Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ad hominem. Guilt by association. Argument by assertion. Trying to set a record?

Let's see. People who blow up abortion clinics and kill doctors goes to the central problem of the GOP. These guys are all clearly nuts. A movement, like the GOP without a clear message is going to attract people like this. Anyway, these things are bound to happen. Hopefully law enforcement will be able to catch the GOP nut jobs before they kill another doctor.
And the pro-abortionists can continue to believe abortion is not murder.

We can only hope.
We can hope SCOTUS eventually revisits the question.
 
I don't think that you've proved that CU is a response to the situation you described.

From the Wikipedia article:

Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. ___ (2010), is a landmark decision by the United States Supreme Court, which held that the First Amendment prohibited the government from restricting independent political expenditures by corporations and unions. The nonprofit corporation Citizens United wanted to air a film critical of Hillary Clinton and to advertise the film during television broadcasts in apparent violation of the 2002 Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act (commonly known as the McCain–Feingold Act or "BCRA"). In a 5–4 decision, the Court held that portions of BCRA §203 violated the First Amendment.
 
And the pro-abortionists can continue to believe abortion is not murder.
And pro-evolutionists can continue to believe that creationism isn't true.

We can hope SCOTUS eventually revisits the question.
And revisit evolution also. If we are going to toss out science let's go for broke.
 
Are you still "on the fence" wrt free speech, or do you think speech should be restricted?

Citizens United v. FEC:

The Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 (known as BCRA or McCain–Feingold Act)—specifically §203, which modified the Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971, 2 U.S.C. § 441b—prohibited corporations and unions from using their general treasury to fund "electioneering communications" (broadcast advertisements mentioning a candidate) within 30 days before a primary or 60 days before a general election.

So, BCRA didn't restrict what you could say, just when you could say it. This is similar to the laws preventing you from pamphleteering or putting up signage that endorses a specific candidate or proposition, near a voting booth. This is also similar to the laws that prevent you, for example, from passing out pamphlets or tabling in from of a supermarket or department store without getting permission first (as it's private property).

So, where do you stand on these issues, WildCat? Do you think that I should be allowed to put up signs and pass out pamphlets wherever I like? Or do you think that my "free speech" should be restricted?
 
Last edited:
I just checked the St. Louis paper. No mention whatsoever of the city being shut down. Perhaps the Occutards meant that only 1% of the cities are supposed to go on strike?

http://www.stltoday.com/business/en...cle_8d5d8d68-93b7-11e1-9559-0019bb30f31a.html

Looks like the 'Tards shut down the city afterall. Or at least the sidewalk in front of the Peabody Opera House.

In a statement, Peabody said that in 2011 it paid $1.4 billion in taxes, fees and royalties, including more than $200 million in federal, state and local taxes.

Boyce's comments about Peabody's corporate citizenship made no impression on protesters, who decried what they said was Peabody's failure to pay its fair share of taxes. Many in the noisy crowd outside the opera house waved signs as they chanted "We pay taxes, so should you" and "This is what democracy looks like."

Here's a question I would ask the 'Tards - How do you know $1.4 billion isn't Peabody's fair share? What is their "fair share"? Note: "More than they pay now" is not an answer.
 
WTF??? What on earth did Sotheby's have to do with the banking crisis of 2008? Oh, I know...the 1% must buy things there! And then they must mail those things to the other 1%-ers.

Let's see....100 'Tards chanting and 150 'Tards marching....figuring that only about 10 of them actually have jobs....yep, their plan to shut down the economy is off to a terrific start!!!

The Sotheby's thing has do do with organized labour working without a contract and management hiring inexperienced scabs to ship the objects d'art.

100 ? 150 ? maybe, just maybe the real occupiers were attending the free university and studying politics.

More than two dozen university professors are also planning to hold their regularly scheduled classes in Madison Square as part of the Free University. Outspoken intellectuals will lead public courses: former political prisoner Laura Whitehorn will talk about mass incarceration in the United States; prominent political scientist Frances Fox-Piven will teach; Chris Hedges will discuss the topic of his book, The Death of the Liberal Class; and geographer David Harvey will speak about Reclaiming the City for Anti-Capitalist Struggle.

Locally we have a 2am dance party in support of the revolution. Outside on the lawns of the big government building. There appears to be some confusion as the event was last night ( early this morning, so it's a done deal ) but on the facebook page, people are still confirming their attendance for tonight ( early tomorrow morning ).
 
Yay. Lectures by former terrorists and communists.

What a stupid event.
 
:confused:

I don't understand this post at all.

Citizens United didn't interfere with anyone else's rights, but that's what OWS does when they take over a public park for their sole benefit. That's why OWS protestors got arrested, not because of what they said. However, the government came down on Citizens United solely because of their political speech.

Do you think the government should be regulating political speech?
 
Citizens United v. FEC:



So, BCRA didn't restrict what you could say, just when you could say it.
Sure, you can have all the political speech you'd like... just not for 2 months prior to an election!

Holy crap, you don't see anything wrong with that?

This is similar to the laws preventing you from pamphleteering or putting up signage that endorses a specific candidate or proposition, near a voting booth.
No, it's not at all like that. Place restrictions are perfectly reasonable, time restrictions (regardless of place) are another beast altogether.

Think of it this way, would you support a law that prevents public political demonstrations for 2 months prior to an election?

[This is also similar to the laws that prevent you, for example, from passing out pamphlets or tabling in from of a supermarket or department store without getting permission first (as it's private property).
No, that has to do with private property owners being allowed to control what happens on their own property. They don't need any law for that.

[So, where do you stand on these issues, WildCat? Do you think that I should be allowed to put up signs and pass out pamphlets wherever I like? Or do you think that my "free speech" should be restricted?
You can excercise your freedom of speech whenever you like. And you can do it just about wherever you like so long as it doesn't interfere with other people's rights.

You really don't see the difference between that and forbidding political speech for 2 months prior to an election?
 
They may be Real Occupiers but they're not Real-real Occupiers.
Brandon Baxter, one of the alleged plotters known to his associates as “Skabby,” served as a spokesman for Occupy Cleveland, telling the Cleveland Plain Dealer in early March that he felt “the powers that be, whoever they might be—on all levels of government and those who hold corporate power—are not listening, because not enough people are actually taking a stance.”

Posts on Occupy Cleveland’s Facebook page indicate that Baxter was involved in helping the organization organize and advertise events as recently as February 2012. Baxter and two of the other alleged co-conspirators — Joshua Stafford and Anthony Hayne — list Occupy Cleveland as their “Employer” on Facebook, where the three list one another as friends.

http://ohio.mediatrackers.org/2012/05/01/fbi-busts-occupy-cleveland-members-in-alleged-bomb-plot/
 
Now children.

Billy: They are poopyheads.
Timmy: They are dumb.

:rolleyes:

Another proud day at the JREF.
 
What do you have to say about the Occutards being stung by the FBI trying to score explosives to blow up a bridge?
 
What do you have to say about the Occutards being stung by the FBI trying to score explosives to blow up a bridge?
Same thing I say about the Republicans who kill doctors and blow up abortion clinics, I hope they go to prison. And guilt by association is still a fallacy.
 
Last edited:
OK It's quittin' time.

Sure, I was at the office all day but that slave diving capitalist pigdog of a boss didn't get nothin' produced in his slave drivin' art factory today. Ha ! I spent the day lying on the sofa watching Jerry Springer, take that sucker ! Stick it to the Man...booyah !!

Oh wait...I'm self employed.

Anyway...

Got my Eddie Bauer black cargo's on, my Calvin Klein socks, my Birkenstocks and my bright red shirt. Got my iPhone, my netbook, my Canon camera, my Dissani water, my Land's end rucksack stuffer with Nature Valley granola bars and Monster energy drink. A few pints of Guinness and a bottle of Jack Daniels thrown in just for good measure. Got my Gucci bandanna and some Heinz vinegar just in case of tear gas attack and one of those Guy Fawkes anonymous masks with a rainbow wig that I picked up on sale at Target, $1.99+the fascist sales tax, each. Swatch synchronized to official occupy time, big sign that simply says "protest" on it because I'm not sure what the march is all about. Take that facebook ! I'm not registering my personal data for you to sell simply so I can stay in the occuloop. I'm a radical !

Gonna jump in the Chevrolet Astro and burn some Esso gas heading downtown to go join the People's Solidarity March.

My shirt says I <3 Monsanto on it but it's the only red shirt I've got. Since I'm not supposed to shop today, occupiers will understand....right ?
 

That's deciding the earlier law was unconstitutional. In fact, isn't OWS often complaining about how their First Amendment rights are being violated? Yet when corporations and other organizations have their First Amendment rights upheld and supported by the government, it's not really about free speech? You're right, it is a double standard. Just not the one you think.

So is there a separate Mayday thread or is this it? Seattle's having a bit of fun today.
I've already seen people trying to downplay and disassociate.

Weird how someone can join a movement named after a military term, which often uses hostile, confrontational language, frames itself as adversarial to the 1%, and then be surprised when people in the movement try to use violence to achieve their goals. I also find it odd how so many OWSers claim they're not about violence only after someone in OWS is violent in the name of OWS.

Same thing I say about the Republicans who kill doctors and blow up abortion clinics, I hope they go to prison. And guilt by association is still a fallacy.
Tu quoque. Got it.
 
Last edited:
My shirt says I <3 Monsanto on it but it's the only red shirt I've got. Since I'm not supposed to shop today, occupiers will understand....right ?
Big waste of time. Besides, protesting is unpatriotic and the people who are spending millions to finance politicians are not self serving. So, nothing to worry about. A good citizen is an obedient citizen. A follower. One who never questions. See, it's like this, the founding fathers knew that govt could never act contrary to the interests of citizens. They knew that the people who run corporations are not be corruptible. They also knew that it is not possible to use money to purchase influence.

So take my advice, the Monsanto shirt is nice but instead get one that says simply "sheeple" go home and watch TV. Confident in the belief that there is nothing at all wrong with the relationship between business and politicians.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom