I'm trying to educate occupiers to not actively support the very institutions they're actively protesting. For some reason, this is falling on deaf ears.
That's still just criticism, though. You might see it as constructive, but it could be construed as
concern trolling. Do you actually think that if every member of OWS threw away their smartphone, that would actually cause some tangible change? We all have to pick our battles. Obviously, some people don't think, like you do, that throwing away their smartphone is worth the effort (i.e. the tradeoff between loss of convenience and social change).
There's numerous examples of this. I don't use Facebook. This is due to their privacy issues, and because I see free/open source, decentralized networks, such as Diaspora, as a much better alternative. I prefer freedom over the convenience of Facebook. However, many of my friends do use Facebook, and refuse to sign up with Diaspora. This is either because A) they don't understand the issues, or B) don't consider them important enough to take a stand. I could stand back and mock them as "hypocrites", but I don't think that I'd keep my friends very long. The charitable thing to do is try to understand them, and explain to them my point of view. If I am unable to convince them, that is
my failure,
not theirs.
See, this is the important thing. Right now, OWS is pretty much the only game in town. We can stand back, and look down on them, and mock them, but if OWS fails, the US fails. The economic catastrophe is continuing. There've been some patches made, but the problems that created the meltdown are still there, and things are set up to get a lot worse before they get any better.
I'm assuming, of course, that you yourself don't use a smartphone. (I don't, either. But it's not because I want to "stick it to the man". It's because I can't afford it. I wouldn't get an iPhone or anything like that, because I don't like Apple's products or business models. If I were to get one, it'd probably be an Android from T-Mobile. That's separate from what I see as the relevance of OWS, though, which I see as largely a movement against government corruption, mainly as it pertains to financial institutions. So, unless your smartphone came from Bank of America, or something like that, I don't really know what the problem is?)