Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Straw man. Again. You're making a false binary.

1. People who have been part of OWS and have "legitimate gripes".
2. People who have little knowledge of OWS and criticize "everything" about it.

Which leaves out

3. People who have little knowledge of OWS and have legitimate gripes
4. People who have been part of OWS and criticize everything.
5. People who have been part of OWS and criticize some things about it.
Wow, that's a lot of nitpicking. Talk is cheap. I see a lot of criticism of OWS, but not a lot of people willing to create an alternative. I'd be a lot more impressed if some of these people were willing to put their money where their mouth is.

It's kind of ironic that you get so defensive in response to external criticism of OWS
Ha-ha, are you serious? This is a debate. Are you seriously calling me out on defending my opinions?
 
Oddly enough, the closest thing I've seen to a concern troll is someone JAQing off in the conspiracy forums.

I honestly think the concern troll is more of a boogeyman than actual fact, used to dismiss people one disagrees with.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concern_troll#Concern_troll

Well, golly, maybe the whole notion of a "net troll" is just a boogeyman, "used to dismiss people one disagrees with"! Surely, you can't prove what someone's motivations are for posting something. So, we can only assume that all posts on the internet are 100% honest and sincere, and anyone who says otherwise is just making an ad hominem.
 
I see a lot of criticism of OWS, but not a lot of people willing to create an alternative. I'd be a lot more impressed if some of these people were willing to put their money where their mouth is.
I don't mind criticism of OWS per se. I think criticism can be a good thing and I think there is much to criticize. I mind the broad brush dismissal of the group based on ad hominem and other fallacy.
 
Wow, that's a lot of nitpicking. Talk is cheap. I see a lot of criticism of OWS, but not a lot of people willing to create an alternative. I'd be a lot more impressed if some of these people were willing to put their money where their mouth is.
And, of course, you whip right past the part where you were making logical fallacies and a pertinent question or two, in order to make more logical fallacies, and, of course, not saying what you consider "legitimate gripes", which seem to have more to do with who's making the claims than their actual content, judging by your posts.

Also, OWS seems perfectly fine criticizing the 1% without actually being sure what needs to be changed or how. Yet whenever this is pointed out, one gets excuses.

Ha-ha, are you serious? This is a debate. Are you seriously calling me out on defending my opinions?
No, but I am calling you out on what I see as your hypocrisy. People outside groups who criticize "everything" don't have legitimate arguments, according to you, but OWS is mostly about the 99% demanding change from the 1%, according to their own rhetoric.

Well, golly, maybe the whole notion of a "net troll" is just a boogeyman, "used to dismiss people one disagrees with"! Surely, you can't prove what someone's motivations are for posting something. So, we can only assume that all posts on the internet are 100% honest and sincere, and anyone who says otherwise is just making an ad hominem.
Please stop straw-manning. I think that people are denounced as "concern trolls" much, much more often than they actually are concern trolls, especially since the definition of the term relies on somehow gauging someone's intentions over the Internet. Yep, there are people who are concern trolls. But there's no way to be sure unless they say so. I almost never assume someone is deliberately trolling, since stupidity and denial are always an option.

And, of course, a legitimate criticism may cause just as much disruption as that of a concern troll. In fact, there is nothing in the definition of concern troll that actually says their concerns are not valid. Not only is it not denied, it is not addressed at all, much like the definition of the similar "Tone Argument".

1. Straw man.
2. I don't have to propose an alternative in order to criticize their current course of action.
2b. If I did, it would be to figure out what the most important parts of their disparate messages are, and to focus on those. Triage. Prioritize. Put someone or someones in charge and make them actually responsible.
...
"Legitimate" according to what standard? And why all three? Why should someone have to help out in order to have "legitimate" gripes worthy of considering? Occupy's central platform is criticism of the 1%, but that's considered perfectly valid, despite the fact that most people have only the vaguest idea of how the 1% live....


And, really, quote-mining? That's an Ergo tactic. Do you want to be like him?

Come to think, the very idea of a "concern troll" relies on someone being able to discern someone's intentions over the Internet. I am rather leery of any pejorative term like that, especially if it's being used to dismiss what the person is actually saying. It's really just a glorified Ad Hominem, as is lending more weight to someone's criticism of OWS just because they are or are not a part of it, instead of evaluating the criticism on its own merits.

So, for all the marbles; Axiom_Blade, can an individual have a legitimate criticism or criticisms of Occupy without being part of or ever having been part of the movement?
 
Last edited:
Come to think, the criticisms most likely to cause Fear Uncertainty and Doubt in a movement are those which challenge its most central tenets and beliefs. Which, coincidentally, are those most likely to get the person making them labelled a concern troll.
 
Is this the money = speech argument? Bribery is perfectly okay, because that's just "free speech"?
If you are against the Citizens United ruling you are against free speech, because it was a free speech case decided solely on the 1st Amendment. "Congress shall make no law... abridging freedom of speech", which is exactly what McCain-Feingold tried to do.

If you think anyone shouldn't be allowed to spend as much money as they like in order to present their point of view on any subject, but political ones in particular, then you are by definition against free speech.

All clear? Or will you go on about how you're all for free speech, but only by those people or entities you agree with or approve?
 
Oddly enough, the closest thing I've seen to a concern troll is someone JAQing off in the conspiracy forums.

Good call, in fact it's the only place (the 9/11 section) I've seen concern trolling used.
 
IMO: You are special pleading and engaging in ad hominem. But I don't want to belabor it. I think if anyone was ripe to changing his or her mind on a subject it would be me. I like capitalism. I don't like much of the rhetoric and the tactics of OWS. I've no ideological loyalty to anything. I grew up conservative but have moved to the middle.

Ad hominem against who? ...damn is there an echo in here ?

We've already covered occupy being an anti-capitalism movement loaded with all sorts of horse hockey rhetoric and direct action. Occupy demands ideological loyalty, centrists need not apply except to up the numbers at actions.

I can honestly say I find your complaints silly and ad hoc

You're not ringing The People's Gong on me are you ?

It is imperative that we get it into people's heads that there are real problems of govt corruption and corporate influence

Yes, we know, we don't care all that much as long as there fuel at the gas stations, the lights stay on and the supermarkets are full.

Having studied sociology

Oh, well there's your problem [/Adam Savage]

Often times significant social change takes large boisterous shows to move people off of their intransigent asses.

Yes, exactly. That's what I'm doing here putting on a large boisterous show trying to convince occupiers to give up their consumerist ways and kick the 1% in the financial gonads. Yet....I get The Peoples Gong.

It's an outside one but the best we've got at the moment.

So far, the product hasn't lived up to the hype.

So, in the end, I find your attempt to distinguish between the protestors of the 60s and OWS to be entirely underwhelming and revealing of your bias.

You mean I've been "EXPOSED" ? That's the ticket ! I am the ideologically impure 99%

IMO, you have a pretty weak argument.

Yea, I'll admit this live your ideology is a tough sell. Damn capitalists just make like too easy, for instance, I'm just going to go hop on my bike, head down to the farmer's market and pick myself up a peck of fail. See I'm baking an occu-pie

Gonnnnnnnnnnnnnng

I'll get my hat.
 
Yes, exactly. That's what I'm doing here putting on a large boisterous show trying to convince occupiers to give up their consumerist ways and kick the 1% in the financial gonads.
How is that working out for you?

So far, the product hasn't lived up to the hype.
You are entitled to an opinion. Mine differs. Now what?

Yea, I'll admit this live your ideology is a tough sell.
Yeah, it would seem your idea is precious to few but yourself. Hey, you might be right. It sounds reasonable but in the end I don't give a **** about anarchists walking the talk anymore than I give a **** that most of the hippies of the 60s were sell outs.

Now what?
 
Last edited:
Now what ?

That's up to occupy. They can continue on with the gong show and present us with hours of uproarious real life entertainment or they can get their act together and challenge the 1% like they tried to do on bank transfer day.
 
Now what ?
Yeah, regarding our participation in this thread. Your advice to OWS doesn't seem to have had much effect. I was wondering if you had some advice for those who want OWS to adopt your advice?
 
So now it's about the destruction of the wilderness? Good job staying on message, Occutards!!!

(I only watched the first 30 seconds. Heading out the door. I'll watch this sitcom tonight)
 
Now we wait until occupy supplies us with some new material

M1GS...one week to go.
 
Now we wait until occupy supplies us with some new material

M1GS...one week to go.
Until then keep an eye on the GOP. They never seem to disappoint. Obama also but he pales compared to Romney and company. Too bad Santorum is out of the race. We could have supplied him with lots and lots of advice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom