Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, I can't see it working as a single strategy IIRC English environmentalists tried a don't fly tactic as part of a global warming awareness campaign, dunno what happened with it. My point is, of course that when it comes to lifestyle vs ideology, lifestyle wins 99.9% of the time with with very little ( save band aid on a brain tumour type solutions ) getting done in the long run.

So rather than going on about how the oil companies are keeping us from using renewable energy maybe occupy should put some effort into exploring real world solutions, that is, if they're really concerned about AGW.

Just using one example.

I hear you on the manipulated desires idea but it still comes down to the want, not the need for, the latest and greatest. Sure the companies are trying to create brand loyalty but the want for, say, the latest in TV technology comes from the simple human desire for a status symbol,be it brand A, B or C.

My son is six so he's not had much exposure to trends, so to speak. One sentence I inadvertently left out was mention of his creating products in his mind that he wants. I won't bore you with the details except to say that many, many of his statements begin with the phrase "I want". Yes, I know it's only going to get worse, much worse but right now I'm happy delaying the inevitable.

Granted there are exceptions to point 2, however I'm talking about billions of people all wanting things they can't afford and the only reason i can see for this is that desire for status that I just mentioned. Here's an example and I wish I'd taken a photo. I'm in a market in dirt poor Honduras and I see a stall selling vegetables and the proprietor had handmade his own Nike logo sign and hung it over his booth. He wasn't wearing any shoes, I checked.

I'm not per se against consumerism, business (corporations et al), advertising or marketing.

You may not be, but occupy at it's anti-capitalist heart is and very much so.
 
No, I can't see it working as a single strategy IIRC English environmentalists tried a don't fly tactic as part of a global warming awareness campaign, dunno what happened with it. My point is, of course that when it comes to lifestyle vs ideology, lifestyle wins 99.9% of the time with with very little ( save band aid on a brain tumour type solutions ) getting done in the long run.

So rather than going on about how the oil companies are keeping us from using renewable energy maybe occupy should put some effort into exploring real world solutions, that is, if they're really concerned about AGW.

Just using one example.

I hear you on the manipulated desires idea but it still comes down to the want, not the need for, the latest and greatest. Sure the companies are trying to create brand loyalty but the want for, say, the latest in TV technology comes from the simple human desire for a status symbol,be it brand A, B or C.

My son is six so he's not had much exposure to trends, so to speak. One sentence I inadvertently left out was mention of his creating products in his mind that he wants. I won't bore you with the details except to say that many, many of his statements begin with the phrase "I want". Yes, I know it's only going to get worse, much worse but right now I'm happy delaying the inevitable.

Granted there are exceptions to point 2, however I'm talking about billions of people all wanting things they can't afford and the only reason i can see for this is that desire for status that I just mentioned. Here's an example and I wish I'd taken a photo. I'm in a market in dirt poor Honduras and I see a stall selling vegetables and the proprietor had handmade his own Nike logo sign and hung it over his booth. He wasn't wearing any shoes, I checked.
I think it important to note that your claim is rather oversimplified. I would first clarify that status includes both prestige and simple acceptance into society (appealing to either require somewhat different strategies). And while status is very important it is only a part of the equation. Well-being and pleasure are also as important if not more so.

Regardless, marketing exploits these desires for status, pleasure and well-being. What is important is this, wants and perception of needs can be artificially increased. The data is simply not debatable. The Yanomamo, Piraha and others serve as controls to falsify the idea that wants are static in all people. Also, it is demonstrable that people can be manipulated to eschew savings for debt to have material things now. And, people in different cultures are more or less likely to be manipulated. Please see this chart. Note America's standing. The difference can only be accounted for by culture.

You may not be, but occupy at it's anti-capitalist heart is and very much so.
I really don't care. There is a real problem and I think at the moment OWS is by far our best shot at raising awareness for that problem. I trust the principles of social and moral progress I so often enumerate.

  • Social and moral progress is the synthesis of the dialectic. --Hegel
  • Social and moral progress is the equilibrium found in an adversarial system. --Sandal
  • Without deviation from the norm there is no progress. --Zappa
OWS makes possible all three. (Quotes are paraphrased).
 
Last edited:
Occupy Cleveland idiot who was busted for planning a terrorist attack and who wasn't a real occupier... happened to sign the lease for Occupy's current space:

One of the five self-described anarchists arrested last week for attempting to blow up a local bridge signed the lease for a West Side warehouse where about a dozen members of the Occupy Cleveland group live.

Of course, there is a good explanation:

Zitt said Hayne happened to be on hand when the organization leased the warehouse to store items and serve as housing for some members.

"We needed a name on the lease, and he agreed to be it," Zitt said. "I want to stress that rent [$600 a month] for the warehouse was paid directly to the landlord. No money was ever given to Hayne."
 
Occupy Cleveland idiot who was busted for planning a terrorist attack and who wasn't a real occupier... happened to sign the lease for Occupy's current space:

Of course, there is a good explanation:
Because that would obviate the OWS message. Isn't ad hominem great? It allows for demonizing an entire group bases upon a single action. It allows for lazy dismissal of a message. One wonders why anyone cares? Perhaps OWS has a point?
 
The huge problem with the occupier and the left in general is that they exist solely to criticize western society and it's "evil" ways. Of course the left has to speculate that we're all victims of "them" and our only recourse is. complain, complain, complain.

It's a guilt motivated philosophy. Guilt at what the evil westerners have done to the planet and it's various cultures and occupy is just a way of trying to tell the world that the occupiers are not part of the problem while at the same time enjoying the fruits of those evil ways.

The only people I see repeatedly using the word "evil" in this context are people like yourself when they are trying to discredit (and stereotype) "leftists". I've rarely seen it used in left-wing writings. It seems to be a manifestation of the desire to artificially reframe the debate into simplistic black and white terms.
 
Last edited:
Words have consequences.
So do actions, and you seem to simply ignore and hand wave away the juvenile and destructive actions of the Occutards, and instead make an issue of the use of slang.

Do you know any of the real "tards" that you are unfavorably comparing OWS people to?
Do I need to in order to plainly see that OWS actions are destructive, naive, and juvenile?
 
I think it important to note that your claim is rather oversimplified. I would first clarify that status includes both prestige and simple acceptance into society (appealing to either require somewhat different strategies). And while status is very important it is only a part of the equation. Well-being and pleasure are also as important if not more so.

.

Yes, we can break it down like that however doing so doesn't hand wave away the desire for the latest and greatest, whatever the product may be. Electronics, health care supplements, cars with the latest features, yachts, what have you, the desire for all these things is driven by wants. I think most of us are aware of how advertising works and are free to do our own research on whether a product presented to us is necessary for life or some ridiculous geegaw designed to separate us from our money.

Occupy could/should help us out here when it comes to making those buying decisions and lead by example. Simple is good.

The Yanomamo, Piraha and others serve as controls to falsify the idea that wants are static in all people.

A very small population. Wikipedia says Piraha numbers about 400 people. How long will their wants for a traditional lifestyle last ? Already they're embracing some consumer goods. IMO The Amish might be a better example of ideology winning out over lifestyle. Show me a country, like Thailand with it's Buddhism (wants craving etc ) rejecting the consumer lifestyle.

Please see this chart. Note America's standing. The difference can only be accounted for by culture.

I'm not sure of what I'm supposed to make of that chart. If we toss away the freak spike at the top, there's not a lot of difference in the amount of per capita savings, 5 grand, 10 grand and reading it one could come away with the impression that there's not a consumer debt problem in western society and everything is good.

I really don't care.

You should, it's political extremism and the want for some sort of non existent anywhere in the world utopia. I wonder why Cubans can't leave their country for a holiday ?

Social and moral progress is the synthesis of the dialectic. --Hegel
Social and moral progress is the equilibrium found in an adversarial system. --Sandal
Without deviation from the norm there is no progress. --Zappa
OWS makes possible all three. (Quotes are paraphrased).

I can't say I understand the first two quotes, philosophy was never my strong suit however the Zappa quote nails it. Go on occupiers deviate, not just in words but in actions. Show us how it's done.
 
The only people I see repeatedly using the word "evil" in this context are people like yourself when they are trying to discredit (and stereotype) "leftists". I've rarely seen it used in left-wing writings. It seems to be a manifestation of the desire to artificially reframe the debate into simplistic black and white terms.

Maybe you could shed some insight as to WHY occupiers would set up shop outside a bank shareholders meeting waving banners that "expose" all the banks wrongdoings ? I can't see any other reason that raising awareness that this bank is evil.

Same thing in Toronto with a gold mining corporation's shareholders meeting and several more such actions are scheduled for the future.
 
Yes, we can break it down like that however doing so doesn't hand wave away the desire for the latest and greatest, whatever the product may be. Electronics, health care supplements, cars with the latest features, yachts, what have you, the desire for all these things is driven by wants. I think most of us are aware of how advertising works and are free to do our own research on whether a product presented to us is necessary for life or some ridiculous geegaw designed to separate us from our money.
No need to make this difficult. Humans can be manipulated. Demand for consumer goods can be increased.

Occupy could/should help us out here when it comes to making those buying decisions and lead by example. Simple is good.
Occupy should do what they deem they should.

A very small population. Wikipedia says Piraha numbers about 400 people. How long will their wants for a traditional lifestyle last ? Already they're embracing some consumer goods. IMO The Amish might be a better example of ideology winning out over lifestyle. Show me a country, like Thailand with it's Buddhism (wants craving etc ) rejecting the consumer lifestyle.
Population size and duration are irrelevant. By all means choose your example, any of them are fine to falsify the notion that human desire cannot be manipulated.

I'm not sure of what I'm supposed to make of that chart. If we toss away the freak spike at the top, there's not a lot of difference in the amount of per capita savings, 5 grand, 10 grand and reading it one could come away with the impression that there's not a consumer debt problem in western society and everything is good.
I don't accept your conclusions but even if I did, it still falsifies the notion. It still would serve as evidence that human desire varies by culture.

You should, it's political extremism and the want for some sort of non existent anywhere in the world utopia. I wonder why Cubans can't leave their country for a holiday ?
To care would be irrational. I live in a democracy. At best OWS contributes to the dialectic. At worst, OWS contributes to the dialectic.

I can't say I understand the first two quotes...
Assuming that democracy and freedom are good things, how did we as a species living in a modern civilization acquire them? It wasn't an accident.

  1. Hegel: We advance as a society through discussion and debate. Argument and reason. We attempt to persuade each other to our ideas. This is the dialectic. It's why you are here on the JREF. You are contributing to it right now.
  2. Sandal: Think of a trial, plaintiff and defendant. They are adversaries. They battle for the truth and in doing so are most likely to arrive at the best outcome. It's not perfect but in a Democracy it is a good way to incrementally move toward the best outcomes. Which is why we got rid of slavery, segregation and why violent crime rates are declining.
...philosophy was never my strong suit however the Zappa quote nails it. Go on occupiers deviate, not just in words but in actions. Show us how it's done.
I kinda doubt that is the solution. At least by itself. Perhaps as part of comprehensive strategy. But even then I'm skeptical.
 
Last edited:
No need to make this difficult. Humans can be manipulated. Demand for consumer goods can be increased.

Agreed however if occupy isn't going to even acknowledge that they are being manipulated into buying and using the latest consumer goods then this argument is moot wrt the power corporations have over society. We're victims of the corporations, remember ?

Occupy should do what they deem they should.

No, occupy is claiming to speak for everyone, the 99%, they should listen to us and our criticisms yet they don't. Any Joe on the street could have foretold that the occupy, the tents tactic was doomed to failure right from the start, that they'd be over run with homeless people and get themselves shut down.

Occupy told us they were going to rebuild society from the ground up, they didn't listen when we told them we didn't want our society rebuilt on some sort of anarchist model.

Occupy ignored us when we said they needed to defend their identity after they, predictably, attracted every cause in the book, from twoofers to chemtrailers to immigrant rights groups and appeared to be taking over the protest industry with their brand.

Simply because they didn't listen to the people they were claiming to represent, they lost everything and are now vainly attempting to rebuild something that's doomed, once again to failure.

Population size and duration are irrelevant. By all means choose your example, any of them are fine to falsify the notion that human desire cannot be manipulated.

They're completely revalent, it's what takes an idea from the fringes to the mainstream. If occupy tells us we're being manipulated the least they can do is prove that they themselves haven't been manipulated.

I don't accept your conclusions but even if I did, it still falsifies the notion. It still would serve as evidence that human desire varies by culture.

It doesn't really, there could be all sorts of factors at play here maybe Europeans are more educated about advertising and debt or maybe they don't have the same bankruptcy protection laws, you know the good law:) that we have here in the US and Canada.

To care would be irrational.

This is politics, this is an emotional issue, it's all about caring.

Assuming that democracy and freedom are good things, how did we as a species living in a modern civilization acquire them? It wasn't an accident.

Hegel: We advance as a society through discussion and debate. Argument and reason. We attempt to persuade each other to our ideas. This is the dialectic. It's why you are here on the JREF. You are contributing to it right now.
Sandal: Think of a trial, plaintiff and defendant. They are adversaries. They battle for the truth and in doing so are most likely to arrive at the best outcome. It's not perfect but in a Democracy it is a good way to incrementally move toward the best outcomes. Which is why we got rid of slavery, segregation and why violent crime rates are declining.

Cheers, thanks for the clarification.

I kinda doubt that is the solution. At least by itself. Perhaps as part of comprehensive strategy. But even then I'm skeptical.

No, it's not the sole solution, I just want occupy to address it, something they simply refuse to do. All they can do is respond with "that's stupid" or some such asshattery,it's a problem when your movement has no identity, it can be about anything and everything at any time
 
It's not as if no one has identified the failures or make recommendations.

Then what is the purpose of OWS? We've been told that they are raising awareness of how unfair the world is, yet you say we've already identified the failures.
 
Last edited:
You live in a society where the govt removed regulations that had been in effect since the great depression to protect us from greed and power. Banks were allowed to become to large to fail and the govt failed to provide sufficient oversight for financial institutions putting the economy at risk. This resulted in the banking collapse and your money being used to bail out the geniuses that packaged worthless assets into complex derivatives and sold them to clients. Your money was used to purchase those worthless assets. Now, govt malfeasance and corporate corruption might not bother you. A growing debt to cover the markers for those drunk wagers might not bother you. But you still got hosed.

You realize "the governement" is not some mysterious black box that decisions come out of, right? "The government" is us. They removed banking regulations because we elected people who promised to do that. The solution is to now elect people who promise to undo it.
 
"Decolonization remembers and rebuilds the many systems of civilization – economics, government, politics, spirituality, environmental sustainability, nutrition, medicine and understandings of self, identity, gender and sexuality – that existed before colonization."

Holy crap what idiocy! Yeah, let's recreate pre-colonial America so the natives can torture each other to death like in the good old days. And ritual human sacrifice, have to bring back that lovely tradition!

Ah yes, the Noble Savage. :rolleyes:

And if we reinstitute nutrition and medicine from the 1600's, we can all die by the time we are 41!!!
 
1Agreed however if occupy isn't going to even acknowledge that they are being manipulated into buying and using the latest consumer goods then this argument is moot wrt the power corporations have over society. We're victims of the corporations, remember ?

2No, occupy is claiming to speak for everyone, the 99%, [opinion]they should listen to us and our criticisms yet they don't. Any Joe on the street could have foretold that the occupy, the tents tactic was doomed to failure right from the start, that they'd be over run with homeless people and get themselves shut down.

Occupy told us they were going to rebuild society from the ground up, they didn't listen when we told them we didn't want our society rebuilt on some sort of anarchist model.

Occupy ignored us when we said they needed to defend their identity after they, predictably, attracted every cause in the book, from twoofers to chemtrailers to immigrant rights groups and appeared to be taking over the protest industry with their brand.

Simply because they didn't listen to the people they were claiming to represent, they lost everything and are now vainly attempting to rebuild something that's doomed, once again to failure. [/opinion]

3They're completely revalent, it's what takes an idea from the fringes to the mainstream. If occupy tells us we're being manipulated the least they can do is prove that they themselves haven't been manipulated.

4It doesn't really, there could be all sorts of factors at play here maybe Europeans are more educated about advertising and debt or maybe they don't have the same bankruptcy protection laws, you know the good law:) that we have here in the US and Canada.

5This is politics, this is an emotional issue, it's all about caring.

Cheers, thanks for the clarification.

6 No, it's not the sole solution, I just want occupy to address it, something they simply refuse to do. All they can do is respond with "that's stupid" or some such asshattery,it's a problem when your movement has no identity, it can be about anything and everything at any time

  1. I'm at a loss as to how that would follow. I don't understand the logic. It makes no sense to me.
  2. A.) These are your opinions. B.) I disagree. C.) I'm not personally interested.
  3. A.) Again, I'm completely missing your logic. I understand your opinion but what OWS ought to do is nothing more than that and I can see no compelling reason to agree with you.
  4. Those factors would not in any way obviate my thesis. Of course there are other factors. Of course it's a complex dynamic. My point still stands. People can be manipulated and wants and desires can be increased. Your example of the Amish being rather excellent. Some cultures can counterbalance, to some degree, manipulation.
  5. I don't know if you are being serious. If you are then you misunderstand what I mean by "care" as it relates to my point here. OWS has virtually no chance of overthrowing the govt and/or installing anarchy for some very important reasons that I won't go into right now. Caring about the extremist desires of OWS would be as irrational as caring about killer bees.
  6. I respect that it is what you want. I'm just not personally interested and I don't think they are either. But you are of course free to your opinion.
 
Last edited:
Hegel: We advance as a society through discussion and debate. Argument and reason. We attempt to persuade each other to our ideas. This is the dialectic. It's why you are here on the JREF. You are contributing to it right now.

While I agree that discussion and debate are important for society, I don't think that is what Hegel meant by dialectic. The word dialectic has a specific, technical meaning for Hegel, that certainly doesn't mean something like discourse or discussion. It is the forming of an idea or proposition (commonly called a thesis) into it's negation (the antithesis), which then both are taken up into a synthesis. It is the manner in which history develops (in a rational way) towards the Absolute Knowing, in a way 'the end of history'. Hegel claimed he had already attained this Absolute Knowing, from which he can see the way history has unfolded.

Ok, philosophy lecture over. I'll go back into hiding now. :boxedin:
 
While I agree that discussion and debate are important for society, I don't think that is what Hegel meant by dialectic. The word dialectic has a specific, technical meaning for Hegel, that certainly doesn't mean something like discourse or discussion. It is the forming of an idea or proposition (commonly called a thesis) into it's negation (the antithesis), which then both are taken up into a synthesis. It is the manner in which history develops (in a rational way) towards the Absolute Knowing, in a way 'the end of history'. Hegel claimed he had already attained this Absolute Knowing, from which he can see the way history has unfolded.

Ok, philosophy lecture over. I'll go back into hiding now. :boxedin:
Thank you. I have conflated two definitions.

Merriam-Webster said:
Discussion and reasoning by dialogue as a method of intellectual investigation; specifically : the Socratic techniques of exposing false beliefs and eliciting truth b : the Platonic investigation of the eternal ideas.

Hegelian process of change in which a concept or its realization passes over into and is preserved and fulfilled by its opposite; also : the critical investigation of this process.
Though I didn't invent the idea I'm propagating. I need to find my source to see where I went wrong and try to better understand Hegel in this light.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom