Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Axiom_Blade;8219950 [i said:
What am I doing to help that effort to organize?[/i] If I have a solution, then I have to do whatever I can to help make that solution happen.

I'm trying to educate occupiers to not actively support the very institutions they're actively protesting. For some reason, this is falling on deaf ears.

I ask occupiers, hey, if you're worried about your privacy and government intrusion into your personal life, how come you're carrying a GPS enabled smartphone around. Don't you know They can track your every movement ?

Occupiers are unable to respond with anything other than " 'cause they're cool and I need to access the internet to check to the occupy camp via foursquare then update my facebook status, then tweet something, yea, this little gizmo is worth paying the bourgeoisie capitalist pigdog scum $80 a month for."

Occupiers seem genuinely perplexed that I can live without a smartphone, like they've been brainwashed by the corporations into believing this is a necessity.
 
I would never have to be dishonest or cower in fear for skepticism. No, I meant cynicism. The idea that any deception renders people/groups/movements without merit leaves me nowhere to turn. That is the logical extension of your argument and that is by definition cynical.

How much deception will you tolerate, especially from a movement whose sole focus is moral superiority ?
 
I'm trying to educate occupiers to not actively support the very institutions they're actively protesting. For some reason, this is falling on deaf ears.

I ask occupiers, hey, if you're worried about your privacy and government intrusion into your personal life, how come you're carrying a GPS enabled smartphone around. Don't you know They can track your every movement ?

Occupiers are unable to respond with anything other than " 'cause they're cool and I need to access the internet to check to the occupy camp via foursquare then update my facebook status, then tweet something, yea, this little gizmo is worth paying the bourgeoisie capitalist pigdog scum $80 a month for."
Of course, none of them are here to defend themselves. We only have your hearsay. But that's fine. Let's follow your logic.

If one has a problem with a product or govt service then one cannot use the product or service and be morally consistent. That's fallacious for a number of reasons. First off it is ad hominem poisoning the well. You are attacking the person instead of the person's arguments. One can expect more from their govt without having to opt out of society. If the protestors are claiming that cell phones with GPS are immoral then you would have an argument.

Occupiers seem genuinely perplexed that I can live without a smartphone, like they've been brainwashed by the corporations into believing this is a necessity.
Of course this is a lot of broad brush attacks on people who cannot defend themselves about something that is for many if not most irrelevant. Those who claim technology is a government means of controlling people and tracking them and use the technology can be said to be inconsistent.

Those who want and expect better privacy don't really have to give up their technology to be morally consistent.
 
30 years and this is the best we can do?
The consortioum was formed post-Macondo, recent blowout we all watched on tv.

Good for you. That's quite compelling I'm sure. Just as my laughing at the idiots in the GOP is compelling to you. And trust me on this, I laugh almost daily. So, we all laugh. Not sure what that is supposed to demonstrate.
I await something tangible idea-wise from OWS. At least tea-party had/has a few actual concerns.

I continue to be amazed you seem to find dielectical ideas in the mobs that characterized OWS.
 
How much deception will you tolerate, especially from a movement whose sole focus is moral superiority ?
That's a great question. I wonder if I ought to vote. I mean that with all sincerity. Look, I don't find a lot of honesty out there. I find Romney to be a shameless prevaricator. His dishonesty is so blatant and so craven that I look at the Republicans who support him and wonder, how on Earth can they stomach this man? And while Obama is measurably better it's far from saintly. So yeah, I'm back to sheer cynicism. You don't live in America so perhaps you don't have to put up with the likes of the GOP and their near daily baldfaced lies. But I have to live here. I have to make choices and prioritize my moral conflicts. OWS is small potatoes as far as that goes. They aren't making laws the way my legislators are. They don't hold the power to start wars or make policy by fiat.

Again, I simply can't afford your cynicism. I have to find away to deal with liars and manipulators of this world. OWS is the least of my worries.
 
The consortioum was formed post-Macondo, recent blowout we all watched on tv.
That's the best we can do after 30 years?

I await something tangible idea-wise from OWS. At least tea-party had/has a few actual concerns.
? I didn't vote for OWS. I only expect them to uncomfort the corrupt. And corruption and malfeasance are some pretty "actual" concerns.

I continue to be amazed you seem to find dielectical ideas in the mobs that characterized OWS.
I continue to be amazed that you can't. Perhaps more importantly, given the recent links, you don't even care to try.
 
Of course, none of them are here to defend themselves. We only have your hearsay. But that's fine. Let's follow your logic.

If one has a problem with a product or govt service then one cannot use the product or service and be morally consistent. That's fallacious for a number of reasons. First off it is ad hominem poisoning the well. You are attacking the person instead of the person's arguments. One can expect more from their govt without having to opt out of society. If the protestors are claiming that cell phones with GPS are immoral then you would have an argument.

So what do they mean when they, occupy make such a vague complaint about ?

They have sold our privacy as a commodity

Now how on earth did they obtain the information to sell as a commodity ? If occupy isn't going to up with the specifics and fill in the blanks, my skeptical mind naturally wanders and questions just what information they're concerned about being sold.

We all know how facebook makes their money and shunning it in favour of the more "correct" Diaspora would be a logical step, But noooooooo, it's all about the bookface groups, groups, ironically, which I don't have access to because I don't have an account. It's like occupy is demanding I enter my personal details into facebook, to be sold, just so I can protest my personal details being sold.
 
So what do they mean when they, occupy make such a vague complaint about ?
They have sold our privacy as a commodity
I think privacy is a legitimate concern. I don't know what the solutions are or if there is a solution. I'm completely at a loss as to how you dismiss an entire movement over something so trivial. They have a complaint and they are seeking redress, and? I mean, come on.

Now how on earth did they obtain the information to sell as a commodity ? If occupy isn't going to up with the specifics and fill in the blanks, my skeptical mind naturally wanders and questions just what information they're concerned about being sold.

We all know how facebook makes their money and shunning it in favour of the more "correct" Diaspora would be a logical step, But noooooooo, it's all about the bookface groups, groups, ironically, which I don't have access to because I don't have an account. It's like occupy is demanding I enter my personal details into facebook, to be sold, just so I can protest my personal details being sold.
Yeah, don't give a ****. Sorry. It's simply not a compelling reason to dismiss a movement.

Even if I thought you had a valid point, sometimes I side with the GOP and their group of liars and idiots and sometimes I side with the Democrats and their group of liars idiots. I joined the PTA and they had a gaggle of liars and idots. I was a long time member of the NRA and I still think they have something to offer and they're crawling with liars and idiots.

Look, you are ignoring my point to hammer home a trite point. If you refuse to acknowledge the fact that life, politics, conscience and a commitment to civic involvement forces me to make coalitions with people I don't entirely agree with then you simply are not showing good faith.

That part of the discussion was over with posts ago. I'm happy to oblige you for awhile but at some point I've got to ask you why you are ignoring the elephant in the room. Why are you ignoring the elephant in the room?
 
Last edited:
That's a great question. I wonder if I ought to vote. I mean that with all sincerity. Look, I don't find a lot of honesty out there.


Yes, I've heard the voting system is the US described as a choice between evil and diet evil.

I agree there's not a lot of honesty out there. That's not a political statement, it's a statement on the human condition. Pretty much everybody is acting in their own interests and if you want to call that statement cynical, then by all means do. That attitude has sure kept me from making some dumb purchases.

I have to find away to deal with liars and manipulators of this world.

They're usually pretty easy to spot, they tend to overdo it.
 
I'm sorry, how on Earth is that a valid comparison? Your toilet isn't a public good. That your toilet overflows doesn't harm thousands of people.

Please to explain?

If you don't think working toilets are a public good, you should take a look at the mortality rates from cholera in Haiti.
Other than in the explosion and fire on the rig (which I assume was an expense the oil companies would prefer to prevent), how many people died as a result of the blowout?
 
If you don't think working toilets are a public good, you should take a look at the mortality rates from cholera in Haiti.
Okay, let's advance the discussion. Let's grant the premise. Is there a compelling public health need to improve janitor technology?

Other than in the explosion and fire on the rig (which I assume was an expense the oil companies would prefer to prevent), how many people died as a result of the blowout?
Two years after, miles of coastline still have traces of oil. Marine life is still being harmed.

This was not necessary. The booms and skimmers were just as infective following the BP disaster as they were 30 years ago.

BP oil spill's health effects will be felt for generations, scientist warns

The BP oil spill: Two years on

How Does the BP Oil Spill Impact Wildlife and Habitat?

So, I will ask you again, how is it a valid comparison?
 
Last edited:
I think privacy is a legitimate concern. I don't know what the solutions are or if there is a solution. I'm completely at a loss as to how you dismiss an entire movement over something so trivial. They have a complaint and they are seeking redress, and? I mean, come on.

I'm not dismissing them over this one point, it's just one of a series of inconsistencies I, and others, have pointed out since this thread's inception.

"Oh poor us" the occupiers say, "we signed on to a free program, read the terms of service, agreed to them and now...we're victims"

If you refuse to acknowledge the fact that life, politics, conscience and a commitment to civic involvement forces me to make coalitions with people I don't entirely agree with then you simply are not showing good faith.

And if you. sir, are refusing to see what the core of the occupy movement is (anti-capitalism) then you will soon find yourself alienated from a movement you're currently only nibbling around the edges of.
 
I'm not dismissing them over this one point, it's just one of a series of inconsistencies I, and others, have pointed out since this thread's inception.
It's a valid concern and I don't, for the reasons I gave, find it inconsistent.

And if you. sir, are refusing to see what the core of the occupy movement is (anti-capitalism) then you will soon find yourself alienated from a movement you're currently only nibbling around the edges of.
OWS is not monolithic and the are supported by many capitalists. If you could show me plans of overthrowing the government I would then care. As it is they are trying to get people to wake up and face the corruption of govt and corporate influence.

If you can't show me how they plan on overthrowing the government (and how they could) then you are just engaging in ad hominem poisoning the well and demagoguery.
 
I'm trying to educate occupiers to not actively support the very institutions they're actively protesting. For some reason, this is falling on deaf ears.

That's still just criticism, though. You might see it as constructive, but it could be construed as concern trolling. Do you actually think that if every member of OWS threw away their smartphone, that would actually cause some tangible change? We all have to pick our battles. Obviously, some people don't think, like you do, that throwing away their smartphone is worth the effort (i.e. the tradeoff between loss of convenience and social change).

There's numerous examples of this. I don't use Facebook. This is due to their privacy issues, and because I see free/open source, decentralized networks, such as Diaspora, as a much better alternative. I prefer freedom over the convenience of Facebook. However, many of my friends do use Facebook, and refuse to sign up with Diaspora. This is either because A) they don't understand the issues, or B) don't consider them important enough to take a stand. I could stand back and mock them as "hypocrites", but I don't think that I'd keep my friends very long. The charitable thing to do is try to understand them, and explain to them my point of view. If I am unable to convince them, that is my failure, not theirs.

See, this is the important thing. Right now, OWS is pretty much the only game in town. We can stand back, and look down on them, and mock them, but if OWS fails, the US fails. The economic catastrophe is continuing. There've been some patches made, but the problems that created the meltdown are still there, and things are set up to get a lot worse before they get any better.

I'm assuming, of course, that you yourself don't use a smartphone. (I don't, either. But it's not because I want to "stick it to the man". It's because I can't afford it. I wouldn't get an iPhone or anything like that, because I don't like Apple's products or business models. If I were to get one, it'd probably be an Android from T-Mobile. That's separate from what I see as the relevance of OWS, though, which I see as largely a movement against government corruption, mainly as it pertains to financial institutions. So, unless your smartphone came from Bank of America, or something like that, I don't really know what the problem is?)
 
We all know how facebook makes their money and shunning it in favour of the more "correct" Diaspora would be a logical step, But noooooooo, it's all about the bookface groups, groups, ironically, which I don't have access to because I don't have an account. It's like occupy is demanding I enter my personal details into facebook, to be sold, just so I can protest my personal details being sold.

I think that Diaspora (or something like it) would be a logical step for all social movements. However, we're dealing with a couple of things here.

A) Like it or not, most of the people are on Facebook. So, a viable social movement has to have at least some Facebook presence. Fortunately, Diaspora and Friendica both have ways to push posts out to Facebook and Twitter, so you can handle all of your social networking from one interface.

B) Most activists, even those who are tech savvy, aren't educated on privacy or computing issues. They can see why recycling is important, but not why it's important to use free/open source software, or decentralized social networks. This is an education issue, and it's slowly changing. There are many Occupy accounts on Diaspora, but it seems to be more popular with groups like Anonymous, for obvious reasons. Again, OWS's main thrust isn't privacy or tech issues, but economic ones.

(Personally, getting an FB account in order to support a social movement wouldn't be a deal-breaker for me. I wouldn't quit my job if they made me get an FB account, either. I'd just make a dummy account that has as little useful info as possible. Cost/benefit analysis.)
 
Last edited:
Last week there was a massive toilet overflow in my bathroom. The technology to fight that spill was exactly as it was when it backed up forty years ago.

There are a lot of valid reasons to think plumbers don't have our best interests at heart. Their job is to make as much money as they can with as little effort as needed to avoid disaster.
How long will we put up with Big Plumbing refusing to innovate unless it puts money in their pockets?
I grew up in a country with US-style taps. Now in Europe, they have a tap each for the cold and hot water. There is no practical reason to do so, I think, since to get water to the right temperature, you have to put it in the basin, which is less sanitary than running water. I'm pretty sure it's so plumbers can make more money or something.

Which would make it the most mildly inconveniencing conspiracy ever.
 

Democratic lawmakers attributed Cuomo's move in part to the Occupy protesters who had targeted him across the street from the Capitol for months and had begun demonstrating just outside his office.
So they may have harassed an official into changing his mind.

Johnson said the bank had agreed to work with the church to help pay its mortgage after demonstrations by Occupy members. Demonstrators had set up a camp at the church in Atlanta's Vine City neighborhood, just west of downtown.

In January, Johnson learned his congregation would be allowed to stay in the building.
Is there any reason they didn't just give the Church the money?

Here's some more from Occupy Atlanta.
http://www.ajc.com/news/atlanta/12-occupy-atlanta-followers-1348372.html
http://www.examiner.com/article/19-occupy-atlanta-protesters-arrested-standoff-with-police
http://downtown.11alive.com/news/news/91068-apd-officers-occupied-during-occupy-atlanta
And here they are trying to stop what appears to be a legit eviction.

In Rhode Island, Occupy Providence pushed for – and won – a temporary day center to serve the homeless during the winter. Protesters made the center's opening a condition of their departure from a public park downtown, where they had camped against the city's wishes for more than three months.
"We'll leave the park we're in illegally only if you make a shelter."

Also from Occupy Rhode Island, they threw condoms at Pro-Lifers, including teenage girls, and otherwise disrupted the rally. I'm not sure what abortion has to do with the economy, but sure, why not.

Also in Rhode Island, the state's junior U.S. senator, Sheldon Whitehouse, introduced a bill in November to crack down on high credit card interest rates – the same week he visited the Providence encampment. While there was no direct relationship between Occupy and the bill, Whitehouse spokesman Seth Larson said Thursday, the legislation no doubt resonated with the protesters.
That's right, the article even includes things that it states have nothing to do with Occupy.

You've managed to change my mind. I'm going from "Occupy hasn't done anything" to "Occupy hasn't done much". As RandFan helpfully reminds us, Occupy is not a monolith. I still find it intellectually dishonest that OWS-supporters are willing to claim the beneficial actions, but once someone does something negative, they are No True Occupier'd faster the the US Government disavows Mission Impossible.

I also wonder about all the foreclosures they claim to have stopped. Won't that have some sort of negative economic effect down the line?

This is all East Coast stuff. In my neck of the woods (Pacific NW), I know Occupy did some protests/sit-ins to protect victims of foreclosures, also. I don't know how successful they were. The media doesn't like to cover stuff like this.

One of the hard lessons of activism I've learned is that it's really easy to throw rocks at what other people are doing. I can criticize, but if I have a better idea of how to fix our country, then I have to start putting in the effort to make it happen. Otherwise, I'm part of the problem.
Which is, by and large, exactly what Occupy does when they say they're "raising awareness". RandFan even made much saltwater about how they might eventually get around to doing something significant, just like the civil rights movement, really.

I'm not pointing fingers at you, or anybody else in particular, but if I find myself looking at OWS and saying "Jeeze, those guys need to get it together and organize!" then the question becomes What am I doing to help that effort to organize? If I have a solution, then I have to do whatever I can to help make that solution happen.
And I'm not. I found them vague and undirected from when I first heard of them, and nothing has really changed. Well, I have a lot more contempt than I did last fall, especially when I look at how they insist on portraying themselves as the innocent victims even when they knowingly and deliberately break the law, specifically by showing only the police response and not what they were responding to.

Most notably, in the UC Davis incident, where the "peaceful protestors" were attempting to obstruct the police's transport of their lawful prisoners, and the policeman had specifically tried to get them to leave using lesser force. Yet whenever this is actually pointed out to Occupy-supporters, they make excuses or outright ignore it. How are people outside the movement supposed to solve Occupy's problems when Occupy itself doesn't even acknowledge them? I am under no moral or ethical obligation to do so, I think.
 
That's still just criticism, though. You might see it as constructive, but it could be construed as concern trolling. Do you actually think that if every member of OWS threw away their smartphone, that would actually cause some tangible change? We all have to pick our battles. Obviously, some people don't think, like you do, that throwing away their smartphone is worth the effort (i.e. the tradeoff between loss of convenience and social change)....
"Concern trolling" is, generally, used as an excuse to ignore actual valid criticism by attacking the motivations of the person providing it. In almost every case, it ignores the actual content of the message.

...See, this is the important thing. Right now, OWS is pretty much the only game in town. We can stand back, and look down on them, and mock them, but if OWS fails, the US fails....
Wild hyperbole aside, go with a flawed model because they're the only model? I don't think that's a very good idea, since OWS is all about change. If it can't even change itself, on what grounds can it demand change of others?
 
I think that Diaspora (or something like it) would be a logical step for all social movements. However, we're dealing with a couple of things here.

A) Like it or not, most of the people are on Facebook. So, a viable social movement has to have at least some Facebook presence. Fortunately, Diaspora and Friendica both have ways to push posts out to Facebook and Twitter, so you can handle all of your social networking from one interface.
If Occupy is the 99%, where's their network?

B) Most activists, even those who are tech savvy, aren't educated on privacy or computing issues. They can see why recycling is important, but not why it's important to use free/open source software, or decentralized social networks. This is an education issue, and it's slowly changing. There are many Occupy accounts on Diaspora, but it seems to be more popular with groups like Anonymous, for obvious reasons. Again, OWS's main thrust isn't privacy or tech issues, but economic ones....
Doesn't matter what their main thrust is. They specifically mention privacy in their manifesto, yet take actions that actively lessen that privacy. Which means they're either hypocrites, or the manifesto is wrong. Once again, OWS talks the talk, but doesn't walk the walk.
 
That's still just criticism, though. You might see it as constructive, but it could be construed as concern trolling. Do you actually think that if every member of OWS threw away their smartphone, that would actually cause some tangible change? We all have to pick our battles. Obviously, some people don't think, like you do, that throwing away their smartphone is worth the effort (i.e. the tradeoff between loss of convenience and social change).

Nah, it's not concern trolling, it's an outright attack. Occupy says "corporations are bad mmmmmkay" I say stop supporting them then, occupy says "no". Consumerism is the very source of the corporations power, the more we buy the more wealthy and influential, influential as in they can offer a politician a plum job after that politician gives up politics and wants to enter the private sector to make some real money.

I don't use facebook because I'm boring. nobody wants to hear which supermodel I'm banging this week, which Ferrari I'm driving today nor what colour I painted the helicopter. If I did use it I'd be like your friends who don't really give a rip and be careful about what I posted on it. As we all know, the internet is forever.

See, this is the important thing. Right now, OWS is pretty much the only game in town. We can stand back, and look down on them, and mock them, but if OWS fails, the US fails.

We can take them to task until they get it right. Oh, and I posit that the US would have to fail before occupy, as it stands now, can succeed. Anti-capitalism can only lead to one form of government.

I don't use a smartphone simply because I don't want one. I kind of like being unreachable when I'm out and about and as a bonus, the money I save, about a grand a year, allows me to fly off to some warm tropical destination every January.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom