Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Citizens United v. FEC:



So, BCRA didn't restrict what you could say, just when you could say it. This is similar to the laws preventing you from pamphleteering or putting up signage that endorses a specific candidate or proposition, near a voting booth. This is also similar to the laws that prevent you, for example, from passing out pamphlets or tabling in from of a supermarket or department store without getting permission first (as it's private property).

So, where do you stand on these issues, WildCat? Do you think that I should be allowed to put up signs and pass out pamphlets wherever I like? Or do you think that my "free speech" should be restricted?

So let me get this straight. The various community city ordinances around the country decided via democratic means, restricting park hours and camping, each dependent on their respective communities, is a horrible oppression which you and other OWSers suffer tremendously, is an unacceptable restriction on peacefully assembly and first amendment rights that time and place restrictions are draconian in your opinion but 60 days prior to an election is a reasonable time and place restriction on speech? Two weeks seems more reasonable to me.
 
OWS did not prevent anybody from using those things.
Yeah, except for taking over the thing with tents and such... :rolleyes:

Somebody camping in a park does not interfere with my rights. You can come to my city and camp in the park all you want. I promise I will not feel oppressed in the slightest.
And this illustrates the problem perfectly! You don't have the right to decide for others. Society as a whole decides, and people want parks to be parks and not squatter camps.

Do you think that if it had been made 3 months before it would've been banned? It's not the content. It's the time period.
Once again, it's a ban on political speech for 2 months prior to an election. Such a thing horrifies me, you think it's ok?

I do, actually. You've convinced me.
Hmmm, no sarcasm detected... ;)

I guess it's just too bad OWS doesn't have millions of dollars for an ad campaign, huh?
They had over $500,000 at one point, what happened to it?
 
So let me get this straight. The various community city ordinances around the country decided via democratic means, restricting park hours and camping, each dependent on their respective communities, is a horrible oppression which you and other OWSers suffer tremendously, is an unacceptable restriction on peacefully assembly and first amendment rights that time and place restrictions are draconian in your opinion but 60 days prior to an election is a reasonable time and place restriction on speech? Two weeks seems more reasonable to me.
Without taking issue with the substance of your argument, the logic, it seems to me, is problematic. So, if a law that did happen to infringe on free speech was decided via democratic means then it would be okay so long as it was dependent on respective communities? Also, isn't "horrible oppression" a bit of a straw man?
 
Without taking issue with the substance of your argument, the logic, it seems to me, is problematic. So, if a law that did happen to infringe on free speech was decided via democratic means then it would be okay so long as it was dependent on respective communities? Also, isn't "horrible oppression" a bit of a straw man?

time and manner restrictions are old news, Cox vs. New Hampshire and so on. No city should be able to restrict free speech and I agree with you there, no matter how democratic the restriction is but these various city ordinances such as the 10 p.m. noise ordinances that is so commonplace in so many city's, is most definitely constitutional as are the park hours and camping restrictions in public parks. You made a good argument earlier about civil disobedience in this regard, but certainly no argument that this is a restriction on free speech and assembly which some OWSers imagine this to be. Their free assembly and speech is not being infringed, they only imagine it to be. We, the other 99%, can make decisions on our park hours and whether people can camp in them or not. The minority can't dictate these regulations to us and claim "free speech".
 
time and manner restrictions are old news, Cox vs. New Hampshire and so on. No city should be able to restrict free speech and I agree with you there, no matter how democratic the restriction is but these various city ordinances such as the 10 p.m. noise ordinances that is so commonplace in so many city's, is most definitely constitutional as are the park hours and camping restrictions in public parks. You made a good argument earlier about civil disobedience in this regard, but certainly no argument that this is a restriction on free speech and assembly which some OWSers imagine this to be. Their free assembly and speech is not being infringed, they only imagine it to be. We, the other 99%, can make decisions on our park hours and whether people can camp in them or not. The minority can't dictate these regulations to us and claim "free speech".
Thanks. I was only questioning the logic of your previous argument. I've no problem with this post.
 


More Oakland insanity. Anybody who goes to that city on business or pleasure is a fool.
 
Occutard given an easy ride on NBC:



I guess the good thing about going easy on them is they don't get defensive and will blurt out their stupid radical anti-capitalist aims. Like this dildo.
 
No... you didn't. RF said, "guilt by association is still a fallacy." That was the point. There's not tu quoque in that point.
And directly before that, he said "Same thing I say about the Republicans who kill doctors and blow up abortion clinics, I hope they go to prison." He made the comparison again in #4988. Or did you not know most of the people opposed to OWS in this thread are conservative?

You continue to apply guilt to all of OWS for a small handfuls of idiots that want the OWS to be something it is not.
OWS members do something good, all of OWS takes credit, even when it's outside of what's generally regarded as their goals. OWS is dealt with by police, help, help, it's all of OWS who's being oppressed. OWS members do something bad, and it's the fault of only the people who did the bad things, who don't represent OWS and never really did.
 
http://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Protesters-gather-in-downtown-Seattle-3525107.php

Anthony J Petroff · Top Commenter · Rainier Beach High School said:
"Some of these people think it's fun and games out there. It isn't," Diaz said.

Certainly we should abhor violence; however, that should include an aversion to the economic violence that has quietly vandalized our standard of living behind closed doors--certainly not fun and games.
...
That is a remarkably strained segue.

And, of course, the usual "agent provocateurs!!1" logic, including the one guy who said that the anarchist's clothes looked too new, and they guy insisting that no one else understands anarchism except those who agree with him.
 
Last edited:
To be fair, they are getting something done, which is a nice change.

It's just that that something is property destruction, vandalism, and assaulting police.
 
Occutard given an easy ride on NBC:



I guess the good thing about going easy on them is they don't get defensive and will blurt out their stupid radical anti-capitalist aims. Like this dildo.

Sweet Jeebus, that newsbabe is as dumb as a post.
 
Guess who's back? Mama Dreadlocks:

Stacey Hessler, 39, left her four children at home in Florida to take an 18-hour bus ride to today's protest.

"This is the focal point," Hessler said in Bryant Park. "I want to be here to help make sure there are as many of us as possible so everyone else around the world can be inspired to stage protests."

She carried a sign saying "a woman's place is in the revolution."

Hessler was last seen being carted off to jail back in November, her tresses flying as she violently resisted arrest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom