Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
You seem opposed to OWS and yet impatient that they get something done. Why's that then?
I'm opposed to them, in part, because they haven't gotten anything done and don't really seem to want to. Some of their claims are good, some are nonsense ("economic inequality" is code for "some people have more money than others"), but they can't even determine what they want or how to accomplish it in more than the vaguest terms.

And the "not a monolith" claims are a contradiction in terms; if OWS is so diverse that they can't even unify long enough to figure out what they want, and they don't have desires in common that are important enough to unify over, then they can't really call themselves a movement.

I said "in part". In addition to the not getting anything done, there's the hypocrisy of wanting to demand accountability of others while refusing to have any for themselves. Any negative incidents are downplayed, distorted, ignored, or dismissed with "No True Occupier".

And no, I'm not "impatient" that they get something done. I criticize them for not getting anything significant done. There's a difference. Their biggest achievement, so far, has been costing the 99% a few million dollars of taxpayer money in cleanup fees and other city resources. And, of course, the occasional rape, theft, murder, and other crimes.
 
...

Yes, exactly. :)

Occupy is all about how horrible life in the USA is, we don't need to be bringing up the living conditions of the rest of the world that would only complicate things and lead to a 12 hour general assembly discussion with nothing being resolved in the end.
It's not like they've done much better just being concerned with the US.

Incidentally, Occupy Auckland and Occupy London would be surprised to know they're US concerns, as well as a few other people.
 
Last edited:
Occupy is all about how horrible life in the USA is...
I think this was one of the most difficult memes I ever had to give up. "America, love it or leave it". I despised liberals because they "hated America". I called them "hate America first crowd".

I no longer subscribe to that. Oh sure, there are people who "hate America". But I think mostly people hate injustice. The people who fought against child labor didn't do so because they thought how horrible life in the USA was. The same can be said of the struggle against slavery, against segregation, against unsafe working conditions, for suffrage, for rights in general.

Such rhetoric strikes me as both broad brush and fallacious. It's ad hominem and simply attacks the individual without addressing their grievances.
 
... and take those jobs from the poorest 95% to give them back to the richest 5% who own the world?
It would seem to me that this is a fallacy. False consolation, an appeal to guilt, red herring... it's an attempt to deflect a valid concern by pointing to an irrelevancy. I also think it's a false equivalency and Tu Quoque argument. I'm honestly not sure how such a statement does anything to advance the discussion. What exactly is the proposition the statement is supposed to establish? Hypocrisy (you are the 1% too)? If it is hypocrisy then how exactly?

Please believe me that I'm trying to bring down the heat in my own posts as it is clear this subject brings up much emotion. I'm not trying to attack but understand and if I believe that a post doesn't help the conversation I want point that out.
 
It would seem to me that this is a fallacy. False consolation, an appeal to guilt, red herring... it's an attempt to deflect a valid concern by pointing to an irrelevancy. I also think it's a false equivalency and Tu Quoque argument. I'm honestly not sure how such a statement does anything to advance the discussion. What exactly is the proposition the statement is supposed to establish? Hypocrisy (you are the 1% too)? If it is hypocrisy then how exactly?

Jobs were outsourced to countries with lower wages, i.e. poor countries. That was, naturally, done to increase profits for corporations, but it had the unintended side effect of boosting the economy of those poor countries. This has led, directly or indirectly, to the growth of a new middle class in many developing countries (of which probably the greatest example is Brazil, where the local middle class now outnumbers the poor; and yes, government policies had a lot to do with it too -- especially the bolsa familia was a stroke of genius). What do you think will happen to them if the US or the wealthy West in general "brings those jobs back" and goes all protectionist again? The net gainers would be people who, by and large, enjoy a better living standard and have more economic opportunities than the people who draw the short end of the stick. This probably wouldn't much concern the 1%, but it would mean the global 5% telling the global 95% that "Hey, we actually need your stuff 'cuz it used to be ours, so give it back." I may be wrong, but I was under the impression that this is just the sort of behavior OWS critizises in the 1%, so yes, it is hypocrisy. It's the "me me me" -game again; there's nothing inherently wrong with it, but don't try to dress it up as a quest for 'justice' or 'equality'.

There used to be a lot of talk about sharing the wealth of the West with poorer nations. This is, in fact, what has happened through outsourcing or globalization, yet a lot of people seem peeved about it. Seriously, what did you think it would be like?
 
Last edited:
Jobs were outsourced to countries with lower wages, i.e. poor countries. That was, naturally, done to increase profits for corporations, but it had the unintended side effect of boosting the economy of those poor countries. This has led, directly or indirectly, to the growth of a new middle class in many developing countries (of which probably the greatest example is Brazil, where the local middle class now outnumbers the poor). What do you think will happen to them if the US or the wealthy West in general "brings those jobs back" and goes all protectionist again?
I understand all of this. Not sure why you felt it was necessary but fine.

The net gainers would be people who, by and large, enjoy a better living standard and have more economic opportunities than the people who draw the short end of the stick. This probably wouldn't much concern the 1%, but it would mean the global 5% telling the global 95% that "Hey, we actually need your stuff 'cuz it used to be ours, so give it back."
Assuming your premise for sake of argument, and? I fall back on my assertion that your argument seems to me to be fallacious for a number of reasons (see previous post).

There used to be a lot of talk about sharing the wealth of the West with poorer nations. This is, in fact, what has happened through outsourcing or globalization, yet a lot of people seem peeved about it. Seriously, what did you think it would be like?
Putting aside for a moment the idea of a zero sum game and that outsourcing is the only possible way to "share the wealth" (which seems to me a straw man given the context of the thread) how does this address my point that your argument is otherwise fallacious?
 
I understand all of this. Not sure why you felt it was necessary but fine.

Assuming your premise for sake of argument, and? I fall back on my assertion that your argument seems to me to be fallacious for a number of reasons (see previous post).

And I fall back on my assertion that it shows hypocrisy on the part of OWS (see the edited message; and yes, it is a tu quoque argument -- that is how you establish hypocrisy).

Putting aside for a moment the idea of a zero sum game and that outsourcing is the only possible way to "share the wealth" (which seems to me a straw man given the context of the thread) how does this address my point that your argument is otherwise fallacious?

It's not the only way, but it looks like it has been somewhat effective. It has led to some measure of success in alleviating poverty, which hasn't happened in countries that have opted out of the process.
 
Last edited:
And I fall back on my assertion that it shows hypocrisy on the part of OWS (see the edited message)
I'm sorry but I don't believe that you did assert hypocrisy. In any event, it is irrelevant and fallacious.

It's not the only way, but it looks like it has been somewhat effective. It has led to some measure of success in alleviating poverty, which hasn't happened in countries that have opted out of the process.
So, if I understand you, it's morally wrong for people in America to seek to bring jobs that have left America back to America because to do so makes them hypocrites? Your argument is that they have made their own beds in wanting to improve conditions in other countries and now they need to be silent or they are hypocrites, right?

  • Let's assume the premise for a moment. You are painting everyone of them with a broad brush. No one in OWS can speak to bring jobs back because of a position held by some of them to improve the lives of others. Never mind that A.) OWS never made that argument and B.) None of them offered to sacrifice their well being for people in another country. Wanting to help someone doesn't mean giving up any and all rights to help one's self should there be a moral conflict between the two.
  • That it is effective isn't a valid reason to accuse them of hypocrisy. They didn't offer to sacrifice themselves.
  • It is reasonable for a society to prioritize the needs of that society above other societies given a conflict between the two. Americans have worked to create the common good will, infrastructure and institutions first and foremost to benefit Americans. It's not unreasonable for Americans to expect that their society would prioritize the needs of Americans above others given such a moral conflict.
I'm sorry but, IMHO, I find your argument fallacious in general and wrong on specifics.
 
Last edited:
So, if I understand you, it's morally wrong for people in America to seek to bring jobs that have left America back to America because to do so makes them hypocrites?

No. It's hypocritical of the OWS to complain that the people wealthier than them have benefited on their expense, and then turn around and tell people poorer than them that they need to give up (some of) their livelihood for the benefit of OWSers. And that's pretty much what "bring back outsourced jobs" means.

Or well, it would be hypocritical, if OWS had made such an argument, but apparently it hasn't made any arguments (which doesn't really surprise me). And you can be a hypocrite without offering to sacrifice yourself -- it's easy, just demand from others something you're not prepared to do yourself.
 
Last edited:
No. It's hypocritical of the OWS to complain that the people wealthier than them have benefited on their expense, and then turn around and tell people poorer than them that they need to give up (some of) their livelihood for the benefit of OWSers. And that's pretty much what "bring back outsourced jobs" means.
IMO: This is a false equivalency. Americans belong to a society with a common good will. The wealthy benefit directly from being in that society. The wealthy benefit from the contributions of all who have contributed to that society. OWS asks for justice and equality first and foremost in their society. That is reasonable. They can also seek for equality and justice in other nations while setting priorities.

As I said earlier, I'm not against this in principle, but just do everyone a favor and be honest about what you're asking (and what side-effects it will have).
I see no dishonesty whatsoever. Americans belong to a society that Americans have built for their common good. The wealthy benefit directly from American society and it is in the best interest of everyone in our society to see to the well being of everyone in our society first. This does not mean that we cannot help others in other societies.

Sorry, but, IMHO, you simply are not making your case.
 
It is reasonable for a society to prioritize the needs of that society above other societies given a conflict between the two. Americans have worked to create the common good will, infrastructure and institutions first and foremost to benefit Americans. It's not unreasonable for Americans to expect that their society would prioritize the needs of Americans above others given such a moral conflict.

Let's try it this way:

It is reasonable for a company to prioritize the needs of shareholders above others given a conflict between the two. The shareholders have invested to create the common good will, infrastructure and institutions first and foremost to benefit the shareholders. It's not unreasonable for shareholders to expect that their company would prioritize the needs of shareholders above others given such a moral conflict.

Yeah, works for me. If this is an OWS argument, I may have more in common with the movement than I thought.
 
OWS asks for justice and equality first and foremost in their society.

In other words, they ask for it when it benefits them. Which is OK, but if you're asking for justice and equality first and foremost when it benefits you, are you really asking for justice and equality, or just looking out for numero uno?
 
Last edited:
Let's try it this way:

It is reasonable for a company to prioritize the needs of shareholders above others given a conflict between the two. The shareholders have invested to create the common good will, infrastructure and institutions first and foremost to benefit the shareholders. It's not unreasonable for shareholders to expect that their company would prioritize the needs of shareholders above others given such a moral conflict.
I've zero problems with any of this. Not sure what it has to do with the discussion at hand but yeah, I'm great with this.

Being in a society will result in dilemma. The point of the dialectic is to try and resolve the dilemma. Corporation are free to pursue their goals within the law. Citizens are free to seek laws to benefit citizens. That citizens would seek to bring jobs back to America might very well be in conflict with the goals of the corporations and the goals of OWS to help others in other nations but it doesn't make them hypocrites. Morality is about prioritizing goals. That citizens would make an argument that corporations should consider the needs of citizens doesn't make them hypocrites. In the long run it just might be in the best interest of corporations to prioritize the needs of American citizens over the needs of others in other nations.

Social and moral progress is the equilibrium found in an adversarial system (paraphrased) --Michael Sandel
 
Last edited:
In other words, they ask for it when it benefits them.
In other words they prioritize goals. BTW: Many are in fact willing to sacrifice for others. It's not an all or nothing proposition.

Your standard seem to be, "don't ever speak up for others in other nations because if you do so you will be a hypocrite to prioritize your needs over others". For example, I cannot advocate for my neighbors and then put the needs of my family above theirs. Either be willing to sacrifice the needs of my family always or I can't advocate for others.

If that is your position, and I apologize if it is not, it strikes me as black and white thinking, fallacious.
 
Last edited:
It would seem to me that this is a fallacy. False consolation, an appeal to guilt, red herring... it's an attempt to deflect a valid concern by pointing to an irrelevancy. I also think it's a false equivalency and Tu Quoque argument.
That's right, lay down that chaff.
 
...his has led, directly or indirectly, to the growth of a new middle class in many developing countries (of which probably the greatest example is Brazil, where the local middle class now outnumbers the poor; and yes, government policies had a lot to do with it too -- especially the bolsa familia was a stroke of genius). ...
I looked it up. That does sound like a good program. It's a good thing Brazil has the money to spend.
 
In other words they prioritize goals. BTW: Many are in fact willing to sacrifice for others. It's not an all or nothing proposition.

Your standard seem to be, "don't ever speak up for others in other nations because if you do so you will be a hypocrite to prioritize your needs over others". For example, I cannot advocate for my neighbors and then put the needs of my family above theirs. Either be willing to sacrifice the needs of my family always or I can't advocate for others.

If that is your position, and I apologize if it is not, it strikes me as black and white thinking, fallacious.

Quote-mine, straw man. OWS is hypocritical because they claim to be populist, yet prioritize some groups over others. They decry what they see as unfair privilege of the "1%", yet are mostly concerned with the interests of the US alone, which is the world's 1%. They complain about the things corporations have done(including colonialism, as mentioned in the manifesto you linked), yet would, apparently, have said corporations take actions that worsen the lot of people employed in third-world countries by the ebil Incs. and make the companies less profitable. Or do you think companies are able to pay several times the wages to several times less the workers and maintain the same level of production?
 
Last edited:
It's not like they've done much better just being concerned with the US.

Incidentally, Occupy Auckland and Occupy London would be surprised to know they're US concerns, as well as a few other people.

Agreed.

It's gone well beyond the thread title and we should probably be talking occupy global rather than OWS.

I'll just amend my statement and replace US with *the western world under capitalism.*
 
I think this was one of the most difficult memes I ever had to give up. "America, love it or leave it". I despised liberals because they "hated America". I called them "hate America first crowd".

I no longer subscribe to that. Oh sure, there are people who "hate America". But I think mostly people hate injustice. The people who fought against child labor didn't do so because they thought how horrible life in the USA was. The same can be said of the struggle against slavery, against segregation, against unsafe working conditions, for suffrage, for rights in general.

This is well beyond "liberal" this is hard core leftism. Anarchist, Communist, whatever you want to call them they make your average everyday liberal look like a religious fundamentalist by comparison.

After the revolution, there will be no leave it. N. Korea, The Former USSR, Cuba...That kind of political freakishness has to keep their people from mass migrating even with the propaganda and brainwashing.

But hey, if you want to join in the struggle against capitalism and equate it with the struggle against slavery, segregation, unsafe working conditions, all movements with specific goals in mind rather that the general "tear down the system" of occupy it's your right....for now.

See, after the revolution, when capitalism is gone and we're living under stupid, criticism of the government won't be possible, so best we get it out of our systems now while we can.

Such rhetoric strikes me as both broad brush and fallacious. It's ad hominem and simply attacks the individual without addressing their grievances.

Yes ! That's the ticket, by Jove you've got it !

Viva la Revolution !
 
This is well beyond "liberal" this is hard core leftism. Anarchist, Communist, whatever you want to call them they make your average everyday liberal look like a religious fundamentalist by comparison.

After the revolution, there will be no leave it. N. Korea, The Former USSR, Cuba...That kind of political freakishness has to keep their people from mass migrating even with the propaganda and brainwashing.

But hey, if you want to join in the struggle against capitalism and equate it with the struggle against slavery, segregation, unsafe working conditions, all movements with specific goals in mind rather that the general "tear down the system" of occupy it's your right....for now.

See, after the revolution, when capitalism is gone and we're living under stupid, criticism of the government won't be possible, so best we get it out of our systems now while we can.
I really don't want to be dismissive but I can't find anything here to respond to. Granting the principle of charity at best it's assertion. At worst it strikes me as straw men and an appeal to guilt.

I would sincerely like a discussion but I need something substantive, logically valid argument. Opinion is fine but I would need more than just opinion.

Such rhetoric strikes me as both broad brush and fallacious. It's ad hominem and simply attacks the individual without addressing their grievances.
Yes ! That's the ticket, by Jove you've got it !

Viva la Revolution !
So, what I'm hearing is that you don't take me seriously enough to address my points? Okay, that's fine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom