Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is statistically likely that by now I should have met an intelligent occutard or have seen one on TV. But I haven't. You agree that at some point we have to label the whole movement "stupid", yes? How long should we wait?

About as long as we wait for OWS to get anything done, I suspect.
 
It is statistically likely that by now I should have met an intelligent occutard or have seen one on TV. But I haven't. You agree that at some point we have to label the whole movement "stupid", yes? How long should we wait?
With all due respect Scrut your post is silly and absurd. It's the kind of crap one can get arguing with creationists and conspiracy theorists. It's an attack on people not arguments. It doesn't advance the discussion. Your personal observations are worth as much as any creationist.

Creationist: "I've never seen a missing link, seriously, how long before we have to label evolution 'stupid', yes? How long should we wait?"

There are none so blind as they who will not see.
 
Creationist: "I've never seen a missing link, seriously, how long before we have to label evolution 'stupid', yes? How long should we wait?"

There are none so blind as they who will not see.
Special pleading in 3, 2, 1...
 
With all due respect Scrut your post is silly and absurd. It's the kind of crap one can get arguing with creationists and conspiracy theorists. It's an attack on people not arguments. It doesn't advance the discussion. Your personal observations are worth as much as any creationist.

Creationist: "I've never seen a missing link, seriously, how long before we have to label evolution 'stupid', yes? How long should we wait?"

There's no such thing as a missing link. However, you seem to be arguing (or at least implying) that there is an intelligent, non-naive occutard. Where?

There are none so blind as they who will not see.

Agreed.
 
However, you seem to be arguing (or at least implying) that there is an intelligent, non-naive occutard. Where?

There are none so blind as they who will not see.

Agreed.
It's understandable that you don't like OWS and I get the need to mock and deride. I think there is value to that in our dialog. I started a thread calling Santorum stupid and a liar and I've been particularly malicious about him and others at times. However, when someone wanted to have a serious discussion and to set aside the mockery and derision to honestly consider some aspect, I'm willing to do that.

I can't say much more without personalizing the discussion. I respect your right to an opinion but it's disappointing that you would have such a low opinion of me that you couldn't engage me substantively. That's fine.

All the best to you.
 
No confusion here. I agree with many of the points at to the effects caused by corporations when there is far too little oversight. Power and money tend to be corrupting influences. I like capitalism but I'm not naive as to the fact that corporations are run by corruptible people and the invisible hand has its limitations.

IMO: a number of those points desperately need to be addressed.

Agreed. More oversight. Stronger EPA legislation and enforcement, more unionization, a massive "Buy American" campaign to lure those manufacturing jobs that were shipped overseas...that sort of thing.
 
Agreed. More oversight. Stronger EPA legislation and enforcement, more unionization, a massive "Buy American" campaign to lure those manufacturing jobs that were shipped overseas...that sort of thing.
Thanks. Some good points of discussion. I appreciate that.

The EPA isn't my biggest concern. Important but not a priority given the economy. But I could be persuaded to increase regulation, I would have to see the specifics. America is one of the most regulated western industrialized nations (if not the most). Regulation is a real concern of mine. I think we regulate poorly and it's damn difficult to get rid of bad laws. Take a look at the attempt to get rid of oil subsidies. The subsidies are not popular with American voters. No valid basis for them that I have seen, but it failed. Laws that prop up sugar companies to the consternation of about everyone but the sugar companies. IMO: We need to find a way to change the dynamics so corporations have less influence. But yes, very much for more oversight. I would clean house at the upper levels of the SEC and, I don't know if it is possible. Find a way to lessen the corrupting power of the relationship between investigators and those they investigate. Jack Abrahmov detailed just how easy it is to pay off investigators without breaking the law. He has a plan.

I'm skeptical that a "Buy American" campaign would work. I'd like to see the arguments in favor. Unions, unfortunately it would seem, are more corruptible than corporations. I think they are likely requisite to stopping the decline of the middle class. I don't know without bargaining power the slide can be stopped (assuming there is an erosion of the middle class).
 
Agreed.
More oversight; Stronger EPA legislation and enforcement,
more unionization,
Those are reasons companies chose and choose to leave the US.

a massive "Buy American" campaign to lure those manufacturing jobs that were shipped overseas...that sort of thing.
ROFL. Most of us buy based on what we see as best price and utility.

Reducing the corporate tax rate might entice some manufacturers to return to the US.
 
Those are reasons [some] companies chose and choose to leave the US.
FIFY. There are many good things about being in America. Hell, we have some the wealthiest people on Earth. The myopic "tax only" view isn't helpful.

Reducing the corporate tax rate might entice some manufacturers to return to the US.
I'm not opposed to it. So long as we can raise the personal tax rate. 11 years of Bush tax cuts have done little to nothing.
 
FIFY. There are many good things about being in America. Hell, we have some the wealthiest people on Earth. The myopic "tax only" view isn't helpful.
It isn't myoptic; corporations long-ago noticed low-tax is good for the bottom line, and subsequent executive compensation determination. Other factors do come into play, but note we are discussing 'manufacturing' which in the US already faces 6 times the wage they expect to pay elsewhere.

I'm not opposed to it.
Good.

So long as we can raise the personal tax rate. 11 years of Bush tax cuts have done little to nothing.
On 1/1/2013 you and most of us will discover than isn't true, unless congress acts before then which I doubt.
 
It isn't myoptic; corporations long-ago noticed low-tax is good for the bottom line, and subsequent executive compensation determination. Other factors do come into play, but note we are discussing 'manufacturing' which in the US already faces 6 times the wage they expect to pay elsewhere.
It is myopic. There is manufacturing in the US. There are other factors. There are other things we can do to keep manufacturing in the US and to lure some of it back. Thinking our only possible hope lies in tax policy is frankly silly.

?

On 1/1/2013 you and most of us will discover than isn't true, unless congress acts before then which I doubt.
We don't need to wait for anything. We have 11+ years. If that isn't enough to tell us what the results of the Bush tax cuts are then 1/1/13 surely isn't going to tell us anything substantive. It could tell us that we've decided to double down on stupid and that we've decided to keep doing what hasn't worked. That remains to be seen.
 
Last edited:
It is myopic. There is manufacturing in the US. There are other factors. There are other things we can do to keep manufacturing in the US and to lure some of it back. Thinking our only possible hope lies in tax policy is frankly silly.
It's even sillier to think EEOC, OSHA, EPA, etc will be lessened, not tp mention unions.

We don't need to wait for anything. We have 11+ years. If that isn't enough to tell us what the results of the Bush tax cuts are then 1/1/13 surely isn't going to tell us anything substantive. It could tell us that we've decided to double down on stupid and that we've decided to keep doing what hasn't worked. That remains to be seen.

Bush tax cuts expire 12/31/2012.
 
Last edited:
There was a thread in December which showed that even with the tax cuts, the 1% still paid more taxes, proportionately, than the amount of wealth they represented. Everyone else payed roughly equal or less. Which means one of OWS's central claims is flat wrong.
 
Those are reasons companies chose and choose to leave the US.


ROFL. Most of us buy based on what we see as best price and utility.

Reducing the corporate tax rate might entice some manufacturers to return to the US.

Yes, I'm aware of this however exporting jobs was one of the concerns raised by occupy. I'm just saying bring those jobs back and instead of whining on Press TV about how oppressed they, as occupiers are, they could actually bat around solutions instead of complaints.

Seems to me that if the left wants the workers to own the means of production, it would be in their best interests to work on bringing those means of production back home.

RandFan has some ideas in post #4688, maybe occupy can pick up on those.

... and take those jobs from the poorest 95% to give them back to the richest 5% who own the world?

Yes, exactly. :)

Occupy is all about how horrible life in the USA is, we don't need to be bringing up the living conditions of the rest of the world that would only complicate things and lead to a 12 hour general assembly discussion with nothing being resolved in the end.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom