Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
While I agree that discussion and debate are important for society, I don't think that is what Hegel meant by dialectic. The word dialectic has a specific, technical meaning for Hegel, that certainly doesn't mean something like discourse or discussion. It is the forming of an idea or proposition (commonly called a thesis) into it's negation (the antithesis), which then both are taken up into a synthesis. It is the manner in which history develops (in a rational way) towards the Absolute Knowing, in a way 'the end of history'. Hegel claimed he had already attained this Absolute Knowing, from which he can see the way history has unfolded.
Well I've had a fun afternoon studying.

wiki said:
Social change

Hegelian: The classic Hegelian dialectic model of change is based on the interaction of opposing forces. Starting from a point of momentary stasis, Thesis countered by Antithesis first yields conflict, then it subsequently results in a new Synthesis.
So, while discussion is not requisite of the dialectic, social change is the result of the synthesis. The opposing forces likely being different views held by different people.

Traditionally, this dimension of Hegel's thought has been analyzed in terms of the categories of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis. Although Hegel tended to avoid these terms, they are helpful in understanding his concept of the dialectic. The thesis, then, might be an idea or a historical movement. Such an idea or movement contains within itself incompleteness that gives rise to opposition, or an antithesis, a conflicting idea or movement. As a result of the conflict a third point of view arises, a synthesis, which overcomes the conflict by reconciling at a higher level the truth contained in both the thesis and antithesis. This synthesis becomes a new thesis that generates another antithesis, giving rise to a new synthesis, and in such a fashion the process of intellectual or historical development is continually generated” (reference- Encarta Encyclopedia)
So, while I did wrongly attribute discourse to the Hegelian dialectic (as opposed to the Aristotelian dialectic which is), the basic process is correct, would you agree? I would posit that because of confirmation bias conflict is not likely to rise in any one person sufficient to drive social change. The conflict arises between people because of the exchange of ideas.

If you want please feel free to PM me.
 
Last edited:
Because that would obviate the OWS message. Isn't ad hominem great? It allows for demonizing an entire group bases upon a single action.

I don't think calling the guy who planned a terrorist attack on a bridge an idiot constitutes ad hominem. If I were to call him an idiot and dismiss some argument that he had made on that basis, you'd have a point. But to call him an idiot based on his plan to blow up a bridge is a tautology.

As for demonizing an entire group based on a "single" action, apparently you have not been paying attention to the thread. There have been hundreds of single actions--rapes, murders, bombings, assaults, etc., not to mention the occasional broken window at Starbucks or Wells Fargo. When do we cease to see these as unrelated incidents, and begin to recognize them as predictable extensions of the "logic" that begat Occupy in the first place?
 
Last edited:
Check it out. Occutard Oakland May Day. Photos, vids and commentary.

What a bunch of pathetic losers and try-hard revolutionaries.

A speech by an anarchist at the event:



Question: What's crazier? The dude giving the speech or the dude on drugs with his arms in his shirt talking to himself?

The Decolonize Oakland rally.

Apparently the OWS movement is too white and too male.
 
Last edited:
Check it out. Occutard Oakland May Day. Photos, vids and commentary.

What a bunch of pathetic losers and try-hard revolutionaries.

A speech by an anarchist at the event:



Question: What's crazier? The dude giving the speech or the dude on drugs with his arms in his shirt talking to himself?

The Decolonize Oakland rally.

Apparently the OWS movement is too white and too male.

It's funny that a new word has been created through this thread, and we can have our laughs and jollies. It's great, iddin it?

I'm wondering if some conservatives here are aware that a good handful of tea partyists have actually joined the OWS movement?

Any idea?

Conservatives?
 
I don't think calling the guy who planned a terrorist attack on a bridge an idiot constitutes ad hominem. If I were to call him an idiot and dismiss some argument that he had made on that basis, you'd have a point. But to call him an idiot based on his plan to blow up a bridge is a tautology.

As for demonizing an entire group based on a "single" action, apparently you have not been paying attention to the thread. There have been hundreds of single actions--rapes, murders, bombings, assaults, etc., not to mention the occasional broken window at Starbucks or Wells Fargo. When do we cease to see these as unrelated incidents, and begin to recognize them as predictable extensions of the "logic" that begat Occupy in the first place?

I have yet to hear an answer for this...

Any reason that conservatives here are dismissing the violence that begat the Tea Party?
 
I have yet to hear an answer for this...

Any reason that conservatives here are dismissing the violence that begat the Tea Party?

I don't know much about the Tea Party and any violence they may or may not have committed. I do know a fair amount about OWS and the violence, murders, rapes, property damage, and other laws they have broken.

No need for a Tu Quoque. Jane already said something about comparing conservative reactions to the TP (heh) and OWS. I pointed out that in the interests of fairness, liberal and centrist reactions should be discussed as well. I'm pretty sure the whole thing is an ad hominem designed to show conservative "double standards" while diverting the subject from the actual validity or lack thereof of the criticisms.
 
Last edited:
Check it out. Occutard Oakland May Day. Photos, vids and commentary.

What a bunch of pathetic losers and try-hard revolutionaries.

A speech by an anarchist at the event:



Question: What's crazier? The dude giving the speech or the dude on drugs with his arms in his shirt talking to himself?

The Decolonize Oakland rally.

Apparently the OWS movement is too white and too male.

From the Decolonize Oakland manifesto, I particularly liked "Leaderlessness is the new tyranny."
I found the four signatures of Anonymous on it to be particularly revolutionary acts.
 
From the Decolonize Oakland manifesto, I particularly liked "Leaderlessness is the new tyranny."
I found the four signatures of Anonymous on it to be particularly revolutionary acts.

I wonder if they were wearing those edgy Guy Fawkes clown masks while signing? That's how you know you're a true revolutionary!
 
I have yet to hear an answer for this...

Any reason that conservatives here are dismissing the violence that begat the Tea Party?

Perhaps you could provide some links to examples of the violence you are talking about?
 
I have yet to hear an answer for this...

Any reason that conservatives here are dismissing the violence that begat the Tea Party?

Are you referring to the Boston Tea Party, or the modern tea party movement?
 
I don't think calling the guy who planned a terrorist attack on a bridge an idiot constitutes ad hominem. If I were to call him an idiot and dismiss some argument that he had made on that basis, you'd have a point. But to call him an idiot based on his plan to blow up a bridge is a tautology.
Simply calling someone an idiot is not ad hominem.

As for demonizing an entire group based on a "single" action, apparently you have not been paying attention to the thread. There have been hundreds of single actions--rapes, murders, bombings, assaults, etc., not to mention the occasional broken window at Starbucks or Wells Fargo. When do we cease to see these as unrelated incidents, and begin to recognize them as predictable extensions of the "logic" that begat Occupy in the first place?
By that logic we must condemn the protestors of the 60s. I reject your argument. How many people have participated in OWS? How many have participated in violent crime? How are you controlling for your confirmation bias? I don't conclude that the right to life movement is violent because of the many bombings, burning of buildings and murders are carried out by right to life members.
 
I have yet to hear an answer for this...

Any reason that conservatives here are dismissing the violence that begat the Tea Party?

Want a medal?

I thought they weren't violent?

Um Yeah. Whatever.
It all depends on who it is that is doing the violence. How many Americans condemn the Boston Tea party but are more than happy to point out that members of OWS has broken windows?
 
So you're responding to a point no one actually made instead of the post you quoted?
We've already been through this: Fortunately "tard" hasn't yet reached the pinnacle of slang to be considered a "bigot slur" by the PC language police except in some highly sensitive souls such as yourself. You'll know when it does since it will won't be spoken or written, but only referenced as the "t" word, but by then of course the politically correct terminology will have begun to morph into a negative slang, and the PC speech police will be all over using "developmentally disabled" or "DD" to refer to the likes of the Occutards.

But hey, keep focusing on these PC language issues and ignore the pathetic actions of the Occutards.
I'm fine with just calling them "idiots". Is that a neutral enough term? Can we all agree that it's a subjective opinion?

I note a marked reluctance among those who are complaining the most* about about the term Occutard to condemn the protestors who were deliberately trying to provoke the police by comparing them to animals. The donuts alone could be taken as a joke, but implying cops are comparable to fish in intelligence is an insult, without equivocation.

*I've complained too, just not very much. I've explained why twice.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom