One Million Rupees Offer to prove "Homeopathy is Paranormal"
- Thread starter Dr. MAS
- Start date
-
- Tags
- homeopathy
Mojo
Mostly harmless
What difference do you think there is between a 30X homeopathic preparation and the pure solvent? What test would you suggest using to detect this difference?Kumar said:Yes, Try try again, you will gain till you get or it dies by itself. Become A Thirsty Crow. You know Necessity is the mother of invention.
Basis: something was experianced by many & mass......
Please try to leave thirsty crows out of it. And why does necessity come into it? It is not necessary to try to explain effects that are not observed to occur, or to try to detect differences that don't exist.
Badly Shaved Monkey
Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2004
- Messages
- 5,363
Kumar said:Yes, Try try again, you will gain till you get or it dies by itself. Become A Thirsty Crow. You know Necessity is the mother of invention.
Basis: something was experianced by many & mass......
So, if we repeat the same test of homeopathy 1,000 times and on one occasion we get a positive answer should we believe that one correct answer and reject the other 999?
Dan Beaird
Critical Thinker
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2004
- Messages
- 342
Kumar said:
Can you possibly be this dense?
A DBT is a series of tests. When designing the protocol people who have studied actual math and statistics determine how many individual test cases they need to run to get a statistically valid result. If the test has a large enough sample and is run honestly you should get about the same results every single time.
If you get amazing results out of your DBT protocol then maybe someone else might choose to run the test as well to independently verify the study.
Nobody in their right mind will endlessly repeat a study in the hopes that they will get a different result. Well at least nobody that the mass/existing scientific community will pay attention to.
Finally: it is the homeopaths who must prove their candy pills work, nobody else. There are supposedly scientists in the homeopathic community who have tried and failed, nobody else really cares about it until you start trying to sell the stuff. Then we call you on the carpet for the frauds and liars that you are.
Dan Beaird,
One study is not the absolute criteria of rejection/discredit to whole system. Moreover it was on cows & homeopaths were not involved. You may also be getting many many tests failed during trial test, experiment & on practical public experiance with the time. Willit discredit/reject whole system? No, you have to try again with other remedies, potencies, protocols..alongwith homeopaths on their line.
One study is not the absolute criteria of rejection/discredit to whole system. Moreover it was on cows & homeopaths were not involved. You may also be getting many many tests failed during trial test, experiment & on practical public experiance with the time. Willit discredit/reject whole system? No, you have to try again with other remedies, potencies, protocols..alongwith homeopaths on their line.
Mojo
Mostly harmless
Why would the fact that a study used cows have any bearing on the results (unless homeopathy is just placebo, of course).Kumar said:
Kumar said:Remedies should be matched as per provings. I don't know, whether proving was done on cows?
Perhaps you share this insight with vested interests?
http://www.vethomopath.com/indcattle.htm
Rolfe
Adult human female
How come Kumar knows less about homoeopathy than the people he's trying to persuade?Kumar said:Remedies should be matched as per provings. I don't know, whether proving was done on cows?
Provings are never done on animals. Isn't that lovely, no animal testing, great marketing tool. Which still doesn't stop homoeopaths from claiming that homoeopathy can be applied to animals, and works on animals. You explain it, I can't.
Except that it seems to work on animals every bit as well as it seems to work on humans.
Rolfe.
I'm still waiting for one of the homeopaths who claim they can explain how homeopathy works to actually do so.Donks said:
I have set up new threads for them and everything.
Dr MAS
Homeopath Syed
Homeo Man....
We're waiting.
Please note this offer is not open to Kumar or any of his subsidiaries, affiliates, alter egos, friends, interior voices or sock puppets
I'm not so sure.Donks said:
I suspect that gathering such a collection of dense misunderstandings and confusion together might cause a gravitational collapse and create a black hole.
Or open a portal to Hell.
Or be annoying.
Chris Haynes
Perfectly Poisonous Person
Kumar said:
Please.
Please be unable to reply/talk until you've read up on the basics of physics and chemistry that you have been directed to many times.
Ashles said:
I called meeting of 500 doctors from different areas and cities to discuss this issue.
The following amendments were made to our previous offer
1. If you are interested in providing evidence or proofs that "Homeopathy does not work" then you have very good chance to win one million ruppees.
For this purpose, we have made very very very very very simple rules so that everybody should have equal chance to win the prize. Simply send request letter for registeration before starting work. Details are available at www.nchpakistan.com discussion board.
Prove this statement scientifically. For this purpose you can design any protocol, no restriction.
2. Send your controlled study thesis endorsed three Ph.D's chemist from three different universities at my address.
Dr. MAS
Chief Executive
World Homeopathic Computer Club
Iqbal Poly Homeopathic Clinic
Near Main Police Station
Main Market, Kharian
Pakistan
Phone: 0092-5771-531658
Mobile: 0092-300-6263403
You people are also invited to demonstrate your claim in homeopathic seminar which will be held on 29th may 2005. Minister of health pakistan is the chief guest.
I will bear all your expenses in Pakistan. You don't have to bother about Hotel expenditures, travelling and entry in the seminar. Lunch is also free.
Dr. MAS
Chief Programe Organizer
4th International Homeopathic Seminar
District Council Hall, Grt, Pakistan
I will bear all your expenses in Pakistan. You don't have to bother about Hotel expenditures, travelling and entry in the seminar. Lunch is also free.
Dr. MAS
Chief Programe Organizer
4th International Homeopathic Seminar
District Council Hall, Grt, Pakistan
