Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, however those rules are created and enforced by the will of the majority, plus, who cares about alcohol when there's so much yummy acid in need of gobbling ?
Exactly, all those hippies marching for civil rights in the 60s damn sure were not doing any acid or other drugs for that matter. And hey, anarchy? Does anyone think that the hippies supported communes or socialism? Let's get real people. They were organized and as straight laced and conservative as Richard Nixon. Am I right?
 
Come to think, the very idea of a "concern troll" relies on someone being able to discern someone's intentions over the Internet. I am rather leery of any pejorative term like that, especially if it's being used to dismiss what the person is actually saying. It's really just a glorified Ad Hominem, as is lending more weight to someone's criticism of OWS just because they are or are not a part of it, instead of evaluating the criticism on its own merits.

In order to be a proper concern troll, I'd have to appear to be supporting occupy but having concerns wrt to their methods or format or something that strikes me as needing revision.

For instance I might say I support the M1GS but take issue with occupy Toronto's methods of addressing the people.. I may question whether this method of raising awareness by engaging in a cult like chant in a subway car might frighten rather than positively influence people. I might question what might happen should a corporation adopt this method of advertising then speculate it would go over like a pregnant pole vaulter. Then my occucomrads might want to call me a concern troll depending how in with the crowd I was at the time.

So, now that we have occupy the center of the universe, in all their multitudes,torturing their captive audience I couldn't help notice that they were reading their cues from smartphones. There appears to be some resistance from occusympathisers over these things and not only their enriching of the 1% but the hidden and significantly more sinister costs of owning these devices.

See a lot of those minerals that go into making one of those things come from the Congo. As we all , know rape and murder are common at the militarized mines in the Congo, so the phones could more properly be referred to as rape phones.

It would be helpful for occupy to keep in mind or at least acknowledge that every time somebody buys one of these rape phones that it's stained by the **** and urine of raped women's leaking fistulas.

The first part of dealing with a problem, any problem, is admitting that there is a problem. Occupiers and their voracious demand for consumer goods refuses to take this first step, they just reply with a flippant "so what ? We like our consumer goods and don't want to cut ourselves off from society"

Sure they may complain about 11-year-old mine slaves, women whose vaginas have been perforated by object insertion rape, and families forced to eat one another in each other's presence but will that stop them from buying, from purchasing and consuming ? Heck no.

With apologies to Ashley Judd
 
In order to be a proper concern troll, I'd have to appear to be supporting occupy but having concerns wrt to their methods or format or something that strikes me as needing revision. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ashley-judd/post_1312_b_786835.html
I don't think your actions come under "concern" troll. But something close to it.

However, while I think one can offer legitimate and sincere advice to an opponent or adversarial group, I often think it just comes of as insincere and patronizing. I've done it in the past and it was typically for rhetorical effect. IMO, that's how your "advice" comes off. The point, it seems to me, is to ridicule. I kinda doubt you think it would be taken any other way, right?
 
Exactly, all those hippies marching for civil rights in the 60s damn sure were not doing any acid or other drugs for that matter. And hey, anarchy? Does anyone think that the hippies supported communes or socialism? Let's get real people. They were organized and as straight laced and conservative as Richard Nixon. Am I right?

The point being, of course, that anarchy isn't a workable model in situations that aren't either small and/or temporary.

The civil rights movement was about equality before the law, they achieved those goals and those same people are today, decades later, still yelling about what a racist society 'we" are.

Occupy went straight to the screaming.
 
I don't think your actions come under "concern" troll. But something close to it.

However, while I think one can offer legitimate and sincere advice to an opponent or adversarial group, I often think it just comes of as insincere and patronizing. I've done it in the past and it was typically for rhetorical effect. IMO, that's how your "advice" comes off. The point, it seems to me, is to ridicule. I kinda doubt you think it would be taken any other way, right?

I'm not even close to concern troll, I'm nowhere near subtle enough but I can play one if you want.

Ridicule ?? I suppose you could read that into my posts, they're nothing worse than the rhetoric Occupy spouts.
 
The point being, of course, that anarchy isn't a workable model in situations that aren't either small and/or temporary.
Fair enough but it doesn't have anything to do with their complaints of corporate corruption anymore than the hippies communism had to do with civil rights, etc..

The civil rights movement was about equality before the law, they achieved those goals and those same people are today, decades later, still yelling about what a racist society 'we" are.
Doesn't really help the discussion.

Occupy went straight to the screaming.
I was there. As I recall, the hippies went straight for the screaming.
 
Last edited:
I'm not even close to concern troll, I'm nowhere near subtle enough but I can play one if you want.
Please to read my post again. I think you miss where I said you were not a concern troll.

Ridicule ?? I suppose you could read that into my posts, they're nothing worse than the rhetoric Occupy spouts.
I think a lot of the rhetoric of OWS is awful. So yeah, that's a good moral foundation.
 
..

Doesn't really help the discussion.

Yes it does, we're comparing a movement with concrete goals to one that's against everything that passes across it's plate.

I was there. As I recall, the hippies went straight for the screaming.

No doubt, and what did the hippies get in the end ? The civil rights leaders got their laws changed, the hippies got ? Uh corporate jobs ?

Please to read my post again. I think you miss where I said you were not a concern troll.

You said I was something close to it. Now given that concern troll is a very specific type of troll, which may or may not be actual trolling, trolling is in the eye of the beholder you must have meant some sort of undefined type of troll.

I think a lot of the rhetoric of OWS is awful. So yeah, that's a good moral foundation.

Yet you're defending them tooth and nail. Don't forget Occupy is coming from a position of moral superiority, from a social justice perspective.
 
Yes it does, we're comparing a movement with concrete goals to one that's against everything that passes across it's plate.
No it doesn't. The criticism would apply equally to both groups and in both cases irrelevant.

No doubt, and what did the hippies get in the end ?
The hippies got civil rights, changes in attitudes about women and minorities, end to the war.

You said I was something close to it.
Yeah, sorry, I did. I think there are some parallels. It's a rhetorical device you are employing. I don't think you expect to be taken seriously as someone who is sincerely concerned or offering sincere advice. You are employing an obvious conceit, acting as if you are concerned.

Yet you're defending them tooth and nail. Don't forget Occupy is coming from a position of moral superiority, from a social justice perspective.
A LOT of the rhetoric of civil rights activists was simply awful. They were coming from a position of moral superiority, from a social justice perspective.

BTW: Stout, no I'm not defending them tooth and nail. I'm defending an important aspect of their message.
 
The hippies got civil rights, changes in attitudes about women and minorities, end to the war.

Was it the hippies or the blacks that got equality under the law ? As to changes in attitudes, on the surface maybe, but those same activist types are still on about how racist we are, even with equality under the law, just look at the Trayvon Martin Debate.

We even have a thread running here on the JREF about how men are conditioned to hate women. If you want I can even link to a feminist site that says women are conditioned to hate women.

Given this, can we really say "things have changed" ?

On paper, sure but as far as attitudes go, leftist activists, will try their damndest to convince you nothing has changed.

Yeah, sorry, I did. I think there are some parallels. It's a rhetorical device you are employing. I don't think you expect to be taken seriously as someone who is sincerely concerned or offering sincere advice. You are employing an obvious conceit, acting as if you are concerned.

OK, maybe I've been reading too much occupy literature and some of the technique has rubbed off. They way they're headed now, their doomed to failure and they know it. They know the 1% is going to be on the golf course come M1GS and all they're really going to do is piss off commuters and further alienate themselves.

Yea, sure I'd support them on their anti corruption ideas only they've mired themselves in so much cowspoo, on purpose, and made it all about them and their right to set up tents that I doubt their sincerity.

Do you, in all honesty feel that the message you're defending is getting the attention it deserves from occupy ? From what I'm seeing that message is getting buried in the histrionics.
 
Was it the hippies or the blacks that got equality under the law ?
???

I think you are laboring under some very odd presumptions.

  • Hippies and blacks are not mutually exclusive.
  • Hippies were fighting for, among other things, civil rights for minorities and women.
  • Even if there were no black hippies or no female hippies, they got what they were after so it wouldn't matter regardless, right? I mean, I'm not gay but I can work for gay marriage, and someday I can say my goals have come to pass, right?
Do you, in all honesty feel that the message you're defending is getting the attention it deserves from occupy ? From what I'm seeing that message is getting buried in the histrionics.
I'm very happy so far. But then, my bias is different than yours.
 
Last edited:
In order to be a proper concern troll, I'd have to appear to be supporting occupy but having concerns wrt to their methods or format or something that strikes me as needing revision. ...
Hm. By that logic, if you're outside the movement you can be dismissed as an outsider, and if you're inside/supporting the movement, you can be dismissed as a concern troll who isn't "really" part of the movement. Convenient.
 
Last edited:
I'm not even close to concern troll, I'm nowhere near subtle enough but I can play one if you want.

Ridicule ?? I suppose you could read that into my posts, they're nothing worse than the rhetoric Occupy spouts.

Wait, did he just say it seems patronizing to offer advice to one's opponent by way of offering advice to you, his opponent?

...

Yet you're defending them tooth and nail. Don't forget Occupy is coming from a position of moral superiority, from a social justice perspective.

But they're totally not being patronizing when they do so, when they claim they're better than the 1%.
 
No it doesn't. The criticism would apply equally to both groups and in both cases irrelevant.

The hippies got civil rights, changes in attitudes about women and minorities, end to the war.
Or you have an as yet unjustified correlation-causation problem.

...

A LOT of the rhetoric of civil rights activists was simply awful. They were coming from a position of moral superiority, from a social justice perspective.

BTW: Stout, no I'm not defending them tooth and nail. I'm defending an important aspect of their message.
Only you seem able to key in on that aspect. I don't see it amid the mish-mash I'm aware of.
 
Or you have an as yet unjustified correlation-causation problem.
I'll grant the premise. You missed the point. The point being, Stout's criticism is applicable to both.

Only you seem able to key in on that aspect. I don't see it amid the mish-mash I'm aware of.
In all honesty I can't see how you could miss it. I wonder sometimes if people don't see what they want to see. And yes, I include myself in that.
 
I think you are laboring under some very odd presumptions.

  • Hippies and blacks are not mutually exclusive.
  • Hippies were fighting for, among other things, civil rights for minorities and women.
  • Even if there were no black hippies or no female hippies, they got what they were after so it wouldn't matter regardless, right? I mean, I'm not gay but I can work for gay marriage, and someday I can say my goals have come to pass, right?
I'm very happy so far. But then, my bias is different than yours.

Yes, they got what they wanted, equality under the law, if you were rooting for gay marriage, that would be another specific demand to change a law or laws.

Occupy has bupkis when it comes to changing laws, especially here in Canada. Yes, in the US you can screw around with corporate personhood, Citizens United and the likes but up here, it's just complain complain complain.

Take that example form Occupy Toronto I posted yesterday, the subway harangue. Where in that, is anything to do with ending undue corporate power and influence on government ?
 
Hm. By that logic, if you're outside the movement you can be dismissed as an outsider, and if you're inside/supporting the movement, you can be dismissed as a concern troll who isn't "really" part of the movement. Convenient.

Yes, exactly.

Concern trolling is usually done by entering a conversation among strangers, talking up the game, then raising "concerns" and focusing in on those concerns.

Sure, I can see some of their points, like maybe it's a bad use of resources to go overseas and bomb the crap out of foreign countries but if I want to go protest that, then I'll go to an anti-war action. No need for the greater oversight. branding, and baggage of occupy.
 
Oddly enough, the closest thing I've seen to a concern troll is someone JAQing off in the conspiracy forums.

I honestly think the concern troll is more of a boogeyman than actual fact, used to dismiss people one disagrees with.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concern_troll#Concern_troll
These Do-Nothings profess a commitment to social change for ideals of justice, equality, and opportunity, and then abstain from and discourage all effective action for change. They are known by their brand, 'I agree with your ends but not your means.'[26]

I seriously and honestly think OWS needs radical changes if they want to accomplish anything significant. As I said upthread, "Attempting to correct errors often causes trouble among those who would prefer things stay the way they are."
 
Yes, they got what they wanted, equality under the law, if you were rooting for gay marriage, that would be another specific demand to change a law or laws.

Occupy has bupkis when it comes to changing laws, especially here in Canada. Yes, in the US you can screw around with corporate personhood, Citizens United and the likes but up here, it's just complain complain complain.

Take that example form Occupy Toronto I posted yesterday, the subway harangue. Where in that, is anything to do with ending undue corporate power and influence on government ?
IMO: You are special pleading and engaging in ad hominem. But I don't want to belabor it. I think if anyone was ripe to changing his or her mind on a subject it would be me. I like capitalism. I don't like much of the rhetoric and the tactics of OWS. I've no ideological loyalty to anything. I grew up conservative but have moved to the middle.

I can honestly say I find your complaints silly and ad hoc. It is imperative that we get it into people's heads that there are real problems of govt corruption and corporate influence. This is my number one goal. It is requisite to change. OWS, in my opinion, is doing more, much more, for that cause than anyone has in a long time.

  • Will OWS ultimately lead to anything?
  • Are some of the actions of OWS overshadowing their mission statement?
Here's the difference between you and I. I have the humility to admit that I don't know. Having studied sociology and human psychology I know that complex social problems are not easily solved. Often times significant social change takes large boisterous shows to move people off of their intransigent asses. OWS looks like it has a shot. It's an outside one but the best we've got at the moment.

So, in the end, I find your attempt to distinguish between the protestors of the 60s and OWS to be entirely underwhelming and revealing of your bias. You don't like them and that's fine. I understand, but beyond deriding and mocking them I can find little substance to your arguments. If you can't change my mind, an unabashed patriot, Ayn Rand fan, guy who frequently apologizes and regularly grants arguments and publicly admits when he finds himself wrong, then, IMO, you have a pretty weak argument.

But, that's just my humble opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom