Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's right, Stout. You're not important enough to talk to. If you were important, Occupy would tape dollar bills across their mouths and not talk to you.
 
I don't think it has anything to do with whether they "want" to hear. I think that if they did hear it they would find it less than compelling. I'm sorry but that's my take. I think the real question is this, why should they care about your opinion?

I don't know. If you are not interested in their mission statement then perhaps nothing. Perhaps you could take solace in the advice of Ghandi that you posted and be the change you want to see. I've no idea if that will solve anything but perhaps it will make it seem like it.

They should care because I am the 99%

I have become the change I want to see.

Occupy Canada spouted a bunch of nothing, save the approved slogans then quickly made it all about them and their right to set up tents. Occupy Vancouver even went so far as to demand not only housing, but housing together so they could continue to collaborate on occupy matters and, wait for it...daily transportation to and from the occupy site.
 
They should care because I am the 99%
Actually no, you are a tiny fraction of a tiny fraction of the 99%. No group can cater to every whim. Given that you bear them contempt, why is your opinion more important as it relates to their causes which you disagree with? Perhaps OWS isn't for you.

I have become the change I want to see.
There you go. You don't like the goals of OWS. You don't like how they go about achieving those goals. You have a better way. You have put it into practice. Perhaps you can start your own group. And, I mean that with all sincerity. You don't need to obsess over (what I surmise is your opinion) a feckless organization.
 
I don't know if that is true. It's not my argument. I'm saying that Stout's opinion, IMHO, isn't compelling.

Of course it's not compelling... to you, you're only seeing a little tiny fraction of the greater occupy mission.

For occupy there's no column inches, no Youtube moments, no awareness to be raised by inconveniencing yourself by giving up the enemy's goods. Heck using facebook to organise is "using the system against itself"
 
Actually no, you are a tiny fraction of a tiny fraction of the 99%. No group can cater to every whim. Given that you bear them contempt, why is your opinion more important as it relates to their causes which you disagree with? Perhaps OWS isn't for you.

There you go. You don't like the goals of OWS. You don't like how they go about achieving those goals. You have a better way. You have put it into practice. Perhaps you can start your own group. And, I mean that with all sincerity. You don't need to obsess over (what I surmise is your opinion) a feckless organization.

It's not so much their causes as their methods. I offer concrete workable real world solutions to their causes. Worried about AGW and peak oil ? Ditch the cars and planes. Worried about privacy ? Take steps to protect it. Worried that the corporations have too much power, don't empower them. Simple stuff really.

I'm not obsessing over them, I'm home sick as a dog and keeping myself busy.:)
 
Of course it's not compelling... to you, you're only seeing a little tiny fraction of the greater occupy mission.
The part I think has a real chance for success.

For occupy there's no column inches, no Youtube moments, no awareness to be raised by inconveniencing yourself by giving up the enemy's goods.
Not sure how much I agree or disagree. I really don't care.

Heck using facebook to organise is "using the system against itself"
Sounds good to me.
 
It's not so much their causes as their methods. I offer concrete workable real world solutions to their causes.
Perhaps but you've failed to convince me. We'll see if you can get them on your side.

Worried about AGW and peak oil ? Ditch the cars and planes. Worried about privacy ? Take steps to protect it. Worried that the corporations have too much power, don't empower them. Simple stuff really.
Sounds reasonable. You should see if you can start a group doing that. I don't think you will convince anyone in OWS to follow your suggestions if you condescend and bear them such contempt.

I'm not obsessing over them, I'm home sick as a dog and keeping myself busy.:)
Get better. :)
 
Sounds reasonable. You should see if you can start a group doing that. I don't think you will convince anyone in OWS to follow your suggestions if you condescend and bear them such contempt.

Yes, it's unfortunate that sometimes the flock must be browbeat so see the error of their ways. Deep down, occupiers know consumerism is the moral disease and there's more to the cure than protesting at Walmart.

Get better.

Thanks:) common cold, if mucus was a commodity I'd be a tycoon, good thing I bought all that kleenex stock;)
 
And people who are emotionally involved in something are rarely able to assess criticism logically. I've seen people who dismissed and ignored perfectly valid criticism of serious problems on their part because they were het up.

You're talking out of both sides of your mouth; either you can ignore criticism,(which FUD may still be) or you can't.
So, what's your proposed alternative? Bend over backwards to satisfy the gripes of every random cynic? You simply can't run any type of organization or movement that way.

Also, your use of "enemies" is telling of an Us v. Them mentality.
Okay, maybe I shouldn't use the word "enemies". How about "ne'er-do-wells"? "Malcontents"? "Trolls"?
Whatever I call them, they're non-productive people and, essentially, troublemakers. I'm not talking about people who've actually done their time and helped out, and have legitimate gripes. I'm talking about people who just come off the street (or on internet message boards), who have no idea what your movement's about, but still feel like they have the authority to tell you that everything you're doing is wrong. I'm sorry, but those people are not worth listening to.

Straw man. Doing nothing, at this point, would be a better net gain than Occupy, IMO.
Well, maybe you're right. Maybe if we all just shut up and go away, everything will fix itself. That's worked before, right?
 
So, what's your proposed alternative? Bend over backwards to satisfy the gripes of every random cynic? You simply can't run any type of organization or movement that way.
1. Straw man.
2. I don't have to propose an alternative in order to criticize their current course of action.
2b. If I did, it would be to figure out what the most important parts of their disparate messages are, and to focus on those. Triage. Prioritize. Put someone or someones in charge and make them actually responsible.

Okay, maybe I shouldn't use the word "enemies". How about "ne'er-do-wells"? "Malcontents"? "Trolls"?
"Opponents" or "people with different opinions than I have".

Whatever I call them, they're non-productive people and, essentially, troublemakers.
Attempting to correct errors often causes trouble among those who would prefer things stay the way they are.

I'm not talking about people who've actually done their time and helped out, and have legitimate gripes.
"Legitimate" according to what standard? And why all three? Why should someone have to help out in order to have "legitimate" gripes worthy of considering? Occupy's central platform is criticism of the 1%, but that's considered perfectly valid, despite the fact that most people have only the vaguest idea of how the 1% live.

I'm talking about people who just come off the street (or on internet message boards), who have no idea what your movement's about, but still feel like they have the authority to tell you that everything you're doing is wrong. I'm sorry, but those people are not worth listening to.
Straw man. Again. You're making a false binary.

1. People who have been part of OWS and have "legitimate gripes".
2. People who have little knowledge of OWS and criticize "everything" about it.

Which leaves out

3. People who have little knowledge of OWS and have legitimate gripes
4. People who have been part of OWS and criticize everything.
5. People who have been part of OWS and criticize some things about it. (Like these folks. Notice how OWS supports start in on the personal attacks.
http://matadornetwork.com/change/im-breaking-up-with-you-occupy/
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/max-bean/occupy-movement_b_1394181.html
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/max-bean/you-cant-leave-occupy-wal_b_1411194.html)

And so on, and so forth.

All you're really saying is that only OWS can "legitimately" criticize OWS. And that's largely discouraged.

Well, maybe you're right. Maybe if we all just shut up and go away, everything will fix itself. That's worked before, right?
I believe Occupy has done more harm than good. As such, doing nothing would be a greater net good than the movement. It might not solve problems, but it wouldn't make them worse, either.

It's kind of ironic that you get so defensive in response to external criticism of OWS, yet OWS's 1% vs 99% is all about criticizing the 1% from the outside.
 
Last edited:
On a completely unrelated subject, does anyone know how the symbolic hunger strikers are going?
 
Last edited:
attachment.php


I think that is brilliant. It's an excellent metaphor and a great example of confirmation bias.
Really? I see people demanding the end of the right to free speech. I find it highly disturbing, nothing great or brilliant or excellent about it. OWS, at least this faction of it, is demanding a totalitarian government where speech is strictly regulated.

Maybe your cup of tea, but certainly not mine.
 
So why am I "biased" ? I know the hard left and their ridiculous anarchist politics when I see it. Outside of a Rainbow Gathering or a pirate ship the anarchist model is unworkable and childish.
Oh, you've never seen a Rainbow Gathering in action. Nothing anarchistic about it, there are many stringent rules (such as no alcohol) and they are enforced.
 
Creationist: "I've never seen a missing link, seriously, how long before we have to label evolution 'stupid', yes? How long should we wait?"
Evolution is rife with examples of predicted "missing links" which were eventually found in the fossil record.

Have you located a single intelligent spokesperson/member for OWS yet? I have yet to find one who even understands the Citizens United decision, yet they are willing to repeal the 1st Amendment to reverse it.
 
Jobs were outsourced to countries with lower wages, i.e. poor countries. That was, naturally, done to increase profits for corporations
Actually it's done to just stay in business. Few are willing to pay $3,000 for a made-in-the-USA television when they can get one made in China of equal quality for $600.

Moving operations overseas doesn't increase profits, it just allows them to compete.
 
The price of gas is dictated primarily by what the market will bear and not how much subsidies they get.
But where it is produced is heavily influenced by tax structure. Denying the oil industry the same tax treatment every other capital-intensive venture in which returns are years away enjoys simply encourages production elsewhere. Can't produce in the US below market price? No problem, those wonderful humanitarian countries like Saudi Arabia and Iran will happily pick up the slack to meet demand.

So according to OWS outsourcing certain manufacturing (like televisions) is bad, but outsourcing oil production is good.
 
Come to think, the very idea of a "concern troll" relies on someone being able to discern someone's intentions over the Internet. I am rather leery of any pejorative term like that, especially if it's being used to dismiss what the person is actually saying. It's really just a glorified Ad Hominem, as is lending more weight to someone's criticism of OWS just because they are or are not a part of it, instead of evaluating the criticism on its own merits.
 
Oh, you've never seen a Rainbow Gathering in action. Nothing anarchistic about it, there are many stringent rules (such as no alcohol) and they are enforced.

Yes, however those rules are created and enforced by the will of the majority, plus, who cares about alcohol when there's so much yummy acid in need of gobbling ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom