theprestige
Penultimate Amazing
And yet those are exactly the arguments you are making and dismissing, respectively, in the post I replied to.I'm sorry but this is really a very simple point.
[*]I'm not arguing that anyone else is arguing against rights.
And in the post I replied to, you dismissed a judgement Virus was not making--a judgement about the right of free expression.[*]Virus is not judging the quality of anything but the people.
Agreed.[*]Attacking people and not their arguments is ad hominem.
It's exactly in context that your post makes no sense: Virus does not criticize OWS's right to free expression, but it is exactly that criticism which you dismissed--the criticism Virus isn't making.Please to see my post in context.
I won't quibble on this. My feeling is that it's a personalization of the argument against the quality of their ideas--stupid ideas, therefore stupid people. If you want to make a hard distinction between detailing the ways in which OWS ideas are retarded, and simply calling OWS retards, that's fine with me. If, after scores of pages discussing the quality of the ideas in general and in detail, with some people opting for a shorthand ad hominem to indicate their position on the subject, you insist on rejecting that shorthand, that's fine with me, too.Given the post by virus (the one I'm addressing) what ideas exactly is he judging the quality of? BTW: How does labeling people "occutard" and attacking them personally judge the quality of their ideas?
What I was responding to was a post that dismissed an argument nobody was making. If nobody is saying they should not have or use their right to free expression, then why make counter-arguments specifically about that?
How does that make any sense in the context of Virus's contention that OWS ideas are stupid?RandFan said:God forbid someone should exercise their rights and not shut up and sit down with the rest of the sheeple.