Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'd just like to say that I'm more than happy to engage anyone who can in good faith discuss the issues of this thread. I will to commit to set aside snarky comments. Not always easy for me but I would sincerely like that conversation. :)
 
Maybe you're not getting my point.

If it's changes like the ones you mentioned upthead is what you're looking for, then hitching your wagon to Occupy's team is going to pull it far past your intended destination. Far far past.
 
If it's changes like the ones you mentioned upthead is what you're looking for, then hitching your wagon to Occupy's team is going to pull it far past your intended destination. Far far past.
Thanks. That's an assertion. I don't accept your assertion. So, now what do we do? You have asserted a proposition without any supporting premises. I don't accept your proposition so there is nothing more for me to do but gainsay. It's a non starter.

To quote Monty Python, "an argument is an intelectual process... [consisting of] "a connected series of statements to establish a definite proposition."

You skipped the argument and went straight to the proposition. What you have done is simply made an assertion. Which is fine but without supporting premises and in an attempt to persuade others, it's a fallacy.
 
Well heck it's not my problem if you can't see occupy as a radical left group. Look, they even say it here., first paragraph.

So, now that we've established there is no contradiction, let's proceed with some more rhetoric, this is politics after all.

EDIT...Ok that's over the top even for me, content deleted, but damn, it sure was fun to write.
 
Last edited:
Well heck it's not my problem if you can't see occupy as a radical left group. Look, they even say it here., first paragraph.

So, now that we've established there is no contradiction, let's proceed with some more rhetoric, this is politics after all.

EDIT...Ok that's over the top even for me, content deleted, but damn, it sure was fun to write.
I'm sorry, what exactly does that have to do with your proposition? Let's assume for sake of argument that OWS is a monolithic radical left group. How does that demonstrate that my supporting OWS will take me further than my destination? Get me from point A to point B without simply asserting it?

BTW: That this is a politics forum doesn't excuse you from rational discourse and avoiding fallacy and empty rhetoric. If I honestly thought that most people on this forum didn't care about reason then I wouldn't be here. After 10 years and 40,000 posts I know better. Honestly, if you don't care about skepticism and critical thinking then please let me know and I won't waste any further time on this.
 
Last edited:
A couple of points to keep in mind...

  • It has not been demonstrated that OWS is a monolithic radical left movement.
  • It has not been demonstrated that the primary or major goal of OWS is simply to destroy Democracy and any and all forms of capitalism.
Now, I don't want to be accused of attacking straw man. If these are not your positions then please to let me know and I will apologize. However, if I am wrong in attributing these propositions to you then tell me what are the goals that I should be afraid of?

Please consider that it's possible to share common values with groups of differing ideology. The political term for this is "coalition".

wiki said:
A coalition is a pact or treaty among individuals or groups, during which they cooperate in joint action, each in their own self-interest, joining forces together for a common cause. This alliance may be temporary or a matter of convenience. A coalition thus differs from a more formal covenant. Possibly described as a joining of 'factions', usually those with overlapping interests rather than opposing.

The common cause between OWS and myself is to raise awareness about corporate corruption and the failure of govt to investigate and oversee business and financial institutions.

FTR: The notion that a group in America is going to overthrow the constitution or anything akin to that is, IMHO, simply drinking the Kool-aid.
 
Last edited:
There's no need to assume, we know occupy is a radical left movement. As to monolithic they'll never be that due to there being so many pet issues and causes that infighting over who and what gets precedence will prevent them from ever getting it together.

I just showed you where occupy called themselves the radical left, earlier today I posted a Press TV articled that referred to occupy as an anti capitalist movement and that's just today's occupy offerings.

If you think that radical left politics are going to stop at dealing with things like oil subsidies and the sugar industry, I suggest you familiarise yourself with the ideology. It's about tearing down the whole system. If that's what you're after then, by all means keep supporting occupy however if there's "a few changes" you want to see made then best to form or join something that's not wearing a leather jacket, on the beach in Hawaii, watching a water ski competition, looking at a shark in a circular pen and formulating a "great" idea.

I am the 99%
 
If you think that radical left politics are going to stop at dealing with things like oil subsidies and the sugar industry, I suggest you familiarise yourself with the ideology.
Someone damn well should deal with things like oil subsidies and the sugar industry. These are absurd. Oil is around $100 a barrel and there is no reason I know of to prop up the sugar industry. It's just a double dipping tax on Americans. We get higher priced goods and we prop up the industry for the privilege. Someone explain that to me?

It's about tearing down the whole system.
  • Source?
  • Don't care. I share their goals to raise awareness about corporate corruption govt malfeasance.
If that's what you're after...
I'm after raising awareness about corporate corruption and govt malfeasance.

...then, by all means keep supporting occupy however if there's "a few changes" you want to see made then best to form or join something that's not wearing a leather jacket, on the beach in Hawaii, watching a water ski competition, looking at a shark in a circular pen and formulating a "great" idea.
I'm very happy with OWS. They have actually raised awareness about corporate corruption and govt malfeasance.

If Nixon can go to China then I can go to OWS.

I am the 99%
So am I. And I'm going to support any group that seeks to raise awareness about corporate corruption and malfeasance.
 
Last edited:
We know all about corporate corruption, thing is, we don't really care, we just keep on buying their goods and supporting them.

For instance.

OWS manifesto claims that oil and gas are suppressing alternative energy, yet occupiers continue to buy oil knowing they can get off the grid. It's just inconvenient and nowhere as much fun as going to a march/action.
 
We know all about corporate corruption, thing is, we don't really care, we just keep on buying their goods and supporting them.
I understand the cynicism. Imagine the cynicism of all the people who fought for many years for things like women's rights and ending segregation. Not much gets done if we just ignore the corruption because gosh, it's hard. First we must raise awareness.

OWS manifesto claims that oil and gas are suppressing alternative energy, yet occupiers continue to buy oil knowing they can get off the grid. It's just inconvenient and nowhere as much fun as going to a march/action.
It's not all that easy to get off the grid. But, even if we grant you the proposition, your argument is ad hominem. Poisoning the well.
 
they have inspired several bills, ask of which were filibustered by the GOP.

So when they do try to get something done, and can't, its someone else's fault.

What bills were these?

We know all about corporate corruption, thing is, we don't really care, we just keep on buying their goods and supporting them.

For instance.

OWS manifesto claims that oil and gas are suppressing alternative energy, yet occupiers continue to buy oil knowing they can get off the grid. It's just inconvenient and nowhere as much fun as going to a march/action.

Also, this;
 

Attachments

  • occupyWallStreet.jpg
    occupyWallStreet.jpg
    86.1 KB · Views: 17
Someone damn well should deal with things like oil subsidies and the sugar industry. These are absurd. Oil is around $100 a barrel and there is no reason I know of to prop up the sugar industry. It's just a double dipping tax on Americans. We get higher priced goods and we prop up the industry for the privilege. Someone explain that to me?
Removing the current annual oil Co. subsidies of ~~$4 billion/yr will likely not effect the $100/bbl, but sure may increase price at pump.

Sugar subsidies are insane.

I'm very happy with OWS. They have actually raised awareness about corporate corruption and govt malfeasance.

If Nixon can go to China then I can go to OWS.

So am I. And I'm going to support any group that seeks to raise awareness about corporate corruption and malfeasance.
Now if anyone figures out how to accomplish something based on that fabled raised awareness. :(:rolleyes::)
 
It's not all that easy to get off the grid. But, even if we grant you the proposition, your argument is ad hominem. Poisoning the well.

Of course it's not that easy to get off the grid. What with all that easily acessible oil and gas, unlimited electircity and steady flow of the latest corporate goods, taking a pass on society's offerings is pretty inconvienient.

Ad Hominem ? Against who pray tell ?

Enough OWS participants must have agreed at GA that there was truth to the statement about oil and gas suppressing alternative energy for it to make it onto the manifesto. Unless they're lying to me about the consensus model, this represents what occupy believes.

Occupiers just want the easy way out, they have zero input on reducing the demand for conventional energy products, zero. As a for instance have you ever heard an occupier say something like " I refuse to support the evil oil and gas industry so, henceforth, I will never get on a plane and fly to an exotic destination for a holiday again"

No, your average occupier will dodge an issue like that when their buying a ticket to go visit Machu Pichu and respond, when challenged, about the *exchange of cultural values* or some such rigmarole, even when you point out that the evil overpaid CEO of the oil company that's keeping you off a solar powered plane ( or whatever ) just bought a new golf ball with the proceeds of your ticket sale.

"Oh well, this is problematic" you may hear, but they're off anyway. The CEO is on the golf course and the oil company geologists are collaborating with the engineers on whether that deep water well in the gulf is necessary to meet the demands of the energy hungry occupiers.

As a card carrying member of the 99% ( I lied about the Illuminati thing, btw ) I demand my self appointed representatives cease to ignore my calls for them to walk the talk, quit simply wagging their gums and waving their signs, get off their collective butts and SHOW me how it's done

Speaking of showing how it's done, where's bikerdruid ?
 
Removing the current annual oil Co. subsidies of ~~$4 billion/yr will likely not effect the $100/bbl, but sure may increase price at pump.
The price of gas is dictated primarily by what the market will bear and not how much subsidies they get.

Now if anyone figures out how to accomplish something based on that fabled raised awareness.
Ending slavery, segregation, child labor, winning the right for women to vote, etc., etc.. All took raising awareness first.

Social and moral progress is the synthesis of the dialectic (paraphrased) --Hegel.

It is for that reason that the founding fathers made freedom of expression a right. It is why people protest and have town hall meetings. It was the case made by Soviet dissident Natan Shransky in The Case for Democracy. Without free speech and Democracy nothing else is possible. Now, of course you are not against free speech. But you need to understand why that free speech is so important to begin with. It is fundamental.
 
Of course it's not that easy to get off the grid. What with all that easily acessible oil and gas, unlimited electircity and steady flow of the latest corporate goods, taking a pass on society's offerings is pretty inconvienient.
This does not advance the discussion. It doesn't deal with anything I've said. It's just flippant.

Ad Hominem ? Against who pray tell ?
I honestly cannot tell if you are being serious. Stout, I'm not interested in rhetorical games. If you cannot be serious with me then that's fine. But please don't waste my time. If you honestly don't know, truly honestly don't know, then I'm not sure we can have a meaningful discussion. It's one thing to object to my claim but it's quite another to feign that you don't know the subject of the discussion, the subject of the thread. If your question is simply rhetorical it's not at all helpful. If so then it's silly rhetoric that tells me nothing. I've no idea what your point is.

Enough OWS participants must have agreed at GA that there was truth to the statement about oil and gas suppressing alternative energy for it to make it onto the manifesto. Unless they're lying to me about the consensus model, this represents what occupy believes.

Occupiers just want the easy way out, they have zero input on reducing the demand for conventional energy products, zero. As a for instance have you ever heard an occupier say something like " I refuse to support the evil oil and gas industry so, henceforth, I will never get on a plane and fly to an exotic destination for a holiday again"

No, your average occupier will dodge an issue like that when their buying a ticket to go visit Machu Pichu and respond, when challenged, about the *exchange of cultural values* or some such rigmarole, even when you point out that the evil overpaid CEO of the oil company that's keeping you off a solar powered plane ( or whatever ) just bought a new golf ball with the proceeds of your ticket sale.

"Oh well, this is problematic" you may hear, but they're off anyway. The CEO is on the golf course and the oil company geologists are collaborating with the engineers on whether that deep water well in the gulf is necessary to meet the demands of the energy hungry occupiers.

As a card carrying member of the 99% ( I lied about the Illuminati thing, btw ) I demand my self appointed representatives cease to ignore my calls for them to walk the talk, quit simply wagging their gums and waving their signs, get off their collective butts and SHOW me how it's done
Now you are back to assertion. I'm really not interested in a post full of assertions. I can get that at any CT forum. I like JREF because most people get that the dialectic is more than simply flapping your gums. It requires skepticism, critical thinking and argument. Your premises need to be axiomatic or you need to support your premises.

This is the last time I'm going to ask you to avoid bald assertions. it's not helpful and I simply do not care anymore than I care about the assertions of a creationist. It's okay to provide opinion but not for your entire post.
 
Last edited:
Of course it's not that easy to get off the grid. What with all that easily acessible oil and gas, unlimited electircity and steady flow of the latest corporate goods, taking a pass on society's offerings is pretty inconvienient.

Ad Hominem ? Against who pray tell ? ...
I don't think it is. I think he's just personally irritated by certain negative criticisms of the movement he supports.

It is perfectly relevant to point out what one sees as hypocrisy in a movement. If a group claims to want to reach certain goals, yet advocates/performs actions that seem to run counter to said goals, then pointing such out is a perfectly valid criticism of them.

As a card carrying member of the 99% ( I lied about the Illuminati thing, btw ) I demand my self appointed representatives cease to ignore my calls for them to walk the talk, quit simply wagging their gums and waving their signs, get off their collective butts and SHOW me how it's done

I find it interesting how OWS likes to divide the world into the evil 1% and the 99% they claim to represent, yet willingly ignore criticism from said 99%. I also wonder what it means when someone is not a True Occupier but also, clearly, not part of the 1%.
 
Last edited:
The price of gas is dictated primarily by what the market will bear and not how much subsidies they get.
Actually for Big Oil and its' bottom line it's dictated by transport and storage costs, crude price, transport and storage costs, type of crude as it effects refining costs and output slate, more transport and storage costs, and gas station costs (most stations are lucky to make 2 cents / gallon on gas).

Ending slavery, segregation, child labor, winning the right for women to vote, etc., etc.. All took raising awareness first.
And the awareness was raised by people who specific agendas, which as yet OCS lacks. Corporations Bad just doesn't get specific enough to pique popular awareness.

Social and moral progress is the synthesis of the dialectic (paraphrased) --Hegel.

It is for that reason that the founding fathers made freedom of expression a right. It is why people protest and have town hall meetings. It was the case made by Soviet dissident Natan Shransky in The Case for Democracy. Without free speech and Democracy nothing else is possible. Now, of course you are not against free speech. But you need to understand why that free speech is so important to begin with. It is fundamental.
Agreed, but speech without reasonably specific content remains meaningless babble.
 
As a card carrying member of the 99% ( I lied about the Illuminati thing, btw ) I demand my self appointed representatives cease to ignore my calls for them to walk the talk, quit simply wagging their gums and waving their signs, get off their collective butts and SHOW me how it's done
BTW: Nothing will likely get done if there isn't protest and people are made aware so they can act. The rich and powerful don't want to change. It will only happen when enough people care and are willing to show they care.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom