Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hasn't the government actually made money off the bailouts?
America was brought to the brink of disaster. A depression loomed large and America had little choice but to protect the very idiots who put us in that position. The result is that people were harmed for no good reason. I have no idea if the government ultimately made a tidy some on the fiasco and I don't give a damn. Hurting people through greed and stupidity cannot be justified through profit. At least, that's my opinion.
 
As a matter of fact yes. Intuition isn't axiomatically wrong. On the contrary, as James Randi often points out, we need not be skeptical of all of our assumptions without some basis for doing so. Someone who doesn't accept gravity is acting contrary to common sense.

Oddly enough you would seem to profess beliefs without any justification other than bias and you would seem to do so arbitrarily. Having done so you appeal to derision for my using common sense.
Speaking of rhetoric ... :)

I got it now, only conservatives can be called out by demands for evidence. For Lefty-Libs 'common sense' is fine as is.

Thanks.
 
RandFan said:
As a matter of fact yes. Intuition isn't axiomatically wrong. On the contrary, as James Randi often points out, we need not be skeptical of all of our assumptions without some basis for doing so. Someone who doesn't accept gravity is acting contrary to common sense.

Oddly enough you would seem to profess beliefs without any justification other than bias and you would seem to do so arbitrarily. Having done so you appeal to derision for my using common sense.
Speaking of rhetoric ...

I got it now, only conservatives can be called out by demands for evidence. For Lefty-Libs 'common sense' is fine as is.
That would be a straw man. It does not represent my views or anything I've said. I have simply criticized speaking contrary to common sense in an arbitrary and unjustified manner.
 
That would be a straw man. It does not represent my views or anything I've said. I have simply criticized speaking contrary to common sense in an arbitrary and unjustified manner.
BTW: To illustrate my point, why do you think the marches on Selma were effective? What is your basis for saying so?
 
No they wouldn't.
Well, that's conclusive.



Okay, so I asserted people in suits would get kicked out. You have asserted Occupiers, unfairly, are being kicked out.

The video I have presented shows Occupiers in suits.

http://www.indiegogo.com/Wall-Suits

Enjoy your catch 22. Either Occupiers will get kicked out regardless of what they wear if they present the law, or all they have to do to not get kicked out is wear suits.

But please, feel free to continue to ignore parts of my posts, as you admitted doing.

An idiot throws bricks at his own side and Jane is more concerned about what he's called rather than what he did.

She has a habit of this, throwing out the conversational equivalent of a smoke grenade in order to attempt to derail the subject from something she don't like.
 
"Decolonization remembers and rebuilds the many systems of civilization – economics, government, politics, spirituality, environmental sustainability, nutrition, medicine and understandings of self, identity, gender and sexuality – that existed before colonization."

Holy crap what idiocy! Yeah, let's recreate pre-colonial America so the natives can torture each other to death like in the good old days. And ritual human sacrifice, have to bring back that lovely tradition!
 
"Decolonization remembers and rebuilds the many systems of civilization – economics, government, politics, spirituality, environmental sustainability, nutrition, medicine and understandings of self, identity, gender and sexuality – that existed before colonization."

Holy crap what idiocy! Yeah, let's recreate pre-colonial America so the natives can torture each other to death like in the good old days. And ritual human sacrifice, have to bring back that lovely tradition!


Open Challenge: Find something OWS wrote that isn't stupid.
 
Open Challenge: Find something OWS wrote that isn't stupid.

Did you know that much of the US constitution derives from Native American political philosophy?


Open Challenge: Find something OWS wrote that isn't stupid.

Are you happy to continue using stupid, Nazi-style, disablist rhetoric then?
 
Last edited:
"Decolonization remembers and rebuilds the many systems of civilization – economics, government, politics, spirituality, environmental sustainability, nutrition, medicine and understandings of self, identity, gender and sexuality – that existed before colonization."

Holy crap what idiocy! Yeah, let's recreate pre-colonial America so the natives can torture each other to death like in the good old days. And ritual human sacrifice, have to bring back that lovely tradition!

I guess they're not into things like written languages or the wheel since Native cultures had neither of these things.
 
Also, if somebody mugs you, quit talking to them. That'll teach 'em a lesson!

It helps to think of the mugging not as a one time event otherwise occupy would join forces with the twoofers and demand an investigation into October 2008, but as an ongoing continuous process.

first we have to look at what forces in society created that mugger and once those are identified we can move on to examining the possibility that you may be a mugger enabler.

The first step in reforming the mugger's ways is to not be a victim, this may be inconvenient and require some effort such as not walking down that same street carrying wads of cash. Eventually, you'll starve the mugger and force a change of ways.

/intervention
 
It helps to think of the mugging not as a one time event otherwise occupy would join forces with the twoofers and demand an investigation into October 2008, but as an ongoing continuous process.

first we have to look at what forces in society created that mugger and once those are identified we can move on to examining the possibility that you may be a mugger enabler.

The first step in reforming the mugger's ways is to not be a victim, this may be inconvenient and require some effort such as not walking down that same street carrying wads of cash. Eventually, you'll starve the mugger and force a change of ways.

/intervention
While there is some value to the concept I think it is largely a non-starter. More of a red herring. Many of the problems are removed from average citizens. Abuse and misuse of derivatives and investment insurance, a big part of the problem, are indirect to most consumers. Further, human behavior is a bit more complex than your simplistic solution suggests. If you've not seen it then I recommend watching The Century of the Self. Societies are inherently manipulable. Now, don't get me wrong, I believe in the importance of personal responsibility and I eschew paternalism, but I think it reasonable to accept a certain level of group think and group behavior (culture). So, is it likely that we can get a sufficient number of citizens to divorce themselves from current paradigms and create new ones? Perhaps a more important question is this, can govt effectively regulate commerce?

See, one of the problems that your theory fails to take into account is this, you and I, even if we are divested of banks and other businesses that might harm us, cannot fully escape from the harm.

The shenanigans of the banks cost me a 7-8 year career as an insurance auditor. The work dried up. Where I once had 3 different clients vying for my time to service their clients, I now have none (in the interest of full disclosure I also became disabled at about the same time).

So, I could have kept my money in a mattress and grown my own food and purchased products primarily from mom and pop sources but none of that would have kept me from losing my job.
 
Last edited:
While there is some value to the concept I think it is largely a non-starter. More of a red herring. Many of the problems are removed from average citizens. Abuse and misuse of derivatives and investment insurance, a big part of the problem, are indirect to most consumers. Further, human behavior is a bit more complex than your simplistic solution suggests. If you've not seen it then I recommend watching The Century of the Self. Societies are inherently manipulable. Now, don't get me wrong, I believe in the importance of personal responsibility and I eschew paternalism, but I think it reasonable to accept a certain level of group think and group behavior (culture). So, is it likely that we can get a sufficient number of citizens to divorce themselves from current paradigms and create new ones? Perhaps a more important question is this, can govt effectively regulate commerce?

See, one of the problems that your theory fails to take into account is this, you and I, even if we are divested of banks and other businesses that might harm us, cannot fully escape from the harm.

The shenanigans of the banks cost me a 7-8 year career as an insurance auditor. The work dried up. Where I once had 3 different clients vying for my time to service their clients, I now have none (in the interest of full disclosure I also became disabled at about the same time).

So, I could have kept my money in a mattress and grown my own food and purchased products primarily from mom and pop sources but none of that would have kept me from losing my job.

RF I'm sorry to hear about your job loss and coupled with a disability to boot. That's rough and I can understand your frustration with the system and agree that doing any of the things I suggested would have prevented your situation.

My suggestions are, however neither red herrings or non-starters. Occupy tried something similar with bank transfer day so I know they're at least aware of the idea(s) but for some strange reason, refuse to follow up on both the ideas and the actions. Easier to just wave placards and bang drums I suppose.

I didn't have time to watch the documentary, I'll get to it next week however I did look it up.

Yes, I suppose it is possible that a consumer culture was "created" however I can give three arguments as to why I think people wanting more of everything is part of the natural human condition rather than something thrust on us by the corporate world.

1) My six year old son. This kid has grown up without advertising, as much as possible anyway. His TV shows are ad free and if he's watching something I'm watching, like Mythbusters, we PVR through the commercials.

Yet he wants stuff, lots of stuff, and when he gets that stuff, he quickly looses interest in it and wants different stuff. I didn't teach him this, his school didn't teach him this so where did he get the rampant consumerism idea ? IMO, because it's there, because it's available. He hasn't been brainwashed by anybody and personally, I'm just this side of a minimalist so he's not picking up on my( nor my wife's ) wanting crap for the sake as wanting crap.

2) Third world countries. Granted there may be some corporate influence going on here, but damn, those "poor people" sure want all the stuff we have. TVs cars, phones, brand name clothes..yada yada.

3) The stuff I make. I make something weird, I'm not going to say what it is, not out of snobbery or secret it's just that if I tell you you'll form a picture in your mind or go agooglin' and come up with something that's not even close to my stuff. It sells like stink precisely because it is what it is, unique and hand made and my customers are looking for something that is different. Something that's not corporate made, without a corporate logo and something that's designed to attract attention due to the unusual nature of the product.

The huge problem with the occupier and the left in general is that they exist solely to criticize western society and it's "evil" ways. Of course the left has to speculate that we're all victims of "them" and our only recourse is. complain, complain, complain.

It's a guilt motivated philosophy. Guilt at what the evil westerners have done to the planet and it's various cultures and occupy is just a way of trying to tell the world that the occupiers are not part of the problem while at the same time enjoying the fruits of those evil ways.
 
RF I'm sorry to hear about your job loss and coupled with a disability to boot. That's rough and I can understand your frustration with the system and agree that doing any of the things I suggested would have prevented your situation.

My suggestions are, however neither red herrings or non-starters. Occupy tried something similar with bank transfer day so I know they're at least aware of the idea(s) but for some strange reason, refuse to follow up on both the ideas and the actions. Easier to just wave placards and bang drums I suppose.

I didn't have time to watch the documentary, I'll get to it next week however I did look it up.

Yes, I suppose it is possible that a consumer culture was "created" however I can give three arguments as to why I think people wanting more of everything is part of the natural human condition rather than something thrust on us by the corporate world.

1) My six year old son. This kid has grown up without advertising, as much as possible anyway. His TV shows are ad free and if he's watching something I'm watching, like Mythbusters, we PVR through the commercials.

Yet he wants stuff, lots of stuff, and when he gets that stuff, he quickly looses interest in it and wants different stuff. I didn't teach him this, his school didn't teach him this so where did he get the rampant consumerism idea ? IMO, because it's there, because it's available. He hasn't been brainwashed by anybody and personally, I'm just this side of a minimalist so he's not picking up on my( nor my wife's ) wanting crap for the sake as wanting crap.

2) Third world countries. Granted there may be some corporate influence going on here, but damn, those "poor people" sure want all the stuff we have. TVs cars, phones, brand name clothes..yada yada.

3) The stuff I make. I make something weird, I'm not going to say what it is, not out of snobbery or secret it's just that if I tell you you'll form a picture in your mind or go agooglin' and come up with something that's not even close to my stuff. It sells like stink precisely because it is what it is, unique and hand made and my customers are looking for something that is different. Something that's not corporate made, without a corporate logo and something that's designed to attract attention due to the unusual nature of the product.

The huge problem with the occupier and the left in general is that they exist solely to criticize western society and it's "evil" ways. Of course the left has to speculate that we're all victims of "them" and our only recourse is. complain, complain, complain.

It's a guilt motivated philosophy. Guilt at what the evil westerners have done to the planet and it's various cultures and occupy is just a way of trying to tell the world that the occupiers are not part of the problem while at the same time enjoying the fruits of those evil ways.
Thank you very much for the response.

Regarding your idea, as a means to assert that other methods are not useful or are simply wrong then I very much see it as a red herring. As a tactic of comprehensive plan then I'm fine with it. I'm not enamored for its success but I could be wrong.

Before I address your premises let me clarify something. The argument is not that businesses (corporations and others) create human desire. The argument is that they manipulate our unconscious desires in order to increase and direct them. This BTW is not in any way controversial. Entire fields and sub-fields of study and academia are dedicated to it. Marketing companies actually employ psychologists and behaviorists to figure out how to not only increase market share but to increase the market.

That said:

  1. Your son is indoctrinated/inculcated by social conditioning that you are not even aware of. Your very own desires and behavior are powerful for social conditioning to mold and shape your son's dispositions. Also, your son sees other children playing with toys, enjoying certain foods, wearing certain clothes, etc.. These are powerful social conditioning. Finally your son is a single data point (see rebuttal to premise 3)
  2. Not all people in all societies want more of everything. Societies like the Yanamomo and Piraha don't want more of everything and have they less stress and neurosis. Being introduced to modern societies have not significantly increased the desire of consumer goods. The Piraha have little us for most western products beyond fish hooks, shotguns and alcohol (see Don't Sleep Their Are Snakes).
  3. A.) Our desires to have things are not exclusively for mass produced or commercial stuff. B.) Humans are sociologically diverse. For both genetic and environmental reason some percentage of the population should not want commercial products. That is predicted by the science (see Bell Curve). What would be very surprising is to find that there are not such people.
In the end we can see our society has changed dramatically since the end of WWII. We are more willing to go in debt to purchase non-essential items. We have a greater appetite for commercial items.

I'm not per se against consumerism, business (corporations et al), advertising or marketing.
 
Last edited:
An anecdote of my own.

Your son is indoctrinated/inculcated by social conditioning that you are not even aware of. Your very own desires and behavior are powerful for social conditioning to mold and shape your son's dispositions.
My morning shower and shave ritual is solitary. I keep the door closed and I usually rise before anyone else. One morning when my son was about 3 I walked into the bathroom to see him with shaving cream smeared on his face holding my razor. I remember telling my wife and other family members about that. I've no idea where he picked that up. There could have been a time or two that I shaved with the door open but I honestly could not imagine that. It could have been TV or perhaps he saw another family member shave when we were staying with family. Ultimately it's not important, what I do know is that he wasn't born with the desire to shave.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom