Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, and I posit that the US would have to fail before occupy, as it stands now, can succeed. Anti-capitalism can only lead to one form of government.
Actually no. It can lead to the reduction of corporate control of government. A return to a govt of the people, by the people. A society where the rich and powerful are less able to game the system to their favor.
 
Yes, I've heard the voting system is the US described as a choice between evil and diet evil.

I agree there's not a lot of honesty out there. That's not a political statement, it's a statement on the human condition. Pretty much everybody is acting in their own interests and if you want to call that statement cynical, then by all means do. That attitude has sure kept me from making some dumb purchases.

They're usually pretty easy to spot, they tend to overdo it.
You are completely missing my point and it would seem that you are working hard to do so.

I'm presented with organizations and political parties that lie. Lie a lot. You are arguing that such organizations are not worth my support. What does that leave me with? Nothing. I have to make the best of a bad situation.
 
Nah, it's not concern trolling, it's an outright attack. Occupy says "corporations are bad mmmmmkay"
They do?

I say stop supporting them then, occupy says "no".
How does one stop supporting corporations? Are you saying that the only way you'd approve of Occupy is if every single protester lived completely off the grid, drove cars that they built themselves, out of metal they mined themselves, running off of homebrewed biodiesel, and wearing hand-woven clothing, carrying signs made from home-made paper, etc. etc.

We can take them to task until they get it right.
Waste of time. This is 1% inspiration, and 99% persperation. The reason why OWS is so successful is because they were willing to put in all of the hard work, and even get arrested in the process. If you think you have a better way of doing things, put it to the test. See how many people you can get to rally behind you.
 
"Concern trolling" is, generally, used as an excuse to ignore actual valid criticism by attacking the motivations of the person providing it. In almost every case, it ignores the actual content of the message.

You shouldn't ignore criticism. But it is important to recognize when that criticism is just a bunch of FUD being used by your enemies.

Wild hyperbole aside, go with a flawed model because they're the only model? I don't think that's a very good idea, since OWS is all about change. If it can't even change itself, on what grounds can it demand change of others?

Or, on the other hand, don't go with a model because it's not 100% perfect? Which group has a better model than OWS...?
 
You are completely missing my point and it would seem that you are working hard to do so.

I'm presented with organizations and political parties that lie. Lie a lot. You are arguing that such organizations are not worth my support. What does that leave me with? Nothing. I have to make the best of a bad situation.

No, I'm not missing your point, just saying that if you climb into bed with the occupy crowd you're courting a political idealogy that will give you something fatal rather than the mild case of ploitical herpes you have now.

Anti-capitalism, it's either total la la land or total Chairman Mao. Since we've never had the la la land anywhere, ever, my money's on the control freak. For your own good, of course, for the good of the people and the party.
 
No, I'm not missing your point, just saying that if you climb into bed with the occupy crowd you're courting a political idealogy that will give you something fatal rather than the mild case of ploitical herpes you have now.
No. It is missing the point. And you yourself admit that OWS cannot overthrow the govt. So a coalition with them is in my best interest. Your rhetoric is just silly. BTW: Now you are moving the goal posts. First it was distrust organizations that lie. I point out that I cannot find perfectly honest organizations so you shift to something else.

Anti-capitalism, it's either total la la land or total Chairman Mao. Since we've never had the la la land anywhere, ever, my money's on the control freak. For your own good, of course, for the good of the people and the party.
Sophistry. You can do better.
 
Last edited:
How does one stop supporting corporations? Are you saying that the only way you'd approve of Occupy is if every single protester lived completely off the grid, drove cars that they built themselves, out of metal they mined themselves, running off of homebrewed biodiesel, and wearing hand-woven clothing, carrying signs made from home-made paper, etc. etc.

Drove Cars ???? The womb of mother nature has been ripped open by strip mining to forcibly extract the raw materials to build those things. Then there';s the oil and gas, also forcibly sucked from Gaia's bosom to feed the voracious appetite of those unwilling to ride bicycles like the majority of the world. then there's all that valuable agricultural land paved over with concrete and asphalt. Cars ??? You only drive them because the advertisers make you want them.

Bio diesel is limited in supply, unless you're suggesting we start burning our food for fuel. Yay food security,

Hand woven clothing, now there's a project occupy can get their teeth into. Good quality hand made stuff, of course everybody won't be able to afford the huge wardrobes most of us have now a days but if we could bring that industry back to North America.....hummmmm.

Be the change you want to see in the world-Gandhi

Simple Innit ?
 
Drove Cars ???? The womb of mother nature has been ripped open by strip mining to forcibly extract the raw materials to build those things. Then there';s the oil and gas, also forcibly sucked from Gaia's bosom to feed the voracious appetite of those unwilling to ride bicycles like the majority of the world. then there's all that valuable agricultural land paved over with concrete and asphalt. Cars ??? You only drive them because the advertisers make you want them.

Bio diesel is limited in supply, unless you're suggesting we start burning our food for fuel. Yay food security,

Hand woven clothing, now there's a project occupy can get their teeth into. Good quality hand made stuff, of course everybody won't be able to afford the huge wardrobes most of us have now a days but if we could bring that industry back to North America.....hummmmm.

Be the change you want to see in the world-Gandhi

Simple Innit ?
Stout, Axiom isn't being snarky. This really isn't compelling. I get it. I really do. But it doesn't advance the discussion. I'm not asking you to give it up but could you offer something substantive also? I think some good points have been made by Axiom, your appeal to derision isn't logically valid. It's interesting. It's just that it doesn't address the substantive points made.

If not, thanks anyway.
 
No. It is missing the point. And you yourself admit that OWS cannot overthrow the govt. So a coalition with them is in my best interest. Your rhetoric is just silly. BTW: Now you are moving the goal posts. First it was distrust organizations that lie. I point out that I cannot find perfectly honest organizations so you shift to something else.

Sophistry. You can do better.

So you're willing to form a coalition with the radical left, a group whose sole purpose is to criticize and mock everything about western society, just to get rid of a few oil subsidies and stabilize housing prices ?
 
Stout, Axiom isn't being snarky. This really isn't compelling. I get it. I really do. But it doesn't advance the discussion. I'm not asking you to give it up but could you offer something substantive also? I think some good points have been made by Axiom, your appeal to derision isn't logically valid. It's interesting. It's just that it doesn't address the substantive points made.

If not, thanks anyway.

Like I said

Be the change you want to see in the world

If you don't want my words, then listen to the Indian Guy.
 
Leftist professors attend Occupy Wall Street conference....in Iran.

The old leftist-Islamist alliance strikes again.
 
So you're willing to form a coalition with the radical left, a group whose sole purpose is to criticize and mock everything about western society, just to get rid of a few oil subsidies and stabilize housing prices ?
I'm willing to form a coalition with OWS. I don't accept that thier sole purpose is to criticize and mock everything about western society (that's ad hominem poisoning the well and it's getting a bit one trick pony). Further I reject your characterization of their "sole" purpose. Oil subsidies and housing prices being the very least of my concerns.

  • IMO: The corruption and influence of many corporations over govt is deep and entrenched.
  • It threatens our society and capitalism itself.
  • The results of the housing crises harmed many people in very fundamental ways. Investments and retirement accounts were wiped out. The collapse carried over into many other areas sending our economy into a sever recession.
 
Last edited:
Like I said

Be the change you want to see in the world

If you don't want my words, then listen to the Indian Guy.
Yeah, that's really not helping. It's empty rhetoric. It's a nice bit of feel good cliche but it doesn't establish any proposition.
 
Hand woven clothing, now there's a project occupy can get their teeth into. Good quality hand made stuff, of course everybody won't be able to afford the huge wardrobes most of us have now a days but if we could bring that industry back to North America.....hummmmm.

Be the change you want to see in the world-Gandhi

Simple Innit ?

Another of the common criticisms of OWS is that they need to focus. This is a problem. It's not about occupying a wind-farm. It's not about Native American rights. It's not about animal rights. It's not about the war, either.

It's about Wall Street. We have to fix Wall Street and our corrupt government that keeps bailing them out. This is the salient issue. Not whether or not some kid bought an expensive phone. This is such divisive nonsense. If we're fighting for the same cause, I don't care if you have an iPhone, or Android, or friggin' walkie-talkie.
 
Leftist professors attend Occupy Wall Street conference....in Iran.

The old leftist-Islamist alliance strikes again.

And there goes Virus again... declaring that everything wrong with the world has everything to do with leftism!

Free Republic much?

:rolleyes:
 
You shouldn't ignore criticism. But it is important to recognize when that criticism is just a bunch of FUD being used by your enemies.
And people who are emotionally involved in something are rarely able to assess criticism logically. I've seen people who dismissed and ignored perfectly valid criticism of serious problems on their part because they were het up.

You're talking out of both sides of your mouth; either you can ignore criticism,(which FUD may still be) or you can't. Also, your use of "enemies" is telling of an Us v. Them mentality.

Or, on the other hand, don't go with a model because it's not 100% perfect? Which group has a better model than OWS...?

Straw man. Doing nothing, at this point, would be a better net gain than Occupy, IMO. Thousands of people, six months, and that HuffPost list is less than a dozen items. And several are a stretch. Compare that to the millions of taxpayer dollars spent by cities policing and cleaning up after them.
 
It's about Wall Street. We have to fix Wall Street and our corrupt government that keeps bailing them out. This is the salient issue. Not whether or not some kid bought an expensive phone. This is such divisive nonsense. If we're fighting for the same cause, I don't care if you have an iPhone, or Android, or friggin' walkie-talkie.

The only way you're going to "fix" Wall Street is to deny them the financial power that they've amassed, you'll be effectively voting with your dollars and speaking in a language they understand.

If you want to fix government, then go protest at where the government is, send your message directly to them rather than screwing around protesting at shareholders meetings.

Then drop all the extras, like immigrant rights and the environment, they have their own protest groups and there's no reason to slap the occupy brand on them if fixing Wall St. and government is indeed the the issue.
 
If you want to fix government, then go protest at where the government is, send your message directly to them rather than screwing around protesting at shareholders meetings.
Actually, though counter intuitive, it's a pretty damn good idea. It's not going to change the behavior of Wall Street directly but it focuses directly on the problem. It's not as if government isn't aware of the protests.

Then drop all the extras, like immigrant rights and the environment, they have their own protest groups and there's no reason to slap the occupy brand on them if fixing Wall St. and government is indeed the the issue.
All the "extras" didn't prevent the civil rights workers from success. You are entitled to an opinion but in the end it's just that. I think most people inside of OWS would find your "advice" condescending and self serving ad hominem.
 
All the "extras" didn't prevent the civil rights workers from success. You are entitled to an opinion but in the end it's just that. I think most people inside of OWS would find your "advice" condescending and self serving ad hominem.

Yes, of course it's just an opinion and of course occupy insiders don't want to hear it, it's peeing on the parade.

What I want to know, is what is occupy Canada going to do for me ?
 
Yes, of course it's just an opinion and of course occupy insiders don't want to hear it, it's peeing on the parade.
I don't think it has anything to do with whether they "want" to hear. I think that if they did hear it they would find it less than compelling. I'm sorry but that's my take. I think the real question is this, why should they care about your opinion?

What I want to know, is what is occupy Canada going to do for me ?
I don't know. If you are not interested in their mission statement then perhaps nothing. Perhaps you could take solace in the advice of Ghandi that you posted and be the change you want to see. I've no idea if that will solve anything but perhaps it will make it seem like it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom