Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm not sure. I'm still on the fence on this one. I don't think that I have enough information to make an informed opinion.
You're on the fence about whether the government should restrict political speech?

Isn't it conceivable that an organization could "buy" a politician, by dumping a ton of money into an ad campaign?
Is that how you pick your candidates, by who has the most ads? Or are you concerned about the unwashed masses, who clearly aren't as smart as you are, will vote for the candidate with the most ads?
 
That doesn't mean they claim to speak on behalf of every person. Are there downsides to the rhetoric? Sure. I'm happy to grant that some might take exception to it. Much of the Rhetoric of politically active people and groups engender resentment of like minds.

I don't find it a compelling reason to dismiss OWS. The criticism really strikes me as ad hoc. Perhaps the rhetoric of "we are the 99%" is impolitic. Perhaps not. I honestly don't know. That some might not like it is hardly a reason to dismiss it. Aren't you now speaking on behalf of some unknown group of people?


No; I'm making an observation - about a very specific mindset - not engaging in advocacy.

You can say you don't think the presumptive nature of the rhetoric is a good enough reason to dismiss the movement. However, there's many who think it is.
 
So OWS are like the people who protested the WTO and the G8 summits. Loud opponents of things they don't really understand.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure. I'm still on the fence on this one. I don't think that I have enough information to make an informed opinion.
Isn't it conceivable that an organization could "buy" a politician, by dumping a ton of money into an ad campaign?

Only if he's an honest politician. A dishonest one won't stay bought.
 
The "we are the 99%" and related rhetoric is pretty suggestive that they claim to represent everyone within that category. It makes many people feel that these folks are putting words in their mouths, and a lot of people resent that sort of thing.

Which makes it hilarious when supporters have to backpedal and admit their views are not nigh-universal.

Only when it is actually someone else's fault.
Take a look at the filibuster trend in the last 30 years.

Are bills the only way to get anything major done?

I notice that you cut out the part of my post asking you to specify which bills.
 
...

Are bills the only way to get anything major done?
As the Obama admin continues to demonstrate, no. EPA, DOJ, DOEnergy, DHS, etc don't need bills, just issued Regulations, or choose not to prosecute.

As we have begun to see and will soon see more of from ObamaCare too unless Supreme Court scuttles all or most of it.
 
No; I'm making an observation - about a very specific mindset - not engaging in advocacy.

You can say you don't think the presumptive nature of the rhetoric is a good enough reason to dismiss the movement. However, there's many who think it is.
Fair enough. I suspect that those who do so, do so ad hoc. But that's fine.
 
So OWS are like the people who protested the WTO and the G8 summits. Loud opponents of things they don't really understand.
One only need understand that there is corruption and little or no oversight. In any event, you are engaging in ad hominem poisoning the well.
 
Only if he's an honest politician. A dishonest one won't stay bought.
I don't think that follows but even if it did I don't think it matters. It's easy to keep the money rolling in. Cost of doing business.
 
As the Obama admin continues to demonstrate, no. EPA, DOJ, DOEnergy, DHS, etc don't need bills, just issued Regulations, or choose not to prosecute.
That's a joke. Drilling up. Oil exportation up. While I do think we are overly regulated and badly regulated, Obama has done little to nothing over and above the Bush administration.

As we have begun to see and will soon see more of from ObamaCare too unless Supreme Court scuttles all or most of it.
Demagoguery. Be afraid everyone, be very afraid of Obama. Why? Simple, oil drilling is up oil exportation is up, no gun control legislation, the regulation and oversight this man is not doing goes on and on. The man is simply a monster. And don't forget, Obamacare was invented by Republicans and Republicans were the first to try and implement it. Can you imagine anything more devious? When you implement GOP policies your intentions must be over regulation. Am I right?
 
If buying ads doesn't work then why do rich Republicans spend so much on ads? Are they that stupid?
 
I think it's interesting that when it's a corporation pouring hundreds of thousands of dollars into an ad campaign, that's protected political speech...but when it's some people camping in a park, that's illegal, and must be shut down.
 
I think it's interesting that when it's a corporation pouring hundreds of thousands of dollars into an ad campaign, that's protected political speech...but when it's some people camping in a park, that's illegal, and must be shut down.
And when Wall Street cause a catastrophic recession, the investigators at the SEC often take jobs at the very institutions that caused the mess in the first place.

So, what to do about it? Arrest protestors.
 
I think it's interesting that when it's a corporation pouring hundreds of thousands of dollars into an ad campaign, that's protected political speech...but when it's some people camping in a park, that's illegal, and must be shut down.

When it's a corporation pouring hundreds of thousands of dollars into an ad campaign, that's denying the use of that money to the corporation for other purposes.
When it's some protesters taking over a public venue, that's denying the public the use of that venue for other purposes.
 
Last edited:
When it's a corporation pouring hundreds of thousands of dollars into an ad campaign, that's denying the use of that money to the corporation for other purposes.
(often millions) Even if it is billions, it's a hell of a cheap cost of doing business.

 
I think it's interesting that when it's a corporation pouring hundreds of thousands of dollars into an ad campaign, that's protected political speech...but when it's some people camping in a park, that's illegal, and must be shut down.

Imagining that the camping ordinance is an infringement on your rights is like imagining that a 10 pm noise ordinance(time and Manner restriction, see Cox. V. New Hampshire) disallowing a rock concert at 3am across the street from an orphanage is an infringement on free speech.

Give up the delusions of persecution, nobody is restricting your rights of speech and peaceful assembly. You just need to follow the same reasonable time and manner restrictions we all must follow out of respect for the community in which we live.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom