Wow, that's a lot of nitpicking. Talk is cheap. I see a lot of criticism of OWS, but not a lot of people willing to create an alternative. I'd be a lot more impressed if some of these people were willing to put their money where their mouth is.
And, of course, you whip right past the part where you were making logical fallacies and a pertinent question or two, in order to make more logical fallacies, and, of course, not saying what you consider "legitimate gripes", which seem to have more to do with
who's making the claims than their actual content, judging by your posts.
Also, OWS seems perfectly fine criticizing the 1% without actually being sure what needs to be changed or how. Yet whenever this is pointed out, one gets excuses.
Ha-ha, are you serious? This is a debate. Are you seriously calling me out on defending my opinions?
No, but I am calling you out on what I see as your hypocrisy. People outside groups who criticize "everything" don't have legitimate arguments, according to you, but OWS is mostly about the 99% demanding change from the 1%, according to their own rhetoric.
Well, golly, maybe the whole notion of a "net troll" is just a boogeyman, "used to dismiss people one disagrees with"! Surely, you can't prove what someone's motivations are for posting something. So, we can only assume that all posts on the internet are 100% honest and sincere, and anyone who says otherwise is just making an ad hominem.
Please stop straw-manning. I think that people are denounced as "concern trolls" much, much more often than they actually are concern trolls, especially since the definition of the term relies on somehow gauging someone's intentions over the Internet. Yep, there are people who are concern trolls. But there's no way to be sure unless they say so. I almost never assume someone is deliberately trolling, since stupidity and denial are always an option.
And, of course, a legitimate criticism may cause just as much disruption as that of a concern troll. In fact, there is
nothing in the definition of concern troll that actually says their concerns are
not valid. Not only is it not denied, it is not addressed
at all, much like the definition of the similar "Tone Argument".
1. Straw man.
2. I don't have to propose an alternative in order to criticize their current course of action.
2b. If I did, it would be to figure out what the most important parts of their disparate messages are, and to focus on those. Triage. Prioritize. Put someone or someones in charge and make them actually responsible.
...
"Legitimate" according to what standard? And why all three? Why should someone have to help out in order to have "legitimate" gripes worthy of considering? Occupy's central platform is criticism of the 1%, but that's considered perfectly valid, despite the fact that most people have only the vaguest idea of how the 1% live....
And, really, quote-mining? That's an Ergo tactic. Do you want to be like him?
Come to think, the very idea of a "concern troll" relies on someone being able to discern someone's intentions over the Internet. I am rather leery of any pejorative term like that, especially if it's being used to dismiss what the person is actually saying. It's really just a glorified Ad Hominem, as is lending more weight to someone's criticism of OWS just because they are or are not a part of it, instead of evaluating the criticism on its own merits.
So, for all the marbles;
Axiom_Blade, can an individual have a legitimate criticism or criticisms of Occupy without being part of or ever having been part of the movement?