Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually for Big Oil and its' bottom line it's dictated by transport and storage costs, crude price, transport and storage costs, type of crude as it effects refining costs and output slate, more transport and storage costs, and gas station costs (most stations are lucky to make 2 cents / gallon on gas).
Actually it's what the market will bear. Economics 101. That's not going to change. Costs put pressure on the retail price of gas but in the end if the oil companies can have a larger market and make more money by charging less they will do so. If they can get the same amount of money with subsidies as they can without then they won't lower prices. The only pressure to move prices down is competition. If the subsidies are sufficient and one or more competitors can use the subsidies to cut prices then subsidies can put pressure on the market. There is simply no evidence that subsidies are sufficient to influence the wholesale price of oil or the retail price of gas.

The problem that you are missing is that oil is fungible and is subject to many global variables. Subsidies are so miniscule they are less than a rounding error of the entire market.

Even if we assume that subsidies could change the price of oil, we would be spending money to affect the price of gas for everyone (see chart below). Better to just give Americans vouchers for gas. So, in the end the subsidies do nothing for the price of gas in America.

And the awareness was raised by people who specific agendas, which as yet OCS lacks. Corporations Bad just doesn't get specific enough to pique popular awareness.
This is just a meme. I grew up in the 60s. The mythology about the civil rights movement serves no purpose. There were many conflicting specific agendas and lots of feel good "stop the man" rhetoric. Many wanted communism (hence all of the communes). Many wanted to end the war. Etc., etc..

Agreed, but speech without reasonably specific content remains meaningless babble.
Reasonably specific enough for me. Govt appears to be largely feckless to act against the rich and powerful who ensure their govt lapdogs have plenty of campaign cash and vacations in Aspen (or wherever the kids are hanging out these days).


worldgasprices.gif
 
Last edited:
I don't think it is. I think he's just personally irritated by certain negative criticisms of the movement he supports.

It is perfectly relevant to point out what one sees as hypocrisy in a movement. If a group claims to want to reach certain goals, yet advocates/performs actions that seem to run counter to said goals, then pointing such out is a perfectly valid criticism of them.

I agree and I'm aware of one major reason for that support.

I find it interesting how OWS likes to divide the world into the evil 1% and the 99% they claim to represent, yet willingly ignore criticism from said 99%. I also wonder what it means when someone is not a True Occupier but also, clearly, not part of the 1%.

Yes, that's always intrigued me too. Typical responses say I/we need to get educated, that we're the sheeple, that we're negative nellies.

It's interesting on the energy issue as they're all over ideas like the water engine, orbo, zero point, the 200 mpg carburetor and even just sucking free energy right out of the ether. There's an insistence that all of there miracle sources would be readily available except, you know who, is quashing them.

Then there's the legit sources, solar etc. Pointing out the shortcomings of these sources as anything more than a supplement to oil and nuclear is also met with "that's what they want you to think" or outright dismissal as not being a valid concern ( along with accusations of trolling, of course )
 
BTW: Nothing will likely get done if there isn't protest and people are made aware so they can act. The rich and powerful don't want to change. It will only happen when enough people care and are willing to show they care.

People don't want to change either. We've been talking about peak oil and AGW for how long ? Yet the world's demand, especially among developing countries, for energy increases.

Everybody, everywhere wants these corporate produced goods. Even occupiers.
 
People don't want to change either. We've been talking about peak oil and AGW for how long ? Yet the world's demand, especially among developing countries, for energy increases.

Everybody, everywhere wants these corporate produced goods. Even occupiers.
I accept your premises. I'm not sure though that they are valid reasons to oppose OWS.

How long did people talk about ending slavery before the Civil war? How long did people talk about ending segregation? Laws to advance the rights of women?

The status quo is the status quo in large part because it serves a purpose. There is real social inertia and I'm happy to grant that, but I don't see how it's possible to then infer that--

  • Because of the difficulty of X (address energy needs) we shouldn't do Y (protest govt inaction and subsidies).
  • Because A (OWS) wants and uses B (cheap energy) then we shouldn't do anything to change any of the dynamics of B.
I think you have two incomplete arguments. Get me from X to Y and A to B?
 
Last edited:
Ok, but we'll take the occupy routes(s)

Big government should make big oil stop suppressing alternative energy. Freed from it's shackles, alternative energy eclipses oil and oil is phased out, like witch burning. Everybody does a happy dance and sings hu...the end.

Changing the dynamics of B is what I'm on about ie quit using it.
 
Ok, but we'll take the occupy routes(s)

Big government should make big oil stop suppressing alternative energy. Freed from it's shackles, alternative energy eclipses oil and oil is phased out, like witch burning. Everybody does a happy dance and sings hu...the end.
Thanks. I think there are other ways to deal with oil companies and our dependance of oil. I think first off we need to stop the subsidies. I've not seen any evidence that oil companies are suppressing anything. I'm open to ideas and evidence. Let's as a nation have that discussion. I don't see a problem with that. If OWS sparks a conversation and helps us move in direction to increase other sources of energy I'd be for that.

FWIW: If oil were the only thing OWS was about I likely wouldn't care about them. I'm far more concerned about corporate corruption than anything else. But it's a fair point to start a discussion about and I wouldn't dismiss them out of hand just for that.

Changing the dynamics of B is what I'm on about ie quit using it.
There are lots of other ways to change the dynamics of B. This seems to be a straw man. I don't support calls for anarchy and if OWS is calling for an end to oil production I wouldn't be for that either. Do you have evidence that they are? In any event, I think the discussion a worthy one. Further, I'd still be supporting OWS as I think the issues of corporate corruption most compelling and that was what brought me into OWS to begin with. Wall Street and the ridiculous derivatives and mortgage crap.

  • So, please to demonstrate that OWS wants to end oil production (assuming that is your point)?
  • Explain how OWS can stop oil production?
  • Explain how these issues, even if we grant you your premises is reason to dismiss OWS?
 
Last edited:
I haven't seen any evidence that big oil is suppressing alternative energy either. Occupy must have though they must be basing that claim on something. Maybe they watched Who Killed the Electric Car or something.

Or maybe it makes a nice sound bite, we're all "victims" of big oil.

So then, is making things up an acceptable premise to dismiss OWS ?

Here's the thing about far left politics. It's all about being a victim. THRY are doing this to US. THEY are BAD and WE are good ultra moral mega ethical citizens who are having our lives ( and the planet ) ruined by the evil kitten eating corporations in their relentless quest for profits. THEY bad WE good.

Of course, them, is really us but why quibble over that ?

No all you need do to be a good progressive citizen is complain, complain complain. Feel free to gobble up as many of the planet's resources as you feel you need all you need do is envision a "better" society and whine that it hasn't been handed to you. Pssssssaw, reduce demand, that's for chumps. Sure, get on that plane to Bali, just remember to slap some "save the planet" stickers on your luggage, you know spread the message, raise awareness.

After all

Derrick Jensen has your back.
 
"Hey, could someone pass the buck?" :D

I like how the very first comment is, yep, blaming the companies for lying to people about environmental impact.

Good that Mr, Jensen points this out. I think that not too far down the line there is going to be an epidemic of disappointed anger on the part of all the good folks who have separated their trash, used fluorescent light bulbs, driven hybrids, shortened the length of their showers, and generally tried to live ecologically correct lives. They will be enraged and disappointed to discover that it hasn't made any difference when they were told it would.

The big corporations, with their "human energy; will you join us?" ads proclaiming themselves "part of the solution" will, in time, contribute to the anger when people begin to grasp that these institutions are trying to use marketing spin to persuade us that they're solving the problems when they aren't.

The only question is: Will the environment deteriorate fast enough so that people will be spending too much time and energy being ecological refugees, just trying to survive, to have time to be mad at how badly they are being scammed?
So when people think they're solving the problems, people take the credit, but when people learn they're not, its the corporations' fault.

Reminds me of the story about the military bigwigs arguing about who should get the credit for successful maneuvers in the recent wargames, until they finally turn to the most senior general and ask him. He says "I don't know who gets to take the credit for winning, but I know who would've taken the blame if we lost."
 
Last edited:
I haven't seen any evidence that big oil is suppressing alternative energy either. Occupy must have though they must be basing that claim on something. Maybe they watched Who Killed the Electric Car or something.

Or maybe it makes a nice sound bite, we're all "victims" of big oil.
30 years ago there was a massive oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The technology to fight the spill was exactly as it was when the BP spill happened two years ago. Oil companies don't care to improve their technology. There is a lot of valid reason to think oil companies don't have our best interest at heart. There job is to make as much money as they can with as little effort as needed to avoid disaster.

So then, is making things up an acceptable premise to dismiss OWS ?

Here's the thing about far left politics. It's all about being a victim. THRY are doing this to US. THEY are BAD and WE are good ultra moral mega ethical citizens who are having our lives ( and the planet ) ruined by the evil kitten eating corporations in their relentless quest for profits. THEY bad WE good.

Of course, them, is really us but why quibble over that ?

No all you need do to be a good progressive citizen is complain, complain complain. Feel free to gobble up as many of the planet's resources as you feel you need all you need do is envision a "better" society and whine that it hasn't been handed to you. Pssssssaw, reduce demand, that's for chumps. Sure, get on that plane to Bali, just remember to slap some "save the planet" stickers on your luggage, you know spread the message, raise awareness.

After all
Can we dismiss the entire GOP field for making things up? I mean flat out lying? And no, I don't mean tu quoque, it's wrong to lie. But we have to deal with what we have. Romney has lied so much, so often, it's amazing that he's in the race. And Obama, while better, isn't that much better. Your complaints are ad hoc. You have erected this condition that says only perfect people can complain about real problems. I think that's silly, and again, ad hoc rationalization. You also seek to divide, to pit one group against the other. Now, from a political stand point I understand that.

Take the GOP, they have gotten in bed with some of the worst and most cynical elements of American politics. Right-wing fanatics have turned the GOP into a laughing stock of extremism and religious nuttery. I could regale you with pages of text of how the lunatics have seized control but I don't see the point of that anymore than I see your point of attacking the excesses of the left in an attempt to smear everyone. I'm no more loyal to the left wing nuts as I am the moral majority. But if, IF, the right wing nuts were trying to stop corporate corruption I damn sure as hell would side with them in that endeavor.

The problems are real. Until now people were asleep and couldn't care less. I don't know if OWS can rouse them. I sure as hell hope so.
 
Last edited:
30 years ago there was a massive oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The technology to fight the spill was exactly as it was when the BP spill happened two years ago. Oil companies don't care to improve their technology. There is a lot of valid reason to think oil companies don't have our best interest at heart. There job is to make as much money as they can with as little effort as needed to avoid disaster.

Last week there was a massive toilet overflow in my bathroom. The technology to fight that spill was exactly as it was when it backed up forty years ago.

There are a lot of valid reasons to think plumbers don't have our best interests at heart. Their job is to make as much money as they can with as little effort as needed to avoid disaster.
How long will we put up with Big Plumbing refusing to innovate unless it puts money in their pockets?
 
I'm under no illusions that oil companies have our best interests at heart, I don't expect any corporation, or any business for that matter to have anything but their bottom line as their primary focus. Sure, it helps if they try to woo me, try to make and keep me happy but we know at the end of the day what we have is a business relationship.

Speaking of oil spill technology, just last night on Discovery channel they ran a segment about carbon nanotubes mixed with something, I can't remember what but the idea with these was, you toss them into an oil spill, scoop them up with magnets and simply burn the oil off before dumping them back onto the spill. Dunno who developed the technology though.

I'm sure you're right about the GOP, Obama and their lies. I haven't being paying attention as I don't live in the US. Occupy, however, is something that happened in my immediate vicinity and dominated my local newsfeeds.

I'm not up for political extremism of any stripe in fact I was surprised that the tea party and occupiers got together. I figured they'd annihilate each other, like matter and anti-matter. But now I'm thinking they should get together and mate, maybe they'll produce a offspring movement that the majority of the population can get behind.

Occupy is pretty much dead, it's an exmovement, and the only reason we're still discussing it is because someone has nailed it to the internet. Popular support has fallen off dramatically. They had it, they really did. At it's inception I was astounded by the amount of support occupy got but in the end, they blew it.

Occupy failed to raise any meaningful awareness, sure researching TARP wrt to bank bailouts was interesting but it only led to questioning why occupy was leaving the repayments, plus interest, out of the conversation.

Locally we learned about 9/11 and chemtrails with one group even voicing their opposition to wind turbines because the shadows on the ground caused epileptic seizures.

It was too much, too fast and with all the generalisations and competing conspiracy theories the message of which corporations were corrupt and how quickly got lost amongst the massive amounts of chaff occupy fed to the media.
 
Last week there was a massive toilet overflow in my bathroom. The technology to fight that spill was exactly as it was when it backed up forty years ago.

There are a lot of valid reasons to think plumbers don't have our best interests at heart. Their job is to make as much money as they can with as little effort as needed to avoid disaster.
How long will we put up with Big Plumbing refusing to innovate unless it puts money in their pockets?
I'm sorry, how on Earth is that a valid comparison? Your toilet isn't a public good. That your toilet overflows doesn't harm thousands of people.

Please to explain?
 
I'm under no illusions that oil companies have our best interests at heart, I don't expect any corporation, or any business for that matter to have anything but their bottom line as their primary focus. Sure, it helps if they try to woo me, try to make and keep me happy but we know at the end of the day what we have is a business relationship.

Speaking of oil spill technology, just last night on Discovery channel they ran a segment about carbon nanotubes mixed with something, I can't remember what but the idea with these was, you toss them into an oil spill, scoop them up with magnets and simply burn the oil off before dumping them back onto the spill. Dunno who developed the technology though.

I'm sure you're right about the GOP, Obama and their lies. I haven't being paying attention as I don't live in the US. Occupy, however, is something that happened in my immediate vicinity and dominated my local newsfeeds.

I'm not up for political extremism of any stripe in fact I was surprised that the tea party and occupiers got together. I figured they'd annihilate each other, like matter and anti-matter. But now I'm thinking they should get together and mate, maybe they'll produce a offspring movement that the majority of the population can get behind.

Occupy is pretty much dead, it's an exmovement, and the only reason we're still discussing it is because someone has nailed it to the internet. Popular support has fallen off dramatically. They had it, they really did. At it's inception I was astounded by the amount of support occupy got but in the end, they blew it.

Occupy failed to raise any meaningful awareness, sure researching TARP wrt to bank bailouts was interesting but it only led to questioning why occupy was leaving the repayments, plus interest, out of the conversation.

Locally we learned about 9/11 and chemtrails with one group even voicing their opposition to wind turbines because the shadows on the ground caused epileptic seizures.

It was too much, too fast and with all the generalisations and competing conspiracy theories the message of which corporations were corrupt and how quickly got lost amongst the massive amounts of chaff occupy fed to the media.
Some interesting points but I don't find your opinions about OWS compelling. I've no idea if it is dead. There were many starts and stops during the civil rights movement. I'm not at all interested in finding some judgement about success as that strikes me as naive and pointless. One could pick many points over many years of the civil rights movement, declared it dead and a waste of time. Nothing you've said about OWS couldn't have been said about the civil rights movement. In fact, either I or my parents probably said those very same thing.

So, while I appreciate and respect your opinions I don't accept your judgement or characterization of the movement. If I viewed the world through such a cynical lens I'd either have to be very dishonest with myself and rely on mountains of special pleading or just cower in a corner.

I do very much think OWS has a significant impact on public perception. What I don't know is whether or not it will have any lasting impression. I just honestly don't know. I do know this, this kind of nonsense won't continue indefinitely. OWS will rise again or there will be other groups. You can't **** people forever. At some point enough will wake up and realize that they are not powerless. History has plenty of examples.
 
30 years ago there was a massive oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The technology to fight the spill was exactly as it was when the BP spill happened two years ago. Oil companies don't care to improve their technology. There is a lot of valid reason to think oil companies don't have our best interest at heart. There job is to make as much money as they can with as little effort as needed to avoid disaster.
A consortium was formed to address oil-spill cleanup. It hasn't received press coverage sfaik. I do recall a comment on tv that a new group got a $million for demonstrating the the best oil-recovery technique.

Can we dismiss the entire GOP field for making things up? I mean flat out lying? And no, I don't mean tu quoque, it's wrong to lie. But we have to deal with what we have. Romney has lied so much, so often, it's amazing that he's in the race. And Obama, while better, isn't that much better. Your complaints are ad hoc. You have erected this condition that says only perfect people can complain about real problems. I think that's silly, and again, ad hoc rationalization. You also seek to divide, to pit one group against the other. Now, from a political stand point I understand that.

Take the GOP, they have gotten in bed with some of the worst and most cynical elements of American politics. Right-wing fanatics have turned the GOP into a laughing stock of extremism and religious nuttery. I could regale you with pages of text of how the lunatics have seized control but I don't see the point of that anymore than I see your point of attacking the excesses of the left in an attempt to smear everyone. I'm no more loyal to the left wing nuts as I am the moral majority. But if, IF, the right wing nuts were trying to stop corporate corruption I damn sure as hell would side with them in that endeavor.

The problems are real. Until now people were asleep and couldn't care less. I don't know if OWS can rouse them. I sure as hell hope so.
It roused me to point and laugh.
 
Last edited:
A consortium was formed to address oil-spill cleanup. It hasn't received press coverage sfaik. I do recall a comment on tv that a new group got a $million for demonstrating the the best oil-recovery technique.
30 years and this is the best we can do?

It roused me to point and laugh.
Good for you. That's quite compelling I'm sure. Just as my laughing at the idiots in the GOP is compelling to you. And trust me on this, I laugh almost daily. So, we all laugh. Not sure what that is supposed to demonstrate.
 
About as long as we wait for OWS to get anything done, I suspect.

Here are some of the things that OWS has gotten done. <5 minutes with Google.

This is all East Coast stuff. In my neck of the woods (Pacific NW), I know Occupy did some protests/sit-ins to protect victims of foreclosures, also. I don't know how successful they were. The media doesn't like to cover stuff like this.

One of the hard lessons of activism I've learned is that it's really easy to throw rocks at what other people are doing. I can criticize, but if I have a better idea of how to fix our country, then I have to start putting in the effort to make it happen. Otherwise, I'm part of the problem. I'm not pointing fingers at you, or anybody else in particular, but if I find myself looking at OWS and saying "Jeeze, those guys need to get it together and organize!" then the question becomes What am I doing to help that effort to organize? If I have a solution, then I have to do whatever I can to help make that solution happen.
 
If occupy isn't dead where is it then ? This movement that told us it was going to go on everyday, forever ?

OH, they're still on their winter vacation ( spring training in occuspeak ) and waiting for the M1GS.

We'll see then whether the movement is dead, alive, or merely an animated corpse. Will this year's suicide by stupid attempt actually succeed ? Or will they have learned from their past mistakes and figured out a way to actually relate to the 99% ?

If I viewed the world through such a cynical lens I'd either have to be very dishonest with myself and rely on mountains of special pleading or just cower in a corner.

Cynical...you meant skeptical, right ? Good.
 
If occupy isn't dead where is it then ? This movement that told us it was going to go on everyday, forever ?

OH, they're still on their winter vacation ( spring training in occuspeak ) and waiting for the M1GS.

We'll see then whether the movement is dead, alive, or merely an animated corpse. Will this year's suicide by stupid attempt actually succeed ? Or will they have learned from their past mistakes and figured out a way to actually relate to the 99% ?
I've no idea if they are dead or not. But I'm very grateful for their contributions regardless and I strongly suspect that if OWS is dead other groups will be coming along shortly. You can't **** people forever and get away with it.

Cynical...you meant skeptical, right ?
I would never have to be dishonest or cower in fear for skepticism. No, I meant cynicism. The idea that any deception renders people/groups/movements without merit leaves me nowhere to turn. That is the logical extension of your argument and that is by definition cynical.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom