Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well I said "name something good they've done" and nobody could answer it then I said "Open Challenge: find something they wrote that isn't stupid overblown rhetoric and gibberish" and there were no contenders. And yes, talking about the things OWS does in an OWS thread is totally on-topic and relevant. How do you expect people to judge them? By what they say about themselves?
It's a large movement. The anecdotes don't tell us much. OWS has raised awareness about corporate corruption and the inability of the govt to provide oversight. Just because you have decided that everything that OWS writes is overblown rhetoric doesn't mean that it is so.

So yeah, that all strikes me as smoke screens and diversions. You already know OWS is wrong and focusing on the real problems of corporate corruption doesn't fit your narrative so you focus on anecdotes.
 
Straw man. It's civil disobedience. Of course it's wrong.

Civil Disobedience - The History Of The Concept

I don't mind that you disagree with OWS but I do mind when you engage in straw man argument.

Not in the eyes of their fellow protesters they can't unless they do something really stupid like whip out a machine gun.

Some protesters might express concerns about civil disobedience however I've only ever seen it in a "how will this make the movement look ?" context.
 
Not in the eyes of their fellow protesters they can't unless they do something really stupid like whip out a machine gun.

Some protesters might express concerns about civil disobedience however I've only ever seen it in a "how will this make the movement look ?" context.
I've no idea what this even means. :confused:

"Can't"? "Can't" what?
 
I've no idea what this even means. :confused:

"Can't"? "Can't" what?

Can't condem diversity of tactics without taking the optics stance.

It's simple really. if groups like occupy wanted to rein in the black bloc and their antics they could just come up with say, the white bloc who would vastly outnumber the black bloc and intervene when they, the white bloc, saw trouble brewing.

As it is now, anybody with any sense runs fro the hills when they see the black bloc approaching.
 
Apparently so, since you can't seem to answer "Do you ask for the same justification whenever someone uses the word "idiot"?"

So you are totally against laws that try to make some sort of distinction for "hate crimes"?

I'd also like to point out the irony of accusing you of dodging a simple question, when she has consistently refused to say what the donut-danglers were trying to achieve or how it advances the cause of OWS one inch. All she keeps doing is a handwave about protesting, without saying what they are protesting for and how dangling donuts helps achieve whatever goal. Now she's just calling it street theatre. Well, we certainly know who the clowns in the equation are.

Not in the eyes of their fellow protesters they can't unless they do something really stupid like whip out a machine gun.

Some protesters might express concerns about civil disobedience however I've only ever seen it in a "how will this make the movement look ?" context.

Actually, in the Gothamist threads I linked and quoted in #5233, you can see even people who are Occupy-sympathetic call these kids with the donuts out. Not even for the image of the movement either; openly decrying them for alienating the police. To which the hardcore respond "solidarity!"


Can't condem diversity of tactics without taking the optics stance.

It's simple really. if groups like occupy wanted to rein in the black bloc and their antics they could just come up with say, the white bloc who would vastly outnumber the black bloc and intervene when they, the white bloc, saw trouble brewing.

As it is now, anybody with any sense runs fro the hills when they see the black bloc approaching.
Incidentally someone on one page I saw pointed out the idiotic donut danglers were dressed in black bloc clothing. Which means there's an excellent chance some of them were the same folks smashing store windows and throwing glass jars at cops later.

These are the people you're defending, Jane.
 
Can't condem diversity of tactics without taking the optics stance.

It's simple really. if groups like occupy wanted to rein in the black bloc and their antics they could just come up with say, the white bloc who would vastly outnumber the black bloc and intervene when they, the white bloc, saw trouble brewing.

As it is now, anybody with any sense runs fro the hills when they see the black bloc approaching.
Okay. Well, I'm here for a serious discussion if anyone else is interested. We last left off with civil disobedience if anyone wants to take that up.
 
Okay. Well, I'm here for a serious discussion if anyone else is interested. We last left off with civil disobedience if anyone wants to take that up.

I gather you don't think self policing is a serious idea so we can ask...Civil disobedience, how's that working out for occupy ? What happened to all their support ? The support they had in the first week of the occupation ? Where's Hollywood, Rosie O'Donnell ? You remember her, the one who said that anyone with more than a hundred million in the bank should be executed ?

Turns out she's only got eighty million herself, so yea, I can totally relate to her concerns.
 
I gather you don't think self policing is a serious idea so we can ask...Civil disobedience, how's that working out for occupy ? What happened to all their support ? The support they had in the first week of the occupation ? Where's Hollywood, Rosie O'Donnell ? You remember her, the one who said that anyone with more than a hundred million in the bank should be executed ?

Turns out she's only got eighty million herself, so yea, I can totally relate to her concerns.

Damn, I need to flee the country! :eek:
 
Civil disobedience, how's that working out for occupy ? What happened to all their support ? The support they had in the first week of the occupation ? Where's Hollywood, Rosie O'Donnell ? You remember her, the one who said that anyone with more than a hundred million in the bank should be executed ?
Asked and answered but I will humor you. I grew up in the 60s I learned about the efforts before I was born and I remember when I was young wondering how long the protests were going to last. It was years and the attention and focus waxed and waned. Your analysis is quite frankly wrong. It's ad hoc to justify your preconceptions.

Now, I want to be completely honest. OWS might very well be completely dead. It might be that OWS accomplished nothing (I seriously doubt that). If so that's fine. I can live with that. Democracy is messy. We don't always get what we want. I'm grateful to live in a nation where OWS had a shot and not a nation like the one Natan Sharansky wrote about in The Case for Democracy.

That said, IMO, things are sufficiently bad and that we will continue to see protests. Like the 60s they might flare up and die down but I think eventually we will get there. I have faith in Democracy. My hopes were never pegged just to this movement.
 
Asked and answered but I will humor you. I grew up in the 60s I learned about the efforts before I was born and I remember when I was young wondering how long the protests were going to last. It was years and the attention and focus waxed and waned. Your analysis is quite frankly wrong. It's ad hoc to justify your preconceptions.

Now, I want to be completely honest. OWS might very well be completely dead. It might be that OWS accomplished nothing (I seriously doubt that). If so that's fine. I can live with that. Democracy is messy. We don't always get what we want. I'm grateful to live in a nation where OWS had a shot and not a nation like the one Natan Sharansky wrote about in The Case for Democracy.

That said, IMO, things are sufficiently bad and that we will continue to see protests. Like the 60s they might flare up and die down but I think eventually we will get there. I have faith in Democracy. My hopes were never pegged just to this movement.

So, do we agree that occupy shot themselves in the foot ? That the reoccupation isn't going to happen any time soon as they're all off on the free buses to Chicago ?

Occupy isn't going to give you what you want, not even close As I've stated many times before it's an anti-capitalist movement at heart and things like investment/interest income are the ultimate capitalist evil.
 
So, do we agree that occupy shot themselves in the foot ?
No. Not even close. Could I ask you a favor? Could you not turn my being honest into something dishonest?

Occupy isn't going to give you what you want, not even close As I've stated many times before it's an anti-capitalist movement at heart and things like investment/interest income are the ultimate capitalist evil.
Not sure how many times I can say I disagree and I don't care. It's my hope that some day that you will get that.

Look, you are entitled to an opinion and that's fine. But I must say, I think that when you make categorical declarations you hurt your credibility. It certainly doesn't impress me. I could sit here and declare that those who oppose corporate corruption and who have, in part supported OWS will absolutely benefit from OWS but honesty is important to me.

All in all though that's fine. At least you are capable of engaging in a conversation without browbeating and childish behavior. And for that I thank you.
 
Can't condem diversity of tactics without taking the optics stance.

It's simple really. if groups like occupy wanted to rein in the black bloc and their antics they could just come up with say, the white bloc who would vastly outnumber the black bloc and intervene when they, the white bloc, saw trouble brewing.

As it is now, anybody with any sense runs fro the hills when they see the black bloc approaching.

At least it would be funny watching them fight each other.
 
I gather you don't think self policing is a serious idea so we can ask...Civil disobedience, how's that working out for occupy ? What happened to all their support ? The support they had in the first week of the occupation ? Where's Hollywood, Rosie O'Donnell ? You remember her, the one who said that anyone with more than a hundred million in the bank should be executed ?

That was Roseanne Barr. They're somewhat interchangeable; both Truthers, both hard-core lefties, both love doughnuts a bit too much.
 
Not sure how many times I can say I disagree and I don't care. It's my hope that some day that you will get that.

Yes, it's rather interesting how things are explained many times to them yet it never sinks in.

Not sure if critical thinking is really for them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom