Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm honest in my opinion that I'm skeptical of my biases and I respectfully disagree with those that agree with biased, but skeptical, opinions. Honestly.
 
Occupy needs and wants my support if they want to get anything done
You? Just you? Really? Without you nothing can be done?

So why am I "biased" ?
I don't know how to answer that without being condescending. This is a skeptics forum. How do you not know that answer? Seriously? I know this is coming off as rude and I'm sorry but It's really baffling. Have you ever heard James Randi speak in lectures? Are you familiar with the scientific method? Did you know that the double blind test isn't for dishonest scientists. Everyone is born with biases. As Randi says, we are best at fooling ourselves even if we commit to being honest.

I know the hard left and their ridiculous anarchist politics when I see it. Outside of a Rainbow Gathering or a pirate ship the anarchist model is unworkable and childish. As an example on opening night of our local occupy the participants spent hours arguing over what to call themselves. They wanted the occupy brand however it was problematic. See as a society we're already occupying indigenous lands and there was concern that the indigenous population would find the occupy brand offensive.

The result...The Peoples Assembly of Victoria with the occupy label in smaller lower case letters after.

This took hours to hash out now imagine trying to run an entire society like this, we'd still be living in grass huts.

I'm assuming we're all honest in our opinions here
I don't mean to be dismissive but you are operating from a position that doesn't take into account skepticism and critical thinking. Almost all humans are skeptical of positions that differ from their POV. Skepticism requires the willingness to accept our own bias. That has absolutely nothing to do with honest opinions.

I'm more than happy to have a discussion with you but I don't see the point if you honestly believe you are incapable of bias. That's not skepticism. It's not critical thinking.
 
Refresher course:

Okay, I know I'm coming off as condescending but really, this is a skeptics forum. It is the goal of the JREF to advance skepticism and critical thinking. Understanding hidden bias and assumptions are critical to advancing those goals.

We all are capable of bias. Bias is an evolved attribute. It makes it possible for us to survive. It would be difficult for survival if we didn't make assumptions that we believe to be true. We are biased to trust our intuitions. It doesn't matter if we are honest. We all are prone to bias.

Confirmation bias (wiki)

A great video explaining why we are all subject to confirmation bias.

"If we are never willing to be wrong we can never find out if we are right"

Are you willing to be wrong?
 
Last edited:
You? Just you? Really? Without you nothing can be done?

Yes, just me. Nothing succeeds or fails without my say so. I am Illuminati. ;)

I don't know how to answer that without being condescending

It was a rhetorical question.

I don't mean to be dismissive but you are operating from a position that doesn't take into account skepticism and critical thinking. Almost all humans are skeptical of positions that differ from their POV. Skepticism requires the willingness to accept our own bias. That has absolutely nothing to do with honest opinions

Spare me the critical thinking lecture, please. I know how this works.

Yes, I fully admit I'm biased against the type of government occupy is trying to sell. I don't want it, you don't want, in fact nobody wants it. It's working out real well in Somalia innit ?

Occupy sucked in a lot of good well meaning people with their greasy sales pitch. Jobs, the economy, yea right. Occupy is kind of like those sea monkeys you used to be able to order from the back of the comic books. Sure, the pictures look enticing, but at the end of the day the product leaves a lot to be desired.
 
Spare me the critical thinking lecture, please.
Spare me the rhetorical questions or give me a smilie.

Yes, I fully admit I'm biased against the type of government occupy is trying to sell. I don't want it, you don't want, in fact nobody wants it. It's working out real well in Somalia innit ?

Occupy sucked in a lot of good well meaning people with their greasy sales pitch. Jobs, the economy, yea right. Occupy is kind of like those sea monkeys you used to be able to order from the back of the comic books. Sure, the pictures look enticing, but at the end of the day the product leaves a lot to be desired.
Straw man arguments. There is nothing to respond to here. You've set up a convenient argument to attack. I'm not interested in that. I'm not here to defend anarchists anymore than the all the folks who marched for equal rights march were defending anarchy, communism, etc..
 
If you're not going to defend occupy's core values, like rebuilding society from the ground up, overthrowing capitalism and replacing it with something stupid, why defend it it all ?
 
That mission statement is still the same histrionics and bilge the radical-left have been saying for decades.

They believe corporations eat babies. Nothing much you can do about that.
 
That mission statement is still the same histrionics and bilge the radical-left have been saying for decades.

They believe corporations eat babies. Nothing much you can do about that.
You don't have to be part of the radical-left to understand that:

  • Power corrupts.
  • Corporations have a lot of power and it is increasing.
  • The interests of corporations are not always the interests of citizens.
  • Unchecked corporate power has devastated our economy, destroyed investments and retirements.
 
They also seem to think that every corporation executive has the mentality of Freeza. No, seriously. They attribute everything corporations do to Malice rather than stupidity.
 
Really? Here is their mission statement. Where does it say that?

it is up to the individuals to protect their own rights, and those of their neighbors;
Yet OWS often violates the rights of others, even the 99%, when they see fit. In fact, several of the usual reforms they claim to want would require removing rights the 1% have now.

Also, I thought Occupy wasn't a monolith?

but corporations do not seek consent to extract wealth from the people and the Earth; and that no true democracy is attainable when the process is determined by economic power.
It's not. Influenced, yes. Determined, no.

We come to you at a time when corporations, which place profit over people, self-interest over justice, and oppression over equality, run our governments.
That highlighted bit is manifestly false. Corporations don't choose to oppress people, it generally happens as a side effect of the quest for profit. I'm not saying it's not reprehensible, but portraying them as moustache-twirling puppetmasters is the sort of thing you get from conspiracy theorists.

I also like how Occupy represents the will of the people, while corporations are apparently composed of faceless skinbags of malice and ill-intent in nice suits.

They have perpetuated inequality and discrimination in the workplace based on age, the color of one’s skin, sex, gender identity and sexual orientation.
Really? All of them? Because lumping people into one group sounds a lot like a stereotype. Many corps have departments specifically for dealing with those very issues you describe.

They have held students hostage with tens of thousands of dollars of debt on education, which is itself a human right.
Yes, because the corporation run colleges, and don't often donate a few shedloads of money to educational facilities. Education may be a human right, but no one has a right to college.

They have used the military and police force to prevent freedom of the press.
Ironic, considering OWS has attacked the press on multiple occasions.

They have sold our privacy as a commodity.
Let me guess; being photographed walking down the street? Or selling information you willingly put into Facebook?

They continue to block alternate forms of energy to keep us dependent on oil.
No one's really "blocking" anything; alternative energy just isn't viable large scale yet. The same companies who would be doing the blocking are the ones who are doing most of the AE research.

They have deliberately declined to recall faulty products endangering lives in pursuit of profit.
Profit is what pays the bills. You have too many bills, and the company has to start laying off employees, which is exactly what you decried earlier. It's a very cold-blooded decision, but a reasonable one.

They determine economic policy, despite the catastrophic failures their policies have produced and continue to produce.
Are we talking companies or the illuminati? I get the shadowy omnipotent cabals mixed up.

They purposefully keep people misinformed and fearful through their control of the media.
Okay, now this is textbook conspiracy theory. Who do they think owns most of the media? Oh, right, corporations. Once you start complaining about people "controlling" things they own, then you're two miles into Crazytown. If only there was some sort of ubiquitous Interlinked information Network that was a popular alternative to traditional sources, and has threatened to supplant them entirely for some time now. And its not like the corporations often report favorably on Occupy, right? It's not like HuffPost is owned by AOL or anything, right? Or the Guardian is part of a large media group PLC?

They have perpetuated colonialism at home and abroad. They have participated in the torture and murder of innocent civilians overseas.
I still find it amazing that the actions of a few corporations are laid at the feet of all of them. How is Wendy's responsible for what Blackwater did?
 
Last edited:
Their "mission statement" shows how spectacularly naive they are. Which most of us pretty much knew all along.

I had a conversation with a local occutard supporter a few months ago. When I asked who he thought owned corporations, his reply was "rich people". Unbelievable.
 
Last edited:
That's a damning indictment of capitalism as a whole, don't let the word "corporations" fool you.
No confusion here. I agree with many of the points at to the effects caused by corporations when there is far too little oversight. Power and money tend to be corrupting influences. I like capitalism but I'm not naive as to the fact that corporations are run by corruptible people and the invisible hand has its limitations.

IMO: a number of those points desperately need to be addressed.
 
They also seem to think that every corporation executive has the mentality of Freeza. No, seriously. They attribute everything corporations do to Malice rather than stupidity.
Granting the premise for sake of argument, this seems to me to be an ad hominem. Malice or stupidity the net effect is the same.

FWIW: I don't at all think that all corporations are evil and/or stupid. It doesn't have to be all to be a problem.
 
Their "mission statement" shows how spectacularly naive they are. Which most of us pretty much knew all along.
I think it's rather naive to think that most if not all of those points have a basis in reality.

I had a conversation with a local occutard supporter a few months ago. When I asked who he thought owned corporations, his reply was "rich people". Unbelievable.
I think many of the responses by people who are opposed to OWS show how spectacularly naive they are. I can post anecdotes but I'm not sure of the point of that. It's the confirmation bias thing again. Just because I know a lot of colossally stupid Republicans doesn't mean that all Republicans are stupid. That would be fallacy.
 
And with increasing amounts of ways to make money without going through corporations, such as Kickstarter.
 
I think many of the responses by people who are opposed to OWS show how spectacularly naive they are. I can post anecdotes but I'm not sure of the point of that. It's the confirmation bias thing again. Just because I know a lot of colossally stupid Republicans doesn't mean that all Republicans are stupid. That would be fallacy.

It is statistically likely that by now I should have met an intelligent occutard or have seen one on TV. But I haven't. You agree that at some point we have to label the whole movement "stupid", yes? How long should we wait?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom