Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm fine with just calling them "idiots". Is that a neutral enough term? Can we all agree on that?
Nope. Not PC enough:

"In 19th and early 20th century medicine and psychology, an "idiot" was a person with a very severe mental retardation." - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiot

Since in the natural course of language evolution, people began using that term that referenced severe mental retardation, to others not having mental retardation, it's no difference than using "tard", and thus politically incorrect.
 
Perhaps you could provide some links to examples of the violence you are talking about?

I've posted these before, but I guess I will do it again...



It says at the beginning of this video that a LaRaza member assaulted a town hall attendee. However, this was not a member of LaRaza. This video flat-out lies...



Wanna know how I know this video flat-out lies? Trinitytexas told me.

Next video: Although this is not violence, I could see why violence could erupt in this situation where people are irresponsibly booing, yelling, interrupting, and shouting down a woman in a wheelchair... Yes, tea partyists are such wonderful people...



Oh, and that Gabrielle Giffords was threatened before led to another incident...



And oh yes, how about the many death threats that were phoned in to various congessional offices when the health care bill was passed?



Is that not illegal?
 
At least about the new Tea Party. No True Occupier uses violence or pointless spectacle tactics, right?
 
We've already been through this: Fortunately "tard" hasn't yet reached the pinnacle of slang to be considered a "bigot slur" by the PC language police except in some highly sensitive souls such as yourself. You'll know when it does since it will won't be spoken or written, but only referenced as the "t" word, but by then of course the politically correct terminology will have begun to morph into a negative slang, and the PC speech police will be all over using "developmentally disabled" or "DD" to refer to the likes of the Occutards.

But hey, keep focusing on these PC language issues and ignore the pathetic actions of the Occutards.

Which characteristics do Occupy protestors and people with learning difficulties share that make the comparison such a perfect match for you?

'Police beat homeless "tard" to death.'



So you're responding to a point no one actually made instead of the post you quoted?
I'm fine with just calling them "idiots". Is that a neutral enough term? Can we all agree that it's a subjective opinion?

I note a marked reluctance among those who are complaining the most* about about the term Occutard to condemn the protestors...

I am not complaining about the term being applied to Occupy protestors. I am condemning the unfavorable comparison of people with learning difficulties with Occupy protestors. The portrayal of people with learning difficulties as undesirable outcasts leads to real violence against people with learning difficulties.

...who were deliberately trying to provoke the police by comparing them to animals.


The donuts alone could be taken as a joke, but implying cops are comparable to fish in intelligence is an insult, without equivocation.

That really is pathetic, 000063. You are portraying the police as helpless children. If they are unable to restrain themselves in the the face of some creative anarchist street theatre, then they are clearly dangerous and should leave the police force immediately.

I'd also like to point out that I have apologized for demeaning pigs and promised not to do it again.
 
Last edited:
Which characteristics do Occupy protestors and people with learning difficulties share that make the comparison such a perfect match for you?
Do you ask for the same justification whenever someone uses the word "idiot"? Being part of the thought police must keep you terribly busy, with all those potentially evil thoughts in peoples minds that you need to monitor.
 
You know what's funny? Although the forum is dominated by the left, the number of people voicing support for OWS can by counted on one hand. And even they spend most of their time on smokescreens and diversions.
 
You know what's funny? Although the forum is dominated by the left, the number of people voicing support for OWS can by counted on one hand. And even they spend most of their time on smokescreens and diversions.
? Those who oppose OWS spend most of their time hurling childish insults and posting anecdotes. Who is it that is spending time on smokescreens and diversions?

I have honestly tried to engage in sincere discussion. Stout has been one of the few to indulge me. Everyone else wants to browbeat and engage in childishness.

I'm here. I'm not going anywhere. Anytime you want to have a serious discussion, please, you just let me know. I won't call you names or act childishly. Fair enough?
 
Last edited:

Attachments

  • tard.jpg
    tard.jpg
    54.7 KB · Views: 65
Last edited:
? Those who oppose OWS spend most of their time hurling childish insults and posting anecdotes. Who is it that is spending time on smokescreens and diversions?

I have honestly tried to engage in sincere discussion. Stout has been one of the few to indulge me. Everyone else wants to browbeat and engage in childishness.

I'm here. I'm not going anywhere. Anytime you want to have a serious discussion, please, you just let me know. I won't call you names or act childishly. Fair enough?

Well I said "name something good they've done" and nobody could answer it then I said "Open Challenge: find something they wrote that isn't stupid overblown rhetoric and gibberish" and there were no contenders. And yes, talking about the things OWS does in an OWS thread is totally on-topic and relevant. How do you expect people to judge them? By what they say about themselves?
 
...
I am not complaining about the term being applied to Occupy protestors. I am condemning the unfavorable comparison of people with learning difficulties with Occupy protestors.
Which is, in fact, complaining about the term being applied to Occupiers. If b "unfavorable comparison" you mean they are found lacking in comp

The portrayal of people with learning difficulties as undesirable outcasts leads to real violence against people with learning difficulties.
And there is also real violence against occupiers. However, it is mostly being done by other Occupiers. Real violence happens all the time for the most trivial of reasons. People are often killed after spilling a beer.

That really is pathetic, 000063. You are portraying the police as helpless children.
No, I'm referring to what the protestors were trying to do, which you continue to downplay and not address.

If they are unable to restrain themselves in the the face of some creative anarchist street theatre, then they are clearly dangerous and should leave the police force immediately.
I never made that claim. I claimed that they were trying to produce an aggressive and negative response in the police, which they could then record, edit, and claim they were merely "peacefully protesting". Except they don't seem to be there to protest. They don't seem to be there for any other purpose but to troll the five-oh.

The police did not respond in the desired fashion, and acted in a professional and standards-appropriate manner, as they should both ethically and legally. They just walked on by. If the cops had responded in an aggressive manner, I would readily condemn them. I would still, however, condemn the protestors for provoking them, even as I condemned the police's response as inappropriate.

If it was "street theatre" it was such in which they tried to make the police participants.

What were the aims of the protestors? Because they were ostensibly trying compare the cops to dumb animals; fish. Whether the police react or not does not depend on it being an insult, no matter how much you straw man.

Were the protestors deliberately attempting to insult and/or provoke the police? If they were, do you think that such actions were justified?
I'd also like to point out that I have apologized for demeaning pigs and promised not to do it again.
Yes, and we all applauded, sent a memo to your boss asking for a commendation. Very clever. And by clever I mean derivative, petty, and childish.

Funny how you ignored the part of my post asking if "idiot" is okay. I'm betting that you simply won't 'ave a word said against your Occupy, no matter what it is. You have displayed a marked reluctance to assign any responsibility for anything negative to OWS, period.
 
Last edited:
Specifically, describing the Taliban in terms that made them the innocent victims. She also thinks her comments about the Taliban have been moderate.

Then again, Jane has described the term "losing his noggin" as a crude expletive, as part of her usual tactics of ignoring what people are saying in general to focus on one specific point she can use to ad hominem. In this case, complaining about the term "Occutard" while she refuses to answer questions about what the donut-toting protestors were actually doing, or actual criticism of OWS, such as the sweeping changes the May Day protests did not effect.

I'm probably out of the loop, but what sweeping changes were intended? I got the impression the plan was "protest now, worry about minor details like what we're protesting later,"
 
I'm probably out of the loop, but what sweeping changes were intended? I got the impression the plan was "protest now, worry about minor details like what we're protesting later,"
Kind of my point. They're more concerned with Saying Something than saying anything.

Here are the people you're defending, Jane. Note that this is Union Square, not Montreal. From March.



“One! This is a donut.

Two! It is delicious.

Three! You know you want to ****-ing eat it!”

I have seen children with more maturity than this lot. This is turning even people who support OWS against them. Not even "No True Occupier", straight-up "shut up guys you're making us look bad".

http://gothamist.com/2012/03/23/video_occupy_wall_street_protesters_1.php
http://gothamist.com/2012/03/23/video_occupy_wall_street_protesters_1.php#comment-474516643
I'm sorry but just because the police stand all stoic, doesn't excuse their conduct.
Note how Jarek says its wrong to judge OWS by the actions of a few protestors, yet has no problem judging all the police by those who he feels oppress OWS.

This is police state ****, and the protesters are permitted, justified, under our First Amendment, to express their frustration.

openly mocking the NYPD with a complete lack of respect is not going to help anything.

Oh, like it makes a flying **** of a difference what the protesters do. ...
So one second OWS' 1st Amendment rights are being violated, the next what they do doesn't matter so the cops shouldn't be offended.

http://gothamist.com/2012/03/23/video_occupy_wall_street_protesters_1.php#comment-474475522
Last night the "bait" was a bagel and the guy said it was for the "Jewish cops" hahhahahahahahahahahahhahaha GET IT!!? Yeah, there's nothing wrong with protesting for your right to protest, and street theater has its place, but if you could stop this police/donut joke and work to get the NYPD on our side, please, that would be excellent. Respect earns respect; compassion, compassion, etc.
Oh, look, anti-semitism.




http://www.ethecofem.com/an-occupiers-thoughts-on-leadership-and-authority/
Using this definition, is Occupy really a leaderless movement? In a sense, yes: we have no central command center, no ruling elite, no authority figure from which to take direction. But is this really “leaderless”?
Given that a leader is, by definition, an authority figure from which people take direction, I'd say yes.

I see leaders all the time within my local Occupy movement. I see brave individuals bottom-lining tasks, taking initiative to make widespread change, and helping others learn how to best fight the establishment system. ... Leaders are all over the place in Occupy; rather than saying we’re leaderless, I think we’re best described as a movement full of leaders. What the Occupy movement lacks isn’t leaders, but authority figures.
I always love it when people try to rewrite the dictionary. The funny thing is the definition of "authority" they quote has this as the third definition.

a: power to influence or command thought, opinion, or behaviorb:
a: persons in command;

And, of course, they don't quote the Webster definition of "leader".

: something that leads
2. a person who leads
b (2) : a person who has commanding authority or influence
 
Last edited:
Is it really so hard to answer a simple question?
Apparently so, since you can't seem to answer "Do you ask for the same justification whenever someone uses the word "idiot"?"

I'm not talking about what is in people's minds. I'm talking about has come out of their mouths, things they have expressed in public.
So you are totally against laws that try to make some sort of distinction for "hate crimes"?
 
Jane has described the term "losing his noggin" as a crude expletive as part of her usual tactics of ignoring what people are saying in general to focus on one specific point she can use to ad hominem. In this case, complaining about the term "Occutard" while she refuses to answer questions about what the donut-toting protestors were actually doing, or actual criticism of OWS, such as the sweeping changes the May Day protests did not effect.

Yep, those are the usual tactics, assuming that someone reading this thread is going to see the word occutard and go out and discriminate against the developmentally disabled, after all, three teenagers in the UK did.

By the same token the black bloc is racist after all what are we supposed to think ? A group dressing up in black, calling themselves black, we may just come to the conclusion that black people are all violent clowns.

We see protesters taunting cops, we see videos of protesters getting pepper sprayed and we naturally come to the conclusion that the protesters were asking for it. We become "authoritarian"

We all pay the price for these political extremists actions. Because protesters like to go on destructive rampages, the residents of Chicago are getting permanent surveillance cameras and beach.park closures. Because some moron with a bomb in his shoe tried to blow up a plane, we get to take off our shoes before boarding and because someone doing direct action got on a plane with a bomb in his underwear, we have to go through those porno scanners.

Political extremists,hiding behind their bandannas and masks are no friends to the general population. Not only do they hold us in contempt because we're not them with their oh so superior moral enlightenment that they can twist and manipulate to allow themselves the very same attitudes towards segments of society that they are critical of us for holding. Eg. comparing cops to animals because they "have more power" and hating conservatives for bring conservatives.

We can look at the Kelly Thomas video and see a clear cut case of murder however after the Trayvon Martin incident we're wondering whether there might be a race angle to the assault. Not racist, of course, because as the radical left keeps telling us, Latinos are POC and POC can't be racist because they're not the dominant group in society. The second cop charged in that murder ? Turns out he only had one eye, he was disabled.
 
We see protesters taunting cops, we see videos of protesters getting pepper sprayed and we naturally come to the conclusion that the protesters were asking for it. We become "authoritarian"

And in some cases, the protestors literally are asking for it. The donut incidents in NY and Montreal are examples of protestors deliberately trying to provoke cops into a response. Not to mention the UC Davis pepper spray incident, where the "peaceful protestors" went out of their way to obstruct and threaten officers who were actively trying to leave them alone. And there are many others.


Political extremists,hiding behind their bandannas and masks are no friends to the general population. Not only do they hold us in contempt because we're not them with their oh so superior moral enlightenment that they can twist and manipulate to allow themselves the very same attitudes towards segments of society that they are critical of us for holding. Eg. comparing cops to animals because they "have more power" and hating conservatives for bring conservatives.
And then when you point this out to the very people in the movement, they blame the people responding to the protestors acts instead of the protestors themselves. As if they are unable to even acknowledge the idea of taking the credit for the bad.
 
Well it looks like occupy Ottawa, ooops sorry they've changed their name to Occupied Ottawa is having another kick at the can. Nothing at all about the 99%, they've dropped that pretense and have adopted a never before tactic of honesty by declaring that it's all about them.

Source
 
And in some cases, the protestors literally are asking for it. The donut incidents in NY and Montreal are examples of protestors deliberately trying to provoke cops into a response. Not to mention the UC Davis pepper spray incident, where the "peaceful protestors" went out of their way to obstruct and threaten officers who were actively trying to leave them alone. And there are many others.



And then when you point this out to the very people in the movement, they blame the people responding to the protesters acts instead of the protesters themselves. As if they are unable to even acknowledge the idea of taking the credit for the bad.

Yes a protester can do no wrong. Taunt the cops and when the cops respond like how any normal person would respond to being taunted, the cops are condemned because they "misused" their power.

You figure the occupiers would work with the cops seeing how the cops are part of the 99% but hey, when dealing with political woo, anything goes. Health inspectors, firefighters all proxy agents of the 1% yea, that's it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom