Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are against the Citizens United ruling you are against free speech, because it was a free speech case decided solely on the 1st Amendment. "Congress shall make no law... abridging freedom of speech", which is exactly what McCain-Feingold tried to do.
What does this have to do with Citizen's United?
 
RE: Citizens United and Free Speech. The idea that you are either for one or against the other is typical black and white thinking. Of course, by "free speech" those who make this argument simply mean that govt cannot infringe on speech. If corporations want to infringe on the speech of their employees then that is their right to do so even if there is reasonable basis for that restriction. So, for many, speech isn't itself a good. Only the prevention off govt restrictions is good. Which makes you wonder why it's wrong for govt to interfere with speech in the first place.

It's really bizarre how corporations are not only people but they have more rights than most people. Their rights cannot be infringed by anyone. Workers? Not so much.

Myself, I'd like to see a system of govt that sought to balance rights of business and individuals without a blind belief that the rights of corporations must be protected at all costs.
 
So, you've created a straw man, and then you're telling OWS that's what their ideology is, and they're hypocrites if they don't live by it. I wish I could see the looks on people's faces when you try to sell them that load!

I've created a straw man ?

Do you mean by referring to occupy as anti-capitalist ?

Damn left wing media and their labels

Press TV
rt
The Guardian
Just for fun...the NY Daily News
Oh, here's occupy putting out a call for support from radical left organizations.As we all know, radical left is anti-capitalism

A more effective technique would be to make an argument that occupy isn't anti-capitalist, that's just what the media is calling them, and go for an occupy is anti-corporatist instead.
 
As we all know, radical left is anti-capitalism

Some radical left is anti-capitalism. For instance, I consider some of my views "radical", but I am also pro-capitalism. (Or, at least, I'm not explicitly against it. I don't view it as inherently evil, or as something that must be eradicated.)

And who's deciding what "radical" is? Is this the "radical left" according to US politics, or global politics?

A more effective technique would be to make an argument that occupy isn't anti-capitalist, that's just what the media is calling them, and go for an occupy is anti-corporatist instead.

Perhaps. But I've heard different definitions of "corporatist", so I might have to look up what that is.

The way I see it, in OWS some people are radicals (they want capitalism abolished), and some are moderates (they want to see capitalism better regulated). The moderates are against "rogue capitalism". (The radicals get mentioned more often in the media, because, well, they're radicals.) However, as far as I know, OWS has taken no official position on this.
 
Last edited:
Well, I have no business aligning myself with OWS. This morning I supported the evil corporate machine by eating food I purchased at a supermarket. So, I'm a total hypocrite, because some of my money went into supporting capitalism. Therefore, I will no longer demand that corporate criminals be held responsible for their crimes, and acknowledge that corporations, not citizens, should run Washington.

Curse you and your logic, Stout!
 
Last edited:
Well, I guess they don't speak on behalf of those people who think that there's nothing wrong with the economy. I haven't met any of those, but I'm sure they're out there.

They don't even speak on behalf of everyone who thinks there is something wrong with the economy.
 
They don't even speak on behalf of everyone who thinks there is something wrong with the economy.
I don't think they claim to speak on behalf of everyone anymore than civil rights workers claimed to speak on behalf of all blacks or all women. The 99% is about a group of people that OWS believes is aggrieved just as blacks were a group that civil rights workers believed to be aggrieved.
 
The "we are the 99%" and related rhetoric is pretty suggestive that they claim to represent everyone within that category. It makes many people feel that these folks are putting words in their mouths, and a lot of people resent that sort of thing.
 
The "we are the 99%" and related rhetoric is pretty suggestive that they claim to represent everyone within that category. It makes many people feel that these folks are putting words in their mouths, and a lot of people resent that sort of thing.
That doesn't mean they claim to speak on behalf of every person. Are there downsides to the rhetoric? Sure. I'm happy to grant that some might take exception to it. Much of the Rhetoric of politically active people and groups engender resentment of like minds.

I don't find it a compelling reason to dismiss OWS. The criticism really strikes me as ad hoc. Perhaps the rhetoric of "we are the 99%" is impolitic. Perhaps not. I honestly don't know. That some might not like it is hardly a reason to dismiss it. Aren't you now speaking on behalf of some unknown group of people?
 
Last edited:
Well, I have no business aligning myself with OWS. This morning I supported the evil corporate machine by eating food I purchased at a supermarket. So, I'm a total hypocrite, because some of my money went into supporting capitalism. Therefore, I will no longer demand that corporate criminals be held responsible for their crimes, and acknowledge that corporations, not citizens, should run Washington.

Curse you and your logic, Stout!

What ?? Occupier !! You're not still eating the food from your garden or local farmers market that you put by last fall ?

Shame.

Was it a huge corporate grocery store ? Were the employees unionised ? Did you buy any corporate produced items that may have enriched the corporations and their Bunsen Honewdews to work away in their labs on new ways of poisoning the food supply through pesticides and GMOs ? Was the food you bought shipped in from afar burning precious oil and drowning baby polar bears with the toxic emissions ? Did you buy the harvested flesh of non-human animals who ,most likely died in fear and pain after a short torturous life ?

Did you ask yourself these questions as you were buying that frozen pizza ?

So, now you need to identify those corporate criminals and rat them out. You live in the US right ? A country that no one can accuse of being shy of putting people in jail.

Corporations are citizens, they're just a cult, like occupy.
 
RE: Citizens United and Free Speech. The idea that you are either for one or against the other is typical black and white thinking.
It really is black and white. To disagree with the ruling is to agree that the government can, if they wanted to, censor the editorial pages of the New York Times. Congress was kind enough to exempt such news organizations from the McCain-Feingold bill, an explicit acknowledgement that they could include them if they had wanted. And the government lawyer even argued to the SC justices that the government could ban certain books for a period of time before elections.

Gotta ban those books lest they influence the common folk!
 
Do you think that anyone should have the right to spend as much money as they want (buying advertisements, printing fliers, etc) to convey their opinions on political subjects?

I'm not sure. I'm still on the fence on this one. I don't think that I have enough information to make an informed opinion.
Isn't it conceivable that an organization could "buy" a politician, by dumping a ton of money into an ad campaign?
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure. I'm still on the fence on this one. I don't think that I have enough information to make an informed opinion.
Isn't it conceivable that an organization could "buy" a politician, by dumping a ton of money into an ad campaign?
I'm a bit on the fence also. Power still corrupts and money isn't just speech, money is power.

Rights are not absolute. While we ought to be damn careful about regulating rights, if a right is used to corrupt the system to the point that other rights are perfunctory, then it can and ought to be regulated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom