Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Weird how someone can join a movement named after a military term, which often uses hostile, confrontational language, frames itself as adversarial to the 1%, and then be surprised when people in the movement try to use violence to achieve their goals. I also find it odd how so many OWSers claim they're not about violence only after someone in OWS is violent in the name of OWS.

What have you got against violence being used to achieve goals?
 
.... Tu quoque. Got it.
No... you didn't. RF said, "guilt by association is still a fallacy." That was the point. There's not tu quoque in that point.

You continue to apply guilt to all of OWS for a small handfuls of idiots that want the OWS to be something it is not.
 
Last edited:
No... you didn't. RF said, "guilt by association is still a fallacy." That was the point. There's not tu quoque in that point.
Tu Quoque is an attempt to justify one action with another.

Blowing up bridges is wrong. Killing abortion doctors and blowing up clinics is wrong. You are right, my point wasn't to excuse those who tried to blow up a bridge. On the contrary, I said I want them to go to prison. My point was as you said that guilt by association is a fallacy.
 
What do you have to say about the Occutards being stung by the FBI trying to score explosives to blow up a bridge?

I am shocked that a bunch of Leftist nitwits who couldn't accomplish their goals by political means would resort to violence. Who do they think they are, close personal friends of Barack Obama?
 
I am shocked that a bunch of Leftist nitwits who couldn't accomplish their goals by political means would resort to violence. Who do they think they are, close personal friends of Barack Obama?
What does that mean?
 
Meh..

There was only 50-60 people there and they didn't do anything, even when I pointed out those handy piles of bricks, the ones with occupy stenciled on them, conveniently piled outside select financial corporations.

I think it was the shirt. Even when I said "I see a YouTube moment" wielded the camera and gestured toward the piles muttering about Seattle showing us up. zip..nada. I must have looked to agent provocateury.

Next time I'm dressing up like David Carradine in kung-fu.
 
That article doesn't mention Rebublicans neither do key members of the party try to score C4 to engage in terrorism, like those prominent Occutards did.
 
Last edited:
Why do the tards call Laura Whitehall a "political prisoner" when she was sent to jail for blowing things up with her idiot friends?
 
That article doesn't mention Rebublicans neither do key members of the party try to score C4 to engage in terrorism, like those prominent Occutards did.
It's not Democrats pushing to restrict or end abortion. It wasn't a Democrat who regularly said "Tiller the Baby Killer" on TV.

Virus, I don't really try to marginalize an entire group of people based on the actions of a few. Most in the GOP abhor the violence of the few. I leave the dishonesty and fallacy to others. I just reserve the right to point it out.
 
Just as long as you're comfortable with the anti-capitalist extremists you want to ally with RandFan. Not really my bag though.
 
Just as long as you're comfortable with the anti-capitalist extremists you want to ally with RandFan. Not really my bag though.
I understand. I really do. And I don't fault you for criticizing OWS in general. Their anti-capitalist stance is worth criticizing.
 
Citizens United didn't interfere with anyone else's rights, but that's what OWS does when they take over a public park for their sole benefit.
What rights are OWS interfering with?
Are you saying that it's okay to put restrictions on free speech, if it interferes with someone else's rights?

That's why OWS protestors got arrested, not because of what they said.
Citizens United wasn't about "what they said", either.

However, the government came down on Citizens United solely because of their political speech.
No. Citizens United was not about the content of their speech.

Do you think the government should be regulating political speech?
No, I do not. I think that OWS should be allowed to stay in the park.
 
What rights are OWS interfering with?
The rights of other peiople to use the park, their bank, their street.

Are you saying that it's okay to put restrictions on free speech,
No, no restrictions at all on the speech.

if it interferes with someone else's rights?
It's the physical actions that interfere with other peoples' rights, such as camping in a park or blocking a street or ingress.egress to a place of business.

Citizens United wasn't about "what they said", either.
Absolutely false, it was 100% of what they said. They made a forbiddeen film, forbidden because it advocated a political point of view within 2 months of an election.

No. Citizens United was not about the content of their speech.
It was solely about the content! Do you think if the film had been about gardening instead of Hillary Clinton it would have been banned?

No, I do not.
Glad to see you now agree with the Citizens United decision. :)

I think that OWS should be allowed to stay in the park.
Camping in a park isn't speech, it's a physical action that interferes with others right and ability to enjoy the park. OWS doesn't get to seize the parks for themselves.
 
The rights of other peiople to use the park, their bank, their street.
OWS did not prevent anybody from using those things.

It's the physical actions that interfere with other peoples' rights, such as camping in a park or blocking a street or ingress.egress to a place of business.
Somebody camping in a park does not interfere with my rights. You can come to my city and camp in the park all you want. I promise I will not feel oppressed in the slightest.

It was solely about the content! Do you think if the film had been about gardening instead of Hillary Clinton it would have been banned?
Do you think that if it had been made 3 months before it would've been banned? It's not the content. It's the time period.

Glad to see you now agree with the Citizens United decision. :)
I do, actually. You've convinced me.

Camping in a park isn't speech, it's a physical action that interferes with others right and ability to enjoy the park. OWS doesn't get to seize the parks for themselves.

I guess it's just too bad OWS doesn't have millions of dollars for an ad campaign, huh?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom