interested in understanding that education in few minutes. This is not possible.

Read above and find the answers of your question.

Please tell who among is interested in learning homeopathy?

Come forward.

I am ready to teach everyone. This is my profession and I know how to handle my students. I got first divsion in Master in Education (M.Ed) I was the incharge of 200 principles when I was doing the course. No problem with me.

It's good to see that the caste system is alive and well in India. How dare that lowly untouchable ask questions of MAS, The Great and Terrible... giver of water.

Sickening

 

[Jeff Corey]

Erm, Pakistan. And not Hindu.

 

[Non-Sense Homeopath]

Not really. He seems capable of reading and writing (sometimes even of writing reasonably correct English). It's just basic comprehension he has a problem with.

I know dr. mas, he is a big liar and cheater. he is intentionaly doing all this, he must be banned.

 

[flume]

I know dr. mas, he is a big liar and cheater. he is intentionaly doing all this, he must be banned.

No reason for him to be banned that I know of.
It would be more interesting if he tried to participate in the discussion, but it's his choice not to.
I wish he would think of his explanations here as giving a seminar rather than teaching a class.

 

[Zep]

I know dr. mas, he is a big liar and cheater. he is intentionaly doing all this, he must be banned.

Good try, Mas.

Pretend to be someone else and try and get yourself banned here, so you can take it to your thick-headed homeo friends as "proof" we won't talk to you.

Sorry, that one won't wash. We have had a number of other less-than-reputable people (e.g. Karen Boesen) who have tried that childish trick, and it didn't work for them either. Their accounts are still open and active, and we are still waiting for them too to provide any sort of rational explanation of their antics.

Ditto for you, I'm afraid - if you leave, it will be of your own free will, not ours. And you will be able to come back and join in again any time you like.

So it really would be a whole lot better for you to come down a peg or two and start talking like we was real people...people who DO know at least as much as you do about medicine, science, chemistry, in fact anything you can name so far. And start providing some decent explanations for a change.

Yes?

 

[delphi_ote]

Good try, Mas.

Are you serious?! Using sock puppets to get banned and get pity?

This is just pathetic! Even YECs wouldn't stoop to such a tactic!

 

[Psiload]

Are you serious?! Using sock puppets to get banned and get pity?

This is just pathetic! Even YECs wouldn't stoop to such a tactic!

Check out the sock's profile:

Biography: I hate homeopathy because I dislike Homeopathy
Location: Pakistan
Interests: To place hurdles against homeopathy
Occupation: Philosopher



You have to hand it to the homeopaths on one count... they certainly are an entertaining bunch.

 

[Kumar]

I know dr. mas, he is a big liar and cheater. he is intentionaly doing all this, he must be banned.

What are his intentions?

 

[flume]

Originally posted by Psiload Biography: I hate homeopathy because I dislike Homeopathy
Location: Pakistan
Interests: To place hurdles against homeopathy
Occupation: Philosopher

Okay, that makes me laugh.

Where's Homeo Man? What happened to sheikh? (Or maybe Homeo Man was sheikh's login when he was able to get access?)


On hpathy.com in the chitchat section, in the thread "Catch him if you can" the last post has another bit about the mystery lunch invitation a few days ago. Maybe someone who knows the language could tell if people were in fact being invited to a lunch, or if that was just a metaphor for someone cooking something up.

 

[delphi_ote]

Check out the sock's profile:

Biography: I hate homeopathy because I dislike Homeopathy
Location: Pakistan
Interests: To place hurdles against homeopathy
Occupation: Philosopher



You have to hand it to the homeopaths on one count... they certainly are an entertaining bunch.

Very subtle! I've met kindergarteners more mature than that.

 

[Vikram]

Are you serious?! Using sock puppets to get banned and get pity?

This is just pathetic! Even YECs wouldn't stoop to such a tactic!

Ah! But you forget monsieur that these are HOMEOPATHS.

 

[Non-Sense Homeopath]

Very subtle! I've met kindergarteners more mature than that.

My comments lies in these emoticons.

 

[Homeo Man]

Okay, that makes me laugh.

Where's Homeo Man? What happened to sheikh? (Or maybe Homeo Man was sheikh's login when he was able to get access?)

I am here and quite.

I wanna discuss good points and not fruitless.

 

[MRC_Hans]

I am here and quite.

I wanna do fruitful discussion and not fruitless.

I see. Not much use dicussing homeopathy, then?

Hans

 

[geni]

Check out the sock's profile:

Biography: I hate homeopathy because I dislike Homeopathy
Location: Pakistan
Interests: To place hurdles against homeopathy
Occupation: Philosopher



You have to hand it to the homeopaths on one count... they certainly are an entertaining bunch.

I thought you were jokeing but no. Oh my.