Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
... And isn't arguing by assertion a fallacy?
Hypocrisy aside, you're confusing a statement of fact and an opinion. Again.

A bit categorical don't you think? And your basis for this? Isn't it true that it conforms to your bias? If so then why should anyone not conclude that this is simply ad hoc confirmation bias?

Assertion by question.

Just because a statement confirms to a hypothetical bias doesn't mean that it is not correct. For example, I get really ticked off at people who marginalize male rape. That does not mean that it is okay to marginalize and trivialize the rape of men, as I'm sure you agree.


Not being an American but with admiriation for the US at its best I back you to the hilt on this
I already pointed out that Virus was saying, indirectly, that OWS is not important. That's an opinion, not an ad hominem. I also pointed out that just having free speech does not make what one has to say inherently worthwhile.

RF has been wheeling from one claim to another for the past few pages. For example, he has claimed others are personalizing the debate, yet readily engages in such behaviour himself.
 
Last edited:
If you had asked me the same question about the civil rights movement in the first year after Rosa Parks I'd say the same thing. "I honestly don't know." Why is it you are not getting my point? Could you please acknowledge the point I'm making? I think the point you are making is ad hoc rationalization to justify your bias. You have set an arbitrary requirement. Can you tell me why this requirement of yours is significant in the light of the fact that social progress often takes years if not decades.

You're clearly not getting the opposing point, which is that the civil rights movement had defined goals (voting rights, abolition of the poll tax, housing equality, ending segregation) while OWS not only doesn't have such goals, it actively dissuades its members from advancing anything that might appear to be a goal.

At this point, OWS is basically an anarchist rabble. They had a chance, six months or so ago, to really make a difference; but when the hot lights were on them they just shouted their slogans rather than proposing any kind of real-world solutions.

Maybe slogans were all they ever had anyway.
 
You're clearly not getting the opposing point, which is that the civil rights movement had defined goals (voting rights, abolition of the poll tax, housing equality, ending segregation) while OWS not only doesn't have such goals, it actively dissuades its members from advancing anything that might appear to be a goal.
Having grown up during the 60s I can tell you that the movement often appeared chaotic and without direction. There was conflict about goals between MLK, Malcolm X, the black panthers and many others. I don't at all accept the idea that the movement was monolithic or organized to some significant degree more than OWS. Even if we accept the premise that at some point it was very organized. It would, IMO, be naive or dishonest to look back over all of those years and declare that it was always unified and organized with clearly defined goals. Bear in mind that many of the protestors were communist, anti-war, anti-capitalism, etc.. Their goals don't fit with your neat history.

At this point, OWS is basically an anarchist rabble. They had a chance, six months or so ago, to really make a difference; but when the hot lights were on them they just shouted their slogans rather than proposing any kind of real-world solutions.
Hey, you could be right. But I find your assertion self serving, conforming to your bias. You believe something, so you assert that it is so based on your anecdotal observation, right? If you are just offering an opinion then that's fine. But why should anyone else agree? Why should others not be skeptical that your assertions are simply based on ad hoc rationalization?

Maybe slogans were all they ever had anyway.
They had the means to raise awareness. And in fact, that goal was accomplished. Will it matter in the long run? I've no idea. I think so. I guess I could simply assert that it will make a difference but then that strikes me as a bit of intellectual dishonesty and hubris. Why can't we admit what we don't really know?
 
Last edited:
Having grown up during the 60s I can tell you that the movement often appeared chaotic and without direction. There was conflict about goals between MLK, Malcolm X, the black panthers and many others. I don't at all accept the idea that the movement was monolithic or organized to some significant degree more than OWS. Even if we accept that at some point it was very organized. It would, IMO, be naive or dishonest to look back over all of those years and declare that it was always unified and organized.
Then it's a good thing no one here has declared such. Straw man.

1. Occupy has never had coherent goals.
2. The Civil Rights movement did have coherent goals.
3. This is a critical difference between the two.

Hey, you could be right. But I find your assertion self serving, conforming to your bias.
Watch it, RandFan, you're personalizing the debate, hypocrite. Hit a nerve? Oh, wait, you're personally offended by someone saying OWS isn't important, of course it hit a nerve.

You believe something to be so, so you assert that it is so, right? If you are just offering an opinion then that's fine. But why should anyone else agree?
Because they share his opinion, which is different from yours.

They had the means to raise awareness. And in fact, that goals was accomplished. Will it matter in the long run? I've no idea. I think so. I guess I could simply assert that it will but that strikes me as a bit of intellectual dishonesty and hubris. Why can't we admit what we don't really know?
There's a difference between making a statement of fact about the future, a prediction based on one's subjective opinion, and a statement of fact based on the present. You've been trying to conflate all three for several pages now and it is really quite amusing. And sad.
 
Reading the WSJ, New York Times, St. Louis Post-Dispatch and CNN website on a daily basis.
Not quite what I meant but okay, let's see if we can't advance the discussion. How do you control for your own confirmation bias? How do you control for the conformation bias of the reporters.
 
Not quite what I meant but okay, let's see if we can't advance the discussion. How do you control for your own confirmation bias? How do you control for the conformation bias of the reporters.

Well, when they publish photos of the Occutards meeting with the mayor and flashing their stupid handsigns, I assume the photographer didn't alter them in Photoshop, but maybe he did.
 

Attachments

  • tards1.jpg
    tards1.jpg
    29.4 KB · Views: 0
  • tards2.jpg
    tards2.jpg
    19.5 KB · Views: 0
  • tards3.jpg
    tards3.jpg
    31.3 KB · Views: 3
Last edited:
Well, when they publich a photo of the Occutards meeting with the mayor and flashing their stupid handsigns, I assume the photographer didn't alter them in Photoshop, but maybe he did.
That doesn't answer my question. Let me see if I can help so we can get to the point. I know this is going to come off as condescending and I apologize about that, I don't mean to be, but I honestly don't know how else to get the point across.

Confirmation bias isn't so much about rejecting any particular bit of information. It's about focusing on those thing that reinforce our bias and ignoring those things that are counter to our bias.

So, you cite something that supports your bias, what about information that doesn't? IOW: even if I accept that your premise has any significance, it doesn't demonstrate that you are controlling for confirmation bias. Right?
 
This. They were so proud of themselves for not having leaders, every decision was to be made by popular vote (communicated using stupid hand gestures). I wonder if they've figured out yet that it won't (and can't) work?

And your basis for this?

Reading the WSJ, New York Times, St. Louis Post-Dispatch and CNN website on a daily basis.

Not quite what I meant but okay, let's see if we can't advance the discussion. How do you control for your own confirmation bias? How do you control for the conformation bias of the reporters.

Well, when they publish photos of the Occutards meeting with the mayor and flashing their stupid handsigns, I assume the photographer didn't alter them in Photoshop, but maybe he did.

That doesn't answer my question. Let me see if I can help so we can get to the point. I know this is going to come off as condescending and I apologize about that, I don't mean to be, but I honestly don't know how else to get the point across.

Confirmation bias isn't so much about rejecting any particular bit of information. It's about focusing on those thing that reinforce our bias and ignoring those things that are counter to our bias.

So, you cite something that supports your bias, what about information that doesn't? IOW: even if I accept that your premise has any significance, it doesn't demonstrate that you are controlling for confirmation bias. Right?

You asked how I control my confirmation bias. I guess I could try closing my eyes and not looking at the photos published in the paper. I also allowed fo the possibility that the photos were altered. Do you think they were? How do you control for your confirmation bias?

Here is a photo of the 'Tards not using handsigns. No less embarassing, but at least it shows that I'm not biased.
 

Attachments

  • tards1.jpg
    tards1.jpg
    29.4 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
You asked how I control my confirmation bias. I guess I could try closing my eyes and not looking at the photos published in the paper. I also allowed fo the possibility that the photos were altered. Do you think they were?
I'm more than happy to say they are not. But that has nothing whatsoever to do with my contention. Confirmation bias is the act of accepting only the data that supports your bias. The photos support your bias, right?

I've read a lot of articles by honest and objective people and my observations cause me to have different conclusions than you? How do we reconcile the discrepancy? Is it possible I'm blinded by bias?

How do you control for your confirmation bias?
I can only try. Since I have no objective means to do so, I don't make categorical pronouncements. I have stated time and time again that I honestly don't know many things about the movement such as if it has been or will be effective.
 
Last edited:
BTW:

attachment.php


I think that is brilliant. It's an excellent metaphor and a great example of confirmation bias. You see it simply as stupidity, much as my parents saw the hippies marching for civil rights in tie dye as being stupid.

I don't know if this is good communication. I'll admit that my bias likely plays a part in my judgement.
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.co...attachmentid=25046&stc=1&thumb=1&d=1334686270

I think that is brilliant. It's an excellent metaphor and a great example of confirmation bias. You see it simply as stupidity, much as my parents saw the hippies marching for civil rights in tie dye as being stupid.

I don't know if this is good communication. I'll admit that my bias likely plays a part in my judgement.

The difference is that when the hippies marched in tie dye, they weren't meeting with the mayor. The Mayor of St. Louis took time out of his schedule to meet with these people. He could have simply had them removed from Kiener Plaza (their downtown campsite) but chose not to. Instead, he wanted to find out how the city's need for order could also accomodate their desire to protest peacefully. What do these clowns do? They show up with dollar bills taped over their mouths and instead of having a conversation with the mayor, they flash stupid hand signals, because, you see, they couldn't talk because their mouths were covered which symbolized....well, I'm sure it symbolized something important. And edgy. We can't forget edgy.

Do you think they at least understand why people might laugh at them?
 
The difference is that when the hippies marched in tie dye, they weren't meeting with the mayor. The Mayor of St. Louis took time out of his schedule to meet with these people. He could have simply had them removed from Kiener Plaza (their downtown campsite) but chose not to. Instead, he wanted to find out how the city's need for order could also accomodate their desire to protest peacefully. What do these clowns do? They show up with dollar bills taped over their mouths and instead of having a conversation with the mayor, the flash stupid hand signals, because, you see, they couldn't talk because their mouths were covered which symbolized....well, I'm sure it symbolized something important. And edgy. We can't forget edgy.
None of this addresses my point. In fact, it strikes me as ad hoc in an attempt to justify a position. Even if we grant you the premise that this was a bad idea, and I'm not honestly sure, it is still ignoring my point.

Do you think they at least understand why people might laugh at them?
Sure. I think the hippies of the sixties in their tie dye, torn blue jeans, guys in long hair adorned with flowers at least understood why people might have been inclined to laugh at them while they were protesting.

I honestly don't know if this is effective. It strikes me as silly given the context of the meeting. But then the Starbucks business model of selling low end coffee at very high prices strikes me as down right asinine. Doesn't mean that Starbucks isn't successful. I'm not sure how appealing to intuition helps.
 
I think "confirmation bias" is just RF's latest buzzword. It's easy to dismiss the opinions of others as biased while not supporting said opinion.

Incidentally, everyone, RF's not evading my posts. He's had me on ignore since I repeatedly told him to look up information to make an informed decision instead of parroting the opinions of others. So if you want to quote a post of mine so he'll see it, be sure to change my name.

Unless you can walk up to them, ask them "what can Wall Street do to satisfy you?" and get a coherent response beyond "go away" they are going to suffer from being perceived as idealists without a game plan.

He/she agrees they were breaking the law. He/she also likes to throw in pictures of the Civil Rights movement, and how he agrees they were breaking the law, attempting to draw an imaginary parallel between the morality of arresting black protesters and arresting OWS Protesters. He/she will not say that they should be arrested at all.
....
Gosh, that seems familiar.
 
Last edited:
Not quite what I meant but okay, let's see if we can't advance the discussion. How do you control for your own confirmation bias? How do you control for the conformation bias of the reporters.
Quick, someone ask Rand how he does the same for people he agrees with and see how many unnecessary words and qualified statements he uses to answer!
 
If you had asked me the same question about the civil rights movement in the first year after Rosa Parks I'd say the same thing. "I honestly don't know." Why is it you are not getting my point? Could you please acknowledge the point I'm making? I think the point you are making is ad hoc rationalization to justify your bias. You have set an arbitrary requirement. Can you tell me why this requirement of yours is significant in the light of the fact that social progress often takes years if not decades.

I am getting your point, it's occupy that isn't

So far what have they stood for outside of rich people suck and being an umbrella group for every group with an issue demanding column inches ?

I wouldn't call defining their identity an arbitrary requirement, not if they want my support that is. In light of their failure to do so, as a member of the 99% I've taken the liberty of doing it for them. Until they can prove to me that I've misjudged them as a bunch of self serving hypocrites trying to spread a little collective guilt around and trying to convince us that we're all victims, I'll stand by my assessment.
 
I am getting your point, it's occupy that isn't

So far what have they stood for outside of rich people suck and being an umbrella group for every group with an issue demanding column inches ?

I wouldn't call defining their identity an arbitrary requirement, not if they want my support that is. In light of their failure to do so, as a member of the 99% I've taken the liberty of doing it for them. Until they can prove to me that I've misjudged them as a bunch of self serving hypocrites trying to spread a little collective guilt around and trying to convince us that we're all victims, I'll stand by my assessment.
I'm a little confused. I'm not sure what your support has to do with anything. I'm perfectly capable of understanding and respecting your opinion. I just disagree with your opinion and I think you fail to make a compelling argument for why I should agree with you. I can see how your bias could lead you to pick and choose the data to support your conclusion. I've seen much of the same data, accounts and observations. Perhaps my bias has led me to a different conclusion than yours.

  • I'm honest in my opinion.
  • I accept I could be biased.
  • I'm skeptical of my view point as a matter of course.
  • I respect those who disagree with me.
ETA: Doesn't mean that I support many of the actions of OWS. FWIW: I didn't support many of the actions of those in civil rights movement including the Weather Men, Black Panther Party, etc..
 
Last edited:
I'm a little confused. I'm not sure what your support has to do with anything. I'm perfectly capable of understanding and respecting your opinion. I just disagree with your opinion and I think you fail to make a compelling argument for why I should agree with you. I can see how your bias could lead you to pick and choose the data to support your conclusion. I've seen much of the same data, accounts and observations. Perhaps my bias has led me to a different conclusion than yours.

  • I'm honest in my opinion.
  • I accept I could be biased.
  • I'm skeptical of my view point as a matter of course.
  • I respect those who disagree with me.
ETA: Doesn't mean that I support many of the actions of OWS. FWIW: I didn't support many of the actions of those in civil rights movement including the Weather Men, Black Panther Party, etc..

Occupy needs and wants my support if they want to get anything done. Take bank transfer day for example. The need me, Joe Average, to walk into my bank, withdraw all my assets and tell them that I'm doing so because.......

Occupy needs my support for other things too, like writing to city council and demanding occupy be able to stay in their chosen location. Not a problem in the fall/winter however they were occupying prime real estate that's used constantly for events during the summer and there was no mention of occupy volunteering to vacate this space, to relocate to accommodate these events.

Remember, this was supposed to go on everywhere, forever.

So why am I "biased" ? I know the hard left and their ridiculous anarchist politics when I see it. Outside of a Rainbow Gathering or a pirate ship the anarchist model is unworkable and childish. As an example on opening night of our local occupy the participants spent hours arguing over what to call themselves. They wanted the occupy brand however it was problematic. See as a society we're already occupying indigenous lands and there was concern that the indigenous population would find the occupy brand offensive.

The result...The Peoples Assembly of Victoria with the occupy label in smaller lower case letters after.

This took hours to hash out now imagine trying to run an entire society like this, we'd still be living in grass huts.

I'm assuming we're all honest in our opinions here :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom