Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're on the fence about whether the government should restrict political speech?
Have you stopped beating your wife?...
Nope.

Premise 1: You (Axiom_Blade) do, cannot form, or do not have an opinion on...
Premise 2: ...the matter of whether or not the government should restrict free speech.

Those are all the options possible, all of which are valid answers to the question. It's not a loaded question. You're evading.

Imagining that the camping ordinance is an infringement on your rights is like imagining that a 10 pm noise ordinance(time and Manner restriction, see Cox. V. New Hampshire) disallowing a rock concert at 3am across the street from an orphanage is an infringement on free speech.

Give up the delusions of persecution, nobody is restricting your rights of speech and peaceful assembly. You just need to follow the same reasonable time and manner restrictions we all must follow out of respect for the community in which we live.
Occupy represents the 99%, except for the times when they don't want to, such as when they don't want to obey rules about silly little things.
 
Last edited:
Imagining that the camping ordinance is an infringement on your rights is like imagining that a 10 pm noise ordinance(time and Manner restriction, see Cox. V. New Hampshire) disallowing a rock concert at 3am across the street from an orphanage is an infringement on free speech.

Give up the delusions of persecution, nobody is restricting your rights of speech and peaceful assembly. You just need to follow the same reasonable time and manner restrictions we all must follow out of respect for the community in which we live.
Then again, America has a proud history of civil disobedience. We recognize that sometimes laws need be violated for the good of society. See Civil Disobedience (Thoreau) and Ghandi's Non Violence.

When govt tends to the needs of the rich more than the needs of the disadvantaged then civil disobedience is called for.
 
When govt tends to the needs of the rich more than the needs of the disadvantaged then civil disobedience is called for.
In fighting for civil rights Mario Savio called for protestors to "throw their bodies on the gears". It stands as iconic for how those who are otherwise powerless can become more than things to exploit but the means to achieve social change. The rich have PR firms, marketing campaigns, advertising and of course they can financially benefit politicians. The poor have the ability to rise up and refresh the tree of liberty from time to time. Now we know it can be done without blood.

 
Last edited:
Nope.

Premise 1: You (Axiom_Blade) do, cannot form, or do not have an opinion on...
Premise 2: ...the matter of whether or not the government should restrict free speech.
It's begging the question. Whether or not this is about "free speech" hasn't been established. Of course, if the government is restricting free speech I am against it, but I don't think that has been sufficiently demonstrated yet. As I said, though, I don't think that I'm educated enough on this topic to go 100% either for or against it.

However:
An organization breaks the law, but the courts decide it's okay, because it's "free political speech", and they change the law (Citizens United).
But when OWS breaks the law, the courts throw them in jail, and the law does not get changed. This looks like a double standard to me.
 
Last edited:
Is free speech absolute?

  • Are laws against libel restrictions on free speech? Yes.
  • It is possible to be for free speech and be for some regulations.
 
It's begging the question. Whether or not this is about "free speech" hasn't been established.
The premise also implicitly assumes any acceptance of any limitation equals being against free speech.

  • It's black and white thinking (excludes the middle).
  • It is begging the question.
  • It's obnoxious.
 
Then again, America has a proud history of civil disobedience. We recognize that sometimes laws need be violated for the good of society. See Civil Disobedience (Thoreau) and Ghandi's Non Violence.

When govt tends to the needs of the rich more than the needs of the disadvantaged then civil disobedience is called for.
Ziggurat had an excellent quote addressing this:
To quote from Martin Luther King Jr.'s "Letter from a Birmingham Jail",
In no sense do I advocate evading or defying the law, as would the rabid segregationist. That would lead to anarchy. One who breaks an unjust law must do so openly, lovingly, and with a willingness to accept the penalty. I submit that an individual who breaks a law that conscience tells him is unjust, and who willingly accepts the penalty of imprisonment in order to arouse the conscience of the community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the highest respect for law.

Note that this is pretty diametrically opposed to the attitude of the OWS protesters: they demand to break the law with impunity. They want to claim the mantle of heirs of the civil rights movement, but they are not in fact continuing the tradition at all.

Civil disobedience is about breaking Law A because the law breaks his or her conscience, not about breaking reasonable Law B, because you protest Law A.
If the OWS has an issue with park ordinance laws, they have avenues to get them changed. Part of the reason these laws are in place is to save the tax payers money but hey, it's our parks and we can do whatever we want to with them and keep them open all night if that's the way the community wants to devote its resources but the 99% have a say and a stake in this issue, not just the OWS movement and they shouldn't pretend this infringes on their rights. It does not.
 
not about breaking reasonable Law B, because you protest Law A.
Actually it is. The patriots who participated in the Boston Tea Party were not protesting laws against theft and trespassing. Ghandi's non violence was to violate laws not directly relating to the protest. The civil rights movement often did exactly as OWS is doing now.

I have much respect for MLK and his opinions. Doesn't change anything.
 
Have you stopped beating your wife?
Let's recap, you seem to be confused:
Do you think that anyone should have the right to spend as much money as they want (buying advertisements, printing fliers, etc) to convey their opinions on political subjects?

I'm not sure. I'm still on the fence on this one. I don't think that I have enough information to make an informed opinion.
Isn't it conceivable that an organization could "buy" a politician, by dumping a ton of money into an ad campaign?


Are you still "on the fence" wrt free speech, or do you think speech should be restricted?

How... unsurprising. Fidel Castro agrees.
 
  • Are laws against libel restrictions on free speech? Yes.
  • It is possible to be for free speech and be for some regulations.
  • libel by definition has discrete victims who can prove they were harmed
  • no such victims can be identified in this case
  • the analogy is fatally flawed
  • a section of McCain-Feingold limited free speech by limiting political speech
  • The 1st Amendment prohibits Congress from abridging freedom of speech
  • the 1st Amendment was victorious in the Citizens United case
  • the USA survived for over 220 years without unconstitutional McCain-Feingold political speech limitations
  • the USA can survive another 220 years without regulating freedom of speech
 
It's begging the question. Whether or not this is about "free speech" hasn't been established. Of course, if the government is restricting free speech I am against it, but I don't think that has been sufficiently demonstrated yet. As I said, though, I don't think that I'm educated enough on this topic to go 100% either for or against it.
There, was that so hard? "I do not think I have enough information to form an opinion." It is not begging the question, which is essentially the same as a loaded question (a question with a false or unproven premise), and I've already show that it isn't. At the very outside, the question may be off topic.

However:
An organization breaks the law, but the courts decide it's okay, because it's "free political speech", and they change the law (Citizens United).But when OWS breaks the law, the courts throw them in jail, and the law does not get changed. This looks like a double standard to me.

I don't think that you've proved that CU is a response to the situation you described.

There's also the question of which laws, precisely, get broken. There's a difference between me jaywalking and a senator receiving heretofore illegal campaign contributions, much like there's a difference between a corporation making heretofore illegal contributions and protestors illegally occupying public land and disturbing the peace.
 
Last edited:
But they need to be presenting a coherent message, for that to work.
Corporations don't have our best interest at heart. Power corrupts. Govt can be influenced with money to focus more on corporations than average citizens. I understood this pretty much from the beginning. Like the activists of the 60s and 70s OWS wants people to understand that there are serious problems with many corporations and that govt is failing their job to properly regulate and enforce laws.
 
Corporations don't have our best interest at heart. Power corrupts. Govt can be influenced with money to focus more on corporations than average citizens. I understood this pretty much from the beginning. Like the activists of the 60s and 70s OWS wants people to understand that there are serious problems with many corporations and that govt is failing their job to properly regulate and enforce laws.
So you say and believe, as do perhaps some OWS protestors (neither, you, I nor god knows the answer to that). Remember that corporations have employees, and the more onerous regulations become, the fewer employees will they be able to afford. It makes no more sense than sanctions against Saddam made, or sanctions against Iran or N.K. are making; starve some citizenry, nothing changes in leadership behavior.

I say government doesn't have our best interests at heart, and the Obama admin just continues to pile on.

Copied from elsewhere here (courtesy of mhaze):

http://pjmedia.com/tatler/2012/04/27...al-armendariz/

Notice two of those names: Tom “Smitty” Smith and Jim Schermbeck. Both are well-known around Texas as left-wing, anti-business agitators. Schermbeck is the left-wing filmmaker who figured prominently in former Travis County DA Ronnie Earle’s indictment of Tom DeLay a few years ago. Schermbeck often operates as Erin Brockovich’s sidekick, running around Texas creating environmental scares and then taking those to court. He once opposed a road project in Ellis County, TX, claiming that some slag used to build the road would cause major health problems for residents living near it. After exhaustive and expensive scientific studies, it turned out that there was a problem with the slag: Prolonged exposure to it could cause body odor. So Schermbeck moved on to another project, and eventually got some industrial cement kilns shut down in Midlothian, TX, driving the price of cement up by restricting supply. He also killed a few Texas jobs along the way.

The bolded phrase seems to be the sum total of experience needed to have been given a job in Obama's executive agencies.

http://townhall.com/columnists/john...otes_from_members_of_the_obama_administration

Take a look at these quotes from members of Barack Obama's administration and then ask yourself what sort of man WANTS people like this to help him govern the American people?

1) "Somewhat more broadly, I will suggest that animals should be permitted to bring suit, with human beings as their representatives, to prevent violations of current law." -- Cass Sunstein, Administrator of the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs in the Obama Administration. Yes, we have someone in charge of regulations in D.C. who thinks pigs should be able to sue farmers and cats should be able to sue their owners. Do you think it's a coincidence that the cost of business keeps skyrocketing under Obama because of all the new regulations?

2) "Now, people when I say that look at me and say, ‘What are you talking about, Joe? You’re telling me we have to go spend money to keep from going bankrupt?’ The answer is yes, that’s what I’m telling you." -- Joe Biden, Vice President. When this is how the Vice President of the United States thinks, is it any wonder that this country may only be a decade away from defaulting on our debts and heading into an economic death spiral that we'll never recover from in the lifespan of anyone reading this column?

3) "There’s a different leader in Syria now. Many of the members of Congress of both parties who have gone to Syria in recent months have said they believe he’s a reformer." -- Hillary Clinton, Secretary of State. Yes, the butcher of Syria is a real "reformer," isn't he? If you want to know why our foreign policy has been all bowing, "leading from behind," and chaos, look no further than our Secretary of State who knew nothing about foreign policy going in, but made a career out of being married to the right man.

4) "Though this nation has proudly thought of itself as an ethnic melting pot, in things racial we have always been and continue to be, in too many ways, essentially a nation of cowards." -- Eric Holder, Attorney General. Eric Holder is a throwback to the bad old days in America, when whether you got justice or not depended on the color of your skin. Is it any wonder he doesn't care about Mexicans or a white border patrol agent who lost his life because of Operation Fast and Furious? Is it a surprise that Holder turned a blind eye to the New Black Panthers engaging in voter intimidation and putting a bounty on George Zimmerman's head?

5) "When I became the NASA administrator — or before I became the NASA administrator — (Obama) charged me with three things. One was he wanted me to help re-inspire children to want to get into science and math, he wanted me to expand our international relationships, and third, and perhaps foremost, he wanted me to find a way to reach out to the Muslim world and engage much more with dominantly Muslim nations to help them feel good about their historic contribution to science … and math and engineering." -- Charles Bolden, NASA Administrator. When Neil Armstrong landed on the moon, he said, "That's one small step for a man; one giant leap for mankind." Well, while Obama goes on and on about "investment," "science," and "the future," we've actually taken one giant leap backwards since we no longer have a manned space program. Guess we needed to save that money to funnel into the businesses of people who contribute to Obama's campaign.

6) "One way to carry out this disapproval might be to insist that all illegitimate babies be put up for adoption—especially those born to minors, who generally are not capable of caring properly for a child alone. If a single mother really wished to keep her baby, she might be obliged to go through adoption proceedings and demonstrate her ability to support and care for it. Adoption proceedings probably should remain more difficult for single people than for married couples, in recognition of the relative difficulty of raising children alone. It would even be possible to require pregnant single women to marry or have abortions, perhaps as an alternative to placement for adoption, depending on the society." -- John Holdren, Assistant to the President for Science and Technology. So, we have a man with the morals of Joseph Mengele advising the President on science. It also shouldn't be lost on anyone that while Obama is yammering on about a "war on women," he has someone on his staff who has come out in favor of FORCED ABORTIONS.

7) "Somehow we have to figure out how to boost the price of gasoline to the levels in Europe." -- Steven Chu, Energy Secretary. Ever wonder why gas prices are so high under Obama? Could it be because Obama's Energy Secretary wants to dramatically increase the price of gas? Gas is more than $8 a gallon in most of Western Europe. Guess that gives them something to shoot for if Obama gets a second term.
 
Remember that corporations have employees, and the more onerous regulations become, the fewer employees will they be able to afford.
I believe America has more regulations than most nations. I just think we have very bad regulations. In any event, your argument is fallacious. Lack of proper regulation and oversight has hurt a hell of a lot of people. It's possible to regulate with minimum impact. You are in effect saying that current regulations are the best we can do and we ought not even try to improve the system. Even though there are clear and obvious regulations like the Volker rule that would go a long way to improving the system.

It makes no more sense than sanctions against Saddam made, or sanctions against Iran or N.K. are making; starve some citizenry, nothing changes in leadership behavior.
I'm sorry but this is a silly argument. That it can be difficult to regulate doesn't mean that we can't or shouldn't. American corporations are not sovereign nations.

I say government doesn't have our best interests at heart, and the Obama admin just continues to pile on.
You have missed my point. I'm not trying to demonize corporations. The purpose of govt is very different from the purpose of corporations. Both can be beneficial to society. Govt can manage resources and implement and enforce laws to protect citizens. You can argue that traffic laws and laws against theft are not in the interest of citizens but I think you know better. Likewise, I would not argue that commerce is not in the interest of citizens but I know better. The point is to understand how govt and business can best work for society.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom