Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm sorry but this is really a very simple point.

[*]I'm not arguing that anyone else is arguing against rights.
And yet those are exactly the arguments you are making and dismissing, respectively, in the post I replied to.

[*]Virus is not judging the quality of anything but the people.
And in the post I replied to, you dismissed a judgement Virus was not making--a judgement about the right of free expression.

[*]Attacking people and not their arguments is ad hominem.
Agreed.

Please to see my post in context.
It's exactly in context that your post makes no sense: Virus does not criticize OWS's right to free expression, but it is exactly that criticism which you dismissed--the criticism Virus isn't making.

Given the post by virus (the one I'm addressing) what ideas exactly is he judging the quality of? BTW: How does labeling people "occutard" and attacking them personally judge the quality of their ideas?
I won't quibble on this. My feeling is that it's a personalization of the argument against the quality of their ideas--stupid ideas, therefore stupid people. If you want to make a hard distinction between detailing the ways in which OWS ideas are retarded, and simply calling OWS retards, that's fine with me. If, after scores of pages discussing the quality of the ideas in general and in detail, with some people opting for a shorthand ad hominem to indicate their position on the subject, you insist on rejecting that shorthand, that's fine with me, too.

What I was responding to was a post that dismissed an argument nobody was making. If nobody is saying they should not have or use their right to free expression, then why make counter-arguments specifically about that?

RandFan said:
God forbid someone should exercise their rights and not shut up and sit down with the rest of the sheeple.
How does that make any sense in the context of Virus's contention that OWS ideas are stupid?
 
And yet those are exactly the arguments you are making and dismissing, respectively, in the post I replied to.

  1. Virus has attacked people by disparagingly providing an impetus for what they are doing (they think they are important).
  2. The argument is fallacious. What they think is irrelevant. It is their rights that make them important.
  3. So, to counter him I'm providing the basis for why they are important. Their rights make them important.
  4. The disparaging remark about what they "think" is wrong and is an ad hominem.
wiki said:
The principle of charity.

The Principle of Charity is a methodological presumption made in seeking to understand a point of view whereby we seek to understand that view in its strongest, most persuasive from before subjecting the view to evaluation.
I'm sorry to have snipped the rest of your post but you are not advancing the discussion. I need you to address a point that you are either ignoring or missing.

  • Given the principle of charity, is it within the realm of possibility that #3 above is a valid impetus for OWS?
  • Given the principle of charity, what is the best reading for Virus' "they think they are important" statement?
Look, I understand the desire to spot fallacy and correct people. Lord knows I do it enough and, to be sure, I need to improve my commitment to the principle of charity. However, you need to consider if it is even possible that A.) I had a valid point and B.) that virus didn't?

If you can provide a charitable reading of virus I will withdraw my argument. Not on the grounds that it was fallacious but on the grounds that it is moot.
 
Last edited:
God forbid someone should exercise their rights and not shut up and sit down with the rest of the sheeple.
How does that make any sense in the context of Virus's contention that OWS ideas are stupid?

  • I'm not countering any such contention.
  • I'm countering the ad hominem that these people think they are important.
  • They are American citizens. Their right to free speech and redress makes them important.
 
They do think they're important. They said they're a force so strong mother nature cowers before it or some crap.
 
They do think they're important. They said they're a force so strong mother nature cowers before it or some crap.
Then the charitable reading is that you are saying they take their movement too seriously and/or have an unreasonable sense of self importance. I'm willing to grant that.
 
I would advise them against doing it. But that's my opinion, though I have some background in sociology and psychology, it's impossible to predict what events will captivate public opinion and which will be perceived as good or bad.

Ah, the diversity of tactics argument.

From what I can tell from years of reading the comments section that follow newspaper articles wrt activists going all smashy smashy, public opinion is overwhelmingly against the destruction of property.

This is something the left should pay close attention to when they have their diversity of tactics discussions, especially occupy as they're claiming to represent all of us, the 99%.

Sure, the left tries to say things like "violence" is something that's done against people and claim that things like smashing windows are not "violence" but at the end of the day, causing property destruction to get yourself/group/issue in the news is counterproductive.

Occupy needs to listen more, listen to the 99% because so far their antics have gotten them nowhere.
 
Ah, the diversity of tactics argument.

From what I can tell from years of reading the comments section that follow newspaper articles wrt activists going all smashy smashy, public opinion is overwhelmingly against the destruction of property.

This is something the left should pay close attention to when they have their diversity of tactics discussions, especially occupy as they're claiming to represent all of us, the 99%.

Sure, the left tries to say things like "violence" is something that's done against people and claim that things like smashing windows are not "violence" but at the end of the day, causing property destruction to get yourself/group/issue in the news is counterproductive.
I would tend to intuitively agree.

Occupy needs to listen more, listen to the 99% because so far their antics have gotten them nowhere.
And by this logic the marches of the 60s got them nowhere for years, except of course when it did. Further, I'm not sure it has gotten them nowhere. I'm not even sure how someone could declare something like that. How do you measure that and how do you control for confirmation bias?
 
Well now that the novelty has worn off and become an irrelevant side-show we can sit back and take stock of their actual achievements which is bugger-all.
 
And by this logic the marches of the 60s got them nowhere for years, except of course when it did. Further, I'm not sure it has gotten them nowhere. I'm not even sure how someone could declare something like that. How do you measure that and how do you control for confirmation bias?

In your opinion, what has occupy achieved ?

As far as I can tell, they haven't even come close to their original mandate "rebuilding society from the ground up" and quickly shifted their concerns from society as a whole to the occupiers themselves and how they were being victimized by the very society they were attempting to reform.

Cops, fire department, health inspectors....all members of the 99%
 
...
Sure, the left tries to say things like "violence" is something that's done against people and claim that things like smashing windows are not "violence" but at the end of the day, causing property destruction to get yourself/group/issue in the news is counterproductive. ....
Seriously?

Wow.

Then again, I suppose it's all a piece with saying students that surround, obstruct, and threaten police officers who were trying to leave them alone were merely "peaceful protestors".

In your opinion, what has occupy achieved ?

As far as I can tell, they haven't even come close to their original mandate "rebuilding society from the ground up" and quickly shifted their concerns from society as a whole to the occupiers themselves and how they were being victimized by the very society they were attempting to reform.
"Me me me me meee."

Cops, fire department, health inspectors....all members of the 99%
I especially like how they ignore and downplay the rapes and thefts and other crimes, because that would mean admitting that hey, maybe the police aren't the oppressive tools of the bourgeois 1%, and their presence would actually be beneficial to the safety of the protestors!
 
Yep, seriously

I read a far left forum on a daily basis, It's mostly latte left with all the sociology degrees and analysis wrt events. I don't actually post there because I've been banned so many times that I've run out of email addresses, however I can't stop reading, much like I can't drive by a car accident without looking to see blood and bodies.

Even over there there's little support for smashy smashy. There's a grudging acceptance that it's sometimes necessary however when incidents do happen they're usually blamed on agents provocateur, you know, the black clothing, masks and all. Who knows who's really who.

After the revolution, rapes, thefts and other crimes will be a thing of the past as under the new regime, everybody will be provided with everything the need and deviant behaviour will simply be educated out of the populace by sending them to sociology camp or something like that.
 
After the revolution, rapes, thefts and other crimes will be a thing of the past as under the new regime, everybody will be provided with everything the need and deviant behaviour will simply be educated out of the populace by sending them to sociology camp or something like that.

And the leftitst intellectuals will all have well-paid government jobs overseeing humanity's transition to enlightenment.
 
From Rosa Parks to the Civil Rights Act was 8.5 years. OWS won't accomplish half as much in 85 years because the very nature of their organization precludes their working together to reach a goal.

This. They were so proud of themselves for not having leaders, every decision was to be made by popular vote (communicated using stupid hand gestures). I wonder if they've figured out yet that it won't (and can't) work?
 
jh[HILITE said:
unter1163;8206559]From Rosa Parks to the Civil Rights Act was 8.5 years.
Of course Rosa Parks wasn't the first protest and 8.5 does support my contention right?

OWS won't accomplish half as much in 85 years because the very nature of their organization precludes their working together to reach a goa[/HILITE]l.
I thought they didn't have goals. Anyway, not sure how this addresses the points made? Doesn't this suffer the very same inadequacies? And isn't arguing by assertion a fallacy?
 
In your opinion, what has occupy achieved ?
If you had asked me the same question about the civil rights movement in the first year after Rosa Parks I'd say the same thing. "I honestly don't know." Why is it you are not getting my point? Could you please acknowledge the point I'm making? I think the point you are making is ad hoc rationalization to justify your bias. You have set an arbitrary requirement. Can you tell me why this requirement of yours is significant in the light of the fact that social progress often takes years if not decades.
 
This. They were so proud of themselves for not having leaders, every decision was to be made by popular vote (communicated using stupid hand gestures). I wonder if they've figured out yet that it won't (and can't) work?
A bit categorical don't you think? And your basis for this? Isn't it true that it conforms to your bias? If so then why should anyone not conclude that this is simply ad hoc confirmation bias?
 
Last edited:
If you had asked me the same question about the civil rights movement in the first year after Rosa Parks I'd say the same thing. "I honestly don't know." Why is it you are not getting my point? Could you please acknowledge the point I'm making? I think the point you are making is ad hoc rationalization to justify your bias. You have set an arbitrary requirement. Can you tell me why this requirement of yours is significant in the light of the fact that social progress often takes years if not decades.
"Accomplishing anything of value whatsoever" is an "arbitrary requirement"? How can they claim to be a movement if they have no goals, no aim, no focus, and no movement?

The claim stands. To date, OWS has suceeded at nothing but making an almighty nuisance of themselves. That may change in the future, but as of right now, they ain't done diddly worth diddly.
 
Straw man.

What the protestors think about their relative importance is an irrelevant ad hominem. And I would add, being an American with the right to redress and free speech DOES make them important.

Please don't personalize the argument.

Not being an American but with admiriation for the US at its best I back you to the hilt on this
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom