Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Strange how conservatives did not aim these criticisms towards the tea party.

You'll need something more substantial than tu quoque.

That has no bearing on whether they're valid criticisms of Occupy. Not to mention that the Tea Party, from my limited understanding, has different causes, goals, and methods from Occupy. Why, then, would the same criticisms necessarily be valid?

But, hey, enough of the sidetrack. If you want to discuss the Tea Party, start or use a different thread. If you want to compare OWS to the Tea Party, I suppose some people will be interested in your detailed comparison.
 
You'll need something more substantial than tu quoque.

That has no bearing on whether they're valid criticisms of Occupy. Not to mention that the Tea Party, from my limited understanding, has different causes, goals, and methods from Occupy. Why, then, would the same criticisms necessarily be valid?

But, hey, enough of the sidetrack. If you want to discuss the Tea Party, start or use a different thread. If you want to compare OWS to the Tea Party, I suppose some people will be interested in your detailed comparison.

Thaiboxerken's comment suggests he/she is interested in the comparing conservative criticisms of the OWS and conservative criticisms of the Tea Party (i.e. What motivates conservatives to focus their criticism on OWS?) rather that wishing the compare the two movements.
 
Last edited:
Assuming that's on-topic, then we should also compare liberal and centrist criticisms of the two movements.

Of course, it seems like a red herring to me, dragging the thread away from the current main subject of criticisms of OWS. Others, including people who do not support the movement, may disagree. I don't know enough about the Tea Party and criticisms thereof to participate in such a discussion, and would leave it to those better-informed than I.

However, what motivates people to make such criticisms (or not) is only relevant to the hypothetical discussion in terms of how it influences the criticisms themselves. Again, the motivations of liberal and centrist criticisms should also be examined, if you chose to discuss it.
 
Last edited:
So occutards think they're going to ”shut down New York” more than it ever has been before?

Talk about delusions of grandeur. Bad choice of words, wrong city to make that claim about.
 
The "99 Percent" populist movement, which began as a 24-hour encampment in lower Manhattan last fall and spread to cities across the country, will join organized labor for a day of May 1 protests, in what it has called a "day without the 99 percent."

...Inspired by the pro-democracy Arab Spring, the Wall Street protesters last year targeted U.S. financial policies they blamed for the yawning income gap between rich and poor - between what they called the 1 percent and the 99 percent.

But since last fall, when scores of demonstrators set up a vigil in lower Manhattan's Zuccotti Park and Occupy boasted it had $500,000 in the bank, donations have slowed to a point where Occupy was left in a cash crunch earlier this year.

There is also evidence of media fatigue, with mentions of the term "Occupy Wall Street" down 75 percent this month compared to late last year. So far in April, the term has appeared in 4,323 articles, according to the Factiva data base. Last October, the same search yielded 17,327 references.
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/sns-rt-us-usa-occupy-may1bre84001e-20120430,0,6791470.story

So the only people not demonstrating tomorrow will be the 1%.
:dl:
 
The only sign of OWS I saw today on this great day of action was someone hung a small banner over the Kennedy Expressway that said something about "civic capitalism".
 
http://money.cnn.com/2012/05/01/news/economy/occupy-may-day/index.htm?hpt=hp_t2

In New York, Occupy Wall Street has been planning protests at bridges and tunnels, with picket lines slated at the Chase Building, the New York Times building, Sotheby's and Manhattan's main U.S. Post Office.

WTF??? What on earth did Sotheby's have to do with the banking crisis of 2008? Oh, I know...the 1% must buy things there! And then they must mail those things to the other 1%-ers.

"San Francisco, once a stronghold of the dispossessed, has become a playground for the rich and a living hell for those of us who can't keep up or have no interest in capitalist relations," Bay Area protest organizers said in a statement.

It's all becoming very clear now isn't it? No interest in capitalist relations? Where did you get your iPhone?

The turnout was relatively slim, with about 100 protesters chanting, beating drums and making signs and T-shirts. In addition, Occupy Wall Street said that approximately 150 protesters were marching from Brooklyn to Manhattan via the Williamsburg Bridge.

Beating drums and making t-shirts. I bet the people at Goldman are cowering in fear.

Let's see....100 'Tards chanting and 150 'Tards marching....figuring that only about 10 of them actually have jobs....yep, their plan to shut down the economy is off to a terrific start!!!
 
Last edited:
Apparently there was a plot to blow up a bridge near Cleveland today, and some of the people involved with the plot had attended some Occupy events.

I think this really goes to the central problem of this movement, and why it has failed. These guys are all clearly nuts, but a movement with no clear message is going to attract people like this. It's going to be hard to disassociate from these people, since OWS has disavowed centralized leadership and since nobody in the movement even seems to know what the message and the means of conveying that message are anymore.

Anyway, this was bound to happen, and I am just glad that law enforcement was able to catch these guys before what would have been a massive loss of life. Seems like another nail in the coffin of OWS.
 
Apparently there was a plot to blow up a bridge near Cleveland today, and some of the people involved with the plot had attended some Occupy events.

I think this really goes to the central problem of this movement, and why it has failed. These guys are all clearly nuts, but a movement with no clear message is going to attract people like this. It's going to be hard to disassociate from these people, since OWS has disavowed centralized leadership and since nobody in the movement even seems to know what the message and the means of conveying that message are anymore.

Anyway, this was bound to happen, and I am just glad that law enforcement was able to catch these guys before what would have been a massive loss of life. Seems like another nail in the coffin of OWS.

Clearly, those guys aren't true Occupiers.
 
Apparently there was a plot to blow up a bridge near Cleveland today, and some of the people involved with the plot had attended some Occupy events.

I think this really goes to the central problem of this movement, and why it has failed. These guys are all clearly nuts, but a movement with no clear message is going to attract people like this. It's going to be hard to disassociate from these people, since OWS has disavowed centralized leadership and since nobody in the movement even seems to know what the message and the means of conveying that message are anymore.

Anyway, this was bound to happen, and I am just glad that law enforcement was able to catch these guys before what would have been a massive loss of life. Seems like another nail in the coffin of OWS.
Ad hominem. Guilt by association. Argument by assertion. Trying to set a record?

Let's see. People who blow up abortion clinics and kill doctors goes to the central problem of the GOP. These guys are all clearly nuts. A movement, like the GOP without a clear message is going to attract people like this. Anyway, these things are bound to happen. Hopefully law enforcement will be able to catch the GOP nut jobs before they kill another doctor.

We can only hope.
 
I just checked the St. Louis paper. No mention whatsoever of the city being shut down. Perhaps the Occutards meant that only 1% of the cities are supposed to go on strike?
 
99% of the workers didn't know this was supposed to happen because they stopped caring about OWS months ago.
 
Ad hominem. Guilt by association. Argument by assertion. Trying to set a record?

Let's see. People who blow up abortion clinics and kill doctors goes to the central problem of the GOP. These guys are all clearly nuts. A movement, like the GOP without a clear message is going to attract people like this. Anyway, these things are bound to happen. Hopefully law enforcement will be able to catch the GOP nut jobs before they kill another doctor.

We can only hope.

Just to clarify, when I said "these guys are all clearly nuts," I was referring to the guys who were planning to blow up the bridge, not Occupy Cleveland or OWS in general. Obviously, not everyone in the movement is nuts, nor are they guilty by association.

What I am arguing (by assertion, if you don't mind - I don't particularly feel like writing a formal research paper on this) is that this pretty obviously creates a problem of public perception for OWS. Correct me if you think I am wrong.
 
Just to clarify, when I said "these guys are all clearly nuts," I was referring to the guys who were planning to blow up the bridge, not Occupy Cleveland or OWS in general. Obviously, not everyone in the movement is nuts, nor are they guilty by association.

What I am arguing (by assertion, if you don't mind - I don't particularly feel like writing a formal research paper on this) is that this pretty obviously creates a problem of public perception for OWS. Correct me if you think I am wrong.
My apologies. I'll take the chip of my shoulder and withdraw my earlier post. Though, looking back at your post it still doesn't read that way to me, however, I'll accept that the fault is mine.

Again, sorry and thank you for the clarification and patience.

ETA: Yes, it is a problem.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom