Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm not sure if this is the right thread for this or even where I am going with it so the mods can relocate this post or shove it in AAH for all I care.

Last year the occutards set up shop here in Louisville, on 4th street live (it's a huge food court, near the convention center and the horse racing place). The local police wisely headed off any potential problems by having them relocate off of Mohammed Ali blvd where they have been ever since.

They are in a small walking path/park scarcely the size of a city block. They have cause some property damage, disruption of public peace and business, and have caused the area to become dangerous.

The ideas that they are trying to push forward not only wouldn't work but would make most problems worse... so in what do they think that this will change anything for the better?

PS, they are currently in some hot water because they have been served an eviction notice. They were supposed to have vacated by the start of the year.

Update: They're no longer there and the park is in the middle of getting repairs and maintenance before it can be reopened for the general public. I don't know where Occutard Wooiville went nor do I care.
 
Obviously. A person who did care wouldn't go out of their why to pay attention to news about OWS and then bother to pass that information on to others. For that we thank you.

The park is a possible route on my way to school, but I've been avoiding it because of the Occutards. Last week I saw the park devoid of the tents and it roped off with maintenance crews fixing up the park, I saw that they finally left the place in a newspaper a fellow passenger on the bus was reading shortly after that.
 
The park is a possible route on my way to school, but I've been avoiding it because of the Occutards. Last week I saw the park devoid of the tents and it roped off with maintenance crews fixing up the park, I saw that they finally left the place in a newspaper a fellow passenger on the bus was reading shortly after that.
Well thank you so much for the update. Your lack of caring is duly noted. At least you are not one of those republitards that gets their jollies engaging in discussion about things they don't care about.
 
Last edited:
Well thank you so much for the update. Your lack of caring is duly noted. At least you are not one of those republitards that gets their jollies engaging in discussion about things they don't care about.

What does my (independent for your information) political leanings have to do with me sharing the fact these losers were here and now they're not?
 
What does my (independent for your information) political leanings have to do with me sharing the fact these losers were here and now they're not?
There was no need to malign an entire group of people just to give us an update. But that would seem to be within the guidelines of the JREF. Hopefully OWS isn't the only group that is fair game to malign. However, personalizing the discussion is against guidelines and for that I apologize.
 
Last edited:
There was no need to malign an entire group of people just to give us an update. But that would seem to be within the guidelines of the JREF. Hopefully OWS isn't the only group that is fair game to malign.

Nope. The Teabaggers received just as much (well deserved) derision.
 
Hey RandFan what do you have to say about OWS being co-opted by the Iranian mullahs as an instrument of thier foreign policy?

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mobileweb/sohrab-ahmari/iran-repression_b_1442977.html
I feel just the same as I do about the connect the dots govt-behind-9/11 CT BS.

This movement you want to ally with is pathetic.
Not nearly as pathetic as the corrupt bastards that packaged junk mortgages into complex derivatives and drove our economy into a ditch sending us into a severe recession, wiping out hard worked for investments, retirement accounts, savings, etc..

I'll never get some people's priorities. OWS isn't going to start a Muslim invasion even if they wanted to. But Wall Street and Bankers are planning right now to **** America again for power and greed and many people are worried about the people who are trying to do something about that.

Go figure.
 
Maybe Iran will let you hold a conference on that.
I couldn't give a damn about silly conspiracy theory. The banking scandal and what Wall Street did wasn't a delusion. That they can do it again isn't speculation.
 
Last edited:
Yea, I'll admit this live your ideology is a tough sell. Damn capitalists just make like too easy, for instance, I'm just going to go hop on my bike, head down to the farmer's market and pick myself up a peck of fail. See I'm baking an occu-pie

So, you've created a straw man, and then you're telling OWS that's what their ideology is, and they're hypocrites if they don't live by it. I wish I could see the looks on people's faces when you try to sell them that load!
 
So, for all the marbles; Axiom_Blade, can an individual have a legitimate criticism or criticisms of Occupy without being part of or ever having been part of the movement?

Yes. You're correct. The troll accusation is really secondary to the argument. It answers the question "Why in the name of the FSM would somebody make an argument like that?" If it is used to debate the argument, it is, in fact, ad hominem.

It's entirely possible for someone to truly believe that A) OWS ideology demands that you never buy anything from a corporation, and B) OWS should live by A, and adopt an Amish lifestyle. When you have that kind of an argument, whether or not it's a troll becomes irrelevant. Of course, if OWS were to demand that all members abstain from buying goods and services, it would be about as popular as demanding that everyone protest by pouring gasoline on themselves, and lighting themselves on fire. Such a movement would, of course, be very small, and would only contain fanatics.

I'm not sure that OWS has much of an ideology, much less an "anti-capitalist" one. There are some shared values, and one of those is inclusiveness. If we were to decide that the only way you could be "true OWS" is if you eschewed all aspects of capitalist, that would be exclusiveness, the exact opposite. More to the point: what business do we have, telling the 99% how they should live their lives? Take a mother of 4, who has to work two jobs while she's going to school. Tell her that we won't accept her as part of the movement, unless she quits driving her car and shopping at the supermarket. What do you think her reaction's going to be?

No, we shouldn't be telling the 99% anything. We need to be listening to the 99%, which the media and politicians are not.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure that OWS has much of an ideology, much less an "anti-capitalist" one. There are some shared values, and one of those is inclusiveness. If we were to decide that the only way you could be "true OWS" is if you eschewed all aspects of capitalist, that would be exclusiveness, the exact opposite. More to the point: what business do we have, telling the 99% how they should live their lives? Take a mother of 4, who has to work two jobs while she's going to school. Tell her that we won't accept her as part of the movement, unless she quits driving her car and shopping at the supermarket. What do you think her reaction's going to be?

No, we shouldn't be telling the 99% anything. We need to be listening to the 99%, which the media and politicians are not.

Any group which claims or aspires to represent "the 99%" has set an unachievable goal for themselves. Think of how many individuals truly comprise "the 99%" (as opposed to OWS). There's no such thing as an ideology or specific value that unites them all; not even "frustration with the 1%".

One of the biggest reasons popular movements like OWS encounter so much resistance from behind is exactly because of this presumptuousness in their rhetoric; claiming to be speaking on behalf of people they've never solicited input from (or whose input they rejected or even belittled).
 
One of the biggest reasons popular movements like OWS encounter so much resistance from behind is exactly because of this presumptuousness in their rhetoric; claiming to be speaking on behalf of people they've never solicited input from (or whose input they rejected or even belittled).

Well, I guess they don't speak on behalf of those people who think that there's nothing wrong with the economy. I haven't met any of those, but I'm sure they're out there.
 
Any group which claims or aspires to represent "the 99%" has set an unachievable goal for themselves. Think of how many individuals truly comprise "the 99%" (as opposed to OWS). There's no such thing as an ideology or specific value that unites them all; not even "frustration with the 1%".

One of the biggest reasons popular movements like OWS encounter so much resistance from behind is exactly because of this presumptuousness in their rhetoric; claiming to be speaking on behalf of people they've never solicited input from (or whose input they rejected or even belittled).
How do you know? It sounds ad hoc. I note how many pundits and candidates speak for Americans. Always saying "the American people" this and "the American people" that. I kinda doubt that has much to do with it but I honestly don't know.
 
Yes. You're correct. The troll accusation is really secondary to the argument. It answers the question "Why in the name of the FSM would somebody make an argument like that?" If it is used to debate the argument, it is, in fact, ad hominem.
Then why were you using it?

It's entirely possible for someone to truly believe that A) OWS ideology demands that you never buy anything from a corporation, and B) OWS should live by A, and adopt an Amish lifestyle. When you have that kind of an argument, whether or not it's a troll becomes irrelevant. Of course, if OWS were to demand that all members abstain from buying goods and services, it would be about as popular as demanding that everyone protest by pouring gasoline on themselves, and lighting themselves on fire. Such a movement would, of course, be very small, and would only contain fanatics.

I'm not sure that OWS has much of an ideology, much less an "anti-capitalist" one. There are some shared values, and one of those is inclusiveness.
Inclusiveness based on what, if they don't have an ideology? And if they don't have an ideology, how can they have shared values?

If we were to decide that the only way you could be "true OWS" is if you eschewed all aspects of capitalist, that would be exclusiveness, the exact opposite.
I'm sorry, did you miss all the 99% vs the 1% rhetoric?

More to the point: what business do we have, telling the 99% how they should live their lives? Take a mother of 4, who has to work two jobs while she's going to school. Tell her that we won't accept her as part of the movement, unless she quits driving her car and shopping at the supermarket. What do you think her reaction's going to be?

No, we shouldn't be telling the 99% anything. We need to be listening to the 99%, which the media and politicians are not.

That is a lot of words to avoid answering the question I actually asked.
 
No, we shouldn't be telling the 99% anything. We need to be listening to the 99%, which the media and politicians are not.

Translation: Politicians and "the media" aren't listening to me, therefore they aren't listening to "the people".

Any group which claims or aspires to represent "the 99%" has set an unachievable goal for themselves. Think of how many individuals truly comprise "the 99%" (as opposed to OWS). There's no such thing as an ideology or specific value that unites them all; not even "frustration with the 1%".

One of the biggest reasons popular movements like OWS encounter so much resistance from behind is exactly because of this presumptuousness in their rhetoric; claiming to be speaking on behalf of people they've never solicited input from (or whose input they rejected or even belittled).

Spot on. Very well said.
 
Last edited:
Then why were you using it?
I already covered that.
Inclusiveness based on what, if they don't have an ideology? And if they don't have an ideology, how can they have shared values?
Inclusiveness based on whether or not you're part of the 99%. OWS does have ideology, but it doesn't seem to be particularly ideology-driven. If you talk to 5 occupiers, you'll likely get 5 different ideas of what OWS is. I've talked to occupiers who think it's anti-capitalist, others who are classically liberal, others who think that it's anarchistic.
I'm sory, did you miss all the 99% vs the 1% rhetoric?
What does that have to do with capitalism?
That is a lot of words to avoid answering the question I actually asked.
I'm sorry; I thought I had answered your question. It was right at the top of my post.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom